全民健保實施前後醫院財務面經營績效之研究

A Study of Operating Performance of Hospitals after the Implementation of National Health Insurance

10.29539/CNABH.200612.0001

陳惠芳(Hui-Fang Chen)；謝明娟(Ming-Jiuan Hsieh)；陳俞成(Yu-Cheng Chen)

經營績效 ； 財務比率 ； 醫院 ； Operating performance ； Financial ratio ； Hospitals

嘉南學報（人文類）

32期（2006 / 12 / 01）

303 - 316

繁體中文

台灣地區健康照護體系近年來在政府大力推動整合下，八十四年實施全民健康保險，支付制度由回溯性之論量計酬至前瞻性支付制度再至總額預算，嚴重衝擊台灣地區健康照護產業。據衛生署統計資料顯示民國八十三年至九十四年間醫療機構之醫院由823家減少至556家，衰退率爲32.4%。健康照護相關產業經營管理者在面臨醫療費用不斷上漲，加上消費者意識抬頭及同業競爭的壓力之下，如何降低成本及促使資源合理分配，提昇經營績效，實是目前極待解決的問題。醫療保健服務對民眾健康的影響甚鉅，而且產業的性質相當特殊，在世界各國均爲政府高度介入的產業，雖然在組織理論中，常被定義爲服務業中的非營利組織，但在經營上深受政府的醫療政策及相關法令的影響，雖不像一般企業以營利爲首要目標，但亦應重視經營績效，以提昇服務品質。本研究向行政院主計處購買民國八十五年及九十年「台閩地區工商及服務業普查」次級資料庫，再篩選醫院之內容，共有1,402筆爲研究樣本。本研究採用SPSS10.0進行資料統計分析，以描述性統計分析基本資料的個數、百分比、資產共同比、比率分析的總數、平均值、極大值、極小值；以卡方檢定分析全民健保實施前後與組織特性之相關性；以獨立樣本T檢定分析全民健保實施前後財務績效、財務比率之差異。結果發現，在獲利能力、資產共同比、資產運用效能、成本控制與員工生產力之指標中，發現固定資產面實施前比率較低，流動資產比率較高，然而在資產運用中流動資產之週轉率，在健保實施後呈現較高，固定資產呈現較低；健保實施後獲利能力皆下降近一半，且成本增加之比率高於收入增加之比率；健保實施後呈現每人用人費用增加，然而其生產力亦提高，在全民健保實施前後醫院組織特性之分析中發現，全民健保的實施對小醫院影響較大。

With the Government's full support and consolidation, the health care system in the territory of Taiwan has implemented National Health Insurance since 1995. The payment system transformed from ”fee-for-service” to ”prospective payment system” and finally to ”global budgets”, and thereby made a material impact to the health care industry in the territory of Taiwan. According to the statistics of the Department of Health, the number of hospitals has declined from 823 in 1994 to 556 in 2005, with a declination rate of 32.4%. The medical treatments and health care services have a material influence to the public's health. Meanwhile, due to the particular feature of the industry, it is intervened by governments throughout the world. Though in terms of the organizational theory, it is often defined as a non-profit-making organization in the business of service and its operation is subject to the government's medical treatment policies and relevant laws. Therefore, notwithstanding that such services do not aim at making a profit as its first priority, they still should pay attention to the performance to upgrade the quality of service. This study purchased the database for ”Report on 1996 and 2001 Industry, Commerce and Service Census Taiwan-Fukien Area, the Republic of China from the Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics of the Executive Yuan. For the selection of the contents of hospitals, we obtained a total of 1,402 research samples. Using SPSS10.0 data analysis. The study result shows that in terms of such indexes as profitability, consolidated asset data, performance of application of assets, cost control and productivity, the ratio of fixed assets appears to be lower prior to the implementation of the National Health Insurance, while the ratio of current assets appears to be higher. Nevertheless, the turnover ratio of current assets appears to be higher upon the implementation of National Health Insurance, while the turnover ratio of fixed assets appears to be lower. Further, the profitability declined by approximately 50% after the implementation of National Health Insurance, and the ratio of increase in cost was higher than that of increase in income. Due to the implementation of National Health Insurance, it appears that each employee's expenses were increased, and their productivity was increased relatively. According to the study on the characteristics of hospitals before and after the implementation of National Health Insurance, the implementation of National Health Insurance produced a more significant impact on small-sized hospitals.

1. Bazzoli G.J.,Chan B.,Shortell S. M.,D'Aunno T.(2000).The financial performance of hospitals belonging to health networks and systems.Inquiry,37(3),234-252.
2. Carpenter C. E.,McCue M. J.,Hossack J. B.(2002).Impact of HMO mergers and acquisitions on financial performance.J Health Care Finance,29(2),67-77.
3. Carpenter C. E.,McCue M. J.,Hossack J. B.(2001).Association of bond, market, operational, and financial factors with multi-hospital system bond is sues.J Health Care Finance,28(2),26-34.
4. Chakravarthy B.(1986).Measuring Strategic Performance.Strategic Management Journal,7(5),437-458.
5. Dyer L.,Reeves T.(1995).Human Resource Strategies and Firm Performance: What Do We Know and Where Do We Need to Go?.The International Journal of Human Resource Management,8(3),656-670.
6. Frinh H. Q.,O'connor S. J.(2002).Helpful or harmful? The impact of strategic change on the performance of U.S. urban hospitals.Health Serv Res,37(1),145-171.
7. Jonathan W. C.,Steven C.,Eric S. E.(2000).Strategic Performance Management: Development of a Performance Measurement System at the Mayo Clinic.Journal of Healthcare Management,45(1),58-68.
8. Kumar K.,Subramanian R.,Strandholm K.(2002).Market and efficiency-based strategic responses to environmental changes in the health care industry.Health Care Manage Rev,27(3),21-31.
9. Nakamba P.,Hanson K.(2002).University of Zambia, Markets for hospital services in Zambia.Int J Health Plann Manage,17(3),229-247.
10. Seror A.C.(2002).Internet infrastructures and health care systems: a qualitative comparative analysis on networks and markets in the British National Health Service and Kaiser Permanente.J Med Internet Res,4(3)
11. Venkatraman N.,Ramanujam V.(1986).Measurement of Business Performance on Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches.Academy of Management Review,11(4),801-814.
12. Vijay A. H.(2003).Department Benchmarks.Health Facilities Mangement,16(5),28-29.
13. Walters B. A.,Clarke I.,Henley E. S.,Shandiz M.(2001).Strategic decision-making among top executives in acute-care hospitals.Health Mark Q,19(1),43-59.
14. Weech-Maldonado R.,Neff G.,Mor V.(2003).The relationship between quality of care and financial performance in nursing homes.Health Care Finance,29(3),48-60.
15. Weech-Maldonado R.,Neff G.,Mor V.(2003).Does quality of care lead to better financial performance?: the case of the nursing home industry.Health Care Manage Res,28(3),201-216.
16. Weech-Maldonado R.,Zinn J. E.,Hamilton R. D.(2001).The performance impact of context in TQM implementation: the nursing facility industry.Health Serv Manage Res,14(3),147-158.
17. Zeller T. L.,Stanko B. B.(1997).A New Perspective on Hospital Financial Ratio Analysis.Healthcare Financial Management,51(11)
18. 中華民國長期照護專業協會(2002)。臺閩地區長期照護資源名冊。
19. 江克儉(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立東華大學。
20. 民國94年醫療機構現況及醫療服務量統計
21. 吳萬益、林文寶(2001)。以資源網路觀點探討策略聯盟間管理作爲與績效關係之研究。淡江人文社會學刊，8，55-84。
22. 吳萬益、鄭永忠、江正信(2000)。大型教學醫院組織文化、內部激勵與控制制度對經營績效之影響研究。輔仁管理評論，7(1)，103-130。
23. 郭乃文、鍾國彪(2002)。行政院國科會報告行政院國科會報告,未出版
24. 黃國哲、湯澡薰(2002)。行政院國科會報告行政院國科會報告,未出版
25. 楊志良、劉順仁、朱炫璉(1999)。國內綜合醫院管理控制制度實施現況及成效。會計研究月刊，161，115-118。
26. 葉銀華、柯承恩、蘇裕惠(2000)。中小企業財務結構與經營績效關係之研究。中山管理評論，8(2)，303-323。
27. 蔡明田,廖曜生(2001).The Relationships between Human Resource Management Controls and Firm Performance-Testing the Model of Perrow's Technology Classification.勞資關係論叢,10,29-47.
28. 謝淑慧(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。雲林科技大學。

1. 程建銘,馬志豪,林芷薐(2011)。以Kano二維模型探討醫療服務品質與住院病患滿意度之研究：以中部某區域型醫院爲例。修平學報，23，103-132。
2. 郭怡婷,柯伯昇(2022)。應用倒傳遞類神經網路預測醫療機構盈餘之研究。醫務管理期刊，23(2)，183-197。
3. 蔣靜怡、郎慧珠(2017)。台灣診所之歇業與存活研究及其相關因素探討—以2000年至2010年新設西醫診所研究為例。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，36(6)，626-639。
4. 廖素如,黃劭彥,張茂澤,卓佳慶(2023)。影響私立高中職新生註冊率之關鍵因素。會計學報，9(1)，1-40。
5. 謝明娟、沈姍姍、吳淑雲(2009)。公立醫院經營績效分析—以某南部地區醫院爲例。嘉南學報（人文類），35，545-559。