王通擬經、續經及其“儒風變古”思想析論

Discussion on the Drafting and Reading of Confucian Classics, and "Regeneration of Old Thoughts of Confucian" by Wang Tung

10.6973/CJ.200712.0001

李威熊(Wei-Xiung Li)

王通 ； 中說 ； 擬經 ； 續經 ； 儒風變古 ； Wang Tung ； Chung Shuo ； drafting of Confucian classics ； reading of Confucian classics ； regeneration of old thoughts of Confucian

國文學誌

15期（2007 / 12 / 01）

1 - 30

繁體中文

王通是隋末大儒，他的思想對唐代和宋明理學有一定的影響，但後代的學者對他的人和《中說》等著作都有懷疑；又清修《四庫全書總目提要》指王通「後來聚訟講學，釀為朋黨，以至禍延宗社者，通實為先驅。」又說他是「儒風變古」的關鍵人物，這些問題的真相如何？是本論文所要探討的重點。經由文獻的考查，王通確有其人，《中說》雖非完成於王通之手，但應是王通講學和與弟子答問的重要紀錄。他的治經方法和經學觀都可以上接孔孟；他也是把魏晉玄學轉向以義理詮釋儒經的開風氣者，宋代理學先聲，應上推到王通。

Wang Tung is a scholar at the end of Sui Dynasty. His thoughts had significant influence on the Neo-Confucianism of Tang, Song, and Ming Dynasties, yet scholars of later generations held doubts concerning Wang's existence and his publication of ”Chung Shuo”. ”Main Outline of Si Ku Quan Shu” modified in Ching Dynasty pointed out that ”Wang's lectures were the origin of cliques, and initiated clique clashes”, and also accused him as the key person causing ”regeneration of old thoughts of Confucian”. The truths to those questions are the main points of discussion in this paper. Based on literature review, Wang Tung was a real person, and though ”Chung Shuo” was not completed by Wang, it was a main record of the questions and answers exchanged between Wang and his pupils. His method and perspectives of analyzing the study of Confucian classics were consistent with those of Confucius and Mengtze, and he was also the pioneer in applying metaphysics of Wei and Jin Dynasties on interpretation of Confucian classics. Wang should be regarded as the forerunner of Neo-Confucianism of Song Dynasty.

1. (2005)。文淵閣四庫全書。北京:商務印書館。
2. 尹協理、魏明(1984)。王通論。北京:新華書店。
3. 王勃(1995)。王子安集。上海古籍出版社。
4. 王應麟(1966)。困學紀聞。台北:商務印書館。
5. 吳雁南編、秦學頎編、李禹階編(2001)。中國經學史。福建人民出版社。
6. 李昉(1979)。文苑英華。台北:新文豐出版社。
7. 姚際恆(1977)。古今偽書考。台北:開明印書店。
8. 趙吉惠編(1991)。中國儒學史。河南:中州出版社。

1. 侯雅文(2019)。「超凡印象」與陳維崧領袖地位的形成。東華漢學，29，175-210。
2. 王志浩(2018)。製作聖人：王通形象摶成及其儒學思想研究。靜宜中文學報，13，101-132。