女性主管的性別歧視：性別角色傳統傾向與女王蜂症候群

The Sexual Discrimination from Female Manager: The Inclination of Gender Stereotype and Queen Bee Syndrome

溫金豐(Jin-Feng Uen)；石若瑩(Jo-Ying Shih)；陳淑媛(Shu-Yuan Chen)；張菡琤(Han-Cheng Chang)

女王蜂症候群 ； 女性主管 ； 性別角色刻板印象 ； 性別歧視 ； 性別研究 ； queen bee syndrome ； gender stereotype ； sexual discrimination ； female manager ； gender research

組織與管理

6卷2期（2013 / 08 / 01）

79 - 113

繁體中文

過去討論性別歧視議題多以男性歧視女性等觀點做為探討該議題的理論依據，忽略女性本身可能也是造成性別歧視的重要推手，而其根本緣由應是與傳統性別刻板印象有關。本研究以組織生態學及社會認同理論探討女性主管性別角色傳統傾向與其女王蜂行為的關係，並以女性主管的婚姻狀態及部門性別比例進行調節效果檢驗。研究發現，三個主要的假設都獲得支持，即性別角色傳統傾向與女王蜂症候群具顯著正向關係，以及未婚的女性主管和男性比例較高的部門將使前述關係更為顯著，具有更強烈的正向調節關係。

When it comes to the issues of sexual discrimination, they would be discussed and concluded with male's prejudice and ignored the female's discrimination on gender difference. These unfair discriminations may usually follow the gender stereotyping held by a society. The purpose of this study is to explore the relationship between female managers' inclination of gender stereotype and their queen bee behaviors standing by the viewpoints of Organizational Ecology and Social Identity Theory. Also, we tested the moderating effects of female manager's marriage status and the gender composition of the department. All the hypotheses were supported. The results showed that the stereotype of female managers had a significant positive relationship with queen bee behaviors. The single marital status of female managers and the high-male gender composition of the department strengthened the relationship between the traditional inclination of gender stereotype held by female managers and their queen bee behaviors.

1. 朱蘭慧(2003)。男性性別角色刻板印象之形成與鬆動。應用心理研究，17，85-119。
   連結：
2. 林姿葶、鄭伯壎(2007)。性別與領導角色孰先孰後？主管－部屬性別配對、共事時間及家長式領導。中華心理學刊，49(4)，433-450。
   連結：
3. 黃芳玫、翁任蟬、黃芳雅(2009)。女性勞動參與之研究─1980-2005。臺灣經濟預測與政策，39(2)，1-50。
   連結：
4. U.S. Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2009). Working in the 21st Century. Retrieved from http://www.bls.gov/opub/working/page3b.htm
5. 行政院主計處（2010）。2009社會指標統計年報。臺北市：作者。
6. 韓俊彥（2010）。女性勞動力的崛起。2009社會指標統計年報，75-78。
7. Darwin, C. (1871). The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex. London, UK: John Murray
8. The World Bank. (2011). Labor participation rate, female (% of Female Population Ages 15+). Retrieved from http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.TLF.CACT.FE.ZS
9. Aiken, L. S.,West, S. G.(1991).Multiple regression testing and interpreting interaction.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
10. Ancona, D. G.,Caldwell, D. F.(1992).Demography and design: Predictors of new product team performance.Organization Science,3(3),321-341.
11. Banse, R.,Gawronski, B.,Rebetez, C.,Gutt, H.,Morton, B. J.(2010).The development of spontaneous gender stereotyping in childhood: Relations to stereotype knowledge and stereotype flexibility.Developmental Science,13(2),298-306.
12. Baritono, R.(2008).An ideology of sisterhood?: American women's movements between nationalism and transnationalism.Journal of Political Ideologies,13(2),181-199.
13. Baron, R. M.,Kenny, D. A.(1986).The moderator-mediator bariable fistinction in docial psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,51(6),1173-1182.
14. Baumgartner, H.,Homburg, C.(1996).Applications of structural equation modeling in marketing and consumer research: A review.International Journal of Research in Marketing,13(2),139-161.
15. Bergen, D. J.,Williams, J. E.(1991).Sex stereotypes in the United States revisited: 1972-1988.Sex Roles,24(7-8),413-423.
16. Berry, J. K. R.(1975).A critical look at the queen bee syndrome.Journal of the NAWDAC,38(4),173-176.
17. Blalock, H.(1967).Toward a theory of minority-group relations.New York, NY:Wiley.
18. Breakwell, G. M.(1986).Coping with Threatened Identities.London, UK:Methuen.
19. Chattopadhyay, P.,Tluchowska, M.,George, E.(2004).Identifying the ingroup: A closer look at the influence of demographic dissimilarity on employee social identity.Academy of Management Review,29(2),180-202.
20. Cooper, V. W.(1997).Homophily or the queen bee syndrome: Female evaluation of female leadership.Small Group Research,28(4),483-499.
21. Deaux, K.,Reid, A.,Mizrahi, K.,Ethier, K. A.(1995).Parameters of social identity.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,68(2),280-291.
22. DeKeseredy, W. S.(2011).Feminist contributions to understanding woman abuse: Myths, controversies, and realities.Aggression and Violent Behavior,16(4),297-302.
23. Devine, P. G.(1989).Stereotypes and prejudice: Their automatic and controlled components.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,56(1),5-18.
24. Efthim, P. W.,Kenny, M. E.,Mahalik, J. R.(2001).Gender role stress in relation to shame, guilt, and externalization.Journal of Counseling & Development,79(4),430.
25. Eisenmann, L.(2002).Educating the female citizen in a post-war world: Competing ideologies for American women, 1945-1965.Educational Review,54(2),133-141.
26. Ellemers, N.,Van Den Heuvel, H.,De Gilder, D.,Maass, A.,Bonvini, A.(2004).The underrepresentation of women in science: Differential commitment or the queen bee syndrome?.British Journal of Social Psychology,43(3),315-338.
27. Folbre, N.,Nelson, J. A.(2000).For love or money-Or both?.Journal of Economic Perspectives,14(4),123-140.
28. French, E.(2001).Approaches to equity management and their relationship to women in management.British Journal of Management,13,267-285.
29. Ghodsee, K.(2010).Revisiting the United Nations decade for women: Brief reflections on feminism, capitalism and cold war politics in the early years of the international women's movement.Women's Studies International Forum,33(1),3-12.
30. Hair, J. F.,Black, B.,Babin, B.,Anderson, R. E.,Tatham, R. L.(2006).Multivariate data analysis.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
31. Hannan, M. T.,Freeman, J. H.(1989).Organizational ecology.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
32. Hardin, J. R.,Reding, K. F.,Stocks, M. H.(2002).The effect of gender on the recruitment of entry-level accountants.Journal of Managerial Issues,14(2),251.
33. Hogg, M. A.,Hains, S. C.(1996).Intergroup relations and group Solidarity: Effects of group identification and social beliefs on depersonalized attraction.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,70(2),295-309.
34. Ibarra, H.(1992).Homophily and differential returns: Sex differences in network structure and access in an advertising firm.Administrative Science Quarterly,37(3),422-447.
35. Johnson, Z.,Mathur-Helm, B.(2011).Experiences with queen bees: A South African study exploring the reluctance of women executives to promote other women in the workplace.South African Journal of Business Management,42(4),47-55.
36. Karakowsky, L.,Siegel, J. P.(1999).The effects of proportional representation and gender orientation of the task on emergent leadership behavior in mixedgender work groups.Journal of Applied Psychology,84(4),620-631.
37. Katila, S.,Meriläinen, S.(1999).A serious researcher or just another nice girl?: Doing gender in a male-dominated scientific community.Gender, Work & Organization,6(3),163-173.
38. Khader, S. J.(2008).When equality justifies women's subjection: Luce irigaray's critique of equality and the fathers' rights movement.Hypatia,23(4),48-74.
39. Lawrence, B. S.(2006).Organizational reference groups: A missing perspective on social context.Organization Science,17,80-100.
40. Lipińska-Grobelny, A.,Wasiak, K.(2010).Job satisfaction and gender identity of women managers and non-managers.International Journal of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health,23(2),161-166.
41. Martin, J.(1981).Relative deprivation: A theory of distributive injustice for an era of shrinking resources.Research in Organizational Behavior,3,53-107.
42. Mavin, S.(2008).Queen bees, wannabees and afraid to bees: No more "best enemies" for women in management?.British Journal of Management,19,S75-S84.
43. Mavin, S.(2006).Venus envy 2: Sisterhood, queen bees and female misogyny in management.Women In Management Review,21(5),349-364.
44. Mavin, S.(2006).Venus envy: Problematizing solidarity behaviour and queen bees.Women In Management Review,21(4),264-276.
45. Moore, D.(1999).Gender traits and identities in a "masculine" organization: The Israeli police force.Journal of Social Psychology,139(1),49-68.
46. Myaskovsky, L.,Unikel, E.,Dew, M. A.(2005).Effects of gender diversity on performance and interpersonal behavior in small work groups.Sex Roles,52(9/10),645-657.
47. Oyserman, D.,Harrison, K.(1998).Implications of cultural context: African American identity and possible selves.San Diego, CA:Academic.
48. Schieman, S.,McMullen, T.(2008).Relational demography in the workplace and health: An analysis of gender and the subordinate-superordinate role-set.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,49(3),286-300.
49. Serbin, L. A.,Sprafkin, C.(1986).The salience of gender and the process of sex typing in three- to seven-year-old children.Child Development,57(5),1188-1199.
50. Snipes, R. L.,Oswald, S. L.,Caudill, S. B.(1998).Sex-role stereotyping, gender biases, and job selection: The use of ordinal logit in analyzing likert scale data.Employee Responsibilities & Rights Journal,11(2),81-97.
51. Sparrowe, R. T.,Liden, R. C.(1997).Process and structure in leader-member exchange.Academy of Management Review,22(2),522-552.
52. Spence, J. T.,Helmreich, R. L.(1978).Masculinity and femininity: Their psychological dimensions, correlates, and antecedents.Austin, TX:University of Texas Press.
53. Staines, G.,Tavris, C.,Jayaratne, T. E.(1974).The queen bee syndrome.Psychology Today,5,55-60.
54. Starr, K.(2001).What makes management experience different for women? Secrets revealed through the structure of cathexis.Rethinking Gender, Work and Organization Conference,Keele:
55. Strack, F.,Deutsch, R.(2004).Reflective and impulsive determinants of social behavior.Personality & Social Psychology Review,8(3),220-247.
56. Tajfel, H.(1974).Social identity and intergroup behaviour.Social Science Information,13(2),65-93.
57. Tajfel, H.,Turner, J. C.(1986).The social identity theory of intergroup behavior.Chicago, IL:Nelson.
58. Terborg, J. R.(1977).Women in management: A research review.Journal of Applied Psychology,62(6),647-664.
59. Toder, N. L.(1980).The effect of the sexual composition of a group on discrimination against women and sex-role attitudes.Psychology of Women Quarterly,5(2),292.
60. Zhao, J.,Stockwell, T. I. M.,Macdonald, S.(2009).Non-response bias in alcohol and drug population surveys.Drug & Alcohol Review,28(6),648-657.
61. 李美枝、鍾秋玉(1996)。性別與性別角色析論。本土心理學研究，6，260-299。
62. 程樹德(1999)。愛情的社會生物學。科學月刊，30(2)，100-104。
63. 楊國樞(1981)。中國人的性格與行為： 形成與蛻變。中華心理學刊，23(1)，39-55。

1. 唐孟廷(2016)。年輕女性生涯圖像：從工作與家庭探討。淡江大學未來學研究所碩士班學位論文。2016。1-59。