The Analysis of MIS Collaboration Research Networks and Research Issues Structure: The Example of MIS Quarterly Journal

10.6131/MISR.201009_16(1).0003

Jyun-Cheng Wang；Chui-Chen Chiu；Ching-Hui Chang

Small-World Network ； Scale-Free Distribution ； Social Network Analysis ； Research Co-Author Community ； Research Keywords ； Community Structure Variation

MIS REVIEW：An International Journal

16卷1期（2010 / 09 / 01）

85 - 126

英文

The development of theoretical diversities within management information systems (MIS) discipline has been a constant focus and a frequently discussed issue. Those studies provide a developing pattern for the readers and researchers to track and understand the evolution of information technology and management subjects. Furthermore, the results can be a guidebook for future trends of information management researches. In this research, we collected the authors and keywords from the most prestigious journal in MIS research domain, MISQ, from 1977 to 2007, as the source of data sample. Using social network analysis (SNA) for mapping out the Journal's author collaboration network over time and classifying each article through their keyword-hierarchical structure, we exemplified the development of research communities and referenced domains. While limited by the sampled data, the results of our findings indicated that the structure of co-author research communities fits a scale-free distribution model, a preferential attachment process, in the first decade of these research collaborations. And the research communities developed a stable small-world structures/communities over time, and many distinct clusters are connected to each other by a rather small number of links, since 1997. We conclude by applying the trends of co-author relationship in each MIS sub-domain to provide a new aspect to observe and understand the development of various MIS subjects.

1. Liang, T.-P.,Chen, D.-N.(2005).Evolution of information systems research.Journal of Information Management,12,1-24.
   連結：
2. Abel, T.,Bryan, G. L.,Norman, M. L.(2000).The formation and fragmentation of primordial molecular clouds.The Astrophysical Journal,540,39-44.
3. Alavi, M.,Carlson, P.(1992).A review of MIS research and disciplinary development.Journal of Management Information Systems,8(4),45-62.
4. Allison, P. D.,Long, S. J.,Krauze, T. K.(1982).Cumulative Advantage and Inequality in Science.American Sociological Review,47,615-625.
5. Barabasi, A. L.,Albert, R.,Jeong, H.(1999).Mean-field theory for scale-free random networks.Physica A: Statistical Mechanins and Its Applications,272,173-187.
6. Barabasi, A. L.,Jeong, H.,Neda, Z.,Ravasz, E.,Schubert, A.,Vicsek, T.(2002).Evolution of the social network of scientific collaborations.Physica A: Statistical Mechanins and Its Applications,311,590-614.
7. Barki, H.,Rivard, S.,Talbot, J.(1993).A keyword classification scheme for IS research literature: An Update.MIS Quarterly,14,209-226.
8. Barki, H.,Rivard, S.,Talbot, J.(1988).An information systems keyword classification scheme.MIS Quarterly,12,299-322.
9. Batagelj, V.,Mrvar, A.(2006).Pajek-analysis and visualization of large networks.Lecture Notes in Computer Science,2265,8-11.
10. Benbasat, I.,Weber, R.(1996).Research commentary: Rethinking "diversity" in information systems research.Information Systems Research,7,389-399.
11. Ben-Naim, E.(ed.),Frauendelder, H.(ed.),Toroczkai, Z.(ed.)(2004).Complex Networks.New York:Springer.
12. Brandes, U.,Raab, J.,Wagner, D.(2001).Exploratory network visualization: Simultaneous display of actor status and connections.Journal of Social Structure,2(4),1-28.
13. Claver, E.,Gonzalez, R.,Llopis, J.(2000).An analysis of research in information systems (1981-1997).Information & Management,37,181-195.
14. Cole, J. R.,Cole, S.(1973).Social Stratification in Science.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
15. Cole, S.(ed.)(2001).What's Wrong with Sociology?.New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction Press.
16. Cole, S.(ed.)(2001).What's Wrong with Sociology.New Brunswick:Transaction Press.
17. Crane, D.(1972).Invisible Colleges: Diffusion of Knowledge in Scientific Communities.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
18. Culnan, M. J.(1987).Mapping the intellectual structure of MIS, 1980-1985: A co-citation analysis.MIS Quarterly,11,341-353.
19. Culnan, M. J.,Swanson, E. B.(1986).Research in management information systems, 1980-1984: Points of work and reference.MIS Quarterly,10,289-302.
20. Dorogovtsev, S. N.,Mendes, J. F. F.(2000).Scaling behaviour of developing and decaying networks.Europhysics Letters,52,33-39.
21. Friedkin, N.E.(1998).A Structural Theory of Social Influence.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
22. Gillenson, M. L.,Stutz, J. D.(1991).Academic issues in MIS: Journals and books.MIS Quarterly,15,447-452.
23. Grossman, J. W.(2002).The evolution of the mathematical research collaboration graph.Congressus Numerantium,158,201-212.
24. Grover, V.,Ayyagari, R.,Gokhale, R.,Lim, J.,Coffey, J.(2006).A citation analysis of the evolution and state of information systems within a constellation of reference disciplines.Journal of the Association for Information Systems,7,270-325.
25. Hamilton, S.,Ives, B.(1982).MIS research strategies.Information & Management,5,339-347.
26. Katerattanakul, P.,Han, B. T.,Hong, S.(2003).Objective quality ranking of computing journals.Communications of the ACM,46(10),111-114.
27. Krippendorff, K.(1980).Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology.London:Sage.
28. Landis, J. R.,Koch, G. G.(1977).The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data.Biometrics,33,159-174.
29. Lee, Z.,Gosain, S.,Im, I.(1999).Topics of interest in is: Evolution of themes and differences between research and practice.Information & Management,36,233-246.
30. Lowry, P. B.,Romans, D.,Curtis, A.(2004).Global journal prestige and supporting disciplines: A scientometric study of information systems journals.Journal of the Association for Information Systems,5,29-77.
31. Merton, R.K.(1968).The matthew effect in science.Science,3810,56-63.
32. Milgram, S.(1969).The small world problem.Psychology Today,2,61-67.
33. Moody, J.(2004).The structure of a social science collaboration network: Disciplinary cohesion from 1963 to 1999.American Sociological Review,69,213-238.
34. Moody, J.,Mcfarland, D.,Bender-Demoll, S.(2005).Dynamic network visualization.The American Journal of Sociology,110,1206-1241.
35. Moody, J.,White, D. R.(2003).Structural cohesion and embeddedness: A hierarchical concept of social groups.American Sociological Review,68,103-127.
36. Newman, M. E. J.(2000).Sante Fe Institute Technical Paper 99-12-080Sante Fe Institute Technical Paper 99-12-080,未出版
37. Newman, M. E. J.(2001).The structure of scientific collaboration networks.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,98,404-409.
38. Peffers, K.,Ya, T.(2003).Identifying and evaluating the universe of outlets for information systems research: Ranking the journals.Journal of Information Technology Theory and Application,5,63.
39. Powell, W. W.,White, D. R.,Koput, K. W.,Owen-Smith, J.(2005).Network dynamics and domain evolution: The growth of interorganizational collaboration in the life sciences.The American Journal of Sociology,110,1132-1205.
40. Prasad, S.,Tata, J.(2005).Publication patterns concerning the role of teams/groups in the information systems literature from 1990 to 1999.Information & Management,42,1137-1148.
41. Saunders, C.(2005).Isworld.Net journal rankings.IS World,22 June
42. Swanson, E. B.,Ramiller, N. C.(1993).Information systems research thematics: Submissions to a new journal, 1987-1992.Information Systems Research,4,299-330.
43. Vessey, I.,Ramesh, V.,Glass, R. L.(2002).Research in information systems: An empirical study of diversity in the discipline and its journals.Journal of Management Information Systems,19,129-174.
44. Wade, M.,Biehl, M.,Kim, H.(2006).Information systems is not a reference discipline (and what we can do about it).Journal of the Association for Information Systems,7,247-269.
45. Watts, D. J.(1999).Small World.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
46. Watts, D. J.,Strogatz, S. H.(1998).Collective dynamics of "small-world" networks.Nature,393,440-442.
47. Weber, R. P.(1985).Basic Content Analysis.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
48. Weitz, J. S.,Benfey, P. N.,Wingreen, N. S.(2007).Evolution, interactions, and biological networks.PLoS Biology,5,10-12.
49. Wellman, B.(1996).For a social network analysis of computer networks: A sociological perspective on collaborative work and virtual community.Proceedings of ACM SIGCPR/SIGMIS Conference on Computer Personal ResearchDenver,Denver:
50. Whitley, R.(2000).The Intellectual and Social Organization of the Sciences.New York:Oxford University Press.
51. Yeung, Y.-Y.,Liu, T. C.-Y.,Ng, P.-H.(2005).A social network analysis of researc A social network analysis of research collaboration in physics education.American Journal of Physics,73,145-150.
52. Zuckerman, H.(1977).Scientific Elite: Nobel Laureates in the United States.New York:Free Press.