题名

信用違約交換金融商品應有規範之比較研究

并列篇名

A Critique on the Regulation of Credit Default Swap (CDS)

DOI

10.6199/NTULJ.202306_52(2).0005

作者

莊永丞(Yung-Cheng Chuang)

关键词

信用違約交換 ； 結算處所 ； 櫃檯買賣 ； 信用風險 ； 系統性風險 ； 2010年金融改革法 ； 資訊不對稱 ； Credit Default Swap (CDS) ； Clearinghouse ； Over-the-Counter (OTC) ； Credit Risk ； Systemic Risk ； Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 ； Information Asymmetry

期刊名称

臺大法學論叢

卷期/出版年月

52卷2期（2023 / 06 / 01）

页次

537 - 617

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

信用違約交換（Credit Default Swap）係用以規避授信相對人違約風險之金融商品，然市場充斥眾多套利者利用信用違約交換進行套利行為，如此商品泡沫最終幻滅，成為2008年金融風暴之重要元兇。雖該金融工具有引發系統性危機之虞，招致嚴重的金融風暴；但其存在亦有其正面功能，除可幫助市場發現價格，亦可促使投資人進行避險佈局，故仍難以否定其存在意義，不能也不應全面予以禁止。面對此情，本文認為我國應就該金融工具擬定更佳的規範模式，使其能適當的發揮效用，又不致造成金融市場之系統性風險。我國就信用違約交換係以場外交易之方式交易，定位為衍生性金融商品，然卻不受現行相關法令規範。為能成就上述目標，本文首先釐清信用違約交換之性質，其次建立起我國對於信用違約交換之定性，將其定位為有價證券，受我國證交法之管制，使從事交易者須符合證交法之要求。再者以美國法作為借鏡，探究信用違約交換所衍生之議題、以及規範內容及模式，俾使我國法參考。最後對於我國體制提出建議，認為除信用違約交換應納入證交法管制外，也應對於從事交易者的交易數量、監理模式選擇、建立結算處所、強化商品市場透明化及資訊揭露，避免該商品產生更大規模的系統性風險及資訊不對稱狀況為目標。
英文摘要

Credit Default Swap (CDS) is a financial product used to hedge the default risk of credit counterparties. However, the market was flooded with arbitrageurs using CDS to carry out arbitrage, which eventually led to the collapse of the commodity bubble and became a major culprit of the financial crisis in 2008. CDS has the risk of triggering a systemic crisis and causing a serious financial storm; however, its existence also has its positive function. In addition to helping the market find the price, it can also promote investors to hedge the layout. Therefore, it is still difficult to deny its significance and should not be banned comprehensively. Faced with this dilemma, this thesis argues that Taiwan should also develop a better normative model for CDS so that such financial instruments can function properly without causing systemic risks in the financial market. CDS is traded in the form of over-the-counter (OTC), which is positioned as a financial derivative but is not regulated by existing laws and regulations, but it is not regulated by the current relevant laws and regulations. In order to achieve the above objectives, this thesis firstly clarifies the nature of credit default swaps. In the second part, this thesis would analyze CDS, determine the nature of this financial instrument, and argue it should be regulated under Securities Exchange Act. In the third part, this thesis describes CDS regulation of U.S.A., which could be introduced to Taiwan. Finally, this thesis suggests that, CDS is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Act; in addition, the number of traders involved, the choice of a supervision model, the establishment of a clearinghouse, and the enhancement of transparency and information disclosure in the market should also be targeted to avoid systemic risks and information asymmetries on a larger scale.
主题分类 社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. 洪令家(2017)。內線交易再進化：談衍生性金融商品之內線交易。東吳法律學報，29(2)，117-155。
    連結：
  2. 郭土木(2018)。證券交易法有關經主管機關核定之有價證券其範圍與爭議：兼評最高法院 105 年台抗字第 925 號形式裁定。軍法專刊，64(3)，43-60。
    連結：
  3. Admati, A. R.,Hellwig, M. F.(2018).Rock Center for Corporate Governance at Stanford University Working PaperRock Center for Corporate Governance at Stanford University Working Paper,未出版
  4. Aicher, R. D.,Cotton., D. L.,Khan, TK.(2004).Credit Enhancement: Letters of Credit, Guaranties, Insurance and Swaps (The Clash of Cultures).The Business Lawyer,59(3),897-973.
  5. Albert, M. R.(2011).The Howey Test Turns 64: Are The Courts Grading This Test On A Curve?.William & Mary Business Law Review,2(1),1-50.
  6. Alcser, M. G.(1996).The Howey Test: A Common Ground for the Common Enterprise Theory.University of California Davis Law Review,29(4),1217-1242.
  7. Allen, H. J.(2022).DeFi: Shadow Banking 2.0?.William & Mary Law Review,64(3),919-968.
  8. Arnold, M. T.(1984).When Is a Car a Bicycle and Other Riddles: The Definition of a Security under the Federal Securities Laws.Cleveland State Law Review,33(3),449-490.
  9. Awrey, D.(2019).Split Derivatives: Inside the World's Most Misunderstood Contract.Yale Journal on Regulation,36(2),495-574.
  10. Awrey, D.(2014).The Limits of Private Ordering Within Modern Financial Markets.Review of Banking and Financial Law,34,183-254.
  11. Baker, C. M.(2016).When Regulators Collide: Financial Market Stability, Systemic Risk, Clearinghouses, and CDS.Virginia Law & Business Review,10(3),343-394.
  12. Bank for International Settlements. (2021, May 12). Statistical Release: OTC Derivatives Statistics at end-December 2020. BIS. https://www.bis.org/publ/otc_hy2105.pdf
  13. Barr, M. S.,Jackson, H. E.,Tahyar, M. E.(2021).Financial Regulation: Law and Policy.Foundation Press.
  14. Beylin, I.(2020).Designing Regulation for Mobile Financial Markets.UC Irvine Law Review,10(2),497-555.
  15. Bloink, R. S.(2011).Does Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act Rein in Credit Default Swaps? An EU Comparative Analysis.Nebraska Law Review,89(4),587-633.
  16. Borsani, C. L.(2008).A "Common" Problem: Examining the Need for Common Ground in the "Common Enterprise" Element of the Howey Test.Duquesne Business Law Journal,10,1-17.
  17. Buccola, V. S. J.,Mah, J. K.,Zhang, T.(2020).The Myth of Creditor Sabotage.University of Chicago Law Review,87(8),2029-2088.
  18. Cali-Vasquez, Andrew(2013).Making the Case for Credit Default Swaps: Balancing Liquidity Concerns with Position Limits under Dodd-Frank.Journal of Civil Rights and Economic Development,26(4),883-909.
  19. Cao, T. B.(2017).,Faculty of Law, Victoria University of Wellington.
  20. Chander, A.,Costa, R.(2010).Clearing Credit Default Swaps: A Case Studying in Global Legal Convergence.Chicago Journal of International Law,10(2),639-684.
  21. Charap, A.(2011).Minimizing Risks, Maximizing Flexibility: A New Approach to Credit Default Swap Regulation.Journal of Business and Securities Law,11,127-160.
  22. Chen, K.,Fleming, M.,Jackson, J.,Li, A.,Sarkar, A.(2011).,Federal Reserve Bank of New York.
  23. Coffee, J. C.,Sale, H. A.,Whitehead, C. K.(2012).Securities Regulation: Cases and Materials.Foundation Press.
  24. Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems,Technical Committee of The International Organization of Securities Commissions(2012).Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures.Bank for International Settlements.
  25. Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems,Technical Committee of The International Organization of Securities Commissions(2017).Resilience of Central Counterparties (CCPs): Further Guidance on the PFMI.Bank for International Settlements.
  26. Davis, M. R.(1997).Unregulated Investment in Certain Death: Sec v. Life Partners, Inc.Villanova Law Review,42(3),925-968.
  27. De Vries Robbe, J. J.,Ali, P. U.(2005).Securitisation of Derivatives and Alternative Asset Classes: Yearbook (Global Trade and Finance).Kluwer Law International.
  28. Dickinson, E. (2008). Credit Default Swap: So Dear to Us, So Dangerous (Fordham University-School of Law Working Paper Series). https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1315535
  29. D'Souza, F.,Eills, N. S.,Fairchild, L. M.(2010).Illuminating the Need for Regulation in Dark Markets: Proposed Regulation of the OTC Derivatives Market.University of Pennsylvania Journal of Business Law,12(2),473-516.
  30. Dutt, N. G.(2009).Current United States Credit Default Swap Regulatory Initiatives: A New World Standard Or Just A Ploy?.ILSA Journal of International and Comparative Law,16(1),169-233.
  31. Faubus, B. G.(2010).Narrowing the Bankruptcy Safe Harbor for Derivatives to Combat Systemic Risk.Duke Law Journal,59(4),801-842.
  32. Feder, D.(2019).To Clear or Not to Clear: How SEC Implementation of Dodd-Frank Undermines Title Vii's Mandatory Clearing Requirement.Columbia Business Law Review,2019(1),252-304.
  33. Feder, N. M.(2002).Deconstructing Over-the-Counter Derivatives.Columbia Business Law Review,2002(3),677-748.
  34. Fletcher, Gina-G. S.(2019).Engineered Credit Default Swaps: Innovative or Manipulative?.New York University Law Review,94(5),1073-1145.
  35. Garslian, L.(2016).Towards A Universal Model Regulatory Framework for Derivatives: Post-Crisis Conclusions from The United States and The European Union.University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law,37(3),941-1028.
  36. Greenspan, A.(2007).The Age of Turbulence: Adventures in a New World.Penguin Books.
  37. Griffith, S. J.(2014).Substituted Compliance and Systemic Risk: How to Make a Global Market in Derivatives Regulation.Minnesota Law Review,98(4),1291-1373.
  38. Hayes, A. (2023, March 15). What Is a Credit Default Swap (CDS), and How Does It Work? Investopedia. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/creditdefaultswap.asp
  39. Hearn, F.(2012).How New Swap Regulations Mandated by The Dodd-Frank Act Could Help Stabilize the Repo Market.PIABA Bar Journal,19(3),317-346.
  40. Henderson, M. T.(2009).Credit Derivatives Are Not "Insurance".Connecticut Insurance Law Journal,16(1),1-58.
  41. Hu, H. T. C.(2018).Corporate Distress, Credit Default Swaps, and Defaults: Information and Traditional, Contingent, and Empty Creditors.Brooklyn Journal of Corporate, Financial & Commercial Law,13(1),5-32.
  42. Hull, J. C.(2005).Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives.Prentice Hall.
  43. International Swaps and Derivatives Association, Inc. (2021, May). Key Trends in the Size and Composition of OTC Derivatives Markets in the Second Half of 2020. ISDA. https://www.isda.org/a/iSDgE/Key-Trends-in-the-Size-and-Composition-of-OTC-Derivatives-Markets-in-2H-of-2020.pdf
  44. International Swaps and Derivatives Association, Inc. (2020). ISDA Legal Guidelines for Smart Derivatives Contracts: Credit Derivatives. ISDA. https://www.isda.org/a/ur4TE/Guidelines-for-Smart-Contracts-CDS.pdf
  45. Johnson, K. N.(2011).Things Fall Apart: Regulating the Credit Default Swap Commons.University of Colorado Law Review,82(1),167-257.
  46. Juurikkala, O.(2011).Credit Default Swaps and Insurance: Against the Potts Opinion.Journal of International Banking Law and Regulation,26(3),128-135.
  47. Juurikkala, O.(2014).Financial Engineering Meets Legal Alchemy: Decoding The Mystery of Credit Default Swaps.Fordham Journal of Corporate and Financial Law,19(3),425-487.
  48. Keeton, R. E.,Widiss, A. I.(1988).Insurance Law: A Guide to Fundamental Principles, Legal Doctrines and Commercial Practices.West Academic.
  49. Kimball-Stanley, A.(2008).Insurance and Credit Default Swaps: Should Like Things Be Treated Alike?.Connecticut Insurance Law Journal,15(1),241-266.
  50. Kramer, A. S.,Harris, A. B.,Ansehl, R. A.(2009).The New York State Insurance Department and Credit Default Swaps: Good Intentions, Bad idea.Journal of Taxation and Regulation of Financial Institutions,22(3),22-35.
  51. Krug, A. K.(2015).Investing and Pretending.Iowa Law Review,100(4),1559-1618.
  52. Maharaj, J.(2020).Supplementing Dodd-Frank: An Argument for Further Increasing the Regulation of Credit Default Swaps.Journal of Corporation Law,46,247-262.
  53. Mazando, F. H. C.(2012).The Taxonomy Of Global Securities: Is The U.S. Definition Of A Security Too Board ?.Northwestern journal of International law & business,33(1),121-197.
  54. Monaghan, M. K.(1995).An Uncommon State of Confusion: The Common Enterprise Element of Investment Contract Analysis.Fordham Law Review,63(6),2135-2175.
  55. O'Connor, B. R.(2015).Taming the Wild West of Wall Street: Regulating Credit Default Swaps After Dodd-Frank.John Marshall Law Review,48(2),565-604.
  56. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. (2021, September). Quarterly Report on Bank Trading and Derivatives Activities. OCC. https://www.occ.gov/publications-and-resources/publications/quarterly-report-on-bank-trading-and-derivatives-activities/files/pub-derivatives-quarterly-qtr2-2021.pdf
  57. Partnoy, F.,Skeel, D. A., Jr.(2007).The Promise and Perils of Credit Derivatives.University of Cincinnati Law Review,75(3),1019-1051.
  58. Romano, R.(2018).Pitfalls of Global Harmonization of Systemic Risk Regulation in a World of Financial Innovation.Systemic Risk in the Financial Sector: Ten Years After the Great Crash
  59. Romano, R.(1996).A Thumbnail Sketch of Derivative Securities and their Regulation.Maryland Law Review,55(1),1-83.
  60. Sainsbury, C.(2009).Credit Default Swaps: Use and Regulation.Review of Banking and Financial Law,29,3-12.
  61. Scheerer, A.(2000).Credit Derivatives: An Overview of Regulatory Initiatives In The U.S. and Europe.Fordham Journal of Corporate and Financial Law,5(1),149-203.
  62. Schwarcz, S. L.(2020).Regulating Derivatives: A Fundamental Rethinking.Duke Law Journal,70,545-606.
  63. Schwarcz, S. L.(2008).Systemic Risks.Georgetown Law Journal,97(1),193-249.
  64. Schwartz, R. F.(2007).Risk Distribution in the Capital Markets: Credit Default Swaps, Insurance and a Theory of Demarcation.Fordham Journal of Corporate and Financial Law,12(1),167-201.
  65. Schwarzman, S. (2008, November 4). Some Lesson of The Financial Crisis. Wall Street Journal. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122576100620095567.html
  66. Shadab, H. B.(2010).Counterparty Regulation and its Limits: The Evolution of The Credit Default Swaps Market.New York Law School Law Review,54(3),689-705.
  67. Shadab, H. B.(2010).Guilty by Association? Regulating Credit Default Swaps.Entrepreneurial Business Law Journal,4(2),407-466.
  68. Steinberg, M. I.,Kaulbach, W. E.(1987).The Supreme Court and the Definition of "Security": The "Context" Clause, "Investment Contract" Analysis, and their Ramifications.Vanderbilt Law Review,40(3),489-539.
  69. Stout, L. A.(2009).How Derivatives Led to Disaster and Why Re-Regulating Them Can Prevent Another.Lombard Street,1,4-9.
  70. Stulz, R. M.(2010).Credit Default Swaps and the Credit Crisis.Journal of Economic Perspectives,24(1),73-92.
  71. Subrahmanyam, M. G.,Tang, D. Y.,Wang, S. Q.(2014).Does the Tail Wag the Dog? The Effect of Credit Default Swaps on Credit Risk.The Review of Financial Studies,27(10),2927-2960.
  72. Tarbert, H. P.,Grimm, D. J.(2021).The CFTC'S Swap Data Overhaul.Florida State University Business Review,20(1),1-47.
  73. Turk, M. C.(2015).The Convergence of Insurance with Banking and Securities Industries, and the Limits of Regulatory Arbitrage in Finance.Columbia Business Law Review,2015(3),967-1073.
  74. Uhlein, J. W.(2010).Breakdown in The Mortgage Securitization Market: Multiple Causes and Suggestions for Reform.Syracuse Law Review,60(3),503-530.
  75. United States General Accountability Office (2000). CFTC and SEC: Issues Related to the Shad-Johnson Jurisdictional Accord (Report No. GGD-00-89). GAO. https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc290484/m1/1/
  76. Weinstein, S. N.(2019).Financial Regulation in the (Receding) Shadow of Antitrust.Temple Law Review,91(3),447-512.
  77. Wessel, D. (2006, February 16). Wall Street is Cleaning Derivatives Mess. Wall Street Journal. http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB114004392976375183
  78. Wynkoop, N. L.(2008).The Unregulables? The Perilous Confluence of Hedge Funds and Credit Derivatives.Fordham Law Review,76(6),3095-3126.
  79. 中央銀行（編）(2009).全球金融危機專輯.中央銀行.
  80. 立法院公報處（1968），《立法院公報》，57 卷 17 期，立法院。
  81. 何殷如(2012)。全面解讀信用違約交換（CDS）。證券暨期貨月刊，30(11)，37-52。
  82. 余適安(2010).衍生性金融商品百問.財團法人台灣金融研訓院.
  83. 沈大白,凌志銘(2006)。信用違約交換評價之實證研究：TCRI 信用評等資訊之應用。金融風險管理季刊，2(2)，47-74。
  84. 林建中(2021)。銀行分離管制之基礎理論：美國法之介紹與比較反省。政大法學評論，167，309-401。
  85. 邵之雋(2021)。槓桿交易監理創新的國際經驗介紹。交大法學評論，8，97-128。
  86. 郭土木(2004)。結構式商品之法律問題探討。台灣本土法學雜誌，62，127-137。
  87. 郭土木(2007).期貨交易管理法規.自刊.
  88. 陳文炳(2013)。我國店頭衍生性金融商品交易資訊儲存庫之建置。證券櫃檯，167，10-23。
  89. 陳肇鴻(2007)。論信用違約交換之類型化風險及契約類型。月旦財經法雜誌，9，175-194。
  90. 陳肇鴻(2007)。由美國次級房貸市場風暴論信用衍生性商品及信用證券化產品之使用及管制。律師雜誌，338，77-89。
  91. 楊朝成,陳勝源(2009).投資學.華泰文化事業.
  92. 熊肇穆(2003)。結構型商品簡介。證券暨期貨月刊，21(11)，1-9。
  93. 劉邦海(2010)。店頭市場衍生性商品集中交易對手結算之研究。中央銀行季刊，32(4)，17-42。
  94. 劉連煜(2014).新證券交易法實例研習.元照.
  95. 蔡南芳(2011)。後金融海嘯時代信用衍生性金融商品監理法制之淺論。月旦民商法雜誌，33，106-131。
  96. 鄧淑芬(2009)。專題研討四：店頭衍生性金融商品比對及集中結算機制之探討。證券櫃檯，144，33-38。
  97. 謝易宏(2009)。潰敗金融與管制迷思：簡評美國 2008 年金融改革。月旦法學雜誌，164，186-225。
print cancel