視訊面談與臨場面談的面談表現評價之比較－職務－履歷適配之干擾作用

The Comparison of Interviewees Performance Appraisal between Video-Conferencing and Face-to-Face Media: Positions-Resumes Fit as Moderators

羅新興(Hsin-Hsin Lo)；蕭金蘭(Ching-Lan Hsiao)；羅右杰(Yu-Chieh Lo)

視訊面談 ； 臨場面談 ； 面談表現評價 ； 職務－履歷適配 ； video-conferencing interviews ； face-to-face interviews ； interviewees performance appraisal ； position-resume fit

組織與管理

6卷1期（2013 / 02 / 01）

121 - 140

繁體中文

本研究目的在探討面試官利用視訊面談與臨場面談給予應徵者的面談表現評價差異性，並探索於職務－履歷適配與否的不同情況下，上述視訊面談與臨場面談的應徵者表現評價差異性的不同。本研究採模擬面談實驗法，受試者為企業組織成員，模擬面談一位由研究人員所扮演的應徵者，實驗採用2×2×2的全受試者間設計，回收有效樣本230份。研究結果發現，當職務－履歷不適配時，面試官給予臨場面談應徵者的面談表現評價高於視訊面談應徵者；當職務－履歷適配時，面試官給予臨場面談應徵者與視訊面談應徵者的面談表現評價則沒有差異。本研究也同時討論研究發現的理論貢獻與實務內涵。

This research program contained two major parts: one was to examine the difference of interviewee performance appraisal between video-conferencing and face-to-face interviews; the other was to exploring the difference of interviewee performance appraisal between video-conferencing and face-to-face interviews under whether positions-resumes fit or not. This research was conducted by mock interviews for members of organization and researcher played the role of applicant. The experiment was tested using 2×2×2 between subjects design. The researcher obtained an effective sample of 230. The results of this study showed that interviewees performance appraisals were lower in video-conferencing than in face-to-face interviews when applicants applied specialty information of resumes that could not fit for position requests; however, it was not difference between video-conferencing and face-to-face interviews when applicants applied specialty information of resumes that fit for position requests. We also discussed the theoretical contributions and practical applications about research findings.

1. 孫蒨如、李易儒(2004)。訊息型態及思考目的對稀釋效果的影響。中華心理學刊，46(1)，59-74。
   連結：
2. 陳建丞、蔡維奇(2005)。面談前印象對面試官評量效應之影響：以面談結構性為干擾變數。台大管理論叢，16(1)，155-170。
   連結：
3. 羅新興、李幸穗(2004)。應徵者面談過程所呈現的訊息對面談表現評價的影響─以企業員工的招募甄選為實驗情境。人力資源管理學報，4(3)，55-72。
   連結：
4. Anderson, J. C.,Johnson, E. N.,Kap1an, S. E.(1994).Perceived effects of gender, family structure, and physical appearance on career progression in public accounting: A research note.Accounting, Organizations and Society,19(6),483-491.
5. Arvey, R. D.,Campion, J. E.(1982).The employment interview: A summary and review recent research.Personnel Psychology,35,281-322.
6. Bauer, T. N.,Truxillo, D. M.,Paronto, M. E.,Weekley, J. A.,Campion, M. A.(2004).Applicant reactions to different selection technology: Face-to-face, interactive voice response, and computer-assisted telephone screening interviews.International Journal of Selection and Assessment,12(1/2),135-148.
7. Camussi, E.,Leccardi, C.(2005).Stereotypes of working women: The power of expectations.Social Science Information,44,113-140.
8. Chapman, D. S.,Rowe, P. M.(2001).The impact of videoconference technology, interview structure, and interviewer gender on interviewer evaluations in the employment interview: A filed experiment.Journal of Occupational & Organizational Psychology,74(3),279-298.
9. Chapman, D. S.,Rowe, P. M.(2002).The influence of videoconference technology and interview structure on the recruiting function of the employment interview: A filed experiment.International Journal of Selection and Assessment,10(3),185-197.
10. Chapman, D. S.,Uggerslev, K. L.,Webster, J.(2003).Applicant reactions to face-to-face technology-mediated interviews: A filed investigation.Journal of Applied Psychology,88(5),944-953.
11. Chapman, D. S.,Webster, J.(2001).Rater correction processes in applicant selection using videoconference technology: The role of attributions.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,31(12),2518-2537.
12. Christiansen, N. D.,Wolcott-Burnam, S.,Janovies, J. E.,Burns, G. N.,Quirk, S. W.(2005).Good judge revisited: Individual differences in the accuracy of personality judgements.Human Performance,18(2),123-149.
13. Cooper, V. W.(1997).Homophily or the queen bee syndrome.Small Group Research,28(4),483-499.
14. Ellemers, N.,van den Heuvel, H.,de Gilder, D.,Maass, A.,Bonvini, A.(2004).The underrepresentation of women in science: Differential commitment or the queen bee syndrome?.British Journal of Social Psychology,43,315-388.
15. Ellsworth, P. D.,Carlsmith, J. M.(1973).Eye contact and gaze aversion in an aggressive encounter.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,28,280-292.
16. Gilmore, D. C.,Beehr, T. A.,Love, K. G.(1986).Effects of applicant sex, applicant physical attractiveness, type of rater and type of job on interview decisions.Journal of Occupational Psychology,59(2),103-109.
17. Giordano, G. A.(2006).The effect of computer-mediation, training, and warning on false alarms in an interview setting.Communications of AIS,18,2-25.
18. Heilman, M. E.,Saruwatari, L. R.(1979).When beauty is beastly: The effects of appearance and sex on evaluations of job applicants for managerial and non-managerial jobs.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,23(3),360-372.
19. Hilton, J. L.,Fein, S.(1989).The role of typical diagnosticity in stereotype-based judgments.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,57,201-211.
20. Howard, J. L.,Ferris, G. R.(1996).The employment interview context: Social and situational influences on interviewer decisions.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,26,112-136.
21. Knouse, S. B.(1989).The role of attribution theory in personnel employment selection: A review of the recent literature.The Journal of General Psychology,116(2),183-196.
22. Kobak, K. A.,Williams, J. B. W.,Engelhardt, N.(2008).A comparison of face to face and remote assessment of inter-rater reliability on the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale via videoconferencing.Psychiatry Research,158,99-103.
23. Marlowe, C. M.,Schneider, S. L.,Nelson, C. E.(1996).Gender and attractiveness biases in hiring decisions: Are more experienced managers less biased?.Journal of Applied Psychology,81(1),11-21.
24. Modai, I.,Jabarlin, M.,Kurs, R.,Barak, P.,Hanan, I.,Kitain, L.(2006).Cost effectiveness, safety, and satisfaction with video telepsychiatry versus face-to-face care in ambulatory settings.Telemedicine Journal & E-Health,12(5),515-520.
25. Robbins, S. P.,Judge, T. A.(2009).Organizational Behavior.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Pearson Education.
26. Sia, C. L.,Tan, B. C. Y.,Wei, K. K.(2002).Group polarization and computer-mediated communication: Effects of communication cues, social presence, and anonymity.Information Systems Research,13(1),70-90.
27. Sproull, L. S.,Kiesler, S. B.(1986).Reducing social context cues: Electronic mail in organizational communication.Management Science,32(11),1492-1512.
28. Stevens, C. K.,Kristof, A. L.(1995).Making the right impression: A field study of applicant impression management during job interview.Journal of Applied Psychology,80(5),587-606.
29. Susan, S. G.,Milesb, J. A.,Levesquec, L. L.(2001).The effect of videoconference, telephone, and face-to-face media on interviewer and applicant judgments in employment interviews.Journal of Management,27(3),363-381.
30. Tsai, W. C.,Chen, C. C.,Chiu, S. F.(2005).Exploring boundaries of the effects of applicant impression management tactics in job interviews.Journal of Management,31(1),108-125.
31. Vonk, R.(1993).The negativity effect in trait ratings and in open-ended descriptions of persons.Personality Social Psychology Bulletin,19(3),269-278.

1. 劉仲矩,巫姵瑾(2022)。人工智慧面談關鍵成功因素之重要性研究。科技與人力教育季刊，9(1)，1-20。
2. 羅新興,梁成明(2023)。面試官的失誤憂慮對給予應徵者表現評價之影響：視訊面談與現場面談之比較。組織與管理，16(1)，47-74。
3. 羅新興,梁成明,王彥蓁(2022)。專業能力對面談表現評分的影響－男性與女性面試官在視訊與現場面談之差異。中原企管評論，20(3)，83-104。
4. 羅新興,羅景文,高婷鈺(2021)。視訊面談與現場面談情況下面試官給予應徵者表現評價的比較：面試官調節焦點之干擾效果。人力資源管理學報，21(2)，57-74。