寡占廠商價格預告行為之規範

Regulations on Price Announcement Behavior of Oligopolistic Firms

馬泰成(Tay-Cheng Ma)

卡特爾 ； 價格預告 ； 市場效率 ； cartel ； price announcement ； market efficiency

東海管理評論

17卷1期（2015 / 07 / 01）

53 - 84

繁體中文

本文嘗試結合法律與經濟分析，針對執法機關處理寡占事業預告價格行為之執法原則，提出建議如次：(1)事業私下預告價格訊息之可責性高於公開預告價格者；(2)公告實際價格之可責性高於公告牌價者；(3)不具拘束力之價格預告與具拘束力者比較，其可責性相對較高。

This paper attempts to create a systematic approach to combine both law and economics to design antitrust regulations on price announcement behavior of oligopolistic firms. The suggestions made in this paper include: (1) the culpability involved in the case of private price announcement or communication among oligopolistic firms is higher than the public one. (2) the culpability in information dissemination through ＂real price＂ is higher than through ＂list price＂ announcement; (3) the culpability in exchanges of non-binding future prices among firms is higher than the binding one.

1. 馬泰成(2006)。一致性行為與市場競爭：中油與台塑公告調價資訊案之經濟分析。人文及社會科學集刊，18(4)，541-564。
   連結：
2. Baker, J.(1996).Identifying horizontal price-fixing n the electronic marketplace.Antitrust Law Journal,65,41-55.
3. Genesove, D.,Mullin, W.(2001).Rules, communication, and collusion: narrative evidence from the Sugar Institute case.American Economic Review,91,379-398.
4. Gerven, G.,Varona, E. N.(1994).The Wood Pulp Case and the Future of Concerted Practices.Common Market Law Review,31,575-608.
5. Gillespie, William(1995).Cheap Talk, Price Announcements, and Collusive Coordination.U.S. Department of Justice Antitrust Division.
6. Green, E.,Porter, R.(1984).Non-cooperative collusion under imperfect price information.Econometrica,52,87-100.
7. Hay, G.(2000).The Meaning of Agreements under the Sherman Act: Thoughts form the Facilitating Practices Experiences.Review of Industrial Organization,16,113-129.
8. Hylton, K.(2003).Antitrust Law: Economic Theory and Common Law Evolution.Cambridge University Press.
9. Kühn, K.(2001).Fighting collusion by regulating communication between firms.Economic Policy,16,167-204.
10. Kühn, K.,Vives, X.(1994).Information exchanges among firms and their impact on competition.Institut d'Analisi Economica=CSIC.
11. Novshek, W.,Sonnenschein, H.(1982).Fulfilled Expectations, Cournot duopoly with information acquisition and release.Bell Journal of Economics,13,214-218.
12. OECD(2001).OECD, (2001). Price transparency, DAFFE/CLP22..
13. Overgaard, P. B.,Møllgaard, P.(2005).CIE Discussion PapersCIE Discussion Papers,University of Copenhagen. Department of Economics. Centre for Industrial Economics.
14. Posner, R.(1962).Oligopoly and the antitrust laws: a suggested approach.Standard Law Review,21,1562-1606.
15. Rahl, J.(1962).Conspiracy and the antitrust laws.Illinois Law Review,44,743-786.
16. Slade, M.(1989).Price Wars in price-setting supergames.Economica,56,295-310.
17. Stigler, G.(1964).A Theory of Oligopoly.Journal of Political Economy,72,44-61.
18. Ten Kate, A.,Dircio, M.(2000).Ten Kate, A. and M. Dircio (2000). Information Sharing, Market Making and Collusion, English translation of “ Intercambio de Informacion Entre Competidores Practicas Absolutas” - available on request from Adriaan Ten Kate - atenkate@cfc.gov.mx.
19. Turner, D.(1962).The definition of agreement under the Sherman Act: conscious parallelism and refusals to deal.Harvard Law Review,75,657-663.
20. 公平交易委員會(2004)。,未出版
21. 何之邁(1999).公平交易法專論.自版.
22. 何之邁(2006)。平行行為乎？一致性行為乎？－評析中油、台塑油品調價案。臺北大學法學論叢，58，5-30。
23. 馬泰成(2005)。默契性聯合行為與相關案例研析。公平交易季刊，13(1)，89-112。
24. 馬泰成(2009)。榨取性濫用之管制：政策理念與實務困境。公平交易季刊，17(1)，39-73。
25. 陳坤銘,翁偉任(2004)。寡占市場廠商價格跟隨行為規範之研究。第 11屆競爭政策與公交易法研討會
26. 廖義男(1995).公平交易法之理論與立法.自版.
27. 廖賢洲,楊佳慧(2005)。競爭法對寡占廠商促進行為之規範。月旦法學雜誌，126，85-108。