题名

競選廣告美學對選民的候選人知覺、態度與投票意願之影響

并列篇名

The Effects of Political Advertising Aesthetics on Voter Perceptions, Attitudes, and Voting Intentions toward Candidates

DOI

10.6504/JMBR.202206_39(2).0004

作者

周軒逸(Hsuan-Yi Chou)；呂姿穎(Tzu-Ying Lu)

关键词

競選廣告 ； 美學 ； 藝術注入 ； 空白空間 ； 感知高尚 ； political advertising ； aesthetics ； art infusion ； white space ； perception of sophistication

期刊名称

管理學報

卷期/出版年月

39卷2期（2022 / 06 / 01）

页次

203 - 234

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

近年來許多候選人開始重視選舉美學，競選廣告可視為一種政治與美學交流的形式，但鮮少學者探討視覺美學在競選廣告中的效果，釐清此一議題具有理論和實務價值，尤其選民常依賴政治溝通過程中的視覺線索形成候選人評估與反應。本研究基於藝術注入效果，探討競選廣告注入美學對候選人感知、態度與投票意願的影響，並檢視另一視覺設計元素─空白空間的角色。兩項實驗的結果發現：高美學廣告（無論是藝術感或設計感）相較於低美學廣告，會提升候選人的感知高尚和感知專業，且感知高尚與專業中介廣告美學對候選人態度的正向效果，候選人態度中介廣告美學對投票意願的正向效果；此外，廣告中多空白空間相較於少空白空間，能夠喚起候選人的感知高尚和感知專業，進而提升候選人態度和投票意願。本研究能為競選團隊提供廣告製作上的建議，也對商業行銷具啟發意義。
英文摘要

In recent years, many candidates have begun to emphasize election aesthetics. Political advertising can be considered as an intertwining of politics and aesthetics; nevertheless, few scholars have investigated the effect of visual aesthetics on political advertising. Clarifying this issue has theoretical and practical value, especially because voters often rely on visual cues received during political communication to form candidate evaluations and responses. This study explores how aesthetic infusion in political advertising affects perceptions regarding the advertised candidates and voters' attitudes and voting intentions toward the candidates from the perspective of the art infusion effects. It also examines the impact of another visual design element-white space. The results of the two experiments showed that, regardless of art or design elements, high (vs. low) aesthetic advertising improved voters' perceptions of candidates' sophistication and professionalism. Perceived sophistication and professionalism mediated the positive effects of advertising aesthetics on voters' attitudes. Moreover, voters' attitudes mediated the positive impact of advertising aesthetics on voting intentions. More white space in advertising increased the perceived candidate's sophistication and professionalism, improving voters' attitudes and voting intentions toward the candidate. The findings provide implications on how campaign teams should design political advertisements and promote commercial marketing.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 周軒逸, H.-Y.,練乃華, N.-H.(2010)。時間距離對負面競選廣告效果之影響。臺灣民主季刊，7(2)，33-76。
    連結：
  2. 高榮利, J.-L.(2011)。平面文宣對選舉效益之探討。中華印刷科技年報，507-521。
    連結：
  3. 張芝瑜, C.-Y.,蘇佩萱, P.-H.(2016)。2014 年雙北市長候選人競選形象識別之研究。藝術論文集刊，26，27-68。
    連結：
  4. 曾培育, P.-Y.,郭俊麟, C.-L.(2015)。競選廣告中候選人圖像之傳達設計研究─以台灣地方議員選舉文宣為例。商業設計學報，19，61-80。
    連結：
  5. 黃秀端, S.-D.,徐永明, Y.-M.,林瓊珠, C.-C.(2014)。政治知識的測量。選舉研究，21(1)，89-126。
    連結：
  6. 劉育君, Y.-C.,柯志祥, C.-H.(2018)。新聞網頁留白量對青壯兩代使用者的影響。設計學報，23(4)，1-20。
    連結：
  7. 劉嘉薇, J.-W.(2018)。政治知識的來源：社經地位、傳統媒體使用與新媒體使用。政治學報，66，29-63。
    連結：
  8. Aaker, J. L.(1997).Dimensions of brand personality.Journal of Marketing Research,34(3),347-356.
  9. Akyiaw, S. O.,Asemanyi, A. A.,deGraft-Yankson, P.,Boamah, A.,Adzei, S. E.(2019).Visual aesthetics and aural techniques used in television political campaign ADS during Ghana's 2016 presidential elections.IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science,24(4),63-73.
  10. Albert, W.,Gribbons, W.,Almadas, J.(2009).Preconscious assessment of trust: A case study of financial and health care web sites.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,53(6),449-453.
  11. Antheunis, M. L.,Schouten, A. P.(2011).The effects of other-generated and system-generated cues on adolescents’ perceived attractiveness on social network sites.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,16(3),391-406.
  12. Bajaj, A.,Bond, S. D.(2018).Beyond beauty: Design symmetry and brand personality.Journal of Consumer Psychology,28(1),77-98.
  13. Balzer, W. K.,Sulsky, L. M.(1992).Halo and performance appraisal research: A critical examination.Journal of Applied Psychology,77(6),975-985.
  14. Banerjee, S.(2016).Influence of consumer personality, brand personality, and corporate personality on brand preference: An empirical investigation of interaction effect.Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics,28(2),198-216.
  15. Barrett, A. W.,Barrington, L. W.(2005).Is a picture worth a thousand words? Newspaper photographs and voter evaluations of political candidates.Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics,10(4),98-113.
  16. Blackburn, S.(2005).The Oxford dictionary of philosophy.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  17. Blackwell, R. D.,Miniard, P. W.,Engel, J. F.(2001).Consumer behavior.New York, NY:Harcourt College.
  18. Blijlevens, J.,Thurgood, C.,Hekkert, P.,Chen, L. L.,Leder, H.,Whitfield, T. W.(2017).The aesthetic pleasure in design scale: The development of a scale to measure aesthetic pleasure for designed artifacts.Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts,11(1),86-98.
  19. Bloch, P. H.(1995).Seeking the ideal form: Product design and consumer response.Journal of Marketing,59(3),16-29.
  20. Bloch, P. H.,Brunel, F. F.,Arnold, T. J.(2003).Individual differences in the centrality of visual product aesthetics: Concept and measurement.Journal of Consumer Research,29(4),551-565.
  21. Brunel, F. F.,Kumar, R.(2007).Design and the big five: Linking product aesthetics to product personality.Advances for Consumer Research,34,238-239.
  22. Capelos, T.(2010).Feeling the issue: How citizens’ affective reactions and leadership perceptions shape policy evaluations.Journal of Political Marketing,9(1-2),9-33.
  23. Chamorro-Premuzic, T.,Burke, C.,Hsu, A.,Swami, V.(2010).Personality predictors of artistic preferences as a function of the emotional valence and perceived complexity of paintings.Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts,4(4),196-204.
  24. Chamorro-Premuzic, T.,Furnham, A.(2004).Art judgment: A measure related to both personality and intelligence?.Imagination, Cognition and Personality,24(1),3-24.
  25. Chang, C.(2001).The impacts of emotion elicited by print political advertising on candidate evaluation.Media Psychology,3(2),91-118.
  26. Chaudhuri, A.,Holbrook, M. B.(2001).The chain of effects from brand trust and brand affect to brand performance: The role of brand loyalty.Journal of Marketing,65(2),81-93.
  27. Chmielewski, T. L.(2012).Applying the elaboration likelihood model to voting.International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences,6(10),33-47.
  28. Choi, C. J.,Berger, R.(2010).Ethics of celebrities and their increasing influence in 21st century society.Journal of Business Ethics,91(3),313-318.
  29. Chou, H. Y.(2020).Effects of pronoun use in campaign advertisements on young Taiwanese voters.Chinese Journal of Communication,13(2),165-186.
  30. Chou, H. Y.(2014).Effects of endorser types in political endorsement advertising.International Journal of Advertising,33(2),391-414.
  31. Close, A. G.,Moulard, J. G.,Monroe, K. B.(2011).Establishing human brands: Determinants of placement success for first faculty positions in marketing.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,39(6),922-941.
  32. Coulter, K. S.(2008).The tri-mediation model of persuasion: A case for negative political advertising?.International Journal of Advertising,27(5),853-883.
  33. Cui, Y.(2019).The presentation of brand personality in English-Chinese brand name translation.International Journal of Market Research,61(1),33-49.
  34. Estes, Z.,Brotto, L.,Busacca, B.(2018).The value of art in marketing: An emotion-based model of how artworks in ads improve product evaluations.Journal of Business Research,85,396-405.
  35. Faber, R. J.,Tims, A. R.,Schmitt, K. G.(1993).Negative political advertising and voting intent: The role of involvement and alternative information sources.Journal of Advertising,22(4),67-76.
  36. Fabrigar, L. R.,Petty, R. E.(1999).The role of the affective and cognitive bases of attitudes in susceptibility to affectively and cognitively based persuasion.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,25(3),363-381.
  37. Fahmy, S.,Bock, M. A.,Wanta, W.(2014).Visual communication theory and research: A mass communication perspective.New York, NY:Palgrave Macmillan.
  38. Freedman, P.,Franz, M.,Goldstein, K.(2004).Campaign advertising and democratic citizenship.American Journal of Political Science,48(4),723-741.
  39. Friedman, A.,Ron, S.(2017).Unlocking the power of visual grammar theory: Analyzing social media political advertising messages in the 2016 US election.Journal of Visual Literacy,36(2),90-103.
  40. Friedrich, K.,Nitsch, C.(2019).Celebrity political endorsement and young voters in Europe: A fivecountry comparison on celebrity support effectiveness in the European elections.International Journal of Communication,13,4874-4894.
  41. Galdi, S.,Arcuri, L.,Gawronski, B.(2008).Automatic mental associations predict future choices of undecided decision-makers.Science,321(5892),1100-1102.
  42. Glasman, L. R.,Albarracín, D.(2006).Forming attitudes that predict future behavior: A meta-analysis of the attitude-behavior relation.Psychological Bulletin,132(5),778-822.
  43. Gorn, G. J.(1982).The effects of music in advertising on choice behavior: A classical conditioning approach.Journal of Marketing,46(1),94-101.
  44. Guzmán, F.,Paswan, A. K.,Van Steenburg, E.(2015).Self-referencing and political candidate brands: A congruency perspective.Journal of Political Marketing,14(1-2),175-199.
  45. Guzmán, F.,Sierra, V.(2009).A political candidate’s brand image scale: Are political candidates brands?.Journal of Brand Management,17(3),207-217.
  46. Hagtvedt, H.,Patrick, V. M.(2008).Art infusion: The influence of visual art on the perception and evaluation of consumer products.Journal of Marketing Research,45(3),379-389.
  47. Hagtvedt, H.,Patrick, V. M.(2008).Art and the brand: The role of visual art in enhancing brand extendibility.Journal of Consumer Psychology,18(3),212-222.
  48. Hagtvedt, H.,Patrick, V. M.,Hagtvedt, R.(2008).The perception and evaluation of visual art.Empirical Studies of the Arts,26(2),197-218.
  49. Han, E. K.,Park, C.,Khang, H.(2018).Exploring linkage of message frames with personality traits for political advertising effectiveness.Asian Journal of Communication,28(3),247-263.
  50. Hayes, A. F.(2018).Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach.New York, NY:The Guilford Press.
  51. Huber, G. A.,Arceneaux, K.(2007).Identifying the persuasive effects of presidential advertising.American Journal of Political Science,51(4),957-977.
  52. Huettl, V.,Gierl, H.(2012).Visual art in advertising: The effects of utilitarian vs. hedonic product positioning and price information.Marketing Letters,23(3),893-904.
  53. Hüttl-Maack, V.(2018).Visual art in advertising: New insights on the role of consumers’ art interest and its interplay with the hedonic value of the advertised product.Journal of Product & Brand Management,27(3),262-276.
  54. Jacobson, G. C.(2015).How do campaigns matter?.Annual Review of Political Science,18(1),31-47.
  55. Jho, H.(2018).Beautiful physics: Re-vision of aesthetic features of science through the literature review.Journal of the Korean Physical Society,73(4),401-413.
  56. Kaid, L. L.(2004).Handbook of political communication research.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  57. Kaur, H.,Sohal, S.(2022).Political brand endorsers, political brand preference, and political brand equity: A mediated moderated model.Journal of Marketing Communications,28(1),3-37.
  58. Keller、 K. L.,徐世同（譯）, S.-T.(trans.)(2014).策略品牌管理.臺北市=Taipei:華泰文化=Hwa Tai Publishing.
  59. Kilburn, H. W.(2005).Does the candidate really matter?.American Politics Research,33(3),335-356.
  60. Kim, K.,Ko, E.,Lee, Y. I.(2012).Art infusion in fashion product: The influence of visual art on product evaluation and purchase intention of consumers.Journal of Global Fashion Marketing,3(4),180-186.
  61. Kisida, B.,Bowen, D. H.,Greene, J. P.(2018).Cultivating interest in art: Causal effects of arts exposure during early childhood.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,45,197-203.
  62. Koren, L.(2010).Which "aesthetics" do you mean? Ten definitions.Point Reyes, CA:Imperfect Publishing.
  63. Kreuzbauer, R.,Malter, A. J.(2005).Embodied cognition and new product design: Changing product form to influence brand categorization.Journal of Product Innovation Management,22(2),165-176.
  64. Kumar, M.,Garg, N.(2010).Aesthetic principles and cognitive emotion appraisals: How much of the beauty lies in the eye of the beholder?.Journal of Consumer Psychology,20(4),485-494.
  65. Kwan, C. M.,Dai, X.,Wyer, R. S., Jr(2017).Contextual influences on message persuasion: The effect of empty space.Journal of Consumer Research,44(2),448-464.
  66. Landwehr, J. R.,Wentzel, D.,Herrmann, A.(2012).The tipping point of design: How product design and brands interact to affect consumers’ preferences.Psychology & Marketing,29(6),422-433.
  67. Laustsen, L.,Bor, A.(2017).The relative weight of character traits in political candidate evaluations: Warmth is more important than competence, leadership and integrity.Electoral Studies,49,96-107.
  68. Lavie, T.,Tractinsky, N.(2004).Assessing dimensions of perceived visual aesthetics of web sites.International Journal of Human-Computer Studies,60(3),269-298.
  69. Law, D.,Cheung, M. C.,Yip, J.,Yick, K. L.,Wong, C.(2017).Scoliosis brace design: Influence of visual aesthetics on user acceptance and compliance.Ergonomics,60(6),876-886.
  70. Lee, H. C.,Chen, W. W.,Wang, C. W.(2015).The role of visual art in enhancing perceived prestige of luxury brands.Marketing Letters,26(4),593-606.
  71. Lee, S.,Moon, W. K.(2017).Videostyle of televised political advertising in Korean presidential elections.Korea Observer,48(3),425-451.
  72. Lewis, M.(Ed.),Haviland-Jones, J. M.(Ed.)(2000).Handbook of emotions.New York, NY:The Guilford Press.
  73. Liutko, N.(2015).Aesthetic dimension of political advertising.Toruńskie Studia Międzynarodowe,1(8),71-81.
  74. Lock, A.,Harris, P.(1996).Political marketing‐vive la différence!.European Journal of Marketing,30(10/11),14-24.
  75. Lorand, R.(2002).Aesthetic order: A philosophy of order, beauty and art.New York, NY:Routledge.
  76. Lunardo, R.,Gergaud, O.,Livat, F.(2015).Celebrities as human brands: An investigation of the effects of personality and time on celebrities’ appeal.Journal of Marketing Management,31(5-6),685-712.
  77. Lundberg, K. B.,Payne, B. K.(2014).Decisions among the undecided: Implicit attitudes predict future voting behavior of undecided voters.Plos One,9(1),1-11.
  78. Maehle, N.,Otnes, C.,Supphellen, M.(2011).Consumers’ perceptions of the dimensions of brand personality.Journal of Consumer Behaviour,10(5),290-303.
  79. Marcinkowski, F.,Lünich, M.,Starke, C.(2018).Spontaneous trait inferences from candidates’ faces: The impact of the face effect on election outcomes in Germany.Acta Politica,53(2),231-247.
  80. Margariti, K.,Hatzithomas, L.,Boutsouki, C.,Zotos, Y.(2021).Α path to our heart: Visual metaphors and "white" space in advertising aesthetic pleasure.International Journal of Advertising
  81. Mayer, S.,Landwehr, J. R.(2018).Quantifying visual aesthetics based on processing fluency theory: Four algorithmic measures for antecedents of aesthetic preferences.Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts,12(4),399-431.
  82. McCutcheon, L. E.,Lange, R.,Houran, J.(2002).Evidence for non-pathological and pathological dimensions of celebrity worship.British Journal of Psychology,93(1),67-87.
  83. McNeil, P.(2010).The web designer’s idea book volume 2: More of the best themes, trends and styles in website design.Avon, MA:HOW Books.
  84. Moon, J. Y.,Kwak, J. S.(2010).The effect of art-parody and art-infusion advertisements focusing on product type and regulatory focus.Asian Journal on Quality,11(1),79-88.
  85. Nagel, F.,Maurer, M.,Reinemann, C.(2012).Is there a visual dominance in political communication? How verbal, visual, and vocal communication shape viewers’ impressions of political candidates.Journal of Communication,62(5),833-850.
  86. Noggle, G.,Kaid, L. L.(2000).The effects of visual images in political ads: Experimentl testing of distortions and visual literacy.Social Science Quarterly,81(4),913-927.
  87. Ohanian, R.(1990).Construction and validation of a scale to measure celebrity endorsers’ perceived expertise, trustworthiness, and attractiveness.Journal of Advertising,19(3),39-52.
  88. Olsen, G. D.,Pracejus, J. W.,O'Guinn, T. C.(2012).Print advertising: White space.Journal of Business Research,65(6),855-860.
  89. Orth, U. R.,Malkewitz, K.(2008).Holistic package design and consumer brand impressions.Journal of Marketing,72(3),64-81.
  90. Page, C.,Herr, P. M.(2002).An investigation of the processes by which product design and brand strength interact to determine initial affect and quality judgments.Journal of Consumer Psychology,12(2),133-147.
  91. Parmentier, M. A.,Fischer, E.,Reuber, A. R.(2013).Positioning person brands in established organizational fields.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,41(3),373-387.
  92. Peluso, A. M.,Pino, G.,Amatulli, C.,Guido, G.(2017).Luxury advertising and recognizable artworks: New insights on the "art infusion" effect.European Journal of Marketing,51(11/12),2192-2206.
  93. Peng, L.,Cui, G.,Chung, Y.,Zheng, W.(2020).The faces of success: Beauty and ugliness premiums in ecommerce platforms.Journal of Marketing,84(4),67-85.
  94. Peracchio, L. A.,Meyers-Levy, J.(1994).How ambiguous cropped objects in ad photos can affect product evaluations.Journal of Consumer Research,21(1),190-204.
  95. Peterson, D. A.(2015).Uncertainty and campaigns: The psychological mechanism behind campaign-induced priming.American Politics Research,43(1),109-143.
  96. Pieters, R.,Wedel, M.,Batra, R.(2010).The stopping power of advertising: Measures and effects of visual complexity.Journal of Marketing,74(5),48-60.
  97. Pieters, R.,Wedel, M.,Zhang, J.(2007).Optimal feature advertising design under competitive clutter.Management Science,53(11),1815-1828.
  98. Plummer, J. T.(2000).How personality makes a difference.Journal of Advertising Research,40(6),79-83.
  99. Pracejus, J. W.,O’Guinn, T. C.,Olsen, G. D.(2013).When white space is more than "burning money": Economic signaling meets visual commercial rhetoric.International Journal of Research in Marketing,30(3),211-218.
  100. Pracejus, J. W.,Olsen, G. D.,O'Guinn, T. C.(2006).How nothing became something: White space, rhetoric, history, and meaning.Journal of Consumer Research,33(1),82-90.
  101. Praino, R.,Stockemer, D.(2019).What are good‐looking candidates, and can they sway election results?.Social Science Quarterly,100(3),531-543.
  102. Reber, R.,Schwarz, N.,Winkielman, P.(2004).Processing fluency and aesthetic pleasure: Is beauty in the perceiver’s processing experience?.Personality and Social Psychology Review,8(4),364-382.
  103. Reimann, M.,Zaichkowsky, J.,Neuhaus, C.,Bender, T.,Weber, B.(2010).Aesthetic package design: A behavioral, neural, and psychological investigation.Journal of Consumer Psychology,20(4),431-441.
  104. Robins, D.,Holmes, J.(2008).Aesthetics and credibility in web site design.Information Processing & Management,44(1),386-399.
  105. Rowold, J.(2008).Instrument development for esthetic perception assessment.Journal of Media Psychology,20(1),35-40.
  106. Rozin, P.,Millman, L.,Nemeroff, C.(1986).Operation of the laws of sympathetic magic in disgust and other domains.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,50(4),703-712.
  107. Rule, N. O.,Ambady, N.,Adams, R. B., Jr,Ozono, H.,Nakashima, S.,Yoshikawa, S.,Watabe, M.(2010).Polling the face: Prediction and consensus across cultures.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,98(1),1-15.
  108. Rutter, R.,Chalvatzis, K. J.,Roper, S.,Lettice, F.(2018).Branding instead of product innovation: A study on the brand personalities of the UK’s electricity market.European Management Review,15(2),255-272.
  109. Sengupta, J.,Gorn, G. J.(2002).Absence makes the mind grow sharper: Effects of element omission on subsequent recall.Journal of Marketing Research,39(2),186-201.
  110. Sharma, N.,Varki, S.(2018).Active white space (AWS) in logo designs: Effects on logo evaluations and brand communication.Journal of Advertising,47(3),270-281.
  111. Silvia, P. J.(2009).Looking past pleasure: Anger, confusion, disgust, pride, surprise, and other unusual aesthetic emotions.Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts,3(1),48-51.
  112. Silvia, P. J.(2006).Artistic training and interest in visual art: Applying the appraisal model of aesthetic emotions.Empirical Studies of the Arts,24(2),139-161.
  113. Smith, G.(2001).The 2001 general election: Factors influencing the brand image of political parties and their leaders.Journal of Marketing Management,17(9-10),989-1006.
  114. Spangenberg, E. R.,Crowley, A. E.,Henderson, P. W.(1996).Improving the store environment: Do olfactory cues affect evaluations and behaviors?.Journal of Marketing,60(2),67-80.
  115. Sundar, A.,Noseworthy, T. J.(2014).Place the logo high or low? Using conceptual metaphors of power in packaging design.Journal of Marketing,78(5),138-151.
  116. Sung, Y.,Kim, J.(2010).Effects of brand personality on brand trust and brand affect.Psychology & Marketing,27(7),639-661.
  117. Townsend, C.(2017).The price of beauty: Differential effects of design elements with and without cost implications in nonprofit donor solicitations.Journal of Consumer Research,44(4),794-815.
  118. Townsend, C.,Shu, S. B.(2010).When and how aesthetics influences financial decisions.Journal of Consumer Psychology,20(4),452-458.
  119. Unurlu, C.,Uca, S.(2017).The effect of culture on brand loyalty through brand performance and brand personality.International Journal of Tourism Research,19(6),672-681.
  120. Van Niekerk, A.,Conradie, M.(2016).Branding through art: The commercial value of visual and linguistic signs of art.Critical Arts,30(2),233-251.
  121. Van Steenburg, E.(2015).Areas of research in political advertising: A review and research agenda.International Journal of Advertising,34(2),195-231.
  122. Veer, E.,Becirovic, I.,Martin, B. A.(2010).If Kate voted conservative, would you? The role of celebrity endorsements in political party advertising.European Journal of Marketing,44(3/4),436-450.
  123. Vukadin, A.,Wongkitrungrueng, A.,Assarut, N.(2018).When art meets mall: Impact on shopper responses.Journal of Product & Brand Management,27(3),277-293.
  124. Westerman, S. J.,Gardner, P. H.,Sutherland, E. J.,White, T.,Jordan, K.,Watts, D.,Wells, S.(2012).Product design: Preference for rounded versus angular design elements.Psychology & Marketing,29(8),595-605.
  125. Wu, F.,Samper, A.,Morales, A. C.,Fitzsimons, G. J.(2017).It’s too pretty to use! When and how enhanced product aesthetics discourage usage and lower consumption enjoyment.Journal of Consumer Research,44(3),651-672.
  126. Wu, H. D.,Coleman, R.(2014).The affective effect on political judgment: Comparing the influences of candidate attributes and issue congruence.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,91(3),530-543.
  127. Yamamoto, M.,Lambert, D. R.(1994).The impact of product aesthetics on the evaluation of industrial products.Journal of Product Innovation Management,11(4),309-324.
  128. Zarzosa, J.,Huhmann, B. A.(2019).Measures of aesthetic dimensions and reactions in advertising.International Journal of Advertising,38(2),258-275.
  129. Zheng, X. S.,Chakraborty, I.,Lin, J. J.-W.,Rauschenberger, R.(2009).Correlating low-level image statistics with users-rapid aesthetic and affective judgments of web pages.SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems,Boston, MA.:
  130. 方敘潔, H.-C.(2018)。圖像發聲！設計的政治影響力。LaVie，5月號
  131. 江明晏，2018。選舉網路戰催化傳統政治人物轉型。https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/201811250206.aspx。搜尋日期：2019 年 9 月 15 日。(Chiang, M.-Y. 2018. Election cyber wars catalyze the transformation of traditional politicians. https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/201811250206.aspx. Accessed September 15, 2019.)
  132. 李焜培, K.-P.(1987)。水彩畫欣賞。師友月刊，236，47-50。
  133. 馬岳琳, Y.-L(2016)。美學推手聶永真用設計說出總統心聲。天下雜誌，598
  134. 張鐵志, T.-C.,顏理謙, L.-C.(2016)。一場改變歷史的選戰行銷：這些創意、設計、網路人，把小英送進總統府。數位時代，264
  135. 陳君毅，2018。有做不一定贏，沒做幾乎一定輸！誰是這場選舉社群戰贏家？https://www.bnext.com.tw/article/51183/electionsocial-marketing。搜尋日期：2019 年 9 月 16 日。(Chen, C.-Y. 2018. You do not necessarily win if you do it, but you almost certainly lose if you do not do it! Who is the winner in this election community battle?. https://www.bnext.com.tw/article/51183/electionsocial-marketing. Accessed September 16, 2019.)
  136. 楊淑媛，2018。鄭文燦競總設計感十足網酸：陳學聖競總「中華民國美學」。https://www.ettoday. net/news/20181113/1305341.htm。搜尋日期：2019年 9 月 6 日。(Yang, S.-Y. 2018. Wen-Tsan Cheng’s campaign headquarters is praised for its outstanding design. Internet users criticize Apollo Chen’s campaign headquarters for having “Republic of China aesthetics”. https://www.ettoday. net/news/20181113/1305341.htm. Accessed September 6, 2019.)
  137. 盧冠妃，2016。北門背景招牌多！柯：受不了「中華民國美學」 。 https://news.tvbs.com.tw/life/640633。搜尋日期：2019 年 9 月 20 日。(Lu, K.-F. 2016. Several shop signs appear in the background of the Taipei City Wall-North Gate photographs! Wen-Je Ko: Cannot tolerate “Republic of China aesthetics”. https://news.tvbs. com.tw/life/640633. Accessed September 20, 2019.)
  138. 蘋果仁，2021。修圖 APP 推薦：《PicsArt》免費下載教學， 30 多種人像風格隨你用 。https://applealmond.com/posts/85114。搜尋日期：2021 年 6 月 11 日。(Applealmond, 2021. The recommended photo-editing app: Teaching you how to get the free app "PicsArt" and use more than 30 portrait styles. https://applealmond.com/posts/85114. Accessd June 11, 2021.)
print cancel