融入UbD設計架構與成果導向教育理論於課程教學成效之研究

Combining the Understanding by Design and Outcome-Based Education Theories to Improve Student Learning Performance

10.6870/JTPRHE.201806_2(1).0001

黃燕萍(Yan-Ping Huang)

成果導向教育理論 ； 理解設計理論 ； 創新教學 ； outcome-based education ； understanding by design ； innovative teaching

大學教學實務與研究學刊

2卷1期（2018 / 06 / 30）

1 - 24

繁體中文

過去強調做中學的教學成效演變成現在適性揚才的時代，強調學生學用合一的教學成效，學習成果重點已經從課業分數，轉向學生學習歷程與擁有的就業職能。如何讓學生有學用合一的學習成效，因此本研究利用重視學生理解的課程設計架構與成果導向學習理論，形成理解設計課程品質成果導向（understanding by design and outcome-based education, UDOBE）學習理論進行課程教材設計，讓學生有基礎概念與達成職能品質目標，搭配實作設計個案探討，採用多元評分方式。研究結果顯示，透過UDOBE學習理論進行學習，有助於學生學習成效，讓學生具備良好的就業職能。

Traditional ＂practical learning＂ pedagogy has led to an outcome-based model in an era that focuses on ＂teaching in accordance with students' aptitude.＂ The emphasis has shifted from classroom scores to students' learning process and practical capabilities. Therefore, this paper proposes a combination of understanding by design (UbD) and outcome-based education theory (known collectively as UDOBE theory). This study developed a computer game design course to evaluate the validity of the theory. The course was designed using the UDOBE framework, which provides information regarding basic concepts, and the course consists of case studies on game design, hands-on exercises, game project development, and thorough demonstration. Students' performance was evaluated using multiple grading systems. Using the UDOBE framework and multiple grading systems significantly increased students' outcome-based learning performance and facilitated their acquisition of practical skills.

1. Brandt, R.(1993).On outcome-based education: A conversation with Bill Spady.Educational Leadership,50,66-70.
2. Earle, M. T.,Wyatt, J. E.(2014).Preparing to teach STEM in middle school using understanding by design framework: Focus on using CAD in creative arts.2014 IEEE Integrated STEM Education Conference
3. Gagne, R. M.(1974).Essentials of learning for instruction.Hillsdale, Il:The Dryden Press.
4. Gronlund, N. E.(1970).Stating behavioral objectives for classroom instruction.New York, NY:Macmillan.
5. Gultig, J.(Ed.),Lubisi, C.(Ed.),Parker, B.(Ed.),Wedekind, U.(Ed.)(1998).Understanding outcomes based education: Teaching and assessment in South Africa.Johnnesburg, South Africa:SAIDE.
6. Hargreaves , A.,Moore, S.(2000).Curriculum integrat ion and classroom relevance: A study of teachers' practice.Journal of Curriculum Supervision,15(2),89-112.
7. Hassan, S.,Admodisastro, N. I.,Kamaruddin, A. B.,Salmi, P.,Noraini, C.(2016).Developing a learning outcome-based question examination paper tool for Universiti Putra Malaysia.International Education Studies,9(2),132-140.
8. Huang, Y. P.(2012).Diffusion innovation, perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of information technology.Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on e-Learning, e-Business, Enterprise Information Systems, and e-Government,Athens, GA:
9. Huang, Y. P.,Huang, Y. M.(2013).Programming language learning supported by an accredited course strategy.Proceedings of the 13th IEEE International Advanced Learning Technologies
10. Huang, Y. P.,Shih, W. K.,Lee, J. D.,Chen, T. Y.,Jhang, N. Y.,Chen, C.,Yang, C. W.(2014).A study of mobile embedded technology and on line nuclear energy education learning using the Tsing Hua open-pool reactor.International Journal of Modern Education Forum,3(1),31-33.
11. Huang, Y. P.,Wei, H. W.,Chen, T. Y.,Jhang, N. Y.,Chen, C.,Chen, Y. C.,Shih, W. K.(2015).The effectiveness of integrating somatosensory technology into nuclear energy education learning.Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences,173,476-482.
12. Johnson, M., Jr.(1967).Definitions and models in curriculum theory.Educational Theory,17(2),127-140.
13. Keane, L.,Keane, M.(2016).STEAM by design.Design and Technology Education,21(1),61-82.
14. King, J. A.,Evans, K. M.(1991).Can we achieve outcome-based education.Educational Leadership,49,73-75.
15. Liang, Y. L.,Chen, G. D.,Yang, S. J.(2013).Construction of cognitive maps to improve e-book reading and navigation.Computers & Education,60(1),32-39.
16. Limon, M. R.,Castillo, V.,John, P.(2016).Outcomes-based education integration in home economics program: An evaluative study.Journal of Educational Issues,2(1),289-304.
17. Lui, G.,Shum, C.(2012).Outcome-based education and student learning in managerial accounting in Hong Kong.Journal of Case Studies in Accreditation and Assessment,2,1-13.
18. McTighe, J., & Wiggins, G. (2012). Understanding by design framework. Ret r ieved f rom h t tp: / /www.as cd.org/ASCD/pdf / s i teASCD/publications/UbD_WhitePaper0312. pdf
19. McTighe, J.、Wiggins, G.、賴麗珍譯(2008)。重理解的課程設計―專業發展實用手冊。臺北:心理。
20. Michael, N. A.,Libarkin, J. C.(2016).Understanding by design: Mentored implementation of backward design methodology at the university level.Bioscene: Journal of College Biology Teaching,42(2),44-52.
21. Smyth, J.,Dow, A.(1998).What's wrong with outcomes? Spotter planes, action plans, and steerage of the educational workplace.British Journal of Sociology of Education,19,291-303.
22. Spady, W. D.(2001).Beyond counterfeit reforms: Forging an authentic future for all learners.Lanham, MD:Scarecrow Press.
23. Spady, W. G.(1994).Choosing outcomes of significance.Educational Leadership,51,18-22.
24. Spady, W. G.(1977).Competency based education: A bandwagon in search of a definition.Educational Research,6(1),9-14.
25. Spady, W. G.(1981).Outcome-based instructional management: A sociological perspective.Washington, DC:National Institute of Education.
26. Spady, W. G.(1988).Organizing for results: The basis of authentic restructuring and reform.Educational Leadership,46(2),4-8.
27. Spady, W. G.,Marshall, K. J.(1991).Beyond traditional outcome-based education.Educational Leadership,49,67-72.
28. Terry, B.(2011).Understanding engineering by design [TM] perceptions.Technology and Engineering Teacher,70(4),21-24.
29. Tyler, R. W.(1950).Basic principles of curriculum and instruction.Chicago, IL:University of Chicago press.
30. Wiggins, G.,McTighe, J.(2005).Understanding by design.Alexandria, VA:The Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
31. 李坤崇(2009)。成果導向教育的大學課程革新。教育研究月刊，181，100-116。
32. 李坤崇(2009)。成果導向的課程發展模式。教育研究月刊，186，39-58。