题名

環境法的實效：實證證據說明什麼？

并列篇名

The Effectiveness of Environmental Law: What Does the Evidence Tell Us?

作者

Michael G. Faure；廖宗聖

关键词

環境法 ； 環境法制的實效 ； 實證研究 ； 實證證據解釋 ； 環境政策手段 ； environmental law ； effectiveness of environmental law ； empirical research ； empirical evidences interpretation ； environmental policy instrument

期刊名称

台灣國際法學刊

卷期/出版年月

17卷1期（2020 / 11 / 01）

页次

123 - 162

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

在制定環境法以及選擇環境政策時，環境法學者期望尋求可以促進永續發展的環境法制及具體政策，然而，那些被選中的方法是否真的有效？本文將先提出一些關於各種環境法制及政策實效的實證結果，並在眾多研究中做適當的選擇，使讀者能夠對這些實證研究有所感覺，接著處理並詮釋這些實證研究結果。本文探討的面向有四：（1）決定環境品質的概括研究；（2）關於特定環境法制及政策的具體手段；（3）環境法制的執法；（4）實證研究帶來的機會與挑戰。本文認為實證研究可為環境法學者提供機會，同時也提出挑戰，但只要依照正確的背景情況，謹慎詮釋實證研究結果，即可發揮其應有效用。
英文摘要

Legal scholars pursue various environmental instruments (laws and policies) to reduce environmental harm and to promote sustainable development. The question is to what extent the theoretical assumptions, on which much of our environmental governance is based, in fact work in practice. This article integrates two approaches: First, the author briefly looks at what theory tells us about how environmental law should work. Second, the author spends most of time at looking at the empirical evidence and makes the deep insight into the environmental law effectiveness through plenty of empirical evidences. There are four main parts in the article, including environmental quality determination studies, environmental policy instruments researches, environmental law enforcement and empirical research opportunities and challenges. Finally, this article argues that empirical research does provide many opportunities and useful information for environmental lawyers, but has to be interpreted with caution.
主题分类 社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. Ackerman, B.,Stewart, R.B.(1988).Reforming environmental law: the democratic case for market incentives.Colum. J. Asian L.,13,171-199.
  2. Anant, T.C.A.,Singh, J.(2002).An Economic Analysis of Judicial Activism.EPW,37,4433-4439.
  3. Babbitt, D.J.,Cory, D.C.,Kruchek, B.L.(2004).Discretion and Criminalization of Environmental Law.Duke Envtl. L. & Pol'y F.,15(1),2-4.
  4. Baldwin, R.(2008).LSE, Working PaperLSE, Working Paper,未出版
  5. Barrett, J.J.(1992).Sentencing Environmental Crimes under the United States Sentencing Guidelines: A Sentencing Lottery.Envtl. L.,22,1421-1427.
  6. Becker, G.S.(1968).Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach.J. Polit. Econ.,76(2),169-217.
  7. Becker, G.S.(1983).A theory of competition among pressure groups for political influence.Q. J. Econ.,98,371-400.
  8. Bell, R.,Russell, C.(2002).Environmental policy for developing countries.Issues Sci Technol,18(3),63-70.
  9. Bell,McGillivray, D.(2006).Environmental Law.
  10. Billiet, C.,Rousseau, S.(2005).De zachte rechtshandhaving in het bestuurlijke handhavingspoor: de inspectiebeslissing en het voortraject van bestuurlijke sancties. Een rechtseconomische analyse.Tijdschrift voor Milieurecht,18-19.
  11. Billiet, C.,Rousseau, S.(2003).De hoogte van strafrechtelijke boetes. Een rechtseconomische analyse van milieurechtspraak (1990-2000) van het Hof van Beroep te Gent.TIJDSCHR. MILIEUR,2,120-131.
  12. Binder, S.,Neumayer, E.(2005).Environmental Pressure Group Strength and Air Pollution: an Empirical Analysis.Ecol. Econ.,55,527-538.
  13. Blackman, A.(2009).Columbia's discharge fee programme: incentives for polluters or regulators?.J. Environ. Manage.,90,101-119.
  14. Bluffstone, R.A.,Panayotou, T.(2000).Environmental Liability and Privatisation in Central and Eastern Europe: Towards an Optimal Policy.ERE,29,335-352.
  15. Bongaert, J.,Kraemer, R.A.(1987).Water pollution charges in three countries. Control through incentives.Eur EnvtlL Rev,12-19.
  16. Bös, D.(ed.),Rose, M.(ed.),Seidl, Chr.(ed.)(1988).Welfare and efficiency in public economics.
  17. Braithwaite, J.(1989).Crime, Shame and Reintegration.
  18. Buchanan, J.,Tullock, G.(1975).Polluters' profits and political response: direct controls versus taxes.Am. Econ. Rev.,65,139-147.
  19. Cha, J. Mijin(2005).A Critical Examination of the Environmental Jurisprudence of the Courts of India.Alb L Envtl Outlook,10,197-211.
  20. Cooter, R.(1984).Prices and Sanctions.Colo. L. Rev.,84,1523-1560.
  21. Dam, S.(2003).Green Laws for Better Health: the Past that was and the Future that may be - Reflections from the Indian Experience.Geo. Int'l Envtl. L. Rev.,16,593-608.
  22. Dewees, D.(1992).The Comparative Efficacy of Tort Law and Regulation for Environmental Protection.GENEVA PAP R I-ISS P,17,446-467.
  23. Dewees, D.N.,Duff, D.,Trebilcock, M.(1996).Exploring the Domain of Accident Law: Taking the Facts Seriously.
  24. Divan, S.,Rosencranz, A.(2001).Environmental Law and Policy in India. Cases, Materials and Statutes.
  25. Douma, W.Th.,Massai, L.,Montini, M.(2007).The Kyoto Protocol and beyond: Legal and policy challenges of climate change.
  26. Earnhart, D.(2004).Liability for Past Environmental Contamination and Privatization.ERE,29,97-122.
  27. Easterbrook, F.(1983).Criminal Procedure as a Market System.J. Legal Stud.,12,289-332.
  28. Endres, A.,Ohl, C.(2005).Kyoto, Europe? An economic evaluation of the European Emissions Trading Directive.Eur JL & Econ,19,17-39.
  29. Esty, D.C.,Porter, M.(2005).National Environmental Performance: an Empirical Analysis of Policy Results and Determinants.Environ Dev Econ,10,391-434.
  30. Esty, D.C.,Porter, M.E.(1998).Industrial Ecology and Competitiveness.J. Ind. Ecol.,2,35-43.
  31. Faure, M.(ed.),Verheij, A.(ed.)(2007).Shifts in Compensation for Environmental Damage.
  32. Faure, M.,Peeters, M.(2008).Climate change and European emissions trading: Lessons for theory and practice.
  33. Faure, M.,Ubachs, S.(2005).Harmful tax measures and greying of taxation in the Netherlands: what went wrong?.Critical Issues in Environmental Taxation: Vol. II: International and Comparative Perspectives
  34. Faure, M.G.,Svatikova, K.(2010).Enforcement of Environmental Law in the Flemish Region.European Energy and Environmental Law Review,19,60-79.
  35. Faure, M.G.,Svatikova, K.(2009).EA, Working PaperEA, Working Paper,未出版
  36. Fenn, P.,Veljanovski, C.(1988).A Positive Economic Theory of Regulatory Enforcement.EJ,98,1055-1071.
  37. Frey, B.S.(1997).Morality and Rationality in Environmental Policy.J Consum Policy,22,395-417.
  38. Frey, B.S.(1997).Not Just for the Money: An Economic Theory of Personal Motivation.
  39. T. Goeschl & G. Perino, Instrument Choice and Motivation: Evidence from a Climate Change Experiment (Working Paper, 2009).
  40. Hahn, R.W.(1989).Economic prescriptions for environmental problems: how the patient followed the doctor's orders.J. Econ. Persp.,3(2),5-114.
  41. Hahn, R.W.,Hester, G.L.(1989).Where did all the markets go? An analysis of EPA's emissions trading programme.Yale J. Regulation,6,109-153.
  42. Hansjürgens, B.(ed.)(2005).Emissions trading for climate policy, US and European perspective.
  43. Harford, J.D.,Harrington, W.(1991).A Reconsideration of Enforcement Leverage when Penalties Are Restricted.J. Pub. Econ.,45,391-395.
  44. Harrington, W.(1988).Enforcement Leverage when Penalties are Restricted.J. Pub. Econ.,37,29-53.
  45. Harrington, W.(ed.),Morgenstern, R.D.(ed.),Sterner, Th.(ed.)(2004).Choosing environmental policy: Comparing instruments and outcomes in the United States and Europe.
  46. Jost, P.J.(1996).Limited Liability and the Requirement to Purchase Insurance.Int'l Rev. L. & Econ.,16,259-276.
  47. Kreiser, L.A.(ed.)(2002).Critical Issues in International Environmental Taxation: Insights and Analyses for Achieving Environmental Policy Goals through Tax Policy.
  48. Kuznets, S.(1995).Economic Growth and Income Inequality.Am. Econ. Rev.,49,1-28.
  49. Lye, Lin-Heng(ed.),Milne, Janet(ed.),Ashiabor, Hope(ed.),Deketelaere, Kurt(ed.),Kreiser, Larry(ed.)(2009).Critical Issues in Environmental Taxation: Volume VII: International and Comparative Perspectives
  50. Maloney, M.T.,McCormick, R.E.(1982).A positive theory of environmental quality regulation.J.L. & Econ.,25,99-123.
  51. Monti, A.(2001).Environmental Risk: a Comparative Law and Economics Approach to Liability and Insurance.Eur. Rev. Private L.,1,51-79.
  52. Nash, J.R.,Revesz, R.L.(2007).NYU Law Sch. Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper SeriesNYU Law Sch. Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper Series,未出版
  53. Oates, W.E.,Portney, P.R.,McGartland, A.M.(1989).The net benefits of incentive-based regulation: a case study of environmental standard setting.Am. Econ. Rev.,79,1233-1244.
  54. O'Connor, D.(1998).Applying economic instruments in developing countries: from theory to implementation.Environ Dev Econ,4,96-97+108.
  55. Peeters, M.(2006).Inspection and Market-Based Regulation through Emissions Trading: The Striking Reliance on Self-Monitoring, Self-Reporting and Verification.ULR,2(1),177-195.
  56. Peeters, M.(2006).Enforcement of the EU Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme.EU Climate Change Policy: The Challenge of New Regulatory Initiatives
  57. Peeters, M.,Deketelaere, K.(2006).EU climate change policy. The challenge of new regulatory initiatives.
  58. Pigano, A.,Prost, S.,Van Rompuy, J.(2000).Alternative environmental regulation schemes for the Belgian power generation sector.ERE,16,121-160.
  59. Polborn, M.(1998).Mandatory Insurance and the Judgment-proof Problem.Int'l Rev. L. & Econ.,18,141-146.
  60. Ponsaers, P.,De Keulenaer, S.(2003).Met strafrecht tegen milieudelicten? Rol en functie van bijzondere inspectiediensten in de strijd tegen milieucriminaliteit.Panopticon,24,250-265.
  61. Porter, M.E.(ed.),Sachs, J.(ed.)(2000).The Global Competitiveness Report 2000.
  62. Pozzo, B.(1996).The Liability Problem in Modern Environmental Statutes.Eur. Rev. Private L.,4,112-129.
  63. Raja, A.V.,Xavier, F.(2007).A.V. Raja & F. Xavier, Regulatory Failure and the Economic Efficiency of Public Interest Litigation 12-17 (2007) (unpublished manuscript)..
  64. Raja, A.V.,Xavier, F.(2005).Department of Economics, UoH, Working PaperDepartment of Economics, UoH, Working Paper,未出版
  65. Raja, A.V.,Xavier, F.(2005).SNU, Working PaperSNU, Working Paper,未出版
  66. Rajamani, L.(2007).Public Interest Environmental Litigation in India: Exploring Issues of Access, Participation, Equity, Effectiveness and Sustainability.J Envtl L,19(3),293-317.
  67. Rousseau, S.(2007).CES, Working PaperCES, Working Paper,未出版
  68. Rousseau, S.(2010).Evidence of a filtered approach to environmental monitoring.Eur JL & Econ,29(2),195-209.
  69. Rousseau, S.(2007).Timing of Environmental Inspections: Survival of the Compliant.J. Pub. Econ.,32(1),17-36.
  70. Rousseau, S.(2007).CES, Working PaperCES, Working Paper,未出版
  71. Schoep, G.K.,Schuyt, P.M.(2008).Feiten en percepties van de sanctionering van milieudelicten en delicten betreffende de volksgezondheid.
  72. Selden, Th. M.,Song, D.(1995).Neoclassical Growth, the J-curve for Abatement, and the Inverted U-curve for Pollution.JEEM,29,162-168.
  73. Shavell, S.(1984).A Model of the Optimal Use of Liability and Safety Regulation.RJE,15,271-280.
  74. Shavell, S.(1980).Strict Liability versus Negligence.J. Legal Stud.,9,1-25.
  75. Shavell, S.(1984).Liability for Harm versus Regulation of Safety.J. Legal Stud.,13,257-274.
  76. Shavell, S.(1986).The Judgment-proof Problem.Int'l Rev. L. & Econ.,6,43-58.
  77. Shen, J.,Hashimoto, Y.(2004).J. Econ. & Bus., Working PapersJ. Econ. & Bus., Working Papers,未出版
  78. Stewart, R.B.(2000).Economic incentives for environmental protection: opportunities and obstacles.Environmental Law, The Economic and Sustainable Development
  79. Stewart, R.B.(1988).Controlling environmental risks through economic incentives.Colum. J. Asian L.,13,153-169.
  80. Tietenberg, T.H.(ed.)(1992).Innovation in Environmental Policy.
  81. Tol, R.S.J.(2009).The economic effects of climate change.J. Econ. Persp.,23(2),29-51.
  82. van Velthoven., B.C.J.(2009).Empirics of Tort.Tort Law and Economics
  83. Wang, H.,Wheeler, D.(2005).Financial incentives and endogenous enforcement in China's pollution levy system.J. Envtl. Econ. & Mgmt.,49(1),174-196.
  84. Wittman, D.A.(1977).Prior Regulation versus Post Liability: the Choice between Input and Output Monitoring.J. Legal Stud.,6,193-211.
  85. Zhu, Da,Ru, Jiang(2008).Strategic environmental assessment in China: motivations, politics and effectiveness.J. Environ. Manage.,88,615-626.
print cancel