A Semi-Structured Process for ERP Systems Evaluation: Applying Analytic Network Process

應用分析網路程序法於企業資源規劃系統半結構化評選過程之研究

10.6188/JEB.2003.5(1).04

徐煥智(Huan-Jyh Shyur)

企業資源規劃 ； 分析層級程序法 ； 分析網路程序法 ； 加權計分法 ； Enterprise Resource Planning ； Analytic Hierarchy Process ； Analytic Network Process ； Weighted Score Method

電子商務學報

5卷1期（2003 / 03 / 01）

33 - 49

英文

本文提出一個包含四階段的企業資源規劃系統評選流程。在評選過程中應用分析網路程序法（Analytic Network Process, ANP）來同時解決多評估準則及準則間交互作用對決策之影響。分析網路程序法是以分析層級程序法（Analytic Hierarchy Process, AHP）為基礎並加入回饋機制所發展而成的新技術。在實例驗證中可發現利用本研究所設定之決策過程並配合分析網路程序法的應用是一個可行且確實能提升企業在評選企業資源規劃系統時的決策品質。

This paper illustrates a four-step semi-structured process for ERP system evaluation. We suggest using the Analytic Network Process (ANP) for qualitative reviews of ERP, reviews involving multiple criteria and interdependency of properties. The ANP method is based on the feedback system framework of the well-known Analytic Hierarchy Process. A case study indicates that the evaluated aspects of the method are feasible and the method improves the quality of ERP system selection compared with traditional approaches.

1. Alidi, A.(1996).Use of the Analytic Hierarchy Process to Measure the Initial Viability of Industrial Projects.International Journal of Project Management,14(4)
2. Anandalingam, G.,Olsson, C. E.(1989).A Multi-Stage Multi-Attribute Decision Model for Project Selection.European Journal of Operational Research,43
3. Baker, N.,Freeland, J.(1975).Recent Advances in R＆D Benefit Measurement and Project Selection Methods.Management Science,21(10)
4. Bernroider, E.,Koch, S.(2000).Proceeding of the Sixth Americas Conference on Information Systems.
5. Bingi, P.,Sharma, M. K.,Godla, J. K.(1999).Critical Issues Affecting an ERP Implementation.Information Systems Management,16(3)
6. Buss, M. D. J.(1983).How to Rank Computer Projects.Harvard Business Review,61(1)
7. Enzweiler, A. L.(1997).Software Giants: Get the Big Picture.CMA: the Management Accounting Magazine,71(2)
8. Finnie, G. R.,Wittig, G. E.,Petkov, D. I.(1995).Prioritizing Software Development Productivity Factors Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process.The Journal of Systems and Software,22(2)
9. Glazer, J.(1999).A Focused Method for Vendor Selector.Automatic ID News,15(2)
10. Holland, C. P.,Light, B.(1999).A Critical Success Factors Model for ERP Implementation.IEEE Software,16(3)
11. Hong, S.,Nigam, R.(1981).Proceedings of the First International Conference on Decision Support Systems.Atlanta:
12. Illa, X. B.,Franch, X.,Pastor, J. A.(2000).Proceedings of the Tenth International Workshop on Software Specification and Design.
13. Kontio, J.(1996).IEEE Proceedings of ICSE-18.
14. Langenwalter, G. A.(2000).Enterprise Resources Planning and Beyond.New York:Lucie Press.
15. Laudon, K. C.,Laudon, J. P.(1998).Management Information System - New Approaches to Organization ＆ Technology.Prentice Hall.
16. Lee, J. W.,Kim, S. H.(2000).Using Analytic Network Process and Goal Programming for Interdependent Information System Project Selection.Computer ＆ Operations Research,27(4)
17. Min, H.(1992).Selection of Software: The Analytic Hierarchy Process.International Journal of Physical Distribution ＆Logistics Management,22(1)
18. Saaty, T. L.(1996).The Analytic Network Process.Pittsburgh:RWS Publications.
19. Saaty, T. L.(1999).Fundamentals of the Analytic Network Process.Kobe Japan:ISAHP.
20. Saaty, T. L.(1980).The Analytic Hierarchy Process: Planning, Priority Setting, Resource Allocation.New York:McGraw-Hill International Book Co..
21. Saaty, T. L.,Takizawa, M.(1986).Dependence and Independence: From Linear Hierarchies to Nonlinear Networks.European Journal of Operational Research,26
22. Sanathanam, R.,Schniederjans, M. J.(1993).A Model Formulation System for Information System Project Selection.Computers ＆ Operations Research,20(7)
23. 黃慶來 Hwang, Ching-Lai,Yoon, Kwangsun(1981).Multiple Attribute Decision Making: Methods and Applications: A state-of-the-art survey.New York:Springer-Verlag.

1. 胡宜中、易慧珍、王仁宏(2012)。運用網路程序分析法探討甄選管理師與工程師之關鍵人格特質─以C國營事業為例。人力資源管理學報，12(4)，53-79。
2. 張佳縈、張志仁、胡宜中、王仁宏(2016)。運用網路分析程序法評選中華汽車電動機車通路經銷商。台北海洋技術學院學報，7(2)，48-78。