智能障礙勞工之職能與體能檢測之關聯性研究

A Study of Correlation Between Occupational and Physical Performance Tests for Workers with Intellectual Disabilities

10.3966/207455832020120052003

葉翰霖(Han-Lin Yeh)；張韋豪(Wei-Hao Chang)；姜義村(I-Tsun Chiang)

智能障礙者 ； 勞工 ； 職能表現 ； 體能檢測 ； 加油站 ； 汽車美容 ； intellectual disabilities ； workers ； occupational performance ； physical test ； gas station ； auto detailing

特殊教育學報

52期（2020 / 12 / 01）

49 - 70

繁體中文

身心障礙者穩定就業對自尊、自信心、職業生涯發展及生活獨立自主性皆有正面影響，其中職能表現為持續服務於職場的關鍵因素，而體能表現也影響智能障礙者的身體健康與生活品質。本研究目的為探討工作職能表現與各項體能檢測之關聯性，招募51位加油站或汽車美容之智能障礙勞工進行符合該族群合適的職能表現檢測與相關體能檢測。研究資料以斯皮爾曼等級相關係數與克－瓦二氏單因子等級變異數分析，研究結果顯示：（1）各項職能表現與部分體能檢測達顯著負相關（r = -.33 ~ -.63），即當體能表現愈好職能表現耗費時間越少，其績效亦較佳；（2）經工作任務分組後，除同時具洗車與加油能力工作者於上、下肢肌力及步態移行與其他組有顯著差異之外，其他體能與職能表現在各組間並無差異。本研究發現體能與職能表現存在部分項目之關聯性，可作為未來進一步發展監測智能障礙勞工身體狀況與職能表現之研究基礎。同時，基於考量勞力型工作環境的工作效率與身體負荷能力，建議未來於加油站或汽車美容工作的智能障礙勞工之體能訓練應關注心肺耐力、肌力與肌耐力三個項目。此外，亦建議未來應建立大樣本資料庫，將關聯性較高的項目進一步進行預測力之檢驗分析，以完備智能障礙者就業支持性服務工作。

Ensuring employment opportunities for people with disabilities impacts positively on their self-esteem, self-confidence, career development, and life independence. Occupational performance is the main key of maintaining their employment opportunities. Physical performance also impacts their physical health and quality of life. The purpose of this study was to understand the correlation between occupational performance of workers with intellectual disabilities (ID). Fifty- one workers with ID employed in gas station and/or auto detailing were recruited and completed occupational and physical performance tests. Data were analyzed by Spearman's rank correlation coefficient and Kruskal-Wallis test. The results indicate: (1) the significant correlations between occupational and physical performance tests (r = -.33 ~ -.63) implies that with higher physical performance, workers with ID would be more efficient with their works; (2) except the group who work both in gas station and auto detailing had significant difference in walk test, upper and lower muscular strength, there is no other significance among groups. The study concluded that some physical performance and occupational performance are correlated and could be the foundation for future studies in understanding physical conditions and occupational performance for workers with ID. Because gas station and auto detailing are labor-intensive working environment, cardi-orespiratory endurance, muscular strength and endurance are three domains that are recommended in physical trainings for workers with ID to provide enhanced working efficiency and physical capacity. In addition, studies with big data are needed in order to provide stronger evidence to support of enhancing the support service for labors with ID.

1. 高馨玲,任麗華(2005)。智能障礙者維持就業階段工作適應之探討──以三位中度智能障礙女性為例。特殊教育與復健學報，13，179-207。
   連結：
2. 許雅雯,林麗娟,蔡佳良(2008)。兒童與青少年身心障礙者運動健康行為促進之回顧與探討。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，27(2)，91-100。
   連結：
3. 郭峰誠,張恆豪(2011)。保障還是限制？定額進用政策與視障者的就業困境。臺灣社會研究季刊，83，95-136。
   連結：
4. 陳玫伶(2011)。從開放系統檢視身心障礙者社區化支持性就業服務品質──以A 縣（市）的執行經驗為例。社會發展研究學刊，10，54-72。
   連結：
5. 中華民國憲法增修條文（2005 年 6 月 10日）。身心障礙者權利公約（2014 年 12 月 03日）。
6. 身心障礙者權益保障法（2015 年 12 月 16日）。
7. Almalky, H. A.(2020).Employment outcomes for individuals with intellectual and developmental T disabilities: A literature review.Children and Youth Services Review,1-10.
8. Beck, A. Q.,Clasey, J. L.,Yates, J. W.,Koebke, N. C.,Palmer, T. G.,Abel, M. G.(2015).Relationship of physical fitness measures vs. occupational physical ability in campus law enforcement officers.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,29(8),2340-2350.
9. Bouzas S.,Martínez-Lemos R. I.,Ayán C.(2018).Effects of exercise on the physical fitness level of adults with intellectual disability: A systematic review.Disability and Rehabilitation,41(26),3118-3140.
10. Croce, R.,Horvat, M.(1992).Effects of reinforcement basedexercise on fitness and work productivity in adults with mental retardation.Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly,9(2),148-178.
11. Dawis, R. V.,Lofquist, L. H.(1984).A psychological theory of work adjustment.Minneapolis, MN:University of Minnesota Press.
12. Drannan, J.(2016).The relationship between physical exercise and job performance: The mediating effects of subjective health and good mood.Arabian Journal of Business and Management Review,6(6),1-6.
13. Ellenkamp, J. J. H.,Brouwers, E. P. M.,Embregts, P. J .C. M.,Joosen, M. C.W.,van Weeghel, J.(2016).Work environment-related factors in obtaining and maintaining work in a competitive employment setting for employees with intellectual disabilities: A systematic review.Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation,26(1),56-69.
14. Hauschild, V. D.,DeGroot, D. W.,Hall, S.M.,Grier, T. L.,Deaver, K. D.,Hauret, K. G.,Jones, B. H.(2016).Fitness tests and occupational tasks of military interest: A systematic review of correlations.Occup Environ Med,74,144-153.
15. Hydren, J. R.,Borges, A. S.,Sharp, M. A.(2017).Systematic review and meta-analysis of predictors of military task performance: Maximal lift capacity.The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,31(4),1142-1164.
16. Jeng, S. C.,Chang, C. W.,Liu, W. Y.,Hou, Y. J.,Lin, Y. H.(2017).Exercise training on skill-related physical fitness in adolescents with intellectual disability: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Disability and Health Journal,10,198-206.
17. Kamath, T.,Sandesh, T. S.(2017).The test retest reliability and concurrent validity of functional reach test in 5 to 15 yeas old children with Down’s syndrome - A cross sectional study.International Journal of Physical Education, Sports and Health,4(3),523-529.
18. Lynch, C.,Bird, S.,Lythgo, N.,Selva-Raj, I.(2020).Changing the physical activity behavior of adults with fitness trackers: A systematic review and meta-analysis.American Journal of Health Promotion,34(4),418-430.
19. Machado, M. L.,Santos, F. H.,Schoen, T.,Chiari, B.(2016).Effects of vocational training on a group of people with intellectual disabilities.Journal of Policy and Practice Intellectual Disability,13(1),33-40.
20. Marques, I.,Balle, A. R.,Curado, C.(2018).The contribution of physical exercise to organizational performance.European Journal of Management Studies,23(2),101-121.
21. Mayer, J. M.,Quillen, S. Q.,Verna, J. L.,Chen, R.,Lunseth, P.,Dagenais, S.(2015).Impact of supervised worksite exercise program on back and core muscular endurance in firefighters.American Journal of Health Promotion,29(3),165-172.
22. Nindl, B. C.,Jones, B. H.,van Arsdale, S. J.,Kelly, K.,Kraemer, W. J.(2016).Operational physical performance and fitness in military women: Physiological, musculoskeletal injury, and optimized physical training considerations for successfully integrating women into combat-centric military occupations.Military Medicine,181,50-62.
23. Nota, L.,Santilli, S.,Ginevra, M. C.,Soresi, S.(2013).Employer attitudes towards the work inclusion of people with disability.Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities,27,511-520.
24. Oorsouw, W.,Embregts, P.,Bosman, A.,Jahoda, A.(2009).Training staff serving clients with intellectual disabilities: A meta-analysis of aspects determining effectiveness.Research in Developmental Disabilities,30,503-511.
25. Oppewal, A.,Hilgenkamp, T. I. M.(2019).Adding meaning to physical fitness test results in individuals with intellectual disabilities.Disability and Rehabilitation,2,1-8.
26. Oppewal, A.,Hilgenkamp, T. I. M.,van Wijck, R.,Schoufour, J. D.,Evenhuis, H. M.(2014).Physical fitness is predictive for a decline in daily functioning in older adults with intellectual disabilities: Results of the HA-ID study.Research in Development Disabilities,35,2299-2315.
27. Oppewal, A.,Hilgenkamp, T. I.,van Wijck, R.,Evenhuis, H. M.(2013).Cardiorespiratory fitness in individuals with intellectual disabilities - A review.Research in Developmental Disabilities,34(10),3301-3316.
28. Park, D. S.,Lee, G. C.(2014).Validity and reliability of balance assessment software using the Nintendo Wii balance board: usability and validation.Journal of Neuro Engineering and Rehabilitation,11(99),1-8.
29. Perez-Cruzado, D.,Cuesta-Vargas, A. I.(2016).Changes on quality of life, self-efficacy and social support for activities and physical fitness in people with intellectual disabilities through multimodal intervention.European Journal of Special Needs Education,31(5),553-564.
30. Perez-Sousa, M. A.,Olivares, P. R.,Escobar-Alvarez, J. A.,Parraca, J. A.,Gusi, N.(2018).Fitness as mediator between weight status and dimensions of health-related quality of life.Health and Quality of Life Outcomes,16(1),155-164.
31. Pitetti, K. H.,Rimmer, J. H.,Fernhall, B.(1993).Physical fitness and adults with mental retardation. An overview of current research and future directions.Sports Med,16(1),23-56.
32. Scena, S.,Steinlder, R.,Ceci, M.,Zuccaro, S. M.,Carmeli, E.(2016).Computerized functional reach test to measure balance stability in elderly patients with neurological disorders.Journal of Clinical Medicine Research,8(10),715-720.
33. Sjøgaard, G.,Christensen, J. R.,Justesen, J.B.,Murray, M.,Dalager, T.,Fredslund, G. H.,Søgaard., K.(2016).Exercise is more than medicine: The working age population’s well-being and productivity.Journal of Sport and Health Science,5,159-165.
34. Storer, T. W.,Dolezal, B. A.,Abrazado, M.L.,Smith, D. L.,Batalin, M. A.,Tseng, C. H.,Copper, A. B.(2014).Fire-fighter health and fitness assessment: a call to action.Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,28(3),661-671.
35. Tammelin, T.,Näyhä, S.,Rintamäki, H.,Zitting, P.(2002).Occupational physical activity is related to physical fitness in young workers.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,34(1),158-165.
36. Winnick, J. P.(2005).Introduction to the brockport physical fitness technical manual.Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly,22(4),315-322.
37. Wouters, M.,Evenhuis, H. M.,Hilgenkamp, T. I.(2019).Physical fitness of children and adolescents with moderate to severe intellectual disabilities.Disability and Rehabilitation,42(1),1-11.
38. Wouters, M.,van der Zanden, A. M.,Even-huis, H. M.,Hilgenkamp, T. I.(2017).Feasibility and reliability of tests measuring health-related physical fitness in children with moderate to sever levels of intellectual disability.American Journal on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities,122(5),422-438.
39. Yildirim, N. U.,Erbahceci, F.,Ergun, N.,Pitetti, K. H.,Beets, M. W.(2010).The effect of physical fitness training on reaction time in youth with intellectual disabilities.Percept Mot Skills,111(1),178-186.
40. 王子娟,潘致弘(2011).中高齡勞工工作能力指標資料庫建立之研究.新北市:勞動部勞動及職業安全衛生研究所.
41. 徐文豪,吳亭芳(2017)。支持性就業服務對智能障礙者工作適應之影響──以新北市為例。復健諮商，8，19-45。
42. 勞動部統計處(2019)。108 年身心障礙者勞動狀況報告。取自 https://statdb.mol.gov.tw/html/svy08/0841menu.htm
43. 劉秀之,林明慧,林建邦,謝依婕,陳瓊玲(2017)。臺中市身心障礙者職業輔導評量服務探討──101-103 年度職評報告分析。臺灣職能治療研究與實務，13(1)，11-22。
44. 蔡瀚輝,謝曼麗(2013).中高齡勞工健康體能與工作能力探討研究.新北市:勞動部勞動及職業安全衛生研究所.
45. 衛生福利部(2016)。105 年身心障礙者生活狀況及需求調查報告 。取自https://dep.mohw.gov.tw/dos/cp-1770-3599-113.html
46. 關婉珍,陳靜江(2001)。支持策略在支持性就業中之應用情形與成效分析。特殊教育學報，15，21-48。