踝關節扭傷對本體感覺與靜態平衡能力的影響研究

The Influence of Ankle Sprains on Propriception and Static Balance Performance

10.5297/ser.200406_6(2).0021

黎俊彥(Alex J. Y. Lee)；林威秀(Wei-Hsiu Lin)；黃啟煌(C. H. Huang)

踝關節扭傷 ； 本體感覺 ； 靜態平衡 ； ankle sprain ； proprioception ； static balance

大專體育學刊

6卷2期（2004 / 06 / 01）

249 - 259

繁體中文

踝關節扭傷是最常見與普遍的下肢運動傷害，Freeman指出踝關節扭傷後會降低本體感受能力，並導致身體姿勢穩定性的降低，後續研究(Tropp Ekstrand Gillquist, 1984； Tropp, Odenrick & Gillquist, 1985)亦支持此種觀點，然而最近的研究(Bernier, Perrin & Rijke, 1997; Cornwall & Murrell, 1991)卻顯示似乎並無顯著關係存在。目的：有鑑於相關研究結果的矛盾，本研究利用精密客觀的儀器，來探討有習慣性桌扭傷與正常健康者雙腳本體感覺與站立平衡表現的關係與差異。實驗設計：本研究以16位男性大學生，實驗組共8位有單側習慣性踝扭傷徵兆患者(扭傷組)，而控制組則為8位雙桌健康無扭傷者(正常組)，本研究以BiodexⅢ等速肌力測量儀量測受試者本體感覺功能，以Kisterler測力板搭配Romberg開／閉眼單腳站立測試時，腳底壓力中心的變化作為靜態平衡能力指標。資料收集後以Pearson相關係數考驗各變項間的關係，以獨立樣本t考驗檢定兩組雙腳測試差異情形，以單因子變異數分析考驗各腳本體感覺與平衡測驗的差異。結果：研究顯示：一、個體主動復位表現與開眼或閉眼單腳站立平衡表顯有顯著關係存在；二、扭傷組受傷腳在被動復位、開／閉眼單腳測試上顯著較對側健康腳差，而被動復位與開眼單腳站立平衡表現也顯著較正常組為差。結論：踝關節扭傷的確會降低被動復位本體感覺與開／閉眼站立平衡能力，本研究顯示個體主動復位能力與平衡能力有關，因此為改善站立平衡能力應可加強此方面之復健與訓練，此外扭傷踝關節顯著較差的被動復位能力，似乎驗證個體的被動本體感覺回饋機制可能受損，而運動復健對被動復位能力的影響，與正常組雙腳不同的被動複位能力仍需進一步的研究來加以討探。

Introduction: Anlke sprains are the most common and frequent injury in sports. Freeman demonstrated that an ankle injury would decreased the propriception sensitivity and result in poor postural steadiness in 1965. Further studies (Tropp, Ekstrand, & Gillquist, 1984; Tropp, Odenrick, & Gillquist,1985) also showed similar results. More recent studies (Bernier, Perrin, & Rijke, 1997; Cornwall & Murrell, 1991) indicated that the injury of the ankle was not connection with the balance performance. Purpose: This study utilized the Kistler force plate and Biodex isokinetic dynamometer to testify the difference between subjects with functional instability and normal subjects. Methods: The ankles of 16 college-aged male subjects were tested in this study: 8 subjects with unilateral ankle sprain symptoms (I) and 8 with bilateral non injured healthy ankles (N). The BioedxⅢisokinetic dynamometer was used to assess ankle proprioception function: active and passive position sense. The static balance ability was assessed by Kistler force plate in the form of mean radius of COP (center of pressure) distribution. Pearson correlation, independent t-test and one-way ANOVA analysis were used to exam the difference between different legs (left & right ankle in N; healthy & injured ankles in I).Results: 1. There was strong correlation between active ankle reposition sense and open/close static balance abilities. 2. The injured ankle had significant poor passive ankle reposition sense and open/close static balance abilities than healthy ankles. Ohterwise, the passive ankle reposition sense and open eyes balance ability while having an injured ankle were also significantly poorer than the left & right ankle in N. Conclusions: This study clearly showed that an ankle sprain impaired the passive reposition sense and the close eyes static balance ability. The active ankle reposition sense has positive correlations with balance control. It was recommended that a rehabilitation program for sprained ankles should include proprioception training, especially in restoring the passive reposition sense. More studies are needed to examine the training or rehabilitation effects on the passive repositioning sense.

1. Amason, A.,Gudmundsson, A.,Dahl, H. A.,Johannsson, E.(1996).Soccer injuries in Iceland.Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sport,6
2. Bemier, J. N.(1995).Effect of coordination training on proprioception of the functionally unstable ankle.
3. Bemier, J. N.,Pen-in, D. H.,Rijke, A.(1997).Effect of unilateral functional instability of the ankle on postural sway and inversion and eversion strength.Journal of Athletic Training,32
4. Borsa, P. A.,Lephart, S. M.(1994).Functional assessment and rehabilitation of shoulder proprioception for glenohumeral instability.Journal of Sport Rehabilitation,3
5. Cornwall, M. W.,Murrell, W.(1991).Postural sway following inversion sprain of the ankle.Pediatry Medical Association,81
6. Freeman, M. A. R.(1965).Instability of the foot after injuries to the lateral ligament of the ankle.Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery,47B
7. Friden, T.,Zatterstrom, R.,Lindstrand, A.,Moritz, U.(1989).A stabilomertric technique for evaluation of lower limb instabilities.American Journal of Sports Medicine,17
8. Gam, S.,Newton, R.(1988).Kinesthetic awareness in subjects with multiple ankle sprains.Physicsal Theraphy,68
9. Grigg, P.(1994).Peripheral neural mechanisms in proprioception.Journal of Sport Rehabilitation,3
10. Hoffman, M.,Schrader, J.,Applegate, T.,Koceja, D.(1998).Unilateral postural control of the functionally dominant and nondominant extremities of healthy subjects.Journal of Athletic Training,33
11. Isakov, E.,Mizrahi, J.(1997).Is balance impaired by recurrent sprained ankle?.British Journal of Sports Medicine,31
12. Isakov, E.,Mizrahi, J.,Soizi, P.,Susak, Z.,Lotem, M.(1989).Response of the peroneal muscles to sudden inversion of the ankle during standing.International Journal of Sport Biomechanics,2
13. Kaminski, T, W,Pen-in, D. H.,Gansneder, B. M.(1999).Eversion strength analysis of uninjured and functionally unstable ankles.Journal of Athletic Training,34
14. Konradsen, L.,Rave, J. B.(1991).Prolonged peroneal reaction time in ankle instability.Internal Journal of Sports Medicine,12
15. Leanderson, J.,Eriksson, E.,Nilsson, C.,Wykman, A.(1996).Proprioception in classical ballet dancer: A prospective study of the influence of an ankle sprain on propriception in the ankle join.American Journal of Sports Medicine,24
16. Lentell. G.,Baas, B.,Lopez, D.,McGuire, L.,Sarrels, M.,Snyder, P.(1995).The contributions of proprioceptive deficits, muscle function, and anatomic laxity to functional instability of the ankle.Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy,21
17. Malone, T. R.(1989).Basketball injuries and treatment.Sports Injury Management: Quarterly Series,1
18. McGuine, T. A.,Greene, J. J.,Best, T.,Leverson, G.(2000).Balance as a predictor of ankle injuries in high school basketball players.Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine,10
19. McKniaht, C. M.,Armstrong, C. W.(1997).The role of ankle strength in functional ankle instability.Journal of Sport Rehabilitation,6
20. Nashner. L. M.(1993).Handbook of balance function and Testing.
21. Payne, K. A.,Berg, K.,Latin, R. W.(1997).Ankle injuries and ankle strength, flexibility, and proprioception in college basketball players.Journal of Athletic Training,32
22. Pen-in, P. P.,Bene, M. C.,Pen-in, C. A.,Durupt, D.(1997).Ankle trauma significantly impairs postural control- a study in basketball players and controls.International Journal of Sports Medicine,18
23. Smith, R.W,Reischi, S. F.(1986).Treatment of ankle sprains in young athletes.American Journal of Sports Medicine,14
24. Szczerba, J. E.,Bemier, J. N.,Pen-in, D. H.,Gansneder, B. M.(1995).Intertester reliability of active and passive ankle joint position sense training.Journal of Sport Rehabilitation,4
25. Tropp, H.,Ekstrand, J.,Gillquist, J.(1984).Stabilometry in functional instability of the ankle and its value in predicting injury.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,16
26. Tropp, H.,Odenrick, P.,Gillquist, J.(1985).Stabilometry recrodings in functional and mechanical instability of the ankle joint.International Journal of Sports Medicine,6
27. Yeung, M, S.,Chan, K.,So, C. H.(1994).An epidemiological survey on ankle sprain.British Journal of Sports Medicine,28
28. Zeiisko, J. A.,Noble, H. B.,Porter, M.(1982).A comparison of men's and women's professional basketball injuries.American Journal of Sports Medicine,10
29. 江勁政(2000)。不同項目連動選手平衡能力之定量評估。
30. 吳昇光、陳俊忠(1991)。體操運動傷害調查研究。體院論叢，2
31. 姬榮軍(2001)。老年人動態活動與下階梯動作條件下肌肉勁度調節能力之研究。大專體育學刊，3(2)
32. 謝翔星、黃啟煌(1996)。臺灣區運羽球運動傷害調查研究。大專體育，26

1. 黃彥慈,陳澤河,張博涵,洪敏豪,柯柏任(2023)。踝關節不穩定對一般大學生平衡能力的影響。臺大體育學報，45，25-33。
2. 黎俊彥、黃國堂、邱炳坤、林威秀(2009)。不同等級大專射箭選手平衡控制能力之差異。大專體育學刊，11(2)，85-96。
3. 黎俊彥、黃啟煌、林威秀(2006)。功能性不穩定踝關節對本體感覺與Hoffmann反射之影響。大專體育學刊，8(4)，125-134。
4. 黎俊彥、林威秀(2009)。身體姿勢平衡控制與踝關節傷害發生風險。中華體育季刊，23(1)，65-72。
5. 黎俊彥、彭賢德、張秀光(2013)。不同材質表面對增強式跳躍訓練影響之探討。中華體育季刊，27(3)，245-252。
6. 蘇明耀、賈叢林、黃漢年、陳秀華、張宏明(2013)。兩側性不穩定平衡控制定量評估與大學生站姿能力之研究。華人運動生物力學期刊，8，21-28。
7. (2010)。護具對排球選手平衡能力影響之研究。運動健康與休閒學刊，18，17-24。