諮商團體歷程中成員自我揭露頻率與深度之初探

The Research on the Frequency and Depth of Members' Self-Disclosure in the Process of Group Counseling

10.7040/GJ.200310.0001

吳秀碧(Shue-Pi Woo)；許育光(Yu-Kuang Hsu)；李俊良(Chun-Liang Lee)

諮商團體 ； 自我揭露 ； 團體歷程 ； 團體諮商 ； Counseling groups ； Self-disclosure ； Group process ； Group counseling

彰化師大輔導學報

25期（2003 / 10 / 01）

1 - 24

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討諮商團體的歷程中，成員自我揭露行為在頻率和深度上的變化。研究採取臨床個案觀察研究法，以及問卷調查方法進行。以兩個非結構式、各進行十次的諮商團體作為觀察對象，各分析其第二次至第九次團體聚會單元，觀察成員自我揭露行為在團體歷程中的變化，並進行分析。 研究結果顯示，自我揭露的質和量確實與團體的進行階段有明顯的關係。團體中的成員自我揭露的次數，確實隨團體歷程之進展而有不同變化：彼地彼時（there and then）的自我揭露次數在團體歷程由開始至結束，呈現逐漸下降趨勢；此地彼時（here and then）的自我揭露次數則呈現普遍出現在團體每次聚會有一定的量的現象；此地此時（here and now）的自我揭露次數則隨團體由開始至結束的歷程，呈現逐漸攀升、增多的趨勢；而情緒的宣洩（catharsis）則呈現單峰的曲線，隨著團體初期至中期逐漸上揚，接著從中期到結束又漸漸下降。此外，彼地彼時與此地此時的自我揭露頻率呈現有此消彼長的戲劇性時間點。

This research was aimed to investigate the changes occurred regarding the frequency and depth of members’ self-disclosure behaviors during counseling group process. This research had chosen the Observational Case Studies method and questionnaire as tools. The research had chosen two unstructured groups – each had experienced ten counseling sessions – as the observed cases. In each group, the research analyzed starting from the second to the ninth group meeting session. It was to observe the changes of members’ self-disclosure behaviors during group process, as well as to code the frequency and depth in each session. The results of this research were as following: (1) According to the outcome, the quality and quantity of self-disclosure were obviously related to the stages of the group development. The occurrence of members’ self-disclosure behaviors changed with the group process. (2) Dramatically, self-disclosure frequency appeared to be the opposite between “there and then” and “here and now” at a specific time point. This research based on the discoveries mentioned above, has made suggestions for future researches and implementations for group counseling.

1. Bednar, R. L.,Melnick, J.,Kaul, T.(1974).Risk, responsibility and structure: A conceptual framework for initiating group counseling and psychotherapy.Journal of Counseling Psychology,21,31-37.
2. Berg. W. R.,Gall, M. D.(1983).Education research: an introduction.New York:Longman.
3. Braaten, L.(1991).Group cohesion: A new multidimensional model.Group,15,39-55.
4. Braaten, L.(1990).The different patterns of group Climate critical incidents in high and low cohesion sessions of group psychotherapy.International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,40,477-493.
5. Catina, A.,Tschuschke, V.(1993).A summary of empirical data from the investigation of two psychoanalytic groups by means of repertory grid technique.Group Analysis,26,433-477.
6. Davis, Budman,Soldz,A. P. Beck,C. M. Lewis (Ed.)(2000).The process of group psychotherapy: System for analyzing change.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
7. Donigian, J.,Malnati, R.(1997).Systemic group therapy: A triadic model.New York:Brooks/Cole.
8. Fuhriman, A.,Barlow, S. H.,G. M. Burlingame, (ed.)(1994).Handbook of group psychotherapy: An empirical and clinical synthesis.New York:John Wiley & Sons.
9. Fuhriman, A.,Drescher, S.,Burlingame, G.(1984).Conceptualizing small group process.Small Group Behavior,15,427-440.
10. Hoffman, S.C.(1981).Notre Dame University.
11. Johnson, D. W.,Ridner, L. R.(1974).Self-disclosure, participation, and perceived cohesiveness in small group interaction.Psychological Reports,35,361-362.
12. Jourard, S. M.(1971).The transparent self.New York:Van Nostrand Reinhold.
13. Kirshner, B. J.(1976).University of Maryland.
14. Kline, W. B.(1986).Working through the risks: A structured experience to facilitate self-disclosure.Journal for Specialists in Group Work,11(4),209-212.
15. Kuppersmith, J. H.(1975).University of Mississippi.
16. Lewis, C. M.,Beck, A.P.,Dugo, J. M.,Eng, A. M.(2000).The process of group psychotherapy: Systems for analyzing change(Ed.).Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
17. MacKenzie, K. R.,Tschuschke, V.(1993).Relatedness, group work, and outcome in long-term inpatient psychotherapy groups.Journal of psychotherapy Practice and Research,2,147-156.
18. Morran, D. K.(1982).Leader and member self-disclosing behavior in counseling groups.Journal for Specialists in Group Work,7(4),218-223.
19. Robison, F.,Stockton, R.,Morran, D.(1990).Anticipated consequences of self-disclosure during early therapeutic group development.Journal of Group Psychotherapy, Psychodrama and Sociometry,43,3-18.
20. Scodz, S.,Budman, S.,Davis, M.,Demby, A.(1993).Beyond the interpersonal circumplex in group psychotherapy: The structure and relationship to outcome of the Individual Group Member Interpersonal Process Scale.Journal of Clinical Psychology,49,551-563.
21. Shechtman, Z.,Neomi, V.(1996).Does self-disclosure in friendship increase following roup counseling/therapy? A different case for boys and girls.Sex Roles,35(1-2),123-130.
22. Slavin, R. L.(1993).The significance of here-and now disclosure in promoting cohesion in group psychotherapy.Group,17(3),143-151.
23. Stone, M.,ERIC(Ed.)(1988).The effects of the changing family experience on children and adolescents and a structured group counseling model for adolescents in the school setting.
24. Tschuschke, V.,Dies, R.(1994).Intensive analysis of therapeutic factors and outcome in long-term inpatient groups.International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,44,185-208.
25. Tschuschke, V.,MacKenzie, K. R.,Haaser, B.,Janke, G.(1996).Self-disclosure, feedback, and outcome in long-term inpatient psychotherapy groups.Journal of Psychotherapy Practive and Research,5,35-44.
26. Vinogradov, S.,Yalom, I. P.,G. Stricker,M. Fisher (Ed)(1990).Self-Disclosure in the therapeutic relationship.New York, NY:Plenum Press.
27. Yalom, I. D.(1985).The theory and practice of group psychotherapy.New York, NY:Basic Books.
28. Yalom, I. D.(1995).The theory and practice of group psychotherapy.New York, NY:Basic Books.
29. 林梅鳳、張瑩如、王琪珍(1999)。護生臨床經驗分享團體－自我揭露的內涵。國立成功大學醫學院護理學系創系十週年紀念研討會

1. 簡匯育、詹文姁(2012)。親密關係團體帶領之困境：以訓練團體為例。諮商與輔導，314，36-42。
2. 林俊德(2016)。以團體歷程觀點檢視高齡者參與園藝治療之改變因子。國立臺中科技大學通識教育學報，5，85-106。
3. 劉彥君,卓紋君(2022)。社會計量在團體轉換階段的應用。輔導季刊，58(3)，13-22。
4. 吳秀碧(2010)。系統化訓練模式對諮商團體領導者進階訓練效果之研究。中華輔導與諮商學報，28，99-142。
5. 蕭淑華(2017)。團隊的成長。諮商與輔導，384，28-30。
6. 蕭文、鄭青玫、黃瑛琪(2013)。男性婚暴者參與處遇團體之療效因素與停止暴力轉化歷程初探。諮商心理與復健諮商學報，25，7-63。
7. 謝麗紅,張晨光(2022)。團體諮商的導航系統：團體概念化與評估。輔導季刊，58(3)，23-32。