政策風暴下的視障按摩社群：社群能力建構歷程的觀察

The Community Capacity Building Process of Massage Worker Community in Response to the Judicial Yuan Interpretation No. 649-An Observation

10.29814/TSW.201007.0001

王育瑜(Yu-Yu Wang)；李婉萍(Wan-Ping Lee)

視障按摩社群 ； 社群能力建構 ； visually impaired massage workers community ； community capacity building

臺灣社會工作學刊

9期（2010 / 07 / 01）

1 - 40

繁體中文

司法院649號釋憲案終止了長久以來將按摩列為視障者職業保留的政策，此政策改變預期將對視障按摩社群產生極大衝擊，本研究動機是透過研究者與按摩社群夥伴關係的建立與共同行動，提升視障按摩社群政策倡導的力量。原先設計以參與式行動研究方法進行，然因應社群取得專案經費補助資源與另一外來協助者成為主導者，研究乃改採參與觀察方式。研究發現如同既有關於社群能力建構文獻所指出，社群能力建構必須建立在強烈的社群認同、歸屬感、信任關係，以及豐厚的內外資源網絡連結與有品質的互動。本研究亦發現，外來協助者必須特別注意與社群成員建立平等、尊重，與長期的信任關係，才能在社群能力建構過程中發揮應有的協助功用。此外，社群內部領導者與領導能力的長期培養，是社群組織能力永續發展的關鍵因素。

In Oct. 2008, the Judicial Yuan Interpretation No. 649 declared that the reserved occupation of massage has violated the Constitution. This policy change is expected to have great impacts on this group's lives. This study started with the idea of building a partnership between the researchers and the visually impaired massage workers community, to work together in influencing government policies and actions after the Interpretation No. 649. Participatory action research was originally designed as the method. Nevertheless, as the community had access to more resources, the strategy of this study shifted towards participant observation. The findings of this research is consistent with existing studies on community capacity building, which emphasizes that community capacity building should be based on strong community identity, sense of belonging, trust, as well as inner and outer quality social network. Furthermore, this study also found that persons from outside the community who want to help building community capacity should pay special attention to the quality of the partnership, which should be based on equality, respect, and even long-term understanding, in order to play positive helping functions. Finally, leadership development within the community takes a long time, and is crucial for the community to have long-term influence and capacity.

1. Hall, M. H., McKeown, L., & Roberts, K. (2001). Caring Canadians, Involved Canadians: Highlights from the 2000 National Survey of Giving, Volunteering and Participating. Ottawa, ON: Statistics Canada
2. Arnstein, S. R.(1969).Man's Struggle for Shelter in an Urbanizing World.Cambridge:MIT Press.
3. Balcazar, F. E.,Keys, C. B.,Suarez-Balcazar, Y.(2001).Empowering Latinos with Disabilities to Address Issues of Independent Living and Disability Rights: A Capacity-building Approach.Journal of Prevention and Intervention in the Community,21(2),53-70.
4. Bourdieu, P.,Nice, R.(Trans.)(1984).Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
5. Chaskin, R. J.,Brown, P.,Venkatesh, S.,Vidal, A.(2001).Building Community Capacity.New York:Aldine de Gruyter.
6. Chaskin, R. J.,Goerge, R. M.(2006).Measuring Social Capital: An Exploration in Community - Research Partnership.Journal of Community Psychology,34(4),489-514.
7. Chaskin, R. J.,Goerge, R. M.(1998).Measuring Social Capital: An Exploration in Community-Research Partnership.Journal of Community Psychology,34(4),489-514.
8. Choguill, M. B. G.(1996).A Ladder of Community Participation for Underdeveloped Countries.Habitat International,20(3),431-444.
9. Coleman, J.(1988).Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.American Journal of Sociology,94,95-120.
10. Craig, G.(2007).Community Capacity-building: Something Old, Something New...?.Critical Social Policy,27(3),335-339.
11. Daubon, R. E.,Saunders, H. H.(2002).Operationalizing Social Capital: A Strategy to Enhance Communities' "Capacity to Concert".International Studies Perspectives,3(2),176-191.
12. Davidson, C. H.,Johnson, C.,Lizarralde, G.,Dikmen, N.,Sliwinski, A.(2007).Truths and Myths about Community Participation in Post-disaster Housing Projects.Habitat International,31,100-115.
13. Dowling, B.,Powell, M.,Glendinning, C.(2004).Conceptualizing Successful Partnerships.Health and Social Care in the Community,12,309-317.
14. Fielden, S. J.,Rusch, M. L.,Masinda, M. T.,Sands, J.,Frankish, J.,Evoy, B.(2007).Key Considerations for Logic Model Development in Research Partnerships: A Canadian Case Study.Evaluation and Program Planning,30(2),115-124.
15. Gibbon, M.(2002).Evaluating Community Capacity.Health and Social Care in the Community,10(6),485-491.
16. Healy, K.,Hampshire, A.,Ayres, L.(2004).Beyond the Local: Extending the Social Capital Discourse.Australian Journal of Social Issues,39(3),329-342.
17. Ivey, J.,de Loë, R. C.,Kreutzwiser, R. D.,Ferreyra, C.(2006).An Institutional Perspective on Local Capacity for Source Water Protection.Geoforum,37(6),944-957.
18. Labonte, R.,Laverack, G.(2001).Capacity Building in Health Promotion, Part1: For Whom? And for What Purpose?.Critical Public Health,11(2),111-127.
19. Lane, M. B.(2006).The Role of Planning in Achieving Indigenous Land Justice and Community Goals.Land Use Policy,23(4),385-394.
20. Laverack, G.(1999).Melbourne,Deakin University.
21. Minkler, M.(Ed.),Wallerstein, N.(Ed.)(2003).Community-based Participatory Research for Health.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
22. Moore, S. A.,Severn, R.,Millar, R.(2006).A Conceptual Model of Community Capacity for Biodiversity Conservation Outcomes.Geographical Research,44(4),361-371.
23. Narayan, D. (Ed.)(1997).Voices of the Poor: Poverty and Social Capital in Tanzania.Washington, DC:World Bank.
24. Niekerk, L. V.,Lorenzo, T.,Mdlokolo, P.(2006).Understanding Partnerships in Developing Disabled Entrepreneurs through Participatory Action Research.Disability and Rehabilitation,28(5),323-331.
25. Putnam, R.(1993).Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
26. Putnam, R.(2000).Bowling alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.New York:Simon & Schuster.
27. Putnam, R.(1995).Turning in, Turning out: The Strange Disappearance of Social Capital in America.Political Science and Politics,28,664-683.
28. Romani, M. E. T.,Vanlerberghe, V.,Perez, D.,Lefevre, P.,Ceballos, E.,Bandera, D.,Gil, A. B.,Stuyft, P. V. D.(2006).Achieving Sustainability of Community-based Dengue Control in Santiago de Cuba.Social Science and Medicine,64(4),976-988.
29. Sharpe, E. K.(2006).Resources at the Grassroots of Recreation: Organizational Capacity and Quality of Experience in a Community Sport Organization.Leisure Sciences,28(4),385-401.
30. Sixsmith, J.,Boneham, M.(2003).Older Men's Participation in Community Life: Notions of Social Capital, Health, and Empowerment.Ageing International,28(4),372-388.
31. Stone, W.,Hughes, J.(2000).What role for social in family.Family Matters,56(winter),20-27.
32. Takhar, S.(2006).South Asian Women, Social Capital and Multicultural (Mis)understandings.Community, Work and Family,9(3),291-307.
33. Timmer, D. K.,Loë, R. C. d.,Kreutzwiser, R. D.(2005).Source Water Protection in the Annapolis Valley, Nova Scotia: Lessons for Building Local Capacity.Land Use Policy,24(1),187-198.
34. Woolcock, M.(1998).Social Capital and Economic Development: Toward a Theoretical Synthesis and Policy Framework.Theory and Society,27,151-208.
35. Young, H. M.,Swanson, E. A.,Richards, K.,Walhagen, M. I.,Archbold, P.,Spool, M.,Flaherty-Robb, M.(2006).Expending Influence in Gerontological Nursing through Partnerships: Experiences from the John A. Hartford Foundation Centers of Geriatric Nursing Excellence.Nursing Outlook,54(4),204-211.
36. Zimmerman, M. A.(1995).Psychological Empowerment: Issues and Illustrations.American Journal of Community Psychology,23(5),581-599.
37. 林振春(1995)。凝聚社區意識，建構社區文化。社區發展季刊，69，25-39。
38. 林瑞欽(1994)。社區意識的概念、測量、與提振策略。社會發展研究學刊，1，1-21。
39. 張國聖(2003)。大學的社區意識與社會功能─以桃園地區大專院校的發展策略為例。萬能技術學院存盧紀念圖書資訊館館訊，4，13-21。

1. 藍春琪(2021)。視障按摩服務創新策略之個案研究。商略學報，13(1)，71-88。