求職者觀點下的臺灣家族企業組織形態

Family-Business as an Organizational Form: Taiwanese Job Seekers' Perspectives

10.3966/199687602021021401003

許書瑋(Ryan Shuwei Hsu)；王妙如(Miao-Ju Wang)

Zaltman隱喻萃取技術 ； 求職者 ； 家族企業 ； 組織形態 ； 質性研究 ； Zaltman Metaphor Elicitation Technique (ZMET) ； job seeker ； family business ； organizational form ； qualitative research

組織與管理

14卷1期（2021 / 02 / 01）

79 - 126

繁體中文

從組織形態理論出發，本研究試圖瞭解臺灣求職者對家族企業此一組織形態所抱持的預設期望，並由此整理發展出得以辨識與區別家族企業與非家族企業的組織形態特徵屬性。透過Zaltman的隱喻萃取技術，本研究探索求職者難以言說的預設期望，發展出求職者在六個關係屬性的分析結果，包括組織與工作者未來連動關係、控制關係、人際信賴關係、合作關係、工作回報，以及工作意義等。透過比對家族企業與非家族企業的研究結果，本研究提出以關係責任與關係自主區分求職者對於家族企業與非家族企業在組織形態上的預設特徵屬性。研究的結果有助於我們理解臺灣家族企業在求才市場上所面臨的社會認知環境，以及展現其豐富的在地本土文化意涵。

Extant research suggests that organizational form functions as a collective organizational identity and is often defined by certain default expectations held by external audiences. In this study, we adopt Zaltman's metaphor elicitation technique (ZMET) to explore job seekers' hard-to-articulated default expectations for an important yet understudied organizational form in Taiwan - family business. Our findings suggest that Taiwanese job seekers adopt a relational lens in understanding the organizational form of family business. We identify a total of six relational attributes that define and distinguish family from non-family business. Based on those relational attributes, we identify two organizing concepts to explain the organizational forms of family and non-family business in the eyes of the job seekers: relational obligation and relational autonomy. Our findings contribute to the extant literatures by explicating the rich socio-cognitive and ingenious-cultural meanings of family business in contemporary Taiwan labor markets.

1. 樊景立,鄭伯壎(2000)。華人組織的家長式領導：一項文化觀點的分析。本土心理學研究，13，126-180。
   連結：
2. Albert, S.,Whetten, D.(1985).Organizational identity.Research in organizational behavior,Greenwich, CT:
3. Aldrich, H. E.,Ruef, M.(2006).Organizations evolving.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
4. Ashforth, B. E.,Harrison, S. H.,Corley, K. G.(2008).Identification in organizations: An examination of four fundamental questions.Journal of Management,34(3),325-374.
5. Audretsch, D. B.,Lehmann, E. E.,Schenkenhofer, J.(2018).Internationalization strategies of hidden champions: Lessons from Germany.Multinational Business Review,26(1),2-24.
6. Barber, A. E.,Roehling, M. V.(1993).Job postings and the decision to interview: A verbal protocol analysis.Journal of Applied Psychology,78(5),845-856.
7. Barnett, M. L.,Jermier, J. M.,Lafferty, B. A.(2006).Corporate reputation: The definitional landscape.Corporate Reputation Review,9(1),26-38.
8. Berger, P.,Luckmann, T.(1967).The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge.New York, NY:Doubleday.
9. Block, J. H.,Fisch, C. O.,Lau, J.,Obschonka, M.,Presse, A.(2016).Who prefers working in family firms? An exploratory study of individuals’ organizational preferences across 40 countries.Journal of Family Business Strategy,7(2),65-74.
10. Botero, I. C.(2014).Effects of communicating family ownership and organisational size on an applicant’s attraction to a firm: An empirical examination in the USA and China.Journal of Family Business Strategy,5(2),184-196.
11. Bretz, R. D., Jr.,Judge, T. A.(1998).Realistic job previews: A test of the adverse self-selection hypothesis.Journal of Applied Psychology,83(2),330-337.
12. Cable, D. M.,Aiman-Smith, L.,Mulvey, P. W.,Edwards, J. R.(2000).The sources and accuracy of job applicants’ beliefs about organizational culture.Academy of Management Journal,43(6),1076-1085.
13. Campion, M. C.,Campion, E. D.,Campion, M. A.(2019).Using practice employment tests to improve recruitment and personnel selection outcomes for organizations and job seekers.Journal of Applied Psychology,104(9),1089-1102.
14. Charmaz, K.(2006).Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
15. Cho, T. S.,Hambrick, D. C.(2006).Attention as the mediator between top management team characteristics and strategic change: The case of airline deregulation.Organization Science,17(4),453-469.
16. Chua, J. H.,Chrisman, J. J.,Sharma, P.(1999).Defining the family business by behavior.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,23(4),19-39.
17. Chuang, A.,Hsu, R. S.,Wang, A. C.,Judge, T. A.(2015).Does West “fit” with East? In search of a Chinese model of person-environment fit.Academy of Management Journal,58(2),480-510.
18. Coulter, R. H.,Zaltman, G.(1994).Using the Zaltman metaphor elicitation technique to understand brand images.Advances in consumer research,Provo, UT:
19. Covin, T. J.(1994).Perceptions of family-owned firms: The impact of gender and educational level.Journal of Small Business Management,32(3),29-39.
20. Covin, T. J.(1994).Profiling preference for employment in family-owned firms.Family Business Review,7(3),287-296.
21. Donaldson, T.,Dunfee, T. W.(1994).Toward a unified conception of business ethics: Integrative social contracts theory.Academy of Management Review,19(2),252-284.
22. Edwards, J.(1991).Person-job fit: A conceptual integration, literature review, and methodological critique.International review of industrial and organizational psychology,New York, NY:
23. Gersick, K. E.(1997).Generation to generation: Life cycles of the family business.Boston, MA:Harvard Business Press.
24. Glaser, B. G.,Strauss, A. L.(1967).The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research.Chicago, IL:Aldine.
25. Guba, E. G.,Lincoln, Y. S.(1994).Competing paradigms in qualitative research.Handbook of qualitative research,Thousand Oaks, CA:
26. Hannan, M. T.,Freeman, J.(1977).The population ecology of organizations.American Journal of Sociology,82(5),929-964.
27. Hannan, M. T.,Pólos, L.,Carroll, G. R.(2007).Logics of organization theory: Audiences, codes, and ecologies.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
28. Hauswald, H.,Hack, A.(2013).Impact of family control/influence on stakeholders’ perceptions of benevolence.Family Business Review,26(4),356-373.
29. Hauswald, H.,Hack, A.,Kellermanns, F. W.,Patzelt, H.(2016).Attracting new talent to family firms: Who is attracted and under what conditions?.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,40(5),963-989.
30. Hsu, G.,Hannan, M. T.(2005).Identities, genres, and organizational forms.Organization Science,16(5),474-490.
31. Hsu, R. S.,Stanworth, J. O.(2018).Work as good-minded undertakings and effortless assignments: Chinese meaning of working for hospitality workers and its motivational implications.Journal of Organizational Behavior,39(1),52-66.
32. Hwang, K. K.(1987).Face and favor: The Chinese power game.American Journal of Sociology,92(4),944-974.
33. International Family Enterprise Research Academy(2003).Family businesses dominate.Family Business Review,16(4),235-240.
34. King, B. G.,Whetten, D. A.(2008).Rethinking the relationship between reputation and legitimacy: A social actor conceptualization.Corporate Reputation Review,11(3),192-207.
35. Krappe, A.,Goutas, L.,von Schlippe, A.(2011).The “family business brand”: An enquiry into the construction of the image of family businesses.Journal of Family Business Management,1(1),37-46.
36. Kristof-Brown, A.,Guay, R. P.(2011).Person-environment fit.Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology,Washington, DC:
37. Lacey, J. N.,Crosby, O.(2004).Job outlook for college graduates.Occupational Outlook Quarterly,48(4),15-23.
38. Lakoff, G.,Johnson, M.(1980).The metaphorical structure of the human conceptual system.Cognitive Science,4(2),195-208.
39. Lee, S. H.(2021).An attention-based view of strategic human resource management.Academy of Management Perspectives,35(2)
40. Levy, O.(2005).The influence of top management team attention patterns on global strategic posture of firms.Journal of Organizational Behavior: The International Journal of Industrial, Occupational and Organizational Psychology and Behavior,26(7),797-819.
41. Macrae, C. N.,Bodenhausen, G. V.(2001).Social cognition: Categorical person perception.British Journal of Psychology,92(1),239-255.
42. Markus, H. R.,Kitayama, S.(1991).Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation.Psychological Review,98(2),224-253.
43. Meyer, J. W.,Scott, W. R.(1983).Organizational Environments: Ritual and rationality.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
44. Morgan, G.(1986).Metaphor of organization.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
45. Muchinsky, P. M.,Monahan, C. J.(1987).What is person-environment congruence? Supplementary versus complementary models of fit.Journal of Vocational Behavior,31(3),268-277.
46. Myers, M. D.,Newman, M.(2007).The qualitative interview in IS research: Examining the craft.Information and Organization,17(1),2-26.
47. Nisbett, R. E.,Peng, K.,Choi, I.,Norenzayan, A.(2001).Culture and systems of thought: Holistic versus analytic cognition.Psychological Review,108(2),291-310.
48. Ocasio, W.(2011).Attention to attention.Organization Science,22(5),1286-1296.
49. Ocasio, W.(1997).Towards an attention-based view of the firm.Strategic Management Journal,18,187-206.
50. Ocasio, W.,Joseph, J.(2005).An attention-based theory of strategy formulation: Linking micro- and macro perspectives in strategy processes.Strategy process (Advances in Strategic Management),Bingley, UK:
51. Oyserman, D.,Coon, H. M.,Kemmelmeier, M.(2002).Rethinking individualism and collectivism: Evaluation of theoretical assumptions and meta-analyses.Psychological Bulletin,128(1),3-72.
52. Pólos, L.,Hannan, M. T.,Carroll, G. R.(2002).Foundations of a theory of social forms.Industrial and Corporate Change,11(1),85-115.
53. Ryan, A. M.,Sacco, J. M.,McFarland, L. A.,Kriska, S. D.(2000).Applicant self-selection: Correlates of withdrawal from a multiple hurdle process.Journal of Applied Psychology,85(2),163-179.
54. Saks, A. M.,Wiesner, W. H.,Summers, R. J.(1994).Effects of job previews on self-selection and job choice.Journal of Vocational Behavior,44(3),297-316.
55. Schneider, B.(1987).The people make the place.Personnel Psychology,40(3),437-453.
56. Sovina, J.,Collins, C. J.(2003).The effects of organizational brand equity on employment brand equity and recruitment outcomes.Academy of Management Proceedings,2003(1),B1-B6.
57. Stets, J. E.,Burke, P. J.(2000).Identity theory and social identity theory.Social Psychology Quarterly,63(3),224-237.
58. Trope, Y.,Liberman, N.(2011).Construal level theory.Handbook of Theories of Social Psychology,1&2,118-134.
59. Turban, D. B.,Eyring, A. R.,Campion, J. E.(1993).Job attributes: Preferences compared with reasons given for accepting and rejecting job offers.Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,66(1),71-81.
60. Uggerslev, K. L.,Fassina, N. E.,Kraichy, D.(2012).Recruiting through the stages: A meta-analytic test of predictors of applicant attraction at different stages of the recruiting process.Personnel Psychology,65(3),597-660.
61. Warren, S.(2018).Photography in qualitative organizational research: Conceptual, analytical and ethical issues in photo-elicitation inspired methods.The SAGE handbook of qualitative business and management research methods,London, UK:
62. Yu, K. Y. T.(2009).Affective influences in person-environment fit theory: Exploring the role of affect as both cause and outcome of PE fit.Journal of Applied Psychology,94(5),1210-1226.
63. Zaltman, G.(2003).How customer think: Essential insights into the mind of the market.Boston, MA:Harvard Business School Press.
64. Zaltman, G.,Coulter, R.(1995).Seeing the voice of customer: Metaphor-based advertising research.Journal of Advertising Research,35(4),35-51.
65. 李建興(2017)。台灣家族企業接班大調查，揭開交棒不能說的祕密。遠見雜誌，378，180-187。
66. 曹瓊文,陳世哲(2016)。家族治理：一個被人管研究領域忽略的議題。人文與社會科學簡訊，17(2)，41-48。
67. 楊國樞(1998).家族化歷程泛家族主義及組織管理.臺北市:遠流.
68. 楊國樞(1993)。中國人的社會取向：社會互動的觀點。中國人的心理與行為：理論與方法篇，臺北市:
69. 蔡鴻青(2017)。2016年華人家族治理關鍵報告。家族治理評論，8，20-28。