题名

類粉絲效應：網路負面口碑的抑制與弱化

并列篇名

Zealot Effect: Mitigating the Expansion of Electronic Negative Word-of-Mouth

DOI

10.3966/199687602019081202002

作者

李怡慧(Joyce Yi-Hui Lee)

关键词

內容分析 ； 社會網絡分析 ； 網路口碑 ； 線上網絡影響 ； 線上論壇 ； qualitative content analysis ； social network analysis ； electronic word-of-mouth ； online networked influence ； online discussion forum

期刊名称

組織與管理

卷期/出版年月

12卷2期（2019 / 08 / 01）

页次

55 - 111

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

網路意見日趨氾濫之際，過去口碑行銷研究不斷提醒行銷人員需謹慎地處理網路負面口碑，因為其影響比正面口碑來得更為強大。行銷人員介入有時不只無濟於事，反而招致「業配文」的酸言酸語；若置之不理，又可能發展為難以收拾的「線上風暴」。現有研究較少探討如何控制負面口碑，本研究從線上網絡影響著手，探索成員之間如何相互影響，在負面意見擴大時能將其抑制。本研究以汽車線上論壇為個案，分析負面與正面評論意見如何消長。本研究採用質性研究，以社會網絡分析法解讀負面口碑弱化的過程。研究發現，關鍵影響力來自三方面：孤立無援的負面意見代表、此唱彼和的正面意見領袖群、沉默潛水者的發聲呼應。他們在網絡關係上處在不同的地位，在不同討論階段產生影響力；此三類網絡角色在關鍵議題的角力戰，促使負面評論者的凝聚力潰散、正面討論者互動增強，削弱原本鼓譟激動的負面情緒；研究同時觀察到，具有影響力的討論者熱切地表達對品牌的友善支持，但刻意表明自己並非品牌愛用者或粉絲，此「類粉絲」現象凸顯出不同的粉絲效應，以及對品牌支持的不同表現，形成討論者意見凝聚和相互呼應的新樣貌。
英文摘要

The popularity of online communication platforms (e.g. discussion forum, web community) creates a possible contagious effect regarding electronic word-of-mouth which can be easily spread and lead to the brand or product become well-known. However, organizations might be facing serious impacts caused by electronic negative word-of-mouth (e-NWOM) and consequentially their reputations might become harmed. While researchers have highlighted that marketers and organizations need to make sense of and respond to e-NWOM effectively for preventing ＂online firestorms＂, the questions regarding the management and control of e-NWOM remained unexplored. To fill the research gap, this study addresses the research questions about how explosive e-NOWM becoming mild and the dissemination slowing down. Taking the theoretical lens of online networked influence theory, this research conducts an interpretive case study by using the social network analysis with qualitative approach. The research outcomes demonstrate powerful effect raised by three types of zealous participants. The interactions between them made a significant contribution to the result of e- NWOM reduction. Theoretical contributions and practical implementations derived from the research findings are discussed in this article.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 方世榮,張苑惠(2006)。網路口碑形成之影響因素：以網路涉入程度與虛擬社群管理為干擾因素。電子商務學報，8(4)，499-531。
    連結：
  2. 王光旭(2015)。社會網絡分析在公共行政領域研究的應用。調查研究─方法與應用，34，67-134。
    連結：
  3. 周志宏,韓揚銘,邱建達,范錚強(2017)。行動排隊服務對消費者排隊心理影響之研究。電子商務學報，19(2)，205-238。
    連結：
  4. 林彣珊,唐嘉鴻(2010)。網路口碑說服效果之研究。行銷評論，7(2)，187-208。
    連結：
  5. 姚惠忠,楊奕源(2014)。危機溝通之期望缺口模型。組織與管理，7(2)，127-163。
    連結：
  6. 紀乃文,陳珮綺,林宥吟(2017)。顧客負面事件影響顧客導向公民行為、服務破壞行為的認知與情感歷程：服務人員顧客導向特質與情緒展示規則的干擾效果。組織與管理，10(2)，155-200。
    連結：
  7. 陳蘊芳,郭憲誌,林孟彥(2017)。社群參與之活化。管理學報，34(4)，529-555。
    連結：
  8. 劉夢曉(2017)。負面在線評論和商家反饋對消費者購買意願的影響研究。電子商務學報，19(1)，155-200。
    連結：
  9. 歐素華(2019)。精準分眾以創新：由使用者行為引導媒體服務設計。中山管理評論，27(1)，11-56。
    連結：
  10. Abedi, V. S.,Berman, O.,Krass, D.(2014).Supporting new product or service introductions: Location, marketing and word of mouth.Operations Research,62(5),994-1013.
  11. Adjei, M. T.,Noble, S. M.,Noble, C. H.(2010).The influence of C2C communications in online brand communities on customer purchase behavior.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,38(5),634-653.
  12. Altheide, D. L.(1996).Qualitative media analysis.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  13. Arndt, J.(1967).Role of product-related conversations in the difussion of a new product.Journal of Marketing Research,4(3),291-294.
  14. Baek, S. I.,Kim, Y. M.(2015).Longitudinal analysis of online community dymamics.Industrial Management & Data Systems,115(4),661-677.
  15. Bambauer-Sachse, S.,Mangold, S.(2011).Brand equity dilution through negative online word-of-mouth communication.Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,18,38-45.
  16. Barsade, S.(2002).The ripple effect: Emotional contagion and its effect on group behavior.Administrative Science Quarterly,47(4),644-675.
  17. Berger, J.(2012).Bad reviews can boost sales: Here's why.Harvard Business Review, March,March, 28
  18. Blom, R.,Carpenter, S.,Bowe, B. J.,Lange, R.(2014).Frequent contributors within US newspaper comment forums: An examination of their civility and information value.American Behavioral Scientist,58(10),1314-1328.
  19. Bos, W.,Tarnai, C.(1999).Content analysis in empirical social research.International Journal of Education Research,31,659-671.
  20. Bowman, D.,Narayandas, D.(2001).Managing customer-initiated contacts with manufactures: The impact on share of category requirements and word-of-mouth behavior.Journal of Marketing Research,38(3),281-297.
  21. Brown, J.,Broderickm, A. J.,Lee, N.(2007).Word of mouth communication within online communities: Conceptualizing the online social network.Journal of Interactive Marketing,21(3),2-20.
  22. Bryman, A.,Bell, E.(2003).Business research methods.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  23. Burt, R. S.(2005).Brokerage and closure.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  24. Chevalier, J. A.,Mayzlin, D.(2006).The effect of word of mouth on sales: Online book reviews.Journal of Marketing Research,43(3),345-354.
  25. Chintagunta, P. K.,Gopinath, S.,Venkataraman, S.(2010).The effects of online user reviews on movie box office performance: Accounting for sequential rollout and aggregation across local markets.Maketing Science,29(5),944-957.
  26. Chiu, M.-H. P.,Wu, C.-C.(2012).Integrated ACE model for consumer health information needs: A content analysis of questions in Yahoo! Answers.Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,49(1),1-10.
  27. Colm, L.,Ordanini, A.,Parasuraman, A.(2017).When service customers do not consume in isolation: A typology of customer copresence influence modes.Journal of Service Research,20(3),223-239.
  28. Cranefield, J.,Yoong, P.(2009).Crossings: Embedding personal professional knowledge in a complex online community environment.Online Information Review,33(2),257-275.
  29. Cranefield, J.,Yoong, P.,Huff, S. L.(2015).Rethinking lurking: Invisible leading and following in a knowledge transfer ecosystem.Journal of the Association for Information Systems,16(4),213-247.
  30. Dellarocas, C.,Gao, G.,Narayan, R.(2010).Are consumers more likely to contribute online reviews for hit or niche products?.Journal of Management Information Systems,27(2),127-157.
  31. Dominguez, S.(Ed.),Betina, H.(Ed.)(2014).Mixed methods social networks research.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  32. Eisenhardt, K. M.,Graebner, M. E.(2007).Theory building from cases: Opportunities and challenges.Academy of Management Journal,50(1),25-32.
  33. Fang, R.,Chi, L.,Chen, M.,Baron, R. A.(2015).Bring political skill into social networks: Findings from a field study of entrepreneurs.Journal of Management Studies,52(2),175-212.
  34. Faraj, S.,Johnson, S. L.(2011).Network exchange patterns in online communities.Organization Science,22(6),1464-1480.
  35. Fraade-Blanar, Z.,Glazer, A. M.(2017).Superfandom: How our obsessions are changing what we buy and who we are.London, UK:W. W. Norton & Company.
  36. Freeman, L. C.(1979).Centrality in social-network-conceptual clarification.Social Networks,1(3),215-239.
  37. Friemel, T. N.(2015).Influence versus selection: A network perspective on opinion leadership.International Journal of Communication,9,1002-1022.
  38. Goh, K.-Y.,Heng, C. S.,Lin, Z.(2013).Social media brand community and consumer behavior: Quantifying the relative impact of user- and marketer-generated content.Information Systems Research,24(1),88-107.
  39. Graham, T.,Wright, S.(2014).Discursive equality and everyday talk online: The impact of "superparticipants".Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,19,625-642.
  40. Gregor, S.(2006).The nature of theory in information systems.Mis Quarterly,30(3),611-642.
  41. Gruzd, A.,Wellman, B.(2014).Networked influence in social media: Introduction to the special issue.American Behavioral Scientist,58(10),1251-1259.
  42. Haenlein, M.,Libai, B.(2017).Seeding, referral, and recommendation.California Management Review,59(2),68-91.
  43. Hajli, N.,Sims, J.(2015).Social commerce: The transfer of power from sellers to buyers.Technological Forecasting & Social Change,94,350-358.
  44. Hanna, R.,Rohm, A.,Crittenden, V. L.(2011).We’re all connected: The power of the social media ecosystem.Business Horizons,54(3),265-273.
  45. Hara, N.,Bonk, C. J.,Angeli, C.(2000).Content analysis of online discussion in an applied educational psychology course.Instructional Science,28(2),115-152.
  46. Heckscher, C.(Ed.),Adler, P.(Ed.)(2006).The firm as a collaborative community: Reconstructing trust in the knowledge economy.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
  47. Henning-Thurau, T.,Gwinner, K. P.,Walsh, G.,Gremler, D. D.(2004).Electronic word-of-mouth via consumer-opinion platforms: What motivates consumers to articulate themselves on the Internet.Journal of Interactive Marketing,18(1),38-52.
  48. Herhausen, D.,Luwig, S.,Grewal, D.,Wulf, J.,Schoegel, M.(2019).Detecting, preventing, and mitigating online firestorms in brand communities.Journal of Marketing,83(3),1-21.
  49. Hornik, J.,Satchi, R. S.,Cesareo, L.,Pastore, A.(2015).Information dissemination via electronic word-of-mouth: Good news travels fast, bad news travels faster.Computer in Human Behavior,45,273-280.
  50. Hsieh, H. F.,Shannon, S. E.(2005).Three approaches to qualitative content analysis.Qualitative Health Research,15(9),1277-1288.
  51. Huang, M.,Cai, F.,Tsang, A. S. L.,Zhou, N.(2011).Making your online voice loud: The critical role of WOM information.European Journal of Marketing,45(7/8),1277-1279.
  52. Huffaker, D.(2010).Dimensions of leadership and social influence in online communities.Human Communication Research,36,593-617.
  53. Johnson, S. L.,Safadi, H.,Faraj, S.(2015).The emergence of online community leadership.Information Systems Research,26(1),165-187.
  54. Keiningham, T.,Rust, R. T.,Lariviere, B.,Aksoy, L.,Williams, L.(2018).A roadmap for driving customer word-of-mouth.Journal of Service Management,29(1),2-38.
  55. Kim, H.,Hanssens, D. M.(2017).Advertising and word-of-mouth effects on pre-launch consumer interest and initial sales of experience products.Journal of Interactive Marketing,37,57-74.
  56. Kim, S.,Kandampully, J.,Bilgihan, A.(2018).The influence of eWOM communications: An application of online social network framework.Computers and the Humanities,80,243-254.
  57. King, R. A.,Racherla, P.,Bush, V. D.(2014).What we know and don't know about online word-of-mouth: A review and snythesis fo the literature.Journal of Interactive Marketing,28,167-183.
  58. Kirby, J.(Ed.),Marsden, P.(Ed.)(2005).Connected marketing.London, UK:Butterworth-Heinemann.
  59. Kozinets, R. V.,de Valck, K.,Wojnicki, A. C.,Wilner, S. J. S.(2010).Networked narratives: Understanding word-of-mouth marketing in online communities.Journal of Marketing,74(2),71-89.
  60. Kristopher, F.,Freling, R.,Alhoqail, S.,Cho, H. Y.,Freling, T.(2014).How online product reviews affect retail sales: A meta-analysis.Journal of Retailing,90(2),217-232.
  61. Kwon, K. H.,Stefanone, M. A.,Barnett, G. A.(2014).Social network influence on online behavioral choices: Exploring group formation on social network sites.American Behavioral Scientist,58(10),1345-1360.
  62. Lee, J. Y. H.,Yang, C.-S.,Hsu, C.,Wang, J.-H.(2019).A longitudinal study of leader influence in sustaining an online community.Information & Management,56,306-316.
  63. Lee, J.,Park, D.-H.,Han, I.(2008).The effect of negative online consumer reviews on product attitude: An information processing view.Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,7,341-352.
  64. Lewis-Beck, M. S.(Ed.),Bryman, A.(Ed.),Liao, T. F.(Ed.)(2004).The SAGE encyclopedia of social science research methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  65. Libai, B.,Bolton, R.,Bugel, M. S.,de Ruyter, K.,Gotz, O.,Risselada, H.,Stephen, A. T.(2011).Customer-to-customer interactions: Broadening the scope of word of mouth research.Journal of Service Research,13(3),267-282.
  66. Lim, B. C.,Chung, C. M. Y.(2011).The impact of word-of-mouth communication on attribute evaluation.Journal of Business Research,64(1),18-23.
  67. Lim, Y.-S.,van der Heide, B.(2015).Evluating the wisdom of strangers: The perceived credibility of online consumer reviews on Yelp.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,20,67-82.
  68. Lipizzi, C.,Landoli, L.,Marquez, J. E. R.(2016).Combining structure, content and meaning in online social networks: The analysis of public early reaction in social media to newly launched movies.Technological Forecasting & Social Change,109,35-49.
  69. Litvin, S. W.,Goldsmith, R. E.,Pan, B.(2008).Electronic word-of-mouth in hospitality and tourism management.Tourism Management,29,458-468.
  70. Majchrzak, A.,Faraj, S.,Kane, G.,Azad, B.(2013).The contradictory influence of social media affordances on online communal knowledge sharing.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,19,38-55.
  71. Mehra, A.,Dixon, A. L.,Brass, D. J.,Robertson, B.(2006).The social network ties of group leaders: Implications for group performance and leader reputation.Organization Science,17(1),64-79.
  72. O’Connell, A.(2010).Reading the public mind.Harvard Business Review,October,27-34.
  73. Oh, W.,Jeon, S.(2007).Membership herding and network stability in the open source community: The ising perspective.Management Science,53(7),1086-1101.
  74. Oh, W.,Moon, J. Y.,Hahn, J.,Taekyung, K.(2016).Research note- Leader influence on sustained participation in online collaborative work communities: A simulation-based approach.Information System Research,27(2),383-402.
  75. Panteli, N.(2016).On leaders’ presence: Interactions and influences within online communities.Behaviour & Information Technology,35(6),490-499.
  76. Pfeffer, J.,Zorbach, T.,Carley, K. M.(2014).Understanding online firestorms: Negative word-of-mouth dynamics in social media networks.Journal of Marketing Communications,20(1-2),117-128.
  77. Preece, J.,Nonnecke, B.,Andrews, D.(2004).The top five reasons for lurking: Improving community experiences for everyone.Computers in Human Behavior,20(2),201-223.
  78. Quan-Haase, A.,Suarez, J. L.,Brown, D. M.(2015).Collaboraing, connecting and clustering in the humanities: A case study of networked scholarship in an interdisciplinary, dispersed team.American Behavioral Scientist,59(5),565-581.
  79. Quaschning, S.,Pandelaere, M.,Vermeir, I.(2015).When consistency matters: The effect of valence consistency on review helpfulness.Jounnal of Computer-Mediated Communication,20,136-152.
  80. Roberson, K. M.,O’Reilly, J,Hannah, D. R.(2019).Finding meaning in relationships: The impact of network ties and structure on the meaningfulness.Academy of Management Review
  81. Rosario, A. B.,Sotgiu, F.,De Valck, K.,Bijmolt, T. H. A.(2016).The effect of electronic word of mouth on sales: A meta-analytic review of platform, product, and metric factors.Journal of Marketing Research,53(3),297-318.
  82. Sarker, S.,Ahuja, M.,Sarker, S.,Kirkeby, S.(2011).The role of communication and trust in global teams: A social network perspective.Journal of Management Information Systems,28(1),273-309.
  83. Scott, J.(2017).Social network analysis.London, UK:Sage.
  84. Scott, J.(Ed.),Carrington, P. J.(Ed.)(2011).The Sage handbook of social network analysis.London, UK:Sage.
  85. Sutanto, J.,Tan, C.-H.,Battistini, B.,Phang, C. W.(2011).Emergent leadership in virtual collaboration settings: A social network analysis approach.Long Range Planning,44(5-6),421-439.
  86. Trusov, M.,Bucklin, R. E.,Pauwels, K.(2009).Effects of word-of-mouth versus traditional marketing: Findings from an internet social networing site.Journal of Marketing,73(5),90-102.
  87. Verhagen, T.,van Nes, J.,Feldberg, F.,van Dolen, W.(2014).Virtual customer service agents: Using social presence and personalization to shape online service encounters.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,19,529-545.
  88. Weiss, A. M.,Lurie, N. H.,Macinnis, D. J.(2008).Listering to strangers: Whose responses are valuable, how valuable are they, and why?.Journal of Marketing Research,45(4),425-436.
  89. Welbers, K.,de Nooy, W.(2014).Stylistic accommodation on an Internet forum as bonding: Do posters adapt to the style of their peers.American Behavioral Scientist,58(10),1361-1375.
  90. Wellman, B.,Quan-Haase, A.,Boase, J.,Chen, W.,Hampton, K.,Díaz, I.,Miyata, K.(2003).The social affordances of the Internet for networked individualism.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication,8(3)
  91. Williams, M.,Buttle, F.(2014).Managing negative word-of-mouth: An exploratory study.Journal of Marketing Management,30(13-14),1423-1447.
  92. Wuyts, S. H. K.,Dekimpe, M. G.,Gijsbrechts, E.,Pieters, F. G. M.(2010).The connected customer: The changing nature of consumer and business markets.New York, NY:Routledge.
  93. Yang, F. X.(2013).Effects of restaurant satisfaction and knowledge sharing motication on eWOM intentions.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,41,93-127.
  94. Yetis-Larsson, Z.,Teigland, R.,Dovbysh, O.(2015).Networked entrepreneurs: How entrepreneurs leverage open source software communities.American Behavioral Scientist,59(4),475-491.
  95. Yin, R. K.(2014).Case study research: Design and methods.Los Angeles, CA:Sage.
  96. Zhang, Y.,Trusov, M.,Stephen, A.,Jamal, Z.(2017).Online shopping and social media: Friends or foes?.Journal of Marketing,81(6),24-41.
  97. Zhao, Y.,Gang, K.,Yi, P.,Yang, C.(2018).Understanding influence power of opinion leaders in e-commerce networks: An opinion dynamics theory perspective.Information Sciences,426,131-147.
  98. 羅家德(2011).社會網分析講義.北京市:社會科學文獻.
print cancel