學生如何成為創業家？立基於制度的微觀層次探討

How a Student Become an Entrepreneur? An Institutional Micro-level Process Analysis

10.53106/199687602022021501001

蔡依倫(I-Lun Tsai)；謝如梅(Ru-Mei Hsieh)

制度的微觀基礎 ； 社會互動 ； 創業育成 ； 創業家 ； 競賽邏輯與市場邏輯 ； microfoundations of institutions ； social interaction ； entrepreneurship and incubation ； entrepreneurs ； logics of contest vs. logics of market

組織與管理

15卷1期（2022 / 02 / 01）

1 - 45

繁體中文

創業家身處的制度脈絡關乎其創業行為的展現，然而，既有研究僅探討創業家如何辨識機會，或是創業家如何順從或改變鉅觀制度，對於創業家與制度之互動動態討論卻十分有限。為了填補此一研究缺口，本研究採取制度的微觀層次分析，探究學生如何成為創業家。我們長期追蹤觀察一學生創業團隊，分析他們如何在經歷多元的創業育成制度下，使其新創事業逐漸穩健運作（2013～2018年）。本研究首先歸納出學生創業家與創業育成制度共同建構出的四種社會互動，包含「威權－順從」、「橋接－利用」、「需求－驗證」與「競爭－學習」。再者，不同於過去鉅觀制度觀點認定人們在制度性安排下理所當然成為創業家，本研究指出，行動者為了解決創業實務的困境，試圖鬆解微觀的互動秩序，才逐漸展現出創業家的身分認同。本研究的貢獻在於，從制度的微觀層次探討創業現象，彰顯出人寓居於制度的能動性，填補既有鉅觀與微觀創業研究之不足。

Despite the central role of institutional contexts in the entrepreneurial process, extant researches pay little attention to the interactions between entrepreneurs and institutions. To fill the research gap, the study explored how a student becomes an entrepreneur by examining social interactions between student entrepreneurs and entrepreneurship education at the micro level. We conducted qualitative research on a case of student entrepreneurship by tracing the process of a start-up that is embedded in multiple institutional logics (2013-2018). The research results reveal four forms of social interactions: ＂commanding-conforming,＂ ＂bridging-exploiting,＂ ＂demanding-verifying,＂ ＂competing-learning＂. Furthermore, in contrast to the macro-institutional discourse in which that students took entrepreneurial identity for granted due to homogeneity, the study depicts that students identify themselves as entrepreneurs by releasing interaction orders. Drawing on an institutional perspective at the micro-level process, the study fills the gap between macro- and micro-entrepreneurship researches.

1. 王致遠,蔡敦浩,吳孟珍,李至昱(2017)。創業實作課程如何產生學習：創制研究取徑。管理學報，34(2)，147-166。
   連結：
2. 林家五,黃國隆,鄭伯壎(2004)。從認同到開創：創業家的動態釋意歷程。中山管理評論，12(2)，337-397。
   連結：
3. 張元杰,陳旻男(2010)。新創事業成長策略：商機—資源—組織的共演。科技管理學刊，15(2)，83-116。
   連結：
4. 溫肇東,羅育如,林大溢(2010)。台灣科技創業競賽十年回顧。科技管理學刊，15(4)，121-153。
   連結：
5. 謝如梅,蔡依倫(2016)。時勢造英雄：創業制度與創業活動之關聯性研究。組織與管理，9(1)，89-124。
   連結：
6. Alvarez, S. A.,Young, S. L.,Woolley, J. L.(2015).Opportunities and institutions: A co-creation story of the king crab industry.Journal of Business Venturing,30(1),95-112.
7. Arora-Jonsson, S.,Brunsson, N.,Hasse, R.(2020).Where does competition come from? The role of organization.Organization Theory,1(1)
8. Barley, S.(2019).Working institution.Institutions and organizations: A process view,New York, NY:
9. Barney, J. A. Y.,Felin, T.(2013).What are microfoundations?.Academy of Management Perspectives,27(2),138-155.
10. Bergmann, H.,Hundt, C.,Sternberg, R.(2016).What makes student entrepreneurs? on the relevance (and irrelevance) of the university and the regional context for student start-ups.Small Business Economics,47(1),53-76.
11. Bitektine, A.,Haack, P.(2015).The “macro” and the “micro” of legitimacy: Toward a multilevel theory of the legitimacy process.Academy of Management Review,40(1),49-75.
12. Bjørnskov, C.,Foss, N. J.(2016).Institutions, entrepreneurship, and economic growth: What do we know and what do we still need to know?.Academy of Management Perspectives,30(3),292-315.
13. Blank, S.(2013).Why lean startup change everything.Harvard Business Review,91(5),63-72.
14. Brändle, L.,Berger, E. S.,Golla, S.,Kuckertz, A.(2018).I am what I am－How nascent entrepreneurs’ social identity affects their entrepreneurial self-efficacy.Journal of Business Venturing Insights,9,17-23.
15. DiMaggio, P. J.,Powell, W. W.(1991).The new institutionalism in organizational analysis: Introduction.The new institutionalism in organizational analysis,Chicago, IL:
16. Felin, T.,Foss, N. J.,Ployhart, R. E.(2015).The microfoundations movement in strategy and organization theory.The Academy of Management Annals,9(1),575-632.
17. Fisher, G.,Kuratko, D. F.,Bloodgood, J. M.,Hornsby, J. S.(2017).Legitimate to whom? The challenge of audience diversity and new venture legitimacy.Journal of Business Venturing,32(1),52-71.
18. Friedland, R.,Alford, R. R.(1991).Bringing society back in: Symbols, practices and institutional contradictions.The new institutionalism in organizational analysis,Chicago, IL:
19. Goffman, E.(1983).The interaction order: American Sociological Association, 1982 presidential address.American Sociological Review,48(1),1-17.
20. Gray, B.,Purdy, J. M.,Ansari, S.(2015).From interactions to institutions: Microprocesses of framing and mechanisms for the structuring of institutional fields.Academy of Management Review,40(1),115-143.
21. Greenwood, R.,Raynard, M.,Kodeih, F.,Micelotta, E. R.,Lounsbury, M.(2011).Institutional complexity and organizational responses.The Academy of Management Annals,5(1),317-371.
22. Greve, H. R.(2013).Microfoundations of management: Behavioral strategies and levels of rationality in organizational action.Academy of Management Perspectives,27(2),103-119.
23. Haack, P.,Sieweke, J.,Wessel, L.(2020).Microfoundations and multi-level research on institutions.Microfoundations of institutions,Bingley, UK:
24. Hallett, T.,Hawbaker, A.(2020).Bringing society back in again: The importance of social interaction in an inhabited institutionalism.Microfoundations of institutions,Bingley, UK:
25. Hallett, T.,Ventresca, M. J.(2006).Inhabited institutions: Social interactions and organizational forms in Gouldner’s patterns of industrial bureaucracy.Theory and Society,35(2),213-236.
26. Hardy, C.,Maguire, S.(2017).Institutional entrepreneurship and change in field.The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism,London, UK:
27. Harmon, D. J.,Haack, P.,Roulet, T. J.(2019).Microfoundations of institutions: A matter of structure versus agency or level of analysis?.Academy of Management Review,44(2),464-467.
28. Hwang, H.,Colyvas, J.(2020).What do we talk about when we talk about microfoundations? Conceptualizations of actor and multi-level accounts of the micro in institutional processes.Microfoundations of institutions,Bingley, UK:
29. Jafari-Sadeghi, V.(2020).The motivational factors of business venturing: Opportunity versus necessity? A gendered perspective on European countries.Journal of Business Research,113,279-289.
30. Jennings, P. D.,Greenwood, R.,Lounsbury, M. D.,Suddaby, R.(2013).Institutions, entrepreneurs, and communities: A special issue on entrepreneurship.Journal of Business Venturing,28(1),1-9.
31. Jepperson, R.,Meyer, J. W.(2011).Multiple levels of analysis and the limitations of methodological individualisms.Sociological Theory,29(1),54-73.
32. Khaire, M.(2010).Young and no money? Never mind: The material impact of social resources on new venture growth.Organization Science,21(1),168-185.
33. Kyrö, P.(2015).The conceptual contribution of education to research on entrepreneurship education.Entrepreneurship & Regional Development,27(9-10),599-618.
34. Langley, A.,Smallman, C.,Tsoukas, H.,Van de Ven, A. H.(2013).Process studies of change in organization and management: Unveiling temporality, activity, and flow.Academy of Management Journal,56(1),1-13.
35. Lee, C. K.,Hung, S. C.(2014).Institutional entrepreneurship in the Informal economy: China’s Shan ‐ Zhai mobile phones.Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal,8(1),16-36.
36. Maitlis, S.,Christianson, M.(2014).Sensemaking in organizations: Taking stock and moving forward.Academy of Management Annals,8(1),57-125.
37. Mars, M. M.,Slaughter, S.,Rhoades, G.(2008).The state-sponsored student entrepreneur.The Journal of Higher Education,79(6),638-670.
38. McPherson, C. M.,Sauder, M.(2013).Logics in action managing institutional complexity in a drug court.Administrative Science Quarterly,58(2),165-192.
39. O’Connor, A.(2013).A conceptual framework for entrepreneurship education policy: Meeting government and economic purposes.Journal of Business Venturing,28(4),546-563.
40. Parker, S. C.,Belghitar, Y.(2006).What happens to nascent entrepreneurs? An econometric analysis of the PSED.Small Business Economics,27(1),81-101.
41. Patriotta, G.,Siegel, D.(2019).The context of entrepreneurship.Journal of Management Studies,56(6),1194-1196.
42. Powell, W. W.,Colyvas, J. A.(2008).Microfoundations of institutional theory.The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism,London, UK:
43. Reay, T.,Zilber, T. B.,Langley, A.,Tsoukas, H.(2019).Introduction: Institutions and organizations: A process view.Institutions and organizations: A process view,New York, NY:
44. Rindova, V.,Barry, D.,Ketchen, D. J., Jr.(2009).Entrepreneuring as emancipation.Academy of Management Review,34(3),477-491.
45. Ruef, M.,Scott, W. R.(1998).A multidimensional model of organizational legitimacy: Hospital survival in changing institutional environments.Administrative Science Quarterly,43(4),877-904.
46. Schumpeter, J. A. (1942). Capitalism, socialism and democracy. New York, NY: Harper and Row.
47. Scott, W. R.(2015).Organizations and organizing: Rational, natural and open systems perspectives.New York, NY:Routledge.
48. Seo, M.-G.,Creed, W. D.(2002).Institutional contradictions, praxis, and institutional change: A dialectical perspective.Academy of Management Review,27(2),222-247.
49. Shane, S.(2000).Prior knowledge and the discovery of entrepreneurial opportunities.Organization Science,11(4),448-469.
50. Shane, S.,Nicolaou, N.(2015).Creative personality, opportunity recognition and the tendency to start businesses: A study of their genetic predispositions.Journal of Business Venturing,30(3),407-419.
51. Smets, M.,Jarzabkowski, P.,Burke, G. T.,Spee, P.(2015).Reinsurance trading in Lloyd’s of London: Balancing conflicting-yet-complementary logics in practice.Academy of Management Journal,58(3),932-970.
52. Smets, M.,Morris, T. I. M.,Greenwood, R.(2012).From practice to field: A multilevel model of practice-driven institutional change.Academy of Management Journal,55(4),877-904.
53. Suchman, M. C.(1995).Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches.Academy of Management Review,20(3),571-610.
54. Thébaud, S.(2015).Business as plan B: Institutional foundations of gender inequality in entrepreneurship across 24 industrialized countries.Administrative Science Quarterly,60(4),671-711.
55. Thornton, P. H.,Ocasio, W.(2008).Institutional logics.The SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism,London, UK:
56. Thornton, P. H.,Ocasio, W.,Lounsbury, M.(2012).The institutional logics perspective: A new approach to culture, structure, and process.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
57. Tolbert, P. S.,Coles, R.(2018).Studying entrepreneurship as an institution.Knowledge and institutions,Cham, Switzerland:
58. Tsoukas, H.(2011).Craving for generality and small-N studies: A wittgensteinian approach towards the epistemology of the particular in organization and management studies.The SAGE handbook of organizational research methods,London, UK:
59. Überbacher, F.(2014).Legitimation of new ventures: A review and research programme.Journal of Management Studies,51(4),667-698.
60. Urbano, D.,Aparicio, S.,Audretsch, D.(2019).Twenty-five years of research on institutions, entrepreneurship, and economic growth: What has been learned?.Small Business Economics,53(1),21-49.
61. Van Gelderen, M.(2010).Autonomy as the guiding aim of entrepreneurship education.Education and Training,52(8),710-721.
62. van Gelderen, M.,Kautonen, T.,Fink, M.(2015).From entrepreneurial intentions to actions: Self-control and action-related doubt, fear, and aversion.Journal of Business Venturing,30(5),655-673.
63. Walter, S. G.,Block, J. H.(2016).Outcomes of entrepreneurship education: An institutional perspective.Journal of Business Venturing,31(2),216-233.
64. Yin, R. K.(1994).Case study research: Design and methods.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
65. 林慧貞（2016，2月22日）。台灣本土巧克力，可可公主愛屏東。上下游新聞市集。https://www.newsmarket.com.tw/blog/82493/
66. 教育部青年發展署（ 2014）。 U-start創新創業計畫 。 https://ustart.yda.gov.tw/bin/home.php
67. 教育部資訊與科技教育司（2014，2月22日 ）。青創世代——2014智慧生活創新創業計畫成果發表會。http://www.ensit.tw/?p=2475
68. 郭哲昆、魏勝德、黃振全（2017）。推動屏東可可產業跨域發展。農政與農情，302。https://www.coa.gov.tw/ws.php?id=2506656
69. 湯凱傑,黃怡晴,邱錦田,王玳琪,詹德譯(2017).我國大學校園創業激勵方案成效研析.臺北市:財團法人國家實驗研究院科技政策研究與資訊中心.
70. 黃郁棻,葉家顯,賴又寧,陳心儀(2018).創新激勵獎推動模式與效益分析.臺北市:財團法人國家實驗研究院科技政策研究與資訊中心.
71. 楊海嵐(2013)。創業競賽——創新企業的推手：以Echelon和YEF為例。臺灣經濟研究月刊，36(11)，52-58。
72. 經濟部（ 2014）。 青年創業專案（ 103～ 105年）核定本 。 https://www.moea.gov.tw/Mns/populace/home/Home.aspx