题名

儒商倫理紀律與公司治理：兩個案例研究

并列篇名

Ethical Discipline and Corporate Governance of Confucian Firms: Two Case Studies

DOI

10.6504/JMBR.202306_40(2).0001

作者

胡秀華(Hsiu-Hua Hu)；常逸平(Yi-Ping Chang)；劉世慶(Shih-Ching Liu)；楊政學(Cheng-Hsueh Yang)

关键词

儒家 ； 儒商 ； 倫理紀律 ； 公司治理 ； 個案研究 ； Confucianism ； Confucian firms ； ethical discipline ； corporate governance ； case study

期刊名称

管理學報

卷期/出版年月

40卷2期（2023 / 06 / 01）

页次

107 - 133

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

倫理紀律是公司治理的重要基礎，而倫理紀律的建制需有倫理元素為根基，然各文化的倫理特性有所不同，因此探討不同文化的倫理思想如何形塑企業倫理紀律是重要的。回顧過往文獻，較少以儒學建構企業倫理紀律，進而應用於公司治理之實證研究。此外，在處理儒商相關議題上，因研究者背景所限，對於「儒」（倫理面）與「商」（管理面）會偏向一隅。有鑑於此，本文揉合倫理面與管理面的研究進路，針對兩家代表性當代儒商進行個案分析，探討個案企業如何經由儒學來建構倫理紀律，從而發展公司治理。研究發現個案企業發展倫理紀律的經驗，以及展現公司治理的特色，除了能擴張過往儒商文獻外，亦值得身處華人文化的企業參酌。
英文摘要

Ethical discipline is the important foundation of corporate governance, and the ethical element is the root of the establishment of ethical discipline, however, the ethical characteristic of each culture is difference. Hence, it is important to investigate how ethical thinking in different cultures shift ethical discipline. Through the literature we can find that previous researchers take less empirical research on ethical discipline which apply in corporate governance is established on Confucianism. Besides, in previous studies of Confucian firms, due to the researchers' background, only stress one dimension that Confucianism (ethical dimension) or business (managemental dimension). In the light of this, this study analyzes two representative contemporary Confucian firms through integrating approach of ethical and managemental dimension, and discusses firms how to build ethical discipline shifted by Confucianism to develop the unique corporate governance. This study concludes it can expand the previous literature and provide a reference for those firms that belong to Confucian culture.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 王安智, A. C.(2014)。德行領導：本土概念或普同現象？。中華心理學刊，56(2)，149-164。
    連結：
  2. 周佳敏, C. M.,鄭伯壎, B. S.,黃光國, K. K.,余思賢, S. H.(2017)。從義利兩難到義利合一：使命型儒商超越義利矛盾的心理機制。本土心理學研究，47，305-370。
    連結：
  3. 鄭伯壎, B. S.周麗芳, L. F.,樊景立, J. L.(2000)。家長式領導：三元模式的建構與測量。本土心理學研究，14，3-64。
    連結：
  4. 鄭國鴻, G. H.,吳成豐, C. F.(2006)。公司治理與組織績效—台灣中小企業之研究。台灣金融財務季刊，7(1)，1-27。
    連結：
  5. Agbanusi, C. A.(2015).The relationship between philosophy and culture.AFRREV IJAH: An International Journal of Arts and Humanities,4(3),77-85.
  6. Benson, G. C. S.(1989).Codes of ethics.Journal of Business Ethics,8(5),305-319.
  7. Bowie, N.(2017).Business ethics: A Kantian perspective.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  8. Chan, G.(2008).The relevance and value of Confucianism in contemporary business ethics.Journal of Business Ethics,77(3),347-360.
  9. Cheung, T. S.,King, A. Y. C.(2004).Righteousness and profitableness: The moral choices of contemporary Confucian entrepreneurs.Journal of Business Ethics,54(3),245-260.
  10. Crane, A.,Matten, D.,Glozer, S.,Spence, L.(2019).Managing corporate citizenship and sustainability in the age of globalization.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  11. Creswell, J.W.(2009).Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
  12. Donaldson, T.,Dunfee, T.(1994).Toward a unified conception of business ethics: Integrative social contracts theory.The Academy of Management Review,19(2),252-284.
  13. Dutton, J. E.,Worline, M. C.,Frost, P. J.,Lilius, J.(2006).Explaining compassion organizing.Administrative Science Quarterly,51(1),59-96.
  14. Dyer, W. G.,Wilkins, A. L.(1991).Better stories, not better constructs, to generate better theory: A rejoinder to Eisenhardt.Academy of Management Review,16(3),613-619.
  15. Ferrell, O. C.,Fraedrich, J.,Ferrell, L.(2019).Business ethics: Ethical decision making and cases.Boston, MA:CENGAGE Learning Inc.
  16. Freeman, R. E.(1984).Strategic management: A stakeholder approach.Boston, MA:Pitman.
  17. Garegnani, G. M.,Merlotti, E. P.,Angeloantonio, R.(2015).Untangling the antecedents of code of ethics quality: Does corporate governance matter?.Corporate Governance,15(5),607-622.
  18. Golden-Biddle, K.,Locke, K.(1993).Appealing work: An investigation of how ethnographic texts convince.Organization Science,4(4),595-616.
  19. Gross, N. C,Giacquinta, J. B.,Bernstein, M.(1971).Implementing organization innovation: A sociological analysis of planned change.New York, NY:Basic Book Inc.
  20. Hong, Y.(2002).Business ethics: Is it useful?—An empirical study of Chinese enterprise.Business Ethics: A European Review,11(4),335-342.
  21. Horak, S.,Yang, I.(2017).A complementary perspective on business ethics in South Korea: Civil religion, common misconceptions, and overlooked social structures.Business Ethics: A European Review,27(1),1-14.
  22. Ip, P. K.(2003).Business ethics and a state owned enterprise in China.Business Ethics: A European Review,12(1),64-77.
  23. Ip, P. K.(2002).The Weizhi Group of Xian: A Chinese virtuous corporation.Journal of Business Ethics,35,15-26.
  24. Kidd, S. A.(2002).The role of qualitative research in psychological journals.Psychological Methods,7(1),126-138.
  25. Kjonstad, B.,Willmott, H.(1995).Business ethics: Restrictive or empowering.Journal of Business Ethics,14(6),445-464.
  26. Liu, S. C.(2020).How can corporations adopt Confucianism in business practices? Two representative cases.Business Ethics: A European Review,29(4),796-809.
  27. Nisbett, R. E.(2003).The geography of thought: How Asians and Westerners think differently...and why.New York, NY:The Free Press.
  28. OECD. 2015. G20/OECD Principles of corporate governance. https://www.oecd.org/corporate/principles-corporategovernance/. Accessed May 30, 2021.
  29. Patton, M. Q.(2002).Qualitative research & evaluation method.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  30. Pojman, L.(1995).Ethics: Discovering right and wrong.Belmont, CA:Wadsworth.
  31. Richard, J.,Richard, S.(2007).The elements of moral philosophy.New York, NY:McGraw Hill.
  32. Rodriguez-Dominguez, L.,Gallego-Alvarez, I.,GarciaSanchez, I. M.(2009).Corporate governance and codes of ethics.Journal of Business Ethics,90(2),187-202.
  33. Rubin, H. J.,Rubin, I. S.(1995).Qualitative interviewing: The art of hearing data.London, UK:Sage Publications.
  34. Schein, E. H.(1992).The role of the CEO in the management change: The case of information technology.Transforming organizations,New York, NY:
  35. The World Bank. 2016. Corporate governance. https://www.worldbank.org/en/search?q=corporate+governance. Accessed May 30, 2021.
  36. Tsai, T.,Young, M. N.,Cheng, B. F.(2011).Confucian business practices and firm competitiveness: The case of Sinyi real estate.Frontiers of Business Research in China,5(3),317-343.
  37. Wang, X.,Li, F.,Sun, Q.(2018).Confucian ethics, moral foundations, and shareholder value perspectives: An exploratory study.Business Ethics: A European Review,27(3),260-271.
  38. Wayne, S. J.,Liden, R. C.(1995).Effect of impression management on performance ratings: A longitudinal study.Academy of Management Journal,38(1),232-260.
  39. Weber, M. 1930. The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. New York, NY: Routledge.
  40. Woods, P. R.,Lamond, D. A.(2011).What would Confucius do?—Confucianism and self-regulation in management.Journal of Business Ethics,102(4),669-683.
  41. Yin, R. K.(2003).Case study research: Design and methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
  42. Yin, R. K.(1981).The case study crisis: Some answer.Administrative Science Quarterly,26(1),58-65.
  43. Zhang, H.,Cone, M. H.,Everett, A. M.,Elkin, G.(2011).Aesthetic leadership in Chinese business: A philosophical perspective.Journal of Business Ethics,101(3),475-491.
  44. 丁志達, Z. D.(2013).企業倫理.台北=Taipei:揚智文化事業=Yang-Chih Book Co..
  45. 中華文化永續發展基金會=Foundation of Chinese Culture for Sustainable Development(2018)。,台北=Taipei:中華文化永續發展基金會=Foundation of Chinese Culture for Sustainable Development。
  46. 天下雜誌，2021。2021《天下》韌性企業調查：疫情之年，逆轉勝 200 贏家榜單。https://www.cw.com.tw/article/5114810?template=transformers。搜尋時間：2021 年 10 月 20 日。(Commonwealth Magazine. 2021. Enterprise survey on resilience: The year of the epidemic, reversing the top 200 winners list in 2021. https://www.cw.com.tw/article/5114810?template=transformers. Accessed October 20, 2021.)
  47. 方穎嫻, Y. X.(1996).先秦之仁義禮說.台北=Taipei:文津出版社=Wenchin Publishing.
  48. 王邦雄, P. H.,曾昭旭, C. H.,楊祖漢, C. H.(2018).論語義理疎解.台北=Taipei:鵝湖出版社=Goose Lake Publishing.
  49. 王品集團=Wangprime(2020).王品企業社會責任報告書.台中=Taichung:王品集團=Wangprime.
  50. 台灣金融監督管理委員會證券期貨局，2020。公司治理簡介。https://www.sfb.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=882&parentpath=0%2C8。搜尋日期：2021 年 9 月 3 日。(Financial Supervisory Commission Securities and Futures Bureau. 2020. Introduction to corporate governance. https://www.sfb.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=882&parentpath=0%2C8. Accessed September 3, 2021.)
  51. 台灣證券交易所公司治理中心，2021，歷屆公司治理評鑑。https://cgc.twse.com.tw/evaluationCorp/listCh。搜尋日期：2021 年 11 月 20 日。(Taiwan Stock Exchange Corporate Governance Center. 2021. Previous corporate governance evaluations. https://cgc.twse.com.tw/evaluationCorp/listCh. Accessed November 20, 2021.)
  52. 朱建民, J. M.(1994).儒家的管理哲學.台北=Taipei:漢藝色研出版社=Hanyi Seyan Press.
  53. 牟宗三, T. S.(1983).中國哲學十九講：中國哲學之簡述及其所涵蘊問題.台北=Taipei:臺灣學生書局=Taiwan Student Bookstore.
  54. 牟宗三, T. S.(1974).中國哲學的特質.台北=Taipei:臺灣學生書局=Taiwan Student Bookstore.
  55. 李翔海, X. H.(2017).內聖外王：儒家的境界.南京=Nanking:江蘇人民出版社=Jiangsu People's Publishing.
  56. 李瑞全, S. C.(1999).儒家生命倫理學.台北=Taipei:鵝湖=Goose Lake.
  57. 李樑堅, L. C.(2017).論語百句說管理.台北=Taipei:麗文文化=Liwen Culture.
  58. 周佳敏, C. M.(2021)。國立臺灣大學心理學研究所=Institute of Psychology, National Taiwan University。
  59. 信義企業集團=Sinyi Group(2020).信義企業社會責任報告書.台北=Taipei:信義企業集團=Sinyi Group.
  60. 風傳媒，2021。風傳媒專訪：對兩大房仲品牌的觀察與經營建議。https://markit.co/views/brandequity/?fbclid=IwAR17fa-9JgEf8vvaEvLuX5WgP6ccWgYQuL9Kofy2rKVn OZxXxRcdxMSoL9E。搜尋日期：2021 年 12 月 5日。(Wind Media. 2021. Interview with Wind media: Observations and management suggestions on the two major real estate brokerage brands. https://markit.co/views/brandequity/?fbclid=IwAR17fa-9JgEf8vvaEvLuX5WgP6ccWgYQuL9Kofy2rKVn OZxXxRcdxMSoL9E. Accessed December 5, 2021.)
  61. 孫震, C.(2018).半部論語治天下：論語選譯今釋.台北=Taipei:遠見天下文化=Commonwealth Publishing.
  62. 孫震, C.(2021).孔子新傳：尋找世界發展的新模式.台北=Taipei:遠見天下文化=Commonwealth Publishing.
  63. 高思謙=Kao. S. Q.(1983).中外倫理哲學比較研究.台北=Taipei:中央文物供應社=Central Cultural Relics Supply Agency.
  64. 張振山, C. S.(2020).公司治理理論與實務.台北=Taipei:財團法人中華民國證券暨期貨發展基金會=Chinese Securities and Futures Development Foundation.
  65. 張海鵬, H. P.,王廷元, T. Y.(1995).徽商研究.合肥=Hefei:安徽人民出版社=Anhui People Publishing.
  66. 張德勝, D. S.,金耀基, Y. J.,陳海文, H. W.,陳建民, J. M.,楊中芳, Z. F.,趙志裕, Z. Y.,伊莎白(2001)。論中庸理性：工具理性，價值理性和溝通理性之外。社會學研究，2，33-48。
  67. 陳松山, S. S.,孔羿琁, I. H.,黃德舜, D. S.(2015)。公司治理品質與企業經濟附加價值。評價學報，9，45-72。
  68. 陳勁甫, C. F.,許金田, C. T.(2016).企業倫理：內外部管理觀點與個案.台北=Taipei:前程文化=Vital Wellspring Group.
  69. 曾昭旭, C. H.(1983).道德與道德實踐.台北=Taipei:漢光文化=Hanguang Culture.
  70. 曾炳霖, B. L.(2002)。內外機制並行提昇管理效能，淺談公司治理—以安隆案為中心。會計研究月刊，205，65-83。
  71. 黃文雄, W. X.,蕭志強（譯）, Z. Q.(Trans.)(2013).儒禍.台北=Taipei:前衛出版社=Avanguard Publishing.
  72. 黃光國, K. K.(1995)。儒家價值觀的現代轉化：理論分析與實徵研究。本土心理學研究，3，276-338。
  73. 葉保強, P. K.(2018)。儒商、徽商與朱子。真·君子商贏之道，沙田=Shatin:
  74. 葉保強, P. K.,何順文, S. W.(2020).創辦人價值與公司文化構建：何善衡與恆生銀行早期文化.九龍=Kowloon:信報出版=Hong Kong Economic Journal Publishing.
  75. 葉銀華, Y. H.(2015)。公司治理的真締。會計研究月刊，354，18-19。
  76. 劉國建, G. J.(2003)。論儒家經營理念的系統層次性及其價值功能。廣東工業大學學報：社會科學版，3(2)，71-74。
  77. 樊和平, H. P.(1995).中國人文管理.台北=Taipei:五南出版社=Wunan Publishing.
  78. 蔡仁厚, J. H.(1988).中國哲學史大綱.台北=Taipei:學生書局=Student Bookstore.
  79. 鄭伯壎, B. S.(1995)。差序格局與華人組織行為。本土心理學研究，3，142-219。
  80. 鄧子龍, Z. L.,謝亭亭, T. T(2018)。達則兼濟天下：從君子企業家到君子企業文化。真·君子商贏之道，沙田=Shatin:
  81. 蕭瑞麟, R. L.(2006).不用數字的研究：鍛鍊深度思考力的質性研究.台北=Taipei:培生國際=Pearson International.
  82. 澀澤榮一, E.,蔡哲茂（譯）, Z. M.(Trans.),吳壁雍（譯）, B. Y.(Trans.)(2010).論語與算盤.台北=Taipei:允晨文化=Asian Culture.
  83. 羅庚辛, K. H.(1992)。孔子管理思想之研究。管理與哲學研討會論文集
  84. 顧立雄, L. H.(2019)。深化我國公司治理與強化企業社會責任。證券服務，669，5-9。
print cancel