台北市巷道停車格收費對停車行為與特性之影響-以文山內湖為例

Effects of alley on-street parking charges on parking behaviors and characteristics

林筱涵

路邊停車 ； 違規比 ； 事前與事後比較分析研究 ； street parking ； illegal parking rate ； before and after study

交通大學運輸與物流管理學系學位論文

2016年

碩士

吳宗修

繁體中文

停車政策為交通政策的一環，面對停車供需失衡的窘境，廣設停車場只是一種間接的舒緩手段，降低停車需求才是治本之道。因此不得不以收取停車費手段，適當抑制私人運具的使用與成長。本研究目的為探討台北市實施路邊汽車停車收費計畫對使用者停車行為與特性之改變，亦探討實施收費後是否真正達到其預期效果。採事前事後問卷調查法與實際停車調查法，前者研究發現實施收費後確實有達到將路邊停車格釋放出來給真正路邊停車需求者(臨時停車需求的使用者)，改善久占車位之不當利用停車格現象；後者研究發現實施收費後平均停車延時均有顯著降低之現象，達到收費之預期成效，但平均車位週轉率則皆呈現不顯著甚至沒有變化，且平均車位使用率皆呈現顯著降低之現象。另外，本研究發現實施收費後，違規比皆有顯著上升之現象；再者，進一步進行停車數量分析發現，以計時收費標準之調查時段有達到停車供需正常之改善效果(停車服務水準從D級上升至B級)，計次收費標準之調查時段則皆呈現停車供需達嚴重飽和之現象(停車服務水準從D級降低至E級)，甚至對照組(免費)路段停車行為亦受到影響，皆呈現停車供需達十分嚴重飽和之現象(停車服務水準降低)且違規比亦皆呈現顯著上升之現象。

Parking policy and traffic policy are intimately intertwined, in facing the severely imbalanced parking demand-and-supply predicament, expansion of car parks was merely an expedient. Reduction of parking demand is the true road to a permanent cure. Thus we are obliged to impact paid parking to restrain both growth in numbers and facility usage of private vehicles.The purpose of this study is to investigate how implementation of charge plan for street parking in Taipei affects users' parking behaviors and characteristics. Besides, we also want to verify whether these plans really help us to reach the expected result. In this research, we use both questionnaire and real observation to investigate the parking behavior before and after the implementation of the parking plan. The former showed that this plan really helped those who really needed a parking space found parking blocks (ex. temporary parking users) for their cars, and improper occupation of street parking blocks could help us to improve improper parking behaviors. The latter showed that the implementation of the parking fee could significantly reduce the average parking duration. However, the average parking space turn-over rate barely changed, and the average parking space occupancy decreased significantly. With another method, we found that average parking duration are significantly. Besides, after the implementation of parking fee, illegal parking rate increased significantly. In addition, further analysis for numbers of parking showed that charge based on how long drivers parked could help improve the supply and demand of street parking grids (Performance level of parking service promoted from D to B). However, charge based on number of parking times showed significant shortage of street parking grids, which even brought bad effect on toll-free sections(Performance level of parking service lowered from D to E). These toll-free sections also showed serious shortage of street parking grids and the illegal parking rate raised significantly.

1. 4. 台北市市政府交通局，103年，交通統計年報
   連結：
2. 5. 台北市市政府交通局，104年5月，交通統計月報
   連結：
3. 1. Ibeas, A., dell’Olio, L., Bordagaray, M., Ortuzar, J.de D., 2014. Modelling parking choices considering user heterogeneity. Transportation Research Part A 70, 41–49.
   連結：
4. 2. Ma, Xiaolong., Sun, Xiaoduan., He, Yulong., Chen, Yixin., 2013 Parking choice behavior investigation: A case study at Beijing Lama Temple. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 96, 2635 – 2642.
   連結：
5. 3. Wang, Rui., Yuan, Quan., (2013)Parking practices and policies under rapid motorization: The case of China. Transport Policy 30,109–116
   連結：
6. 5. Axhausen, K.W., Polak, J.W., 1991. Choice of parking: stated preference approach. Transportation 18, 59–81.
   連結：
7. 6. Hensher, D.A., King, J., 2001. Parking demand and responsiveness to supply, pricing and location in the Sydney central business district. Transp. Res. 35A, 177–196.
   連結：
8. 7. Litman, T., 2010. Transportation Cost and Benefit Analysis (II) Parking Costs. Victoria Transport Policy Institute, Victoria.
   連結：
9. 9. Shoup, D.C., 2005. The High Cost of Free Parking. Planners Press, American Planning Association, Chicago.
   連結：
10. 10. Mann, C.J., 2012. Observational research methods–Cohort studies, cross sectional studies, and case–control studies. African Journal of Emergency Medicine. 38–46.
    連結：
11. 一、中文文獻
12. 1. 葉光毅、李泳龍、黃幹忠，2005，「震災交通計畫論」，日台歷史都市防災計畫，2005年學術交流研討會，第1-9頁
13. 2. 台北市停車管理工程處，104年7月，「台北市10年停車計畫」
14. 3. 台北市停車管理工程處，104年7月，「104年全市路邊汽車格停車收費計畫」
15. 6. 台北市停車管理工程處，當我停再一起，「1991~2006停車管理施政典藏」
16. 7. 交通部統計查詢網，機動車輛登記數 (最後瀏覽日期:105.6.21)
17. http://stat.motc.gov.tw/mocdb/stmain.jsp?sys=100&funid=a3301
18. 8. Google Map 提供之內湖區地圖搜尋服務(最後瀏覽日期:104.10.20)
19. https://www.google.com.tw/maps/@25.0817944,121.5752174,17z
20. 9. Google Map 提供之文山區地圖搜尋服務(最後瀏覽日期:104.10.20)
21. https://www.google.com.tw/maps/@24.9809449,121.5549425,17z
22. 10. 台北市停車管理工程處，102 年，台北市汽機車停車供需調查(6個行政區─北區)
23. 11. 監察院，93年3月，都會地區停車問題專案調查研究報告/李友吉，李伸一，郭石吉調查研究 台北市
24. 12. 道路交通安全與執法國際研討會，93年，影響小客車駕駛人違規停車意向成因研究分析/張新立，張起豪
25. 13. 邱俊龍，「停車行為模式在停車場決策分析之研究」，國立臺灣大學土木工程研究碩士論文， 1991
26. 14. 葉祖宏，「陳述性偏好在個體停車選擇行為之研究」，國立交通大學土木工程研究所土木工程研究碩士論文， 2000
27. 15. 陳月娥，社會研究法概要，千葉出版，2015
28. 16. 楊世瑩，SPSS統計分析實務，旗標出版社股份有限公司，2011
29. 二、英文文獻
30. 4. Yun, M., Lao, Y., Ma, Y., Yang, X., 2008. Optimization model on scale of public parking lot considering parking behaviour. In: Proceedings 8th International Conference of Chinese Logistics and Transportation Professionals – Logistics: The Emerging Frontiers of Transportation and Development in China. pp. 2692–2699.
31. 8. Roth, G., 1965. Paying for Parking. Institute of Economic Affairs, London.