以系統性文獻回顧發展圖文教材輔助單板滑雪課堂側錄之關鍵元素

Key factors of Developing Cue Cards of Snowboarding Lecture Recording-A Systematic Review of Snowboard Tutorial Videos

李慈芃(Lee-Tzu Peng)

YouTube影片 ； 學習動機 ； 圖文教材 ； 單板滑雪 ； 課程側錄影片 ； Cue Cards ； Learning Value ； Lecture Recording ； Snowboard Training ； YouTube video

中華印刷科技年報

2022（2022 / 05 / 01）

143 - 152

繁體中文

技能動作教學常以課程側錄回顧動作表現，然缺乏資訊引導的側錄影片若學習者先備知識不足，觀看時則無法判斷觀察重點而容易失去學習專注。圖文教材如何輔助教學現場未經剪輯之課程錄影？本文旨在由學習者角度，以系統性文獻回顧篩選YouTube平台上具代表性單板滑雪網路教學影片，分析使用者評論關鍵字語意，探討引起「學習動機」元素，作為「發展圖文教材輔助單板滑雪課堂側錄影片」之依據。研究結果發現：一、具代表性的293支單板滑雪教學影片，54%影片來自三個主要頻道；二、「學習動機」分為學習價值、任務認知、自我效能、結果期望、與意志力，影片資訊呈現在影片標題（71%）與內容描述（55%）使用文字之語意集中於強調學習價值，顯示影片標題彰顯學習價值是最能吸引使用者觀看影片之方式；三、使用者評論中最常表現「學習動機」的語意則為任務認知（36%）、自我效能（31%）、與學習價值（25%），顯示使用者觀看影片時在意內容是否提供足夠資訊量，影片是否滿足期待，若影片內容能呼應使用者自身經驗，則會進一步發問與互動，深化學習，提高自我效能。

Lecture recording is a useful tool in physical education. However, inexperienced learners may not be able to identify key points in video and become distracted. The purpose of this study was to develop guidelines for ＂Cue Cards of Snowboarding Lecture Recording＂ to improve users' learning motivation. Though a systematic literature review, this paper retained 293 YouTube snowboarding tutorial videos, coded the user comments and video descriptions for argumentative and knowledge construction to explore what resonates with learners' learning motivation. Out findings reveal that 54% of the selected videos were covered by three channels; The most frequent learning motivation factors in user comment were task awareness, self-efficacy, and learning value; while 70% of the keywords in the video title were about learning value, indicating that the most important motivation factor for learning in the video titles was learning value, by emphasizing learning value, users could be attracted to the video contents, and if the content was relevant to their own experiences, users tend to response actively, leading to a deep learning.

1. Inc, H. Digital 2021 Report (October Update). Hootsuite. https://www.hootsuite.com/resources/digital-trends-q4-update
2. Afzal, H.,Ali, I.,Aslam Khan, M.,Hamid, K.(2010).A Study of University Students’ Motivation and Its Relationship with Their Academic Performance.International Journal of Business and Management,5(4),80.
3. Birkett, A. (2017). A Digital Marketer’s Guide to Visual Cues. CXL. https://cxl.com/blog/visual-cues/
4. De Stefani, E.,Rodà, F.,Volta, E.,Pincolini, V.,Farnese, A.,Rossetti, S.,Pedretti, F.,Ferrari, P. F.(2020).Learning new sport actions: Pilot study to investigate the imitative and the verbal instructive teaching methods in motor education.PloS One,15(8)
5. Dubovi, I.,Tabak, I.(2020).An empirical analysis of knowledge co-construction in YouTube comments.Computers & Education,156
6. Guadagnoli, M.,Holcomb, W.,Davis, M.(2002).The efficacy of video feedback for learning the golf swing.Journal of sports sciences,20
7. Kitchenham, B.(2004).Procedures for Performing Systematic Reviews.Keele, UK, Keele Univ.
8. Lee, D. Y.,Lehto, M. R.(2013).User acceptance of YouTube for procedural learning: An extension of the Technology Acceptance Model.Computers & Education,61,193-208.
9. Lim, K.,Kilpatrick, C.,Storr, J.,Seale, H.(2018).Exploring the use of entertainment-education YouTube videos focused on infection prevention and control.American Journal of Infection Control,46(11)
10. Magill, D.,Richard, A.(2012).Motor Learning and Control: Concepts and Applications.
11. Schunk, D. H.(2012).Learning theories: An educational perspective.Pearson.
12. 李勇輝(2017)。學習動機、學習策略與學習成效關係之研究－以數位學習為例。經營管理學刊，14，68-86。
13. 施登堯(2006)。臺灣師範大學體育學系研究所。
14. 胡明霞(2019).動作控制與學習.金名圖書有限公司.
15. 陳思樺,莊素貞,藍立晶,許宥騰(2019)。以視覺提示卡介入降低自閉症學生占有行為之研究。特殊教育與輔助科技半年刊，21，31-40。
16. 葉殷志(2011)。高雄市，國立中山大學資訊管理學系研究所。
17. 謝嘉恩(2015).圖解認知心理學.城邦易博士.