题名

培養因材施教的幼兒教師－大陸66所高校幼兒教育專業人才培養方案分析

并列篇名

Cultivating Preschool Teachers' Ability to Teach Students According to Their Aptitude: An Analysis of the Talent Development Programs for Preschool Education Professionals in 66 Colleges and Universities across China

DOI

10.6246/JHDFS.202212_(23).0004

作者

毛作祥(Zuoxiang Mao)

关键词

人才培養方案 ； 因材施教 ； 幼兒觀察評量 ； 評量素養 ； talent development program ； teaching students according to their aptitude ； observation and assessment of young children ； assessment literacy

期刊名称

人類發展與家庭學報

卷期/出版年月

23期（2022 / 12 / 01）

页次

99 - 140

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

因材施教是2035年實現教育現代化所倚重的教育理念，能否在幼兒教育專業人才培養方案中體現關係重大。本研究在培養因材施教師資的理論基礎上，搜集2015－2020中國大陸的66所高校幼兒教育專業人才培養方案。分析發現，目前以因材施教為培養目標的高校極少，課程設置及教學進程安排對因材施教不夠重視，難以發揮觀察評量課程的最大效用。主要原因在於：僅將因材施教視為理念與原則，而非能力；沒有追蹤和拓展因材施教現代化的內涵；缺乏有效的觀察評量工具的支持，實難以提供教育活動設計所需資訊。研究建議，高校應與幼兒園合作，以《幼兒觀察評量系統》為基礎，編製符合需要的觀察評量工具；同時修訂人才培養方案，整合幼兒觀察評量與教育活動設計，把因材施教做為幼兒教育專業培養的核心能力。
英文摘要

Teaching students according to their aptitude (TSATTA) is a critical educational concept for the realization of education modernization by 2035. Therefore, whether TSATTA can be materialized in talent development programs for preschool education professionals is a matter of significant importance. Building on the theoretical basis of cultivating teachers' TSATTA ability, this study collected data on the talent development programs for preschool education professionals implemented in 66 colleges and universities across China between 2015 and 2020. Our analysis found that few colleges and universities have adopted TSATTA as the goal of talent development and that inadequate attention has been paid to TSATTA in the curriculum design and teaching schedule arrangement, thereby rendering it difficult to maximize the effect of course observation and assessment. The main reasons for these phenomena are as follows: TSATTA has merely been considered an idea and principle rather than an ability; no action has been taken to follow up on and expand the implications of TSATTA modernization; and without the support of effective observation and assessment tools, it is difficult to provide the information required for designing educational activities. Based on the results, this study suggests that colleges and universities should cooperate with kindergartens to develop observation and assessment tools that meet their needs based on the Observation and Assessment System for Young Children. Additionally, colleges and universities should revise their talent development programs by integrating the observation and assessment of young children into the design of educational activities and viewing TSATTA as the core competency to be developed among preschool education professionals.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. Assessment Reform Group(2002).Assessment for Learning: 10 principles.Assessment Reform Group.
  2. Atjonen, P.,Pöntinen, S.,Kontkanen, S.,Ruotsalainen, P.(2022).In enhancing preservice teachers’ assessment literacy: Focus on knowledge base, conceptions of assessment, and teacher learning.Frontiers in Education,7,1-12.
  3. Ausubel, D. P.(1963).The psychology of meaningful verbal learning: An introduction to school learning.Grune & Stratton.
  4. Ausubel, D. P.(1968).Educational psychology: A cognitive view.Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
  5. Beaty, J. J.(2013).Observing development of the young child(8th Edition).Pearson.
  6. Bennett, R. E.(2011).Formative assessment: A critical review.Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice,18(1),5-25.
  7. Berk, L. E.,Winsler, A.(1995).Scaffolding children's learning: Vygotsky and early childhood education.NAEYC.
  8. Birenbaum, M.,DeLuca, C.,Earl, L.,Heritage, M.,Klenowski, V.,Looney, A.,Smith, K.,Timperley, H.,Volante, L.,Wyatt-Smith, C.(2015).International trends in the implementation of assessment for learning: Implications for policy and practice.Policy Futures in Education,13(1),117-140.
  9. Black, P.,Harrison, C.,Lee, C.,Marshall, B.,Wiliam, D.(2004).Working inside the black box: Assessment for learning in the classroom.Phi Delta Kappan,86(1),8-21.
  10. Black, P.,Wiliam, D.(1998).Assessment and classroom learning.Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice,5(1),7-74.
  11. Brodie, K.(2013).Observation, assessment and planning in tne early years: Bring it all together.Open University Press.
  12. Brown, A. H.,Green, T. D.(2019).The essentials of instructional design: Connecting fundamental principles with process and practice.Routledge.
  13. Brown, G.(2020).Responding to assessment for learning: A pedagogical method, not assessment.New Zealand Annual Review of Education,26,18-28.
  14. Cennamo, K.,Kalk, D.(2019).Real world instructional design: An iterative approach to designing learning experiences.Routledge.
  15. Chappuis, J.,Stiggins, R. J.(2017).An introduction to student-involved assessment for learning.Pearson.
  16. Chappuis, J.,Stiggins, R. J.,Chappuis, S.,Arter, J.(2014).Classroom assessment for student learning: Doing it right-using it well.Pearson.
  17. Charteris, J.,Dargusch, J.(2018).The tensions of preparing pre-service teachers to be assessment capable and profession-ready.Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education,46(4),354-368.
  18. Chen, J.-Q.,Krechevsky, M.,Viens, J.,Isberg, E.(1998).Building on children's strengths: The experience of Project Spectrum.Teachers College Press.
  19. Chen, J.-Q.,McNamee, G. D.(2007).Bridging: Assessment for teaching and learning in early childhood classrooms.Corwin Press.
  20. Crain, W.(2014).Theories of development: Concepts and applications.Routledge.
  21. DeLuca, C.(2012).Preparing teachers for the age of accountability: Toward a framework for assessment education.Action in Teacher Education,34(5-6),576-591.
  22. DeLuca, C.,Bellara, A.(2013).The current state of assessment education: Aligning policy, standards, and teacher education curriculum.Journal of Teacher Education,64(4),356-372.
  23. DeLuca, C.,Klinger, D. A.(2010).Assessment literacy development: Identifying gaps in teacher candidates’ learning.Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice,17(4),419-438.
  24. DeLuca, C.,Pyle, A.,Valiquette, A.,LaPointe-McEwan, D.(2020).New directions for kindergarten education: Embedding assessment in play-based learning.The Elementary School Journal,120(3),455-479.
  25. DeLuca, C.,Volante, L.(2016).Assessment for learning in teacher education programs: Navigating the juxtaposition of theory and praxis.Journal of the International Society for Teacher Education,20(1),19-31.
  26. DeLuca, C.,Willis, J.,Cowie, B.,Harrison, C.,Coombs, A.,Gibson, A.,Trask, S.(2019).Policies, programs, and practices: Exploring the complex dynamics of assessment education in teacher education across four countries.Frontiers in Education,4(132)
  27. DuFour, R.(2004).What is a" professional learning community"?.Educational Leadership,61(8),6-11.
  28. Dwyer, C. A.(Ed.)(2007).The future of assessment:Shaping teaching and learning.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  29. Feldman, D. H.(1981).Beyond universals: Toward a developmental psychology of education.Educational Researcher,10(9),21-26.
  30. Fernández, M.,Wegerif, R.,Mercer, N.,Rojas-Drummond, S.(2001).Re-conceptualizing" scaffolding" and the Zone of Proximal Development in the context of symmetrical collaborative learning.The Journal of Classroom Interaction,36(2),40-54.
  31. Gagne, R. M.,Wager, W. W.,Golas, K. C.,Keller, J. M.,Russell, J. D.(2005).Principles of instructional design.Cengage Learning.
  32. Gambhir, M.,Broad, K.,Evans, M.,Gaskell, J.(2008).,International Alliance of Leading Educational Institutes.
  33. Gardner, H.,Kornhaber, M. L.,Wake, W. K.(1996).Intelligence: Multiple perspectives.Harcourt Brace College Publishers.
  34. Gareis, C. R.,Grant, L. W.(2015).Teacher-made assessments: How to connect curriculum,instruction, and student learning.Routledge.
  35. Ginsburg, H. P.,Opper, S.(1988).Piaget's theory of intellectual development.Prentice-Hall, Inc.
  36. Greenberg, J., & Walsh, K. (2012). What teacher preparation programs teach about K-12 assessment: A review. National Council on Teacher Quality. http://www.nctq.org/p/edschools/ docs/assessment_publication.pdf
  37. Grimmer(2017).Observing and developing schematic behaviour in young children: A professional's guide for supporting children's learning, play and development.Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
  38. Gronlund, G.,James, M.(2013).Focused observations: How to observe young children for assessment and curriculum planning.Redleaf Press.
  39. Harrison, C.(2005).Teachers developing assessment for learning: Mapping teacher change.Teacher Development,9(2),255-263.
  40. Haywood, H. C.,Tzuriel, D.(2002).Applications and challenges in dynamic assessment.Peabody Journal of Education,77(2),40-63.
  41. HighScope Educational Research Foundation(2014).COR Advantage scoring guide.HighScope Press.
  42. Hunt, L.,McLaughlin, T.,Cherrington, S.,Aspden, K.,McLachlan, C.(2020).Data, knowledge, action: A teacher led inquiry into data informed teaching in early childhood education.Early Education,66,31-34.
  43. Hussain, S.,Woods, K.(2019).The use of dynamic assessment by educational psychologists in the early years foundation stage.Educational Psychology in Practice,35(4),424-439.
  44. Kodak, T.,Halbur, M.(2021).A tutorial for the design and use of assessment-based instruction in practice.Behavior Analysis in Practice,14(1),166-180.
  45. Kostelnik, M. J.,Soderman, A. K.,Whiren, A. P.(2014).Developmentally appropriate curriculum: Best practices in early childhood education.Pearson Education.
  46. Krechevsky, M.(1998).Project spectrum: Preschool assessment handbook.Teachers College Press.
  47. Leahy, S.,Lyon, C.,Thompson, M.,Wiliam, D.(2005).Classroom assessment: Minute by minute, day by day.Educational Leadership,63(3),19-24.
  48. Lee, J.(2019).A training project to develop teachers' assessment literacy.Handbook of research on assessment literacy and teacher-made testing in the language classroom
  49. Leung, C.(2014).The companion to language assessment.Wiley Blackwell.
  50. Marsh, C.,Day, C.,Hannay, L.,McCutcheon, G.(1990).Reconceptualizing school-based curriculum development.Falmer Press.
  51. McAfee, O. D.,Leong, D. J.,Bodrova, E.(2015).Assessing and guiding young children's development and learning(6th edition).Person Education.
  52. McLachlan, C.,Fleer, M.,Edwards, S.(2018).Early childhood curriculum: Planning, assessment and implementation.Cambridge University Press.
  53. Meisels, S. J.,Liaw, F.-r.,Dorfman, A.,Nelson, R. F.(1995).The Work Sampling System: Reliability and validity of a performance assessment for young children.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,10(3),277-296.
  54. Meisels, S. J.,Xue, Y.,Shamblott, M.(2008).Assessing language, literacy, and mathematics skills with Work Sampling for Head Start.Early Education and Development,19(6),963-981.
  55. Meisels, S. J.,廖鳳瑞（譯）,陳姿蘭（譯）(2002).幼兒表現評量：作品取樣系統.心理出版社.
  56. Mekhitarian, S.(2022).Harnessing formative data for K-12 teachers: Real-time classroom strategies.CRC Press.
  57. Mellati, M.,Khademi, M.(2018).Exploring teachers' assessment literacy: Impact on learners' writing achievements and implications for teacher development.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,43(6),1-18.
  58. NAEYC(2020).Professional standards and competencies for early childhood educators.NAEYC.
  59. Naranjo, N. V.,Robles-Bello, M. A.(2020).Dynamic assessment in preschoolers with down syndrome and nonspecific intellectual disability.Educational Psychology,26(2),101-107.
  60. Piaget, J. ,Coltman, D.(Trans.)(1970).Science of education and the psychology of the child.Viking.
  61. Piaget, J. (1929). The child’s conception of the world (J. Tomlinson & A. Tomlinson, Trans.). Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  62. Piaget, J.,Inhelder, B.(1969).The psychology of the child.Basic Books.
  63. Popham, W. J.(2018).Classroom assessment: What teachers need to know(8th Edition).Pearson.
  64. Pyle, A.,DeLuca, C.,Danniels, E.,Wickstrom, H.(2020).A model for assessment in play-based kindergarten education.American Educational Research Journal,57(6),2251-2292.
  65. Santos, L.,Pinto, J.(2011).Is assessment for learning possible in early school years?.Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences,12,283-289.
  66. Seefeldt, C.(Ed.),Galper, A.(Ed.)(1998).Assessing young child Continuing issues in early childhood education.Prentice Hall.
  67. Smith, P. L.,Ragan, T. J.(2004).Instructional design.John Wiley & Sons.
  68. Stiggins, R. J.(2014).Improve assessment literacy outside of schools too.Phi Delta Kappan,96(2),67-72.
  69. Stiggins, R. J.(1995).Assessment literacy for the 21st century.Phi Delta Kappan,77(3),238.
  70. Stiggins, R. J.,Chappuis, J.(2012).An introduction to student-involved assessment for learning.Pearson.
  71. Thomas, R. M.(2005).Comparing theories of child development.Cengage Learning.
  72. Tyler, R. W. (1949). Basic principles of curriculum and instruction. University of Chicago Press.
  73. Tzuriel, D.(2001).Dynamic assessment of young children.Springer.
  74. Tzuriel, D. (2020). Dynamic cognitive assessment for preschool age children. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education.
  75. Visser(2015).Dynamic assessment with the bayley-iii among young children with developmental disabilities.Journal of Cognitive Education and Psychology,14(1),126-142.
  76. Volante, L.,Fazio, X.(2007).Exploring teacher candidates' assessment literacy: Implications for teacher education reform and professional development.Canadian Journal of Education,30(3),749-770.
  77. Vygotsky, L. S.(1978).Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes.Harvard university press.
  78. Wakabayashi, T.,Claxton, J.,Smith, E. V., Jr.(2019).Validation of a revised observation-based assessment tool for children birth through kindergarten: The COR advantage.Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment,37(1),69-90.
  79. Wiliam, D.(2011).What is assessment for learning?.Studies in Educational Evaluation,37(1),3-14.
  80. Wiliam, D.,Lee, C.,Harrison, C.,Black, P.(2004).Teachers developing assessment for learning: Impact on student achievement.Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice,11(1),49-65.
  81. Wise, A. E.(Es.),Ehrenberg, P.(Es.),Leibbrand, J.(Es.)(2008).It’s all about student learning: Assessing teacher candidates’ ability to impact p-12 students.National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education.
  82. Wood, D.,Bruner, J. S.,Ross, G.(1976).The role of tutoring in problem solving.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry,17(2),89-100.
  83. Wyatt-Smith, V. K. C.(Ed.),Colbert, P.(Ed.)(2014).The enabling power of assessment: Designing assessment for quality learning.Springer.
  84. Xu, Y.,Brown, G. T.(2016).Teacher assessment literacy in practice: A reconceptualization.Teaching and Teacher Education,58,149-162.
  85. 于開蓮,焦豔(2009)。兩種學前教育評價新方案的對比－多彩光譜評價方案與作品取樣系統。學前教育研究，176(8)，9-12。
  86. 中共中央、國務院（2019）。中國教育現代化 2035。Retrieved from http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/ 2019-02/23/content_5367987.htm
  87. 中國高職高專教育網（2020, 2020-11-29）。2020 全國職業院校技能大賽改革試點賽高職組「學前教育專業教育技能」賽項在青島職院順利落幕。 Retrieved 03-06 from https://www. tech.net.cn/news/show-92609.html
  88. 中國教育部（2015）。幼稚園工作規程。Retrieved from http://www.moe.gov.cn/srcsite/A02/ s5911/moe_621/201602/t20160229_231184.html
  89. 中國教育部（2017）。普通高等學校師範類專業認證實施辦法。（教師〔2017〕13 號）。Retrieved from http://www.moe.gov.cn/srcsite/A10/s7011/201711/t20171106_318535.html
  90. 中國教育部（2011）。教師教育課程標準（試行）。Retrieved from http://www.moe.edu.cn/ publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/s6136/201110/125722.html
  91. 中國教育部（2012）。幼稚園教師專業標準（試行）。Retrieved from http://old.moe.gov.cn// publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/s7232/201212/xxgk_145603.html
  92. 中國教育部、國家發展改革委、公安部、財政部、人力資源社會保障部、自然資源部、住房和城鄉建設部、稅務總局、醫療保障局（2021）。「十四五」學前教育發展提升行動計畫。Retrieved from http://www.moe.gov.cn/srcsite/A06/s7053/202112/t20211216_587718. html
  93. 比奈（1927）。兒童學的新觀念（曾展謨譯）。商務印書館。
  94. 王堅紅(2018).學前教育評價.人民教育出版社.
  95. 王策三(1985).教學論稿.人民教育出版社.
  96. 王道俊,王漢瀾(1989).教育學.人民教育出版社.
  97. 田芬(2020)。無聲的劇本：教育學學科人才培養風格研究－基於 5 所師範大學本科培養方案的分析。現代教育科學，2，100-107。
  98. 成尚榮(2021)。高水準因材施教是教育高品質發展的必然命題。人民教育，18，34-38。
  99. 朱家雄(2015).幼稚園教育活動設計與實施.高等教育出版社.
  100. 何菊玲(2018)。因材施教原則的教育正義之意蘊。華東師範大學學報：教育科學版，36(2)，110-116。
  101. 吳剛平(2002).校本課程開發.四川教育出版社.
  102. 李秉德(1991).教學論.人民教育出版社.
  103. 幸曼玲,廖鳳瑞(1995)。表現評量。家政教育，13(2)，19-23。
  104. 林素微(2002)。臺灣師範大學。
  105. 南京師範大學教育系(1984).教育學.人民教育出版社.
  106. 施燕,韓春紅(2011).學前兒童行為觀察.華東師範大學出版社.
  107. 孫培青,杜成憲(2009).中國教育史.華東師範大學出版.
  108. 高瞻教育研究基金會,霍力岩（譯）,劉禕瑋（譯）,劉睿文（譯）,何淼（譯）,穀虹（譯）,杜寶傑（譯）,王冰虹（譯）,任宏偉（譯）,張昭（譯）(2018).學前兒童觀察評價系統.教育科學出版社.
  109. 張海峰,姚先國,張俊森(2010)。教育品質對地區勞動生產率的影響。經濟研究，45(7)，57-67。
  110. 張暘(2009)。因材施教：困境及超越。教育科學研究，10，15-18+27。
  111. 張廣君,張瓊(2015)。當代「因材施教」:生成論教學哲學的審視。課程．教材．教法，35(4)，37-43。
  112. 張蕾(2018)。對因材施教原則的重新審視與再行反思。教學與管理，24，98-100。
  113. 陳世聯,王春燕（譯）(2007).幼稚園課程概論.高等教育出版社.
  114. 陳時見,嚴仲連(2001)。論幼稚園的園本課程開發。學前教育研究，2，27-29。
  115. 程秀蘭(2016).學前教育評價.北京師範大學出版社.
  116. 馮茁(1996)。「因材施教」原則之反思。教育研究與實驗，2，52-55。
  117. 馮喜珍,李瑞鋒(2009)。小學教師關於因材施教的認識。上海教育科研，12，61-64。
  118. 黃爽,霍力岩(2018)。美國《學前兒童觀察記錄系統》的內容、特點與啟示。基礎教育，15(5)，80-89。
  119. 虞永平(2001)。試論園本課程的建設。教育教科研版，8，4-6。
  120. 趙連光,郭力平,陳柯汀(2015)。作品取樣系統的發展及在美國早期教育中的運用與評析。早期教育：教科研版，4，17-21。
  121. 趙慧勤,劉志華,袁虎廷(2016)。應用型本科院校教育技術專業人才培養方案研究。教育理論與實踐：學科版，36(5)，15-17。
  122. 重慶師範大學教育科學學院（2019）。我校學子在第九屆「華文杯」學前教育師範生教學能力測試與交流比賽中喜獲佳績。https://jykx.cqnu.edu.cn/news114.jsp?urltype=tree.Tree TempUrl&wbtreeid=1582 tree.Tree TempUrl&wbtreeid
  123. 鄭繼兵,王紹峰(2013)。從人才培養方案透視高校專業建設的困境及出路。江蘇高教，1，45-47。
  124. 盧曉東(2014)。超越因材施教。教育學術月刊，10，3-17。
  125. 錢兵,張莉(2018)。幼稚園教師兒童行為觀察現狀調查及問題分析。教育導刊（下半月），5，48-51。
  126. 霍力岩,潘月娟,黃爽(2019).學前教育評價.北京師範大學出版社.
print cancel