题名

Subjectification and Resonance in Late Modern Bildung: The Global Model of Waldorf Education

并列篇名

現代晚期之陶養的主體化與共鳴：華德福教育的全球模式

DOI

10.6869/THJER.202012_37(2).0002

作者

Martyn Rawson

关键词

global education ； subjectification ； Waldorf education ； resonance ； 全球教育 ； 主體化 ； 華德福教育 ； 共鳴

期刊名称

清華教育學報

卷期/出版年月

37卷2期（2020 / 12 / 31）

页次

65 - 100

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

This paper explores the significance of subjectification and resonance in global education. Assuming that all schools have the function of enabling socialization, qualification, and subjectification or becoming a subject, the paper argues that this latter process has been neglected because of a one-sided pursuit of qualification, which may lead to alienation. Using the Bildung educational theory and a globalized and postmodern perspective on this, it is suggested that the role of self-formation is an important counterbalance to neoliberal education policies and could offer a way to reconcile Confucian ideas of social harmony and postmodern notions of emancipation. Thus, this study offers a layered model of the Waldorf curriculum. This comprises a global and universally human level, based on an ideal-typical developmental progression, a meso level that offers a local-level skills and knowledge curriculum, and a micro level that requires individual teachers to practice skilled artistry. Furthermore, it is suggested that the role of the teacher should enable subjectification and that an effective teaching approach should counter alienation by seeking experiences of resonance. This model could also be applied beyond the Waldorf discourse.
英文摘要

本文主要在探究主體化和共鳴在全球華德福教育的重要性。假設所有學校都需具有促進社會化、合格化、主體化或成為主體的功能，本文倡導陶冶（Bildung）的教育理論和全球化及後現代的觀點，主張自我形塑對於平衡新自由主義教育政策扮演重要的角色，並能提供一種將儒家的社會和諧思想和後現代的解放觀念結合的途徑。本文提供多層次的華德福課程模型，包含全球普遍性的人性層次以提供個體化的發展架構、一個中階層次在發展在地課程，及一個微觀層次讓個別教師演練教學的藝術。此外，本文還論證了教師在促進主體化的角色和通過尋求共鳴體驗來批判異化的教學方法。本教學模式也可以廣泛應用在華德福教育以外的相關論述領域。
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. Huang, S.-Y.(2014).Translation and world literature in Goethe’s west-east divan.Tamkang Review,45(1),105-128.
    連結：
  2. Antonovsky, A.(1996).The salutogenic model as a theory to guide health promotion.Health Promotion International,11(1),11-18.
  3. Appiah, K. A.(2019).Lies that bind: Creed, country, colour, class, culture.London, England:Profile Books.
  4. Baggini, J.(2018).How the world thinks: A global history of philosophy.London, England:Granta Books.
  5. Ball, S. J.(2013).The education debate.Bristol, England:Policy Press.
  6. Bauman, Z.(2008).The art of life.Cambridge, England:Polity.
  7. Beck, U.(2015).Emancipatory catastrophism: What does it mean to climate change and risk society?.Current Sociology,63(1),75-88.
  8. Benjamin, W.(1996).The task of the translator.Cambridge, MA:Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
  9. Biesta, G.(2020).Have we been paying attention? Educational anaesthetics in a time of crisis.Educational Philosophy and Theory
  10. Biesta, G.(2012).Giving teaching back to education: Responding to the disappearance of the teacher.Phenomenology and Practice,6(2),35-49.
  11. Biesta, G.(2010).Good education in the age of measurement: Ethics, politics and democracy.Herndon, VA:Paradigm Publishers.
  12. Biesta, G.(2019).Reclaiming teaching for teacher education: Towards a spiral curriculum.Beijing International Review of Education,1,259-272.
  13. Biesta, G.(2013).The beautiful risk of education.Boulder, CO:Paradigm Publishers.
  14. Biesta, G.(2014).Remembering forgotten connections: Klaus Mollenhauer’ opening to theorizing education differently.Phenomenology and Practice,8(2),34-38.
  15. Biesta, G.(2019).What is the educational task? Arousing desire for wanting to exist in the world in a grown-up way.Pedagogia y Saberes,50,51-61.
  16. Biesta, G.,Field, J.,Hodkinson, P.,Macleod, F. J.,Goodson, I.(2011).Improving learning through the lifecourse.London, England:Routledge.
  17. Bohnsack, F.(Ed.),Leber, S.(Ed.)(2000).Alternative Konzepte für die Lehrerbildung.Bad Heilbrunn, Germany:Klinkhardt.
  18. Boland, N.(2017).Waldorf: An education of its time.Pacific Journal,51(1),26-30.
  19. Boland, N.(2015).The globalisation of Steiner education: Some considerations.Research in Steiner Education,6(Special issue),192-202.
  20. Bransby, K., & Rawson, M. (2020). Waldorf education for the future: A framework for curriculum practice. Retrieved from https://www.steinerwaldorf.org/steiner-resources/
  21. Dahlin, B.(2017).Rudolf Steiner. The relevance of Waldorf education.Berlin, Germany:Springer.
  22. Dahlin, B.(2010).Steiner Waldorf education, social-threefolding and civil society: Education as cultural power.Research on Steiner Education,1(1),49-59.
  23. Dahlin, B.(2013).Gloves of ice or free hands? A nomadic reading of Rudolf Steiner and Bergson and Deleuze and others on knowledge as nonrepresentational and the importance of Aethesis.Other Education,2(2),67-89.
  24. Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York, NY: Touchstone.
  25. Faulstich, P.(2013).Menschliches Lernen. Eine kritisch-pragmatische Lerntheorie.Bielefeld, Germany:Transcript Verlag.
  26. Festenstein, M . (2019). Dewey’s political philosophy. Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2019/entries/dewey-political/
  27. Gadamer, H.-G.,W, J.(Trans.),Marshall, D. G.(Trans.)(2013).Truth and method.London, England:Bloomsbury.
  28. Gibson, J. J.(1979).The ecological approach to visual perception.Boston, MA:Houghton Mifflin.
  29. Göschel, J. C.(2012).Der biographische Mythos als pädagogisches Leitbild: Transdisziplinäre Förderplanung auf Grundlage der Kinderkonferenz in der anthroposophischen Heilpädagogik.Dornach, Switzerland:Verlag am Goetheanum Athena.
  30. Grotlüschen, A.(2004).Expansive learning: Benefits and limitations of subject-scientific learning theory.Vocational Training: European Journal,36
  31. Hastedt, H.(2012).Was ist Bildung.Stuttgart, Germany:Reclam.
  32. Hattie, J. A. C.(2012).Visible learning for teachers: Maximizing impact on learning.London, England:Routledge.
  33. Heilbronn, R.(Ed.),Foreman-Peck, L.(Ed.)(2015).Philosophical perspectives on the future of teacher education.Oxford, England:WileyBlackwell.
  34. Hickman, R.(Ed.)(2019).The international encyclopedia of art and design education.Hoboken, NJ:John Wiley & Sons.
  35. Hübner, E.(Ed.),Weiss, L.(Ed.)(2017).Lehrersein als Handwerk, Beruf oder Profession- Die Relevanz der reflexiven Persönlichkeitsbildung.Opladen, Germany:Verlag Barbara Budrich.
  36. Hübner, E.(Ed.),Weiss, L.(Ed.)(2017).Personalität in Schule und Lehrerbildung.Opladen and Berlin, Germany:Verlag Barbara Budrich.
  37. Hübner, E.(Ed.),Weiss, L.(Ed.)(2017).Persönalität in Schule und Lehrerbildung: Perspektiven in Zeiten der Ökonomisierung und Digitalisierung.Opladen, Germany:Verlag Barabara Budrich.
  38. Hurrelmann, K.,Bauer, U.(2015).Einführung in die Sozialisationstheorie: Das Modell der produktiven Realitätsverarbeitung.Weinheim, Basel:Beltz.
  39. Illeris, K.(Ed.)(2018).Contemporary theories of learning: Learning theorists...in their own words.London, England:Routledge.
  40. Illeris, K.(Ed.)(2018).Contemporary theories of learning: Learning theorists...in their own voice.London, England:Routledge.
  41. Ingold, T.(2000).The perception of the environment: Essays in livelihood, dwelling and skill.New York, NY:Routledge.
  42. Kern, H.(Ed.),Zdazil, T(Ed.),Götte, W. M.(Ed.)(2018).ehrerbildung für Waldorfschulen.Weinheim, Germany:Beltz Juventa.
  43. Koller, H.-C.(2018).Bildung anders denken: Einführung in die Theorie transformatorischer Bildungsprozesse.Stuttgart, Germany:Kohlhammer.
  44. Koller, H.-C.(2003).Bildung and radical plurality: Towards a redefinition of Bildung with reference to J.-F. Lyotard.Educational Philosophy and Theory,23(1),155-165.
  45. Loebell, P.,Martzog, P.(2016).Wege zur Lehrerpersönlichkeit. Kompetenzerwerb- Persönlichkeitsentwicklung und aktuelle Herausforderung in der Lehrerbildung.Opladen, Germany:Barbara Budrich.
  46. Løvelie, L.(Ed.),Mortensen, K. P.(Ed.),Nordenbo, S. E.(Ed.)(2003).Educating humanity: Bildung in postmodernity.Malden, MA:Blackwell.
  47. McDermott, R.(Ed.)(2012).American philosophy and Rudolf Steiner: Emerson, Thoreau, Peirce, James, Royce, Dewey, Whitehead, Feminism.Great Barrington, MA:Lindisfarne Books.
  48. Meyer-Drawe, K.(2012).Diskurse des Lernens.Munich, Germany:Wilhelm Fink.
  49. Mollenhauer, K.(1990).Ästhetische Bildung zwischen Kritik und Selbstgewissheit.Zeitschrift für Pädagogik,36,481-494.
  50. Moos, L.,Wubbels, T.(2018).General education. Homogenised education for the globalized world?.Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft,21(2),241-258.
  51. Nicol, J.,Taplin, J. T.(2017).Understanding the Steiner Waldorf approach.London, England:Taylor and Francis.
  52. Nussbaum, M.(2006).Education and democratic citizenship.Journal of Human Development and Capabilities,7(3),385-395.
  53. Palmer, P. J.(2017).The courage to teach: Exploring the inner landscape of a teacher’s life, 20th Anniversary Edition.San Francisco, CA:Jossey Bass.
  54. Paull, J.,Hennig, B.(2020).Centenary world maps of the global diffusion of “The School of the Future.Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities,6(1),24-33.
  55. Peng, Z.,Gu, J.,Meyer, M. A.(2018).Grundcharakteristiken der konfuzianischen Allgemeinbildung und deren Transformation in der Vergangenheit und in in der heutigen globalisierenden Zeit.Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft,21,259-298.
  56. Rawson, M.(2019).The development of the person: Possible links to nonformal learning situations, scaffolded reflection and expansive learning in Steiner/Waldorf education.Other Education,8(2),2-25.
  57. Rawson, M.(2021).Steiner Waldorf pedagogy in schools: A critical introduction.Abingdon, England:Routledge.
  58. Rawson, M.(2020).A theory of Waldorf education: Part 2. the role of study and artistic exercises.Research on Steiner Education,2(2),23-36.
  59. Rawson, M. (2020c). De-colonizing your curriculum- some tips for auditing.Waldorf Resources, 2020. Retrieved from http://www.waldorf-resources.org/single-view?tx_news_pi1%5Baction%5D=detail&tx_news_pi1%5Bcontroller%5D=News&tx_news_pi1%5Bnews%5D=8582&cHash=2dbc788a2edf780c3204815255941972
  60. Rawson, M.(2021).A forgotten German philosopher: A self-critical reflection by a high school teacher on Black Lives Matter.Waldorf Research Bulletin,26(1),44-48.
  61. Rawson, M.(2020).A theory of Waldorf teacher education: Part 1. learning dispositions.Research on Steiner Education,2(2),1-22.
  62. Rawson, M.,Richter, T.,Avison, K.(2014).The tasks and content of the Steiner-Waldorf curriculum.Edinburgh, England:Floris Books.
  63. Rittelmeyer, C.(2012).Bildung: Ein pädagogischer Grundbegriff.Stuttgart, Germany:Kohlhammer.
  64. Rosa, H.(2020).The uncontrollability of the world.Cambridge, England:Polity.
  65. Rosa, H.,Wagner, J. C.(Trans.)(2019).Resonance. A sociology of our relationship to the world.Cambridge, England:Polity.
  66. Roselius, K.,Meyer, M. M.(2018).Bildung in globalizing times.Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft,21(2),217-240.
  67. Ross, D.(Trans.),Brown, L.(Ed.)(2009).The Nicomachean Ethics.Oxford, England:Oxford University Press.
  68. Rumpf, H.(2010).Was hätte Einstein gedacht, wenn er nicht Geige gespielt hätte? Gegen die Verkürzung des etablierten Lernbegriffs.Weinheim and Munich, Germany:Juventa Verlag.
  69. Schieren, J.(Ed.)(2016).Handbuch Waldorfpädagogik und Erziehungswissenschaft Standortbestimmung und Entwicklungsperspektiven.Weinheim, Germany:Beltz Juventa.
  70. Schiermer, B.(2020).Acceleration and resonance: An interview with Hartmut Rosa.Acta Sociologica, E-Special: Four generations of critical theory in Acta Sociologica
  71. Sigler, S.(Ed.),Sommer, W.(Ed.),Zech, M. M.(Ed.)(2018).Handbuch. Oberstufenunterricht an Waldorfschulen.Weinheim, Germany and Basel:Beltz Juventa.
  72. Soetebeer, J.(2018).Umbildende Erfahrungen: Goethes Begriff der Selbstbildung.Köln. Weimar Wien, Germany:Böhlau Verlag.
  73. Stebbing, R.(Trans.),Bergman, H. S.(Ed.)(1963).The philosophy of spiritual activity.West Nyack, NY:Rudolf Steiner Publications.
  74. Steiner, R.,Bowen Wedgewood, E.(Trans.),Mariott, R.(Trans.)(1985).The renewal of the social organism.Spring Valley, NY:Anthroposophic Press.
  75. Steiner, R.,Saar, M. M.,(Trans.)(2020).The first teachers course. Anthropological foundations.Methods of teaching. Practical discussions.Bangkok, Thailand:Ratayakom.
  76. Steiner, R.,von Arnim, C.(Trans.)(2018).Social threefolding. Rebalancing culture, politics and economics.Forest Row, England:Rudolf Steiner Press.
  77. Stibbing, R.(Trans.),Allen, P. M.(Ed.)(1963).Truth and science.West Nyack, NY:Rudolf Steiner Publications.
  78. Thiong'o, Ngugi wa(2012).Globalectics. Theory and the politucs of knowing.New York, NY:Columbia University Press.
  79. Verhaeghe, P.(2015).What about me? The struggle for identity in a market based society.Melbourne, Australia:Scribe Publications.
  80. Wertsch, J. V.(Ed.),del Rio, P.(Ed.) ,Alvarez, A.(Ed.)(1995).Sociocultural studies of mind.Cambridge, England:Cambridge University Press.
  81. Willmann, C.,Weiss, L.(2019).INASTE. The next generation of Waldorf teachers.Vienna, Austria:INASTE.
  82. Wulf, C.(Ed.),Zirfas, J.(Ed.)(2014).Handbuch Pädagogische Anthropologie.Wiesbaden, Germany:Springer.
  83. Zhao, T.(2019).Redefining a philosophy for world governance.Singapore:Palgrave Macmillan.
  84. Zhao, T.(2006).Rethinking empire from a Chinese concept ‘All-Under-Heaven’ (Tian-xia).Social Identities,12(1),29-41.
  85. Zhao, Y.(2014).Who’s afraid of the big bad dragon? Why China has the best (and worst) education system in the world.New York, NY:Jossey Bass.
print cancel