事件性的主體：以藝術重啟「超受容性」

Evential Subject: How Art Triggers Anew Transpassibility

陳蕉(Chiao Chen)

未定的區域 ； 事件 ； 事件性的主體 ； 情感內作力－影像 ； 超受容性 ； zones of indiscernibility ； event ； evential subject ； image-affection ； transpassibility

藝術學報

102期（2018 / 06 / 01）

25 - 39

繁體中文

本文從一個有別於現代主體(modem subject)的角度，探討藝術如何在這個技術統治的世界中，讓藝術重新成為「超受容性」(transpassibility)的引發物，亦即讓人重新無預設地向著世界的未知完全敞開。藝術如何讓觀者從影像「事件所使之湧現與展現的可能性來思考自我性」？人與世界之間如何重新建立起一種「召喚」關係?影像事件如何形成情感內作力？本文將借用事件哲學家C.Romano對於事件的相關思考、H. Maldiney的「超受容性」、「召喚」、「遭逢」、G.Deleuze的「情感內作力－影像」概念，以及M. Heidegger對於技術的追問作為主要的研究方法，以兩件影像藝術作品： A. Sala的《一次又一次》和D. Claerbout的《無題，卡爾與朱莉》為例，嘗試思考探索這些問題。

From a non-modern subject's point of view, i.e. a non-substantial perspective on subject, this paper attempts to portray how, in this technocracy-ruling-world, art can trigger anew the ＂transpassibility＂ in people, that is to say to enable one to fully open oneself to the unknown without any presupposition. How can art make viewers reflect on their ipseity through the possibilities articulated in world, which are brought into being by the image-event? How can a ＂call＂ be created between the human and the world? How does an image-event produce ＂image-affection＂? Two art creations-Ann Sala's Time after Time and David Claerbout's Untitled, Carl and Julie-ere examined to help provide the answers to the above questions. The main theoretical references supporting our analysis are: Claude Romano's thinkings on eventiality, Henri Maldiney's ＂transpassibility＂, ＂call＂ and ＂encounter＂ notions, as well as Gilles Deleuze's ＂image-affection＂ concept, and Heidegger's reflections on technology.

1. Anri Sala (n, d). Retrieved from https://www.guggenheim.org/artwork/artist/Anri-Sala
2. Interview with Video Artist David Claerbout. (2016, March 24). Retrieved from http://www.aestheticamagazine.com/interview-david-claerbout/
3. Badiou, A.(1988).L'être et l'événement.Paris, France:Editions du Seuil.
4. Benjamin, W.(1968).Illuminations.New York, NY:Schocken Books.
5. Benjamin, W.、張旭東譯、魏文生譯(2010)。發達資本主義時代的抒情詩人：論波特萊爾。臺北:臉譜。
6. Bergson, H. (1939). Matièreet Mémoire: Essai sur la relation du corps à l'esprit. Paris, France: PUF.
7. Deleuze, G. (1982a). Cinéma, cours 22 du 02-11-82-3 Transcription: Fabienne Kabou Correction: Agathe Vidal. Retrieved from http://www2.univ-paris8.fr/deleuze/article.php3?id_article=160
8. Deleuze, G.(1985).Cinéma2 : L'IMAGE-TEMPS.Paris, France:Minuit.
9. Deleuze, G.(1981).Francis Bacon: Logique de la sensation.Paris, France:Edition de la difference.
10. Deleuze, G. (1982b). Cinéma, cours 22 du 02-11-82-2 Transcription: Anna Mrozek. Retrieved from http://www2.univ-paris8.fr/deleuze/article.php3?id_article=159
11. Deleuze, G. (1982c). Cours 6-12/01/82-1. Retrieved from http://www2.univ-paris8.fr/deleuze/article.php3? id_article=103
12. Dôgen(1980).Shôbôgenzo. La reserve visuelle des événement dans leur justesse.Paris, France:Edition de la Difference.
13. Freud, S.(2013).Conseils aux médecins sur le traitement analytique. La technique analytique.Paris, France:PUF.
14. Heidegger, M.,Fedier, F.(Trans.)(1976).Acheminement vers la parole.Paris, France:Gallimard.
15. Heidegger, M.,Lovitt, W.(Trans.)(1977).The Question Concerning Technology and Other Essays.New York, NY:Harper and Row.
16. Heidegger, M.、孫周興譯(1994)。林中路。臺北:時報文化。
17. Lacoue-Labarthe, P.(1986).La poésie comme expérience.Paris, France:Christian Bourgois.
18. Lévinas, E.(1990).De l'existenceàd l'exisant.Paris, France:Vrin.
19. Maldiney, H.(2003).Art et existence.Paris, France:Klincksieck.
20. Maldiney, H.(2007).Penser l'homme et la folie.Grenoble, France:Jerome Millon.
21. Megglé, V. (2007). L'attention flottante en psychanalyse. Psychanalyse en mouvement. Retrieved from http://www.psychanalyse-en-mouvement.net/actualites/article-104-20071204104-1-attention-flottante-en-psychanalyse.html
22. Merwin, W. S.(2015).Conversations with W. S. Merwin.Jackson, MS:University Press of Mississippi.
23. Miller, E. P.(1999).Harnessing Dionysos: Nietzsche on Rhythm, Time, and Restraint.Journal of Nietzsche Studies,17,1-32.
24. Ranciere, J.(1998).Aux bords du politique.Paris, France:La Fabrique-Editions.
25. Romano, C.(2005).Réponses de Claude Romano à quelques questions.Transversalités,96,53-66.
26. Romano, C.(2012).L'événement et le temps.Paris, France:PUF.
27. Romano, C.(1999).L'événementet le monde.Paris, France:PUF.