题名

延遲改變：永續轉型過程的捍衛制度工作

并列篇名

Delaying Change: How Incumbents' Defensive Institutional Work Avoids Radical Change in Sustainability Transitions

DOI

10.6504/JMBR.202112_38(4).0001

作者

蔡依倫(I-lun Tsai)

关键词

捍衛制度的工作 ； 時間結構化 ； 制度改變 ； 永續轉型 ； 機車電動化 ； defensive institutional work ； temporal structuring ； institutional change ； sustainability transition ； gasoline-powered scooter phase-out

期刊名称

管理學報

卷期/出版年月

38卷4期（2021 / 12 / 01）

页次

411 - 443

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

制度改變帶來的變化有時翻天覆地，有時卻相當緩慢且微小，雖然已有研究證實制度可被改變，但改變停滯的現象卻鮮少被探討。不同於過去多著重於發動改革的制度興業家，本文分析既存者（incumbents）的策略行動，以更了解制度改變的動態性。本研究採質性研究法，探討機車產業的永續轉型與停滯歷程（2007～2020年）。永續轉型停滯常被認為是企業抗拒改變所導致，然而現今永續行為已是理所當然，企業若明顯抗拒將不具正當性；故本文主張問題不在於既存者是否加入改變行列，而是改變應如何安排。本研究分析既存者的捍衛制度工作，發現這些工作不僅影響改變的制度安排，同時也對改變應如何進行傳達出三個時間詮釋：「欲速不達」、「時機未到」與「新舊並存」。值此，本文進一步提出制度改變的延遲機制。本研究補充制度改變的時間研究缺口，並對產業永續轉型帶來實務意涵。
英文摘要

Although institutionalists have verified that institutions do change, how and why the scope and pace of change vary are less explored. Rather than focusing on institutional entrepreneurs, this study highlights the incumbents' reaction to institutional change. By studying the case of the failed sustainability transition involving the phasing out of gasoline- and diesel-powered scooters in Taiwan, this study examines incumbents' defensive institutional work to avoid radical change when deinstitutionalization occurs. The study reveals that this defensive work is devoted to intersubjectively interpreting how change should proceed temporally. The study identifies temporal work characterized as involving following shared beliefs: ＂more haste, less speed,＂ ＂now is not the time,＂ and ＂coexistence.＂ The study further proposes the mechanism underlying the delays in the transition to enhance the understanding of the social construction of institutional change.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 涂敏芬=Tu. M. F.(2019)。制度工作可行嗎？去制度化前緣的能動性解析。中山管理評論，27(1)，101-138。
    連結：
  2. 湯京平, C. P.,廖坤榮, K. J.(2004)。科技政策與民主化：台灣發展電動機車經驗的政治經濟分析。公共行政學報，11，1 1-34 34。
    連結：
  3. 蘇威傑, W. C.(2017)。為什麼企業要發佈永續報告書從非市場觀點解釋。管理學報，34(3)，331-353。
    連結：
  4. Aeon, B.,Aguinis, H.(2017).It’s about time: New perspectives and insights on time management.Academy of Management Perspectives,31(4),309-330.
  5. Ahuja, G.,Yayavaram, S.(2011).Perspective-Explaining influence rents: The case for an institutions-based view of strategy.Organization Science,22(6),1631-1652.
  6. Albert, S.(2013).When: The art of perfect timing.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  7. Amis, J.,Slack, T.,Hinings, C. R.(2004).The pace, sequence, and linearity of radical change.Academy of Management Journal,47(1),15-39.
  8. Bansal, P.,Song, H. C.(2017).Similar but not the same: Differentiating corporate sustainability from corporate responsibility.Academy of Management Annals,11(1),105-149.
  9. Berger, P. L.,Luckmann, T.(1966).The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge.New York:Doubleday.
  10. Brown, A. D.,Ainsworth, S.,Grant, D.(2012).The rhetoric of institutional change.Organization Studies,33(3),297-321.
  11. Brulle, R. J.(2014).Institutionalizing delay: foundation funding and the creation of US climate change counter-movement organizations.Climatic Change,122(4),681-694.
  12. Clegg, S. R.(Ed.),Hardy, C.(Ed.),Lawrence, T.(Ed.),Nord, W. R.(Ed.)(2006).The Sage handbook of organization studies.London, UK:Sage.
  13. Cornelissen, J. P.,Durand, R.,Fiss, P. C.,Lammers, J. C.,Vaara, E.(2015).Putting communication front and center in institutional theory and analysis.Academy of Management Review,40(1),10-27.
  14. Dacin, M. T.,Goodstein, J.,Scott, W. R.(2002).Institutional theory and institutional change: Introduction to the special research forum.Academy of Management Journal,45(1),45-56.
  15. Dacin, M. T.,Munir, K.,Tracey, P.(2010).Formal dining at Cambridge colleges: Linking ritual performance and institutional maintenance.Academy of management journal,53(6),1393-1418.
  16. Davis, G. F.(Ed.),McAdam, D.(Ed.),Scott, W. R.(Ed.),Zald, M. N.(Ed.)(2005).Social movements and organization theory.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
  17. Dunlap, R. E.(Ed.),Brulle, R. J.(Ed.)(2015).Climate change and society: Sociological perspectives.New York:Oxford University Press.
  18. Emirbayer, M.,Mische, A.(1998).What is agency?.American Journal of Sociology,103(4),962-1023.
  19. Flaherty, M. G.(2011).The textures of time: Agency and temporal experience.Philadelphia, PA:Temple University Press.
  20. Fligstein, N.,McAdam, D.(2012).A theory of fields.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  21. Foster, W. M.,Coraiola, D. M.,Suddaby, R.,Kroezen, J.,Chandler, D.(2017).The strategic use of historical narratives: A theoretical framework.Business History,59(8),1176-1200.
  22. Funk, R. J.,Hirschman, D.(2017).Beyond nonmarket strategy: Market actions as corporate political activity.Academy of Management Review,42(1),32-52.
  23. Geels, F. W.(2014).Regime resistance against low-carbon transitions: Introducing politics and power into the multi-level perspective.Theory, Culture & Society,31(5),21-40.
  24. Gehman, J.(Ed.),Lounsbury, M.(Ed.),Greenwood, R.(Ed.)(2016).How institutions matter!.Bingley, UK:Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
  25. Granqvist, N.,Gustafsson, R.(2016).Temporal institutional work.Academy of Management Journal,59(3),1009-1035.
  26. Greenwood, R.(Ed.),Oliver, C.(Ed.),Lawrence, T. B.(Ed.),Meyer, R. E.(Ed.)(2017).The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism.Los Angeles, CA:Sage.
  27. Harmon, D. J.,Green, S. E., Jr.,Goodnight, G. T.(2015).A model of rhetorical legitimation: The structure of communication and cognition underlying institutional maintenance and change.Academy of Management Review,40(1),76-95.
  28. Heinze, K. L.,Soderstrom, S.,Heinze, J. E.(2016).Translating institutional change to local communities: The role of linking organizations.Organization Studies,37(8),1141-1169.
  29. Hernes, T.(2014).A process theory of organization.Oxford, UK:Oxford United Press.
  30. Hirschman, A. O.(1991).The rhetoric of reaction: Perversity, futility, jeopardy.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
  31. Hoffman, A. J.,Jennings, P. D.(2021).Institutional-political scenarios for Anthropocene society.Business & Society,60(1),57-94.
  32. Kunisch, S.,Bartunek, J. M.,Mueller, J.,Huy, Q. N.(2017).Time in strategic change research.Academy of Management Annals,11(2),1005-1064.
  33. Langley, A.(Ed.),Tsoukas, H.(Ed.)(2017).The sage handbook of process organization studies.Los Angeles, CA:Sage.
  34. Lawrence, T. B.,Phillips, N.(2019).Constructing organizational life: How social symbol work shape selves, organization, and institutions.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  35. Lefsrud, L. M.,Meyer, R. E.(2012).Science or science fiction? Professionals’ discursive construction of climate change.Organization Studies,33(11),1477-1506.
  36. Levy, D.,Reinecke, J.,Manning, S.(2016).The political dynamics of sustainable coffee: Contested value regimes and the transformation of sustainability.Journal of Management Studies,53(3),364-401.
  37. Maguire, S.,Hardy, C.(2009).Discourse and deinstitutionalization: The decline of DDT.Academy of Management Journal,52(1),148-178.
  38. Markard, J.,Raven, R.,Truffer, B.(2012).Sustainability transitions: An emerging field of research and its prospects.Research Policy,41(6),955-967.
  39. Micelotta, E.,Lounsbury, M.,Greenwood, R.(2017).Pathways of institutional change: An integrative review and research agenda.Journal of Management,43(6),1885-1910.
  40. Nyberg, D.,Wright, C.(2020).Climate-proofing management research.Academy of Management Perspectives
  41. Nyberg, D.,Wright, C.,Kirk, J.(2020).Fracking the future: The temporal portability of frames in political contests.Organization Studies,41(2),175-196.
  42. Oliver, C.(1991).Strategic responses to institutional processes.Academy of Management Review,16(1),145-179.
  43. Orlikowski, W. J.,Yates, J.(2002).It's about time: Temporal structuring in organizations.Organization Science,13(6),684-700.
  44. Phillips, N.,Lawrence, T. B.,Hardy, C.(2004).Discourse and institutions.Academy of Management Review,29(4),635-652.
  45. Raaijmakers, A. G. M.,Vermeulen, P. A. M.,Meeus, M. T. H.,Zietsma, C.(2015).I need time! Exploring pathways to compliance under institutional complexity.Academy of Management Journal,58(1),85-110.
  46. Rao, H.,Monin, P.,Durand, R.(2003).Institutional change in Toque Ville: Nouvelle cuisine as an identity movement in French gastronomy.American Journal of Sociology,108(4),795-843.
  47. Rodner, V.,Roulet, T. J.,Kerrigan, F.,Vom Lehn, D.(2020).Making space for art: A spatial perspective of disruptive and defensive institutional work in Venezuela’s art world.Academy of Management Journal,63(4),1054-1081.
  48. Schüssler, E.,Rüling, C. C.,Wittneben, B. B. F.(2014).On melting summits: The limitations of field-configuring events as catalysts of change in transnational climate policy.Academy of Management Journal,57(1),140-171.
  49. Scott, W. R.(2013).Institutions and organizations: Ideas, interests and identities.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  50. Shipp, A. J.,Jansen, K. J.(2021).The "Other" time: A review of the subjective experience of time in organizations.Academy of Management Annals,15(1),299-334.
  51. Sillince, J. A. A.,Brown, A. D.(2009).Multiple organizational identities and legitimacy: The rhetoric of police websites.Human Relations,62(12),1829-1856.
  52. Slager, R.,Gond, J. P.,Moon, J.(2012).Standardization as institutional work: The regulatory power of a responsible investment standard.Organization Studies,33(5-6),763-790.
  53. Smets, M.,Morris, T.,Greenwood, R.(2012).From practice to field: A multilevel model of practice-driven institutional change.Academy of Management Journal,55(4),877-904.
  54. Spash, C. L.(2016).This changes nothing: The Paris Agreement to ignore reality.Globalizations,13(6),928-933.
  55. Thornton, P. H.,Ocasio, W.,Lounsbury, M.(2012).The institutional logics perspective: A new approach to culture, structure, and process.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  56. Vaara, E.,Tienari, J.(2008).A discursive perspective on legitimation strategies in multinational corporations.Academy of Management Review,33(4),985-993.
  57. Wadhwani, R. D.,Kirsch, D.,Welter, F.,Gartner, W. B.,Jones, G. G.(2020).Context, time, and change: Historical approaches to entrepreneurship research.Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal,14(1),3-19.
  58. Zietsma, C.,Ruebottom, T.,Shantz, A. S.(2018).Unobtrusive maintenance: Temporal complexity, latent category control and the stalled emergence of the cleantech sector.Journal of Management Studies,55(7),1242-1277.
  59. 三陽，2020。七期環保車更省油更環保，又能拿補助省荷包。http://www.cxwmxy.com/twsym/#。搜尋日期：2021 年 1 月 15 日。(Sanyang motor, 2020. The gasoline-powered scooter that meets the government’s phase 7 emission standard is more fuel-efficient and ecofriendly. http://www.cxwmxy.com/twsym/#. Accessed January 15, 2021.)
  60. 小七車觀點，2020。燃油機車貨物稅該減免？對重機上國道的看法？疫情和油電平權對銷量的影響？｜光陽執行長柯俊斌這樣講！https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtKtPnFn5IE&t=1s 。搜尋時間 2020 年 11 月 25 日 。 (7car perspective. 2020. Could gasoline-powered scooters be exempt from commodity tax? Can a heavy motorcycle go on the highway? How does COVID19 impact on sales of scooters? Kwang-yang CEO gave his thoughts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtKtPnFn5IE&t=1s. Accessed November 25, 2020.)
  61. 小七車觀點，2018。質疑行政院將扼殺燃油機車中華民國機車商業同業公會全國聯合會表達抗議，https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRZpV_RTnEA。搜尋日期： 2020 年 11 月 16 日 。 (7Car perspective. 2018. Questioning the ban on gasoline scooters: The Republic of China Scooter Commercial Association express its opposition. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRZpV_RTnEA. Accessed November 16, 2020.)
  62. 工商時報，2020。綠能抬頭﹗王美花：最快明天電動車銷售量將超越油車 。https://ctee.com.tw/livenews/aj/ctee/a00602002020102113464651。搜尋日期：2020 年 10 月 25 日。(Commercial Times. 2020. Go green: Minister of economic affairs Wang Mei-Hua predicted that the market shares of electric vehicle might exceed the gasoline-powered vehicle. https://ctee.com.tw/livenews/aj/ctee/a00602002020102113464651. Accessed October 25, 2020.)
  63. 工業局， 2021 。 歷年申請購買補助數量 。https://www.lev.org.tw/default.asp。搜尋時間 2021年 2 月 7 日。(Industrial Development Bureau. 2019. Subsidies on the purchase of an electric scooter. https://www.lev.org.tw/default.asp. Accessed February 7, 2021.)
  64. 工業局=Industrial Development Bureau(2019)。,未出版
  65. 天下雜誌，2019。2019 機車產業高峰會-產業永續共好未來 。https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWms4GvrzxI&t= 22s 。搜尋日期： 2020 年 12 月 16 日 。CommonWealth Magazine. 2019. 2019 two-wheels industry summit: Industry sustainability for the better future.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWms4GvrzxI&t=22s. Accessed December 16, 2020)
  66. 台灣區車輛工業同業公會，2021。機車銷售統計。https://www.ttvma.org.tw/statistics。搜尋時間 2021年 2 月 25 日。(Taiwan Transportation Vehicle Manufacturers Association. 2021. Motorcycle-related statistic. https://www.ttvma.org.tw/statistics. Accessed February 25, 2021.)
  67. 交通部，2021。機動車輛登記數，交通部公路總局統計查詢網 。 https://stat.thb.gov.tw/hb01/webMain.aspx?sys=100&funid=defjsp。搜尋時間 2021 年 1月 30 日 (Directorate of General Highway. 2021. Percentage of registered vehicles. https://stat.thb. gov.tw/hb01/webMain.aspx?sys=100&funid=defjsp. Accessed on January 30, 2021)
  68. 年代新聞，2020。貨物稅綁架機車？17%真的合理？https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XofxOwWsLJU。搜尋時間 2020 年 11 月 25 日。(Era News. 2020. Is it fair that the commodity tax exemption only applies to electric vehicles? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XofxOwWsLJU. Accessed November 25, 2020.)
  69. 行政院， 2017 。 20171221 行政院會後記者會 。https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PH1y7Bjp44I 。搜尋日期：2021 年 2 月 15 日。(Executive Yuan. 2017. 20171221 The press conference after a meeting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PH1y7Bjp44I. Accessed February 15, 2021.)
  70. 宋德洤, D. C.,陳志洋, C. Y.,陳文仁(2011).汽機車產業年鑑.新竹=Hsinchu:工業技術研究院產業經濟與趨勢中心=Industry Technology research institute.
  71. 周桂田（編）, K. T.(ed.),張國暉（編）, K. H.(ed.)(2017).能怎麼轉：啟動臺灣能源轉型鑰匙.台北=Taipei:巨流=Chuliu Publisher.
  72. 林淑貞, S. C.(1998).臺灣機車史.台北=Taipei:中華民國機車研究發展安全促進會=Scooter research association of the republic of China.
  73. 洪世章, S.C.(2021).打造創新路徑：改變世界的台灣科技產業.新北市=New Taipei City:聯經=Linking Publishing.
  74. 曾郁茜，2017。臺灣電動機車產業現況及未來發展商機。https://www.greentrade.org.tw/sites/default/files/Outlook%20of%20Taiwan%20E-scooter% 20Industry_1.pdf。搜尋日期：2018 年 12 月 21日。(Tseng, Y. C. 2017. The development and future vision of Taiwan E-scooter. https://www.greentrade. org.tw/sites/default/files/Outlook%20of%20Taiwan%20E-scooter%20Industry_1.pdf. Accessed December 21, 2018.)
  75. 黃靖萱, J. X.,蘇宇庭, Y. T.(2018)。光陽與 Gogoro 互踩地盤，骨子裡要的根本不同。商業周刊，1586
  76. 匯流新聞網，2020。七期燃油車已比一期車污染少95% 。https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C1jMne6iPjE 。搜尋日期：2020 年 12 月 16 日。(CNEWS, 2020. A 7th-phase emission standard fuel-powered scooter has less 95% pollution compared to the 1th-stage one. Accessed December 16, 2020.)
  77. 萬年生,劉又榛(2020)。油電雙雄爭霸關鍵時刻：Gogoro 聯盟單月賣贏光陽，兩強激戰年 500 億市場。今周刊，1203，64-74。
  78. 劉光瑩，2019。不轉型就等死？全台 2.8 萬家黑手店恐被電動車打垮。https://www.cw.com.tw/article/5094216?template=transformers。搜尋日期：2019年 9 月 13 日。 (Liu, K. Y. 2019. Transform or die? 28 thousand scooter shops may suffer from electrification. https://www.cw.com.tw/article/5094216?template=transformers. Accessed September 13, 2019.)
  79. 摩托車雜誌編輯室=Motor World(2019)。呼籲油電平權，率先推出7 期優惠。摩托車雜誌，414，78-79。
  80. 環保署，2021。補助成果。https://mobile.epa.gov.tw/LowPoll/index.aspx。搜尋日期：2021 年 2 月 13日 。 (Environmental Protection Administration. 2021. Subsidies on the purchase of an electric scooter. https://mobile.epa.gov.tw/LowPoll/index.aspx. Accessed February 13, 2021)
  81. 騎趣網，2018。專訪 KYMCO 柯董事長 iONEX 車能網 。https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRzzQAJQeJY。搜尋時間 2020 年 11 月 30 日。(Cyber Rider. 2018. An interview with president of iONEX. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRzzQAJQeJY. Accessed November 30, 2020.)
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。髮夾彎的策略構框：傳統機車企業如何影響電動機車產業政策的制定。組織與管理，17(1)，1-52。
print cancel