犯罪人真的是不理性的嗎？－與陳和華教授商榷

Are Criminals Irrational?-A Dialogue with Prof Hehua Chen

劉濤(Tao Liu)

非理性 ； 低自控 ； 低自珍 ； 有限理性 ； 犯罪情境預防 ； Non-Rationality ； Low-Self Control ； Low Self-Respect ； Bounded Rationality Situational Crime Prevention

犯罪學期刊

17卷1期（2014 / 06 / 01）

107 - 124

繁體中文

犯罪學研究的犯罪人應當是理性的犯罪人。行為人選擇犯罪雖然在價值理性的角度看存在不理性的成分，但是犯罪學的研究應當注重犯罪人行為的實踐理性與工真理性。犯罪人對犯罪的法律後果（法律後果）低自控與低自珍不是決定犯罪人非理性的決定因素。適應性非理性應當注重對於犯罪情境的分析。當代理性選擇理論強調犯罪人的有限理性，犯罪預防的落腳點在於對於犯罪人犯罪機會的控制與犯罪具體社會情境的抑制。

The offenders under the study of criminology should be rational. The offenders may not be rational under the doctrine of value rationality. But it has rationality under the theories of practical rationality and instrumental rationality. The low self control and low self respect for the long term consequences of crime are not the dominant factor for determining the irrationality of criminals. The adaptive non-rationality of criminals should be analyzed under the specific crime situations. The contemporary rational choice theory is of limited one. The prevention of crime shall focus on the control of opportunity of crime and the specific situations of crimes.

1. BAUMER, E,LAURITSEN, J L,ROSENFELD, R(1998).The Influence of Crack Cocaine on Robbery, Burglary, and Homicide Rates: A Cross-City, Longitudinal Analysis.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,35(3),316-40.
2. CLARKE, R V G(1997).Situational crime prevention.Criminal Justice Press.
3. CORNISH, D B,CLARKE, R V G(1986).The reasoning criminal: rational choice perspectives on offending.Springer-Verlag.
4. CORNISH, D B,CLARKE, R V.(1987).UNDERSTANDING CRIME DISPLACEMENT: AN APPLICATION OF RATIONAL CHOICE THEORY.Criminology,25(4),933-48.
5. CULLEN, F T,AGNEW, R.(2006).Criminological Theory: Past to Present: Essential Readings.Roxbury Publishing Company.
6. E. 迪爾凱姆(1995)。社會學方法的準則。商務印書館。
7. FELSON, M,BOBA, R.(2009).Crime and Everyday Life.Sage Publications.
8. HUGHES, G.(1998).Understanding crime prevention: social control, risk, and late modernity.Open University Press.
9. KELLING, G L,COLES, C M.(1997).Fixing Broken Windows: Restoring Order And Reducing Crime In Our Communities.Simon & Schuster.
10. MARTINSON, R.(1974).What Works?: Questions and Answers about Prison Reform.
11. PIQUERO, A,RENGERT, G F(1999).Studying deterrence with active residential burglars.Justice Quarterly,16(2),451-71.
12. POYNER, B.(1983).Design against crime: beyond defensible space.Butterworths.
13. TILLEY, N,FARRELL, G.(2012).The Reasoning Criminologist: Essays in Honour of Ronald V. Clarke
14. WILSON, J Q(1985).Thinking about crime.Vintage Books.
15. 周愫嫻、曹立群(2007)。犯罪學理論及其實證。五南圖書出版股份有限公司。
16. 馬克斯．韋伯(1997)。經濟與社會（上卷）。商務印書館。
17. 張遠煌(2010)。犯罪研究的新視野：從事實、觀念再到規範。法律出版社。
18. 張遠煌(2008)。犯罪學原理。法律出版社。
19. 曹立群編、任昕編(2008)。犯罪學。中國人民大學出版社。
20. 莫里森(2004)。理論犯罪學：從現代到後現代。法律出版社。
21. 陳和華(2012)。犯罪人的適應性非理性及其防控。政法論叢，2012(4)
22. 陳迎新(2005)。博士論文(博士論文)。西南政法大學。