利用多生理訊號探討熱凝療法之療效

The Evaluation of Radiofrequency coagulation efficacy by Multiple Physiological Parameters

10.6840/cycu201700781

林詠哲

熱凝治療 ； 心電圖 ； 光體積變化描記圖 ； 膚電反應 ； RF ； RCG ； PPG ； GSR

中原大學生物醫學工程學系學位論文

2017年

碩士

莊炯承

繁體中文

動機:疼痛治療的目的在於緩解疼痛的效果，大部分病患對於止痛治療，最擔心 的就是副作用問題。尋求療效高、副作用最低的治療，所以神經外科會建議使用 的緩解疼痛的方式就是「熱凝療法」，熱凝療法是以電磁波及熱能針對神經節進 行阻斷，熱凝療法在神經外科上已被廣泛的使用，但熱凝療法的療效一直未被有 效的評估，目前針對熱凝療法療效的評估上，多以視覺類比刻度（visual-analog scale, VAS）進行評估，VAS 量表對於老年人與無法表達的患者會有不便，如此 會讓疼痛評估會出現誤差，所以需要有更客觀的熱凝療法療效的評估方式。 目的:本研究藉由擷取生理訊號，針對熱凝治療前後的療效進行探討，並量測治 療前後的 VAS。以及利用心電圖 (Electro-cardiography, ECG)探討治療前後心律 變異度的改變（Heart rate variability, HRV），且記錄膚電反應(Galvanic skin response, GSR)和光體積變化描記圖(Photoplethysmography, PPG)，並針對相關參 數與療效探討。 方法:本研究收取 60 位慢性疼痛患者，並將患者分為實驗組與控制組各 30 人， 硬體設計方面包含 ECG、PPG 以及 GSR 的生理訊號擷取裝置與資料擷取介面 卡，同步擷取十分鐘受測者在療程前後的心電圖、光體積變化描記圖和膚電反應 三種生理訊號，再透過 LabVIEW 軟體分析計算出自主神經活性相關的 LF、HF 參數值，最後使用 SPSS 統計軟體進行統計分析治療前後心率、RR 間期與自主 神經活性的顯著差異性。 結果:統計結果得知視覺類比刻度尺數值有顯著下降，雖然控制組、PPG 與 GSR 沒有顯著差異存在，但在實驗組的心電圖中代表自主神經的參數值在治療前後有 顯著的差異性，表示治療後交感神經參數下降與副交感神經參數上升的趨勢，此 結果代表著患者的疼痛在接受熱凝治療後有緩解的情形發生。

Abstract Background: The chronic pain effect many patients , the purpose of pain treatment is to relieve the effect of pain, most of the patients for analgesic treatment, and they worried about the side effects. Radiofrequency coagulation is the lowest side effects and high efficacy thermotherapy. However, due to differences between individuals filled, quantitating subjective sensation of pain it is very difficult. So how to assess pain cure level is a important issue to be resolved. Purpose:The study investigated the effect of Radiofrequency coagulation treatment on the autonomic nervous activity in patients with drtected the electrocardiography (ECG), photoplethysmography (PPG) and galvanic skin response(GSR) signal for before and after Radiofrequency coagulation treatment. The aim of this study was to find the Radiofrequency coagulation treatment Efficacy for the chronic patients. Methods: This study collected experimental group and control group each 30 patients. The study measured the Radiofrequency coagulation chronic patients before and after treatment ECG, PPG and GSR three physiological signals processed by LabVIEW software analysis. Final used the SPSS statistical software (Statistic Package for Social Science, SPSS) analysis for statistical analysis. And focus on on three physiological signals in Radiofrequency coagulation before and after treatment efficacy were discussed. Results: Results statistical analysis showed that the VAS of the result has significant of decline. And ECG statistical analysis showed that autonomic nervous changed activity for cure the chronic pain level .Final proved the Radiofrequency coagulation treatment efficacy. Key Word: Radiofrequency coagulation、ECG、PPG、GSR

1. 4. Philip A. Pizzo and Noreen M. Clark, Alleviating Suffering 101 — Pain Relief
   連結：
2. 6. Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations, Pain:
   連結：
3. Current understanding of assessment, management, and treatments. . 2008.
   連結：
4. CHRONIC PAIN DESCRIPTIONS OF CHRONIC PAIN SYNDROMES AND
   連結：
5. properties of cancer multisymptom assessment instruments: a clinical review.
   連結：
6. Support Care Cancer, 2015.
   連結：
7. Fainsinger R, Kaasa S Aass N, and European Palliative Care Research
   連結：
8. heart rate variability selectively predicts cooperative behavior. Physiology &
   連結：
9. rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and
   連結：
10. of pain on autonomic nervous system indices derived from
    連結：
11. and Conrad R, Psychophysiological decoupling in alexithymic pain disorder
    連結：
12. patients. Psychiatry Research, 2016. 237: p. 316-22.
    連結：
13. of chronic pain in United States adults: results of an Internet-based survey.
    連結：
14. 17. Blyth Fm, March Lm, Brnabic Aj, Jorm Lr, Williamson M, and Cousins Mj.,
    連結：
15. Chronic pain in Australia: a prevalence study. pain, 2001(89): p. 127-34.
    連結：
16. Marcos D Dias, Prevalence of chronic musculoskeletal disorders in elderly
    連結：
17. 20. Vahid Eslami, Molly Zimmerman, Trishdeep Grewal, Mindy Katz, and
    連結：
18. An Epidemiologic Analysis of Pain in the Elderly. Journal of Aging and Health,
    連結：
19. 27. Bromm B and Scharein E, Response plasticity of pain evoked reactions in man.
    連結：
20. Physiology & Behavior, 1982. 28: p. 109-116.
    連結：
21. Furlong Pl, and Aziz Q, Psychological traits influence autonomic nervous
    連結：
22. chest pain. Neurogastroenterol Motil, 2013. 25: p. 950-e772.
    連結：
23. 1995 and 14th Conference of the Biomedical Engineering Society of India. An
    連結：
24. spectral analysis of heart rate variability. Seminars in Arthritis and
    連結：
25. Tissue oxygen saturation and finger perfusion index in central hypovolemia:
    連結：
26. T, Monitoring electrical skin conductance: a tool for the assessment of
    連結：
27. postoperative pain in children? Anaesthesiol, 2009. 111(3): p. 513-7.
    連結：
28. 34. Storm H, Changes in skin conductance as a tool to monitor nociceptive
    連結：
29. 35 stimulation and pain. Curr Opin in Anaesthesiol, 2008. 21(6): p. 796-804.
    連結：
30. compared to a developed stress score and to noxious and awakening stimuli on
    連結：
31. patients in anaesthesia. Acta Anasthesiol Scand, 2005. 49(6): p. 798-803.
    連結：
32. Heart rate, skin conductance, and their relation to verbal ratings and stimulus
    連結：
33. 38. Hampton Aj, Hadjistavropoulos T, Gagnon Mm, Williams J, and Clark D, The
    連結：
34. effects of emotion regulation strategies on the pain experience: a structured
    連結：
35. 40.Do Hyoung Kim, Seong Rok Han, Chan Young Choi, Moon Jun Sohn, and
    連結：
36. Chae Heuck Lee, Efficacy of pulsed radiofrequency medial branch treatment
    連結：
37. in low back pain patients. Journal of Back and Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation,
    連結：
38. 43. Nikolai Bogduk, Pulsed Radiofrequency. pain Medicine, 2006. 7(5): p.
    連結：
39. 44. David Byrd and Sean Mackey, Pulsed Radiofrequency for Chronic Pain. Curr
    連結：
40. Pain Headache Rep, 2008. 12(1): p. 37-41.
    連結：
41. literature available. pain Medicine, 2006. 7(5): p. 411-23.
    連結：
42. 46. Holanda Vm, Chavantes Mc, Silva Df, De Holanda Cv, De Oliveira Jo Jr, Wu
    連結：
43. X, and Anders Jj, Photobiomodulation of the dorsal root ganglion for the
    連結：
44. Medical New York. 2005.
    連結：
45. 51. Howmed Webside. ELECTROCARDIOGRAM (ECG). 2010.
    連結：
46. 52. J. Willis Hurst, Naming of the Waves in the ECG, With a Brief Account of Their
    連結：
47. Genesis. American Heart Association, 1998. 98: p. 7.
    連結：
48. Chang. Validation of Automated Arrhythmia Detection for Holter ECG. in
    連結：
49. Proceedings of the 20th Annual International Conference of the ZEEE
    連結：
50. Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society,. 1998.
    連結：
51. and Peter V Sackey, Palmar skin conductance variability and the relation to
    連結：
52. stimulation, pain and the motor activity assessment scale in intensive care unit
    連結：
53. assessment of postoperative pain by monitoring skin conductance: results of a
    連結：
54. conductance correlates with perioperative stress. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand
    連結：
55. chiropractic care on heart rate variability and pain in a multisite clinical study.
    連結：
56. Journal of manipulative and physiological therapeutics, 2006. 23: p. 7.
    連結：
57. 59. Richard A. Roy, Jean P. Boucher, and Alain S. Comtois, HEART R ATE
    連結：
58. PATIENTS VS PATIENTS IN PAIN. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological
    連結：
59. 60. Marek Malik, Heart rate variability Standards of measurement, physiological
    連結：
60. Cardiology and The North AmericanSociety of Pacing and Electrophysiology
    連結：
61. (Membership of the Task Force listed inthe Appendix). European Heart Journal
    連結：
62. 1996. 17: p. 354-381.
    連結：
63. 參考文獻
64. 1. Van Kleef, Liem, Lousberg, Barendse, Kessels, and Sluijter, Radiofrequency
65. lesion adjacent to the dorsal root ganglion for cervicobrachial pain: a
66. prospective double blind randomized study. Neurosurgery, 1996. 38(6): p.
67. 1127-31.
68. 2. Van Kleef M, Spaans F, Dingemans W, Barendse Ga, Floor E, and Sluijter Me,
69. Effects and side effects of a percutaneous thermal lesion of the dorsal root
70. ganglion in patients with cervical pain syndrome. pain, 1993. 52(1): p. 49-53.
71. 3. Slappendel R, Crul Bj, Braak Gj, Geurts Jw, Booij Lh, Voerman Vf, and De
72. Boo T, The efficacy of radiofrequency lesioning of the cervical spinal dorsal
73. root ganglion in a double blinded randomized study: no difference between 40
74. degrees C and 67 degrees C treatments. pain, 1997. 73(2): p. 159-63.
75. in the United States. New England Journal of Medicine, 2012. 366: p.
76. 5. Mattia Pacetti, Pietro Fiaschi, and Sergio Gennaro, Percutaneous
77. radiofrequency thermocoagulation of dorsal ramus branches as a treatment of
78. "lumbar facet syndrome"--How I do it. Acta Neurochir (Wien), 2016: p. 995-8.
79. 7. Dm Harold Merskey and Md Nikolai Bogduk, Phd CLASSIFICATION OF
80. DEFINITIONS OF PAIN TERMS, ed. Second. 1994, SEATTLE: IASP PRESS.
81. 8. Aynur Aktas, Declan Walsh, and Jordanka Kirkova, The psychometric
82. 9. Ahmad K. Ismail, Muhammad A. Abdul Ghafar, Noor Shaza A. Shamsuddin,
83. Nurul A. Roslan, Hilwani Kaharuddin, and Nik A. Nik Muhamad, The
84. Assessment of Acute Pain in Pre-Hospital Care Using Verbal Numerical
85. Rating and Visual Analogue Scales. The Journal of Emergency Medicine,
86. 2015. 49: p. 287–293.
87. 10. Hjermstad Mj, Fayers Pm, Haugen Df, Caraceni A, Hanks Gw, Loge Jh,
88. Collaborative (Epcrc). Studies comparing Numerical Rating Scales, Verbal
89. Rating Scales, and Visual Analogue Scales for assessment of pain intensity in
90. 33
91. adults: a systematic literature review. Journal of pain and symptom
92. management, 2011. 41: p. 1073-1093.
93. 11. Mark R., Jonesken P., Ehrhardtjuan G., Ripollbharat Sharmaira W.,
94. Padnosrachel J., and Kayealan D. Kaye, Pain in the Elderly. Curr Pain
95. Headache Rep, 2016.
96. 12. Beffara B, Bret Ag, Vermeulen N, and Mermillod M, Resting high frequency
97. Behavior 2016. 164: p. 417-28.
98. 13. A. Camm, M. Malik, J. Bigger, G. Breithardt, S. Cerutti, and R. Cohen, Heart
99. clinical use. Circulation, 1996. 93: p. 1043-1065.
100. 14. Hamunen K, Kontinen V, Hakala E, Talke P, Paloheimo M, and Kalso E, Effect
101. photoplethysmography in healthy volunteers. British Journal of Anaesthesia,
102. 2012. 108(5): p. 838-44.
103. 15. Kleiman A, Kramer Ka, Wegener I, Koch As, Geiser F, Imbierowicz K, Zur B,
104. 16. Johannes Cb, Le Tk, Zhou X, Johnston Ja, and Dworkin Rh., The prevalence
105. The Journal of Pain, 2010. 11: p. 1230–1239.
106. 18. Vivian S Miranda, Vivielle Bf Decarvalho, Luciana Ac Machado, and João
107. Brazilians: a systematic review of the literature. Musculoskeletal Disorders,
108. 2012. 13: p. 1-11.
109. 19. Stubbs B, Binnekade Tt, Soundy A, Schofield P, Huijnen Ip, and Eggermont
110. Lh, Are older adults with chronic musculoskeletal pain less active than older
111. adults without pain? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Pain Medicine,
112. 2013. 14: p. 1316-1331.
113. Richard Lipton, Pain and Sleep Disturbance in the Elderly: Evaluation the
114. Role of Stress and Depression. Neurology, 2015. 84: p. 7-310.
115. 21. Lee Je, Kahana B, and Kahana E, Social support and cognitive functioning as
116. resources for elderly persons with chronic arthritis pain. Aging Ment Health,
117. 2016.
118. 22. Alasdair Mort and Lorna Jennifer Philip, Social isolation and the perceived
119. 34
120. importance of in-person care amongst rural older adults with chronic pain: A
121. review and emerging research agend. Journal of pain management 2014.
122. 23. Reyes-Gibby Cc, Aday L, and Cleeland C, Impact of pain on self-rated health
123. in the community-dwelling older adults. PAIN, 2002. 95: p. 75-82.
124. 24. Thomas E, Peat G, Harris L, Wilkie R, and Croft Pr, The prevalence of pain
125. and pain interference in a general population of older adults: cross-sectional
126. findings from the North Staffordshire Osteoarthritis Project (NorStOP). PAIN,
127. 2004. 110: p. 361-368.
128. 25. Robert D. Helme and Stephen J. Gibson, Pain in Older People. Epidemiology
129. of Pain, 1999: p. 919-944.
130. 26. Paula R. Mobily, Keela A. Herr, M. Kathleen Clark, and Robert B. Wallace,
131. 1994. 6: p. 139-154.
132. 28. Klement W, Medert Ha, and Arndt Jo, Nalbuphine does not act analgetically
133. in electrical painful tooth pulp stimulation in man. Pain, 1992. 48: p. 169-274.
134. 29. Farmer Ad, Coen Sj, Kano M, Worthen Sf, Rossiter He, Navqi H, Scott Sm,
135. system recovery following esophageal intubation in health and functional
136. 30. K. Ikeda, Quantitative evaluation of pain by analyzing non-invasively
137. obtained physiological data with particular reference to joint healing with
138. continuous passive motion. Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society,
139. International Meeting, Proceedings of the First Regional Conference., IEEE,
140. 1995.
141. 31. Cohen H, Neumann L, Shore M, Amir M, Cassuto Y, and Buskila D,
142. Autonomic dysfunction in patients with fibromyalgia: application of power
143. Rheumatism, 2000. 29(4): p. 217-227.
144. 32. Høiseth L , Hisdal J, Hoff Ie, Hagen Oa, Landsverk Sa, and Kirkebøen Ka,
145. influence of pain. Critical Care Medicine, 2015. 43(4): p. 747-56.
146. 33. Hullett B, Chambers N, Preuss J, Zamudio I, Lange J, Pascoe E, and Ledowski
147. 35. Storm H, Shafiei M, Myre K, and Raeder J, Palmar skin conductance
148. 36. Michael Czaplik, Christa Hübner, Markus Köny, Julia Kaliciak, Fatima Kezze, Steffen Leonhardt, and Rolf Rossaint, Acute Pain Therapy in Postanesthesia
149. Care Unit Directed by Skin Conductance: A Randomized Controlled Trial. PLoS ONE, 2012. 7(7).
150. 37.Loggia Ml, Juneau M, and Bushnell Mc, Autonomic responses to heat pain:
151. intensity. pain, 2011. 152(3): p. 592-8.
152. laboratory investigation. pain, 2015. 156(5): p. 868-79.
153. 39.Smith Hp, Mcwhorter Jm, and Challa Vr, Radiofrequency neurolysis in a
154. clinical model. Neuropathological correlation. J Neurosurg, 1981. 55(2): p.
155. 246-53.
156. 2016. 29(3): p. 361-366.
157. 41. Miyazaki M, Arai Y, Myoui A, Gobara H, Sone M, Rosenthal Di, Tsushima Y,
158. Kanazawa S, Ehara S, and Endo K, Phase I/II Multi-Institutional Study of
159. Percutaneous Radiofrequency Ablation for Painful Osteoid Osteoma
160. (JIVROSG-0704). Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol, 2016. 39(10): p. 1464-70.
161. 42. Moussa Wm and Khedr W, Percutaneous radiofrequency facet capsule
162. denervation as an alternative target in lumbar facet syndrome. Clin Neurol
163. Neurosurg, 2016. 150: p. 96-104.
164. 396-407.
165. 45. Alex Cahana, Jan Van Zundert, Lucian Macrea, Maarten Van Kleef, and
166. Menno Sluijter, Pulsed radiofrequency: current clinical and biological
167. treatment of low back pain: A pilot study. LASERS IN SURGERY AND
168. 36
169. MEDICINE, 2016. 48(7): p. 653-9.
170. 47. 李和惠, 內外科護理學. 2008, 台北: 華杏出版股份有限公司.
171. 48. Ganong Wf and Barrett Ke, Review of medical physiology: McGraw-Hill
172. 49. P.A Pizzo and N.M. Clark, Alleviating Suffering 101 — Pain Relief
173. in the United States. New England Journal of Medicine, 2012. 366: p. p.
174. 197-199.
175. 50. Alila Le. Alila Medical Media webside.
176. 53. Medis. https://medis.company/cms/index.php.
177. 54. Chun-Lung Chang, Kang-Ping Lin, Te-Ho Tao, Tsai Kao, and Walter H.
178. 55. Anders C Günther, Matteo Bottai, Anna R Schandl, Hanne Storm, Patrik Rossi,
179. patients. Critical Care, 2013. 17(2): p. 1-7.
180. 56. T. Ledowski, J. Bromilow, J. Wu, M. J. Paech, H. Storm, and S. A. Schug, The
181. prospective study. Anaesthesia, 2007. 62: p. 989-993.
182. 57. H. Storm, K. Myre, M. Rostrup, O. Stokland, M. D. Lien, and J. C. R der, Skin
183. 2002. 46: p. 887-8995.
184. 58. Zhang J, Dean D, Nosco D, Strathopulos D, and Floros M, Effect of
185. VARIABILITY MODULATION AFTER MANIPULATION IN PAIN-FREE
186. Therapeutics, 2009. 32.
187. interpretation, and clinical use Task Force of The European Society of