風格投資─臺灣股市的實證

Style Investing-Evidence from Taiwan Stock Markets

10.29724/TMR.201108.0001

王雍智(George Y. Wang)；張澤(Jer Chang)；戴宏廩(Hong-Lin Dai)

風格 ； 風格投資法 ； 投資組合法 ； 價值效應 ； 成長型效應 ； 大型股效應 ； style ； style investing ； style portfolio ； value effect ； growth effect ； large-cap effect

東海管理評論

13卷1期（2011 / 08 / 01）

1 - 46

繁體中文

近年來，台灣股票市場常常存在各種股票概念族群，例如中國概念股、iPhone概念股等，此與財金學者針對公司股票的特性加以分類－在學理上我們將之稱為「風格」（style），有異曲同工之妙；針對股票市場中特定的風格族群進行投資、以獲取超額報酬的風格投資法（style investing），早已成為近年來許多專業投資機構投資決策的方式。本研究利用投資組合法（portfolio approach），以明確的操作性定義，據以建立價值、成長、大型、及小型等四種風格投資組合（style portfolio），與市場投資組合進行超額報酬之檢定。本研究之主要結果有三：第一，價值效應與成長效應不論在短期及長期皆呈現顯著，價值效應尤比成長效應顯著；而大型股效應（或反向規模效應）則存在長期中，一般小型股的異常報酬則不存於台股；第二，分析風格投資組合在多頭、盤整、及空頭市場下的短期表現，僅有價值、成長、及大型股在盤整市場為顯著，但長期報酬則都顯著，顯示風格投資法具有在長期獲得超額報酬的特別意義；第三，因價值、成長、大型股皆為建立在基本面之選股策略，顯示台股仍較偏向弱式效率市場。

In Taiwan stock markets, various concepts of stocks have been raised by practitioners to catch the attention of investors. These so-called concepts are similar to the terminology, style, in finance research. Style investing is referred to as investing similar company characteristics as a style portfolio in order to obtain excess returns. This study examines the short-run and long-run performance of excess return among four groups of style portfolios, i.e., value, stocks, large-capitalization, and small-capitalization, with the portfolio-constructing approach. Three major findings are drawn from the study. First, the study finds evidence for the value effect, the growth effect, and the large-cap effect (or reverse size effect) in Taiwan stock market. Second, since the three market anomalies are statistically significant in the long-run, the implication is that investors should pursue the long-run performance rather than in the short-run with style investing. Third, the market anomalies indicate that Taiwan stock market is weak-form efficient.

1. Graham, B., D. L. Dodd, S. Cottle, and C. Tatham, Jr. (1934), Security Analysis, McGraw Hill, New York.
2. Ahmed, Parvez,Nanda, Sudhir(2001).Style Investing: Incorporating Growth Characteristics in Value Stocks.Journal of Portfolio Management,27(3),47-59.
3. Asgharian, Hossein,Hansson, Björn(2010).Book-to-Market and Size Effects: Compensations for Risks or Outcomes of Market Inefficiencies?.European Journal of Finance,16(2),119-131.
4. Banz, R. W.(1981).The Relationship between Return and Market Value of Common Stocks.Journal of Financial Economics,9,3-18.
5. Bauman, W. Scott,Miller, Robert E.(1997).Investor Expectations and the Performance of Value Stocks versus Growth Stocks.Journal of Portfolio Management,23,57-68.
6. Bernstein, Richard(1995).Style Investing: Unique Insight into Equity Management.New York:John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
7. Brennan, Michael J.,Torous, Walter N.(1999).Individual Decision Making and Investor Welfare.Economic Notes,28(2),119-144.
8. Brown, Stephen J.,Goetzmann, William N.(1997).Mutual Fund Styles.Journal of Financial Economics,43(3),373-399.
9. Capaul, Carlo,Rowley, Ian,Sharpe, William F.(1993).International Value and Growth Stock Returns.Financial Analysts Journal,49,27-36.
10. Chan, K. C.,Chen, N. F.(1991).Structural and Return Characteristics of Small and Large Firms.Journal of Finance,1467-1484.
11. Chan, L. K.,Hamao, Y.,Lakonishok, J.(1991).Fundamentals and Stock Returns in Japan.Journal of Finance,46,1739-1764.
12. Chang, Eric C.,Lewellen, Wilbur G.(1984).Market Timing and Mutual Fund Investment Performance.Journal of Business,57,57-72.
13. Christopherson, Jon A.(1995).Equity Style Classifications.Journal of Portfolio Management,21(3),32-44.
14. Daniel, Kent,Titman, Sheridan(1997).Evidence on the Characteristics of Cross Sectional Variation in Stock Returns.Journal of Finance,52(1),1-33.
15. Dimson, Elroy,Marsh, Paul(1999).Murphy's Law and market anomalies.Journal of Portfolio Management,25(2),53-70.
16. Fabozzi, Frank J.,Francis, Jack C.(1979).Mutual Fund Systematic Risk for Bull and Bear Markets: An Empirical Examination.Journal of Finance,34(5),1243-1250.
17. Fama, Eugene F.,French, Kenneth R.(2006).The Value Premium and CAPM.Journal of Finance,61,2163-2185.
18. Fama, Eugene F.,French, Kenneth R.(2007).The Anatomy of Value and Growth Stock Returns.Journal of Finance,63(6),44-54.
19. Fama, Eugene F.,French, Kenneth R.(1992).The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Return.Journal of Finance,47,427-465.
20. Farrell, James L.(1974).Analyzing Covariation of Returns to Determine Homogeneous Stock Groupings.Journal of Business,47(2),186-208.
21. Gallo, John G.,Phengpis, Chanwit,Swanson, Peggy E.(2008).Institutional Flows and Equity Style Diversification.Applied Financial Economics,18,1441-1450.
22. Gallo, John G,Lockwood, Larry(1997).Benefits of proper style classification of equity portfolio managers.Journal of Portfolio Management,23(3),47-56.
23. Grinold, Richard C.,Kahn, Ronald N.(1992).Information Analysis.Journal of Portfolio Management,18(3),14-21.
24. Groth, John C.,Martin, John D.(1981).Impact of Firm Size on Capital Market Efficiency.Journal of Economics & Business,33,166-71.
25. Henriksson, Roy D.(1984).Market Timing and Mutual Fund Performance: An Empirical Investigation.Journal of Business,57,73-96.
26. Henriksson, Roy D.,Merton, Robert C.(1981).On Market Timing and Investment Performance II: Statistical Procedures for Evaluating Forecasting Skills.Journal of Business,54,513-533.
27. Lakonishok, J.,Shleife, A.,Vishny, R. W.(1994).Contrarian Investment, Extrapolation, and Risk.Journal of Finance,49,1541-1578.
28. Leledakis, George,Davidson, Ian(2001).Are Two Factors Enough? The U.K. Evidence.Financial Analysts Journal,57,96-105.
29. Levy, Robert A.(1974).Beta as a Predictor of Return.Financial Analysts Journal,30(1),61-69.
30. Lintner, J.(1965).Security Prices, Risk, and Maximal Gains from Diversification.Journal of Finance,20
31. Massa, Massimo,Zhang, Lei(2009).Cosmetic Mergers: The Effect of Style Investing on the Market for Corporate Control.Journal of Financial Economics,93,400-427.
32. O'Shaughnessy, J. P.(1996).What Works on Wall Street: A Guide to the Best-Performing Investment Strategies of All Time.New York:McGraw-Hill.
33. Pritamani, Mahesh D.,Shome, Dilip K.,Singal, Vijay(2004).Foreign Exchange Exposure of Exporting and Importing Firms.Journal of Banking & Finance,28(7),1697-1710.
34. Reinganum, Marc R.(1992).A Revival of the Small Firms Effect.Journal of Portfolio Management,18(3),55-62.
35. Reinganum, Marc R.(1981).Abnormal Returns in Small Firm Portfolio.Financial Analyst Journal,31(2),313-321.
36. Ross, S. A.(1976).The Arbitrage Theory of Capital Asset Pricing.Journal of Economic Theory,13,341-360.
37. Sharpe, William F.(1992).Asset Allocation: Management Style and Performance Measurement.Journal of Portfolio Management,18(2),7-19.
38. Sharpe, William F.(1978).Major Investment Styles.Journal of Portfolio Management,4(2),68-80.
39. Sharpe, William F.(1964).Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditional of Risk.Journal of Finance,19,425-442.
40. Teo, Melvyn,Woo, Sung-Jun(2004).Style Effects in the Cross-Section of Stock Returns.Journal of Financial Economics,74(2),367-398.
41. Wang, F.,Xu, Y.(2004).What Determines Chinese Stock Returns?.Financial Analysts Journal,60,65-77.
42. Weiss, Andrew(1999).Why Institutions Systematically Underperform Broadly Based Market Indices.Global Investor,123,27-31.
43. 李命志、林苑宜(2000)。台灣股票市場規模效應與淨值市價比效應實證研究。台灣經濟金融月刊，36(9)，88-98。
44. 洪榮華、雷雅淇(2000)。公司規模、股價、益本比、淨值市價比與股票超常報酬關係之實證研究。管理評論，21，25-48。
45. 陳安琳、李文智、葉仲康(1999)。系統風險及規模與股票報酬關係之實證研究。中華管理評論，3，1-14。
46. 劉維琪、李佳玲(1993)。運用隨機優勢模式再探討台灣股市本益比效應。會計評論，27，1-24。
47. 劉維琪、高孔廉、李春旺(1989)。股價行為與規模效應─台灣股票市場實證研究。管理評論，8，99-121。

1. 顏榳均、黃麟翔、陳尚武、莊可欣(2015)。投資風格對風險調整報酬的影響－台股之實證分析。東亞論壇，488，27-38。