足球頭頂動作對學童運動傷害之探討

The Discussion of Headers and Children's Head Injury

黃子榮(Tzu-Jung Huang)；陳諺霆(Yen-Ting Chen)；梁建偉(Chien-Wei Liang)

足球 ； 頭部傷害 ； 腦震盪 ； 慢性創傷性腦病變 ； Soccer ； Head injury ； Concussion ； Chronical/ traumatic brain damage

興大體育學刊

21期（2022 / 01 / 01）

1 - 11

繁體中文

頭頂球技術已經是比賽中重要的一環，在比賽場上一些初學者或者是學童，在未成熟下使用頭頂球技術，甚至是在激烈對抗中用頭頂球，是否更容易造成頭部傷害，一直是足球界與學術界爭論的話題？其研究極少探討，因此，藉由本文旨在探討學童足球頭頂動作傷害危險因素為何，透過文獻的蒐集有關足球運動中頭頂球是否會對大腦造成損傷，來加以彙整，作為支持本研究的理論基礎，其結論：球員反覆使用頭頂動作，可能對腦部内部組織造成不良影響，肢體碰撞才是造成腦震盪的主要原因，不僅影響選手後續運動的表現，其中隱藏著腦震盪的風險，也可能造成持續終生的後遺症。

Headers have already been one of important skills in football games. For beginners or children in the matches, they might get injuries when they don't excel in this skill or even it is a debatable issue in the field of soccer and academy about whether they would have head injuries easily when applying this skill in the tight game. We have less researches and discussions about it; therefore, this research discusses what factors cause children's head injuries when applying headers and with collections of document, about whether headers cause brain damage, we rearrange those document and make them as a base of theory. The conclusion and suggestions: Heading repetitively, players might have negative effect on their brain but it is serious and violent physical contact causing concussion, which not only affects performances but causes a lifelong side effect to players who are at the risk of suffering concussion.

1. 郭堉圻(2010)。足球頭頂動作的運動傷害之探討。大專體育，106，143-148。
   連結：
2. 程維德,曾宣靜,郃東梅,李政育,廖炎智(2020)。慢性創傷性腦病變。中國針灸學雜誌，8(1)，116-135。
   連結：
3. 黃玉娟,王秀銀(2011)。2010年世界盃足球賽前8強比賽中頭頂球運用分析。文化體育學刊，13，1-11。
   連結：
4. 蔡佳良,吳昇光(2006)。運動與腦震盪。大專體育，83，219-224。
   連結：
5. Babbs, C. F.(2001).Biomechanics of heading a soccer ball: implications for player safety.The Scientific World Journal,1
6. Baroff, G. S.(1998).Is heading a soccer ball injurious to brain function?.The Journal of head trauma rehabilitation,13(2),45-52.
7. Bazarian, J. J.,Blyth, B.,Cimpello, L.(2006).Bench to bedside: evidence for brain injury after concussion looking beyond the computed tomography scan.Academic Emergency Medicine,13(2),199-214.
8. Boden, B. P.,Kirkendall, D. T.,Garrett, W. E.(1998).Concussion incidence in elite college soccer players.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,26(2),238-241.
9. Brooks, J. H.,Fuller, C. W.(2006).The influence of methodological issues on the results and conclusions from epidemiological studies of sports injuries.Sports medicine,36(6),459-472.
10. Comstock, R. D.,Currie, D. W.,Pierpoint, L. A.,Grubenhoff, J. A.,Fields, S. K.(2015).An evidence-based discussion of heading the ball and concussions in high school soccer.JAMA pediatrics,169(9),830-837.
11. Di Virgilio, T. G.,Hunter, A.,Wilson, L.,Stewart, W.,Goodall, S.,Howatson, G.,Ietswaart, M.(2016).Evidence for acute electrophysiological and cognitive changes following routine soccer heading.EBioMedicine,13,66-71.
12. Field, M.,Collins, M. W.,Lovell, M. R.,Maroon, J.(2003).Does age play a role in recovery from sports-related concussion? A comparison of high school and collegiate athletes.The Journal of pediatrics,142(5),546-553.
13. Fuller, C. W.,Junge, A.,Dvorak, J.(2005).A six-year prospective study of the incidence and causes of head and neck injuries in international football.British journal of sports medicine,39(suppl 1),i3-i9.
14. Fuller, C. W.,Smith, G. L.,Junge, A.,Dvorak, J.(2004).An assessment of player error as an injury causation factor in international football.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,32(1_suppl),28-35.
15. Green, G. A.,Jordan, S. E.(1998).Are brain injuries a significant problem in soccer?.Clinics in sports medicine,17(4),795-809.
16. Guskiewicz, K. M.,Marshall, S. W.,Broglio, S. P.,Cantu, R. C.,Kirkendall, D. T.(2002).No evidence of impaired neurocognitive performance in collegiate soccer players.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,30(2),157-162.
17. Guskiewicz, K. M.,McCrea, M.,Marshall, S. W.,Cantu, R. C.,Randolph, C.,Barr, W.(2003).Acute effects and recovery time following concussion in collegiate football players.Journal of American Medical Association,290,2549-2555.
18. Harriss, A.,Johnson, A. M.,Walton, D. M.,Dickey, J. P.(2019).The number of purposeful headers female youth soccer players experience during games depends on player age but not player position.Science and Medicine in Football,3(2),109-114.
19. Inklaar, H.(1994).Soccer injuries.Sports medicine,18(1),55-73.
20. Jordan, S. E.,Green, G. A.,Galanty, H. L.,Mandelbaum, B. R.,Jabour, B. A.(1996).Acute and chronic brain injury in United States National Team soccer players.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,24(2),205-210.
21. Kirkendall, D. T.,Garrett, W. E., Jr(2001).Heading in soccer: integral skill or grounds for cognitive dysfunction.Journal of athletic training,36(3),328.
22. Kolodziej, M. A.,Koblitz, S.,Nimsky, C.,Hellwig, D.(2011).Mechanisms and consequences of head injuries in soccer: a study of 451 patients.Neurosurgical focus,31(5),E1.
23. Koutures, C. G.,Gregory, A. J.(2010).Injuries in youth soccer.Pediatrics,125(2),410-414.
24. Leininger, R. E.,Knox, C. L.,Comstock, R. D.(2007).Epidemiology of 1.6 million pediatric soccer-related injuries presenting to US emergency departments from 1990 to 2003.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,35(2),288-293.
25. Levy, M. L.,Kasabeh, A. S.,Baird, L. C.,Amene, C.,Skeen, J.,Marshall, L.(2012).Concussions in soccer: A current understanding.World Neurosurgery,78,535-544.
26. Lipton, M. L.,Kim, N.,Zimmerman, M. E.,Kim, M.,Stewart, W. F.,Branch, C. A.,Lipton, R. B.(2013).Soccer heading is associated with white matter microstructural and cognitive abnormalities.Radiology,268(3),850-857.
27. Lyman, S.,Fleisig, G. S.,Andrews, J. R.,Osinski, E. D.(2002).Effect of pitch type, pitch count, and pitching mechanics on risk of elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball pitchers.The American journal of sports medicine,30(4),463-468.
28. Maria, G.,Ban, A. S.,Steve, M.,Hala, T.(2010).Epidemiology of acute head injuries in Canadian children and youth soccer players.Injury,41(9),907-912.
29. McGrath, A. C.,Ozanne-Smith, J.(1997).,Monash University Accident Research Centre.
30. McKee, A. C.,Stein, T. D.,Nowinski, C. J.,Stern, R. A.,Daneshvar, D. H.,Alvarez, V. E.,Cantu, R. C.(2013).The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy.Brain,136(1),43-64.
31. Millspaugh, J. A. (1937). Dementia pugilistica. US Naval Med Bull, 35(297), e303.
32. O’Kane, J. W.(2016).Is heading in youth soccer dangerous play?.The Physician and Sportsmedicine,44(2),190-194.
33. O’Kane, J. W.,Spieker, A.,Levy, M. R.,Neradilek, M.,Polissar, N. L.,Schiff, M. A.(2014).Concussion among female middle-school soccer players.JAMA pediatrics,168(3),258-264.
34. Pickett, W.,Streight, S.,Simpson, K.,Brison, R. J.(2005).Head injuries in youth soccer players presenting to the emergency department.British journal of sports medicine,39(4),226-231.
35. Roberts, G. W.,Allsop, D.,Bruton, C.(1990).The occult aftermath of boxing.Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery & Psychiatry,53(5),373-378.
36. Sciascia, A.,Kibler, W. B.(2006).The pediatric overhead athlete: what is the real problem?.Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine,16(6),471-477.
37. Sortland, O.,Tysvaer, A. T.(1989).Brain Damage in Former Association Football Players. An Evaluation by Cerebral Computed Tomography.Neuroradiology,31(1),44-48.
38. Stephens, R.,Rutherford, A.,Potter, D.,Fernie, G.(2010).Neuropsychological consequence of soccer plays in adolescent UK School team soccer players.Journal of neuropsychiatry and clinical neurosciences,22(3),295-303.
39. Stern, R. A.,Riley, D. O.,Daneshvar, D. H.,Nowinski, C. J.,Cantu, R. C.,McKee, A. C.(2011).Long-term consequences of repetitive brain trauma: chronic traumatic encephalopathy.Pm&r,3(10),S460-S467.
40. Tarnutzer, A. A.(2018).Should heading be forbidden in children’s football?.Science and Medicine in Football,2(1),75-79.
41. Tysvaer, A. T.,Løchen, E. A.(1991).Soccer injuries to the brain: a neuropsychologic study of former soccer players.The American Journal of Sports Medicine,19(1),56-60.
42. Witol, A. D.,Webbe, F. M.(2003).Soccer heading frequency predicts neuropsychological deficits.Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology,18(4),397-417.
43. Zhang, M. R.,Red, S. D.,Lin, A. H.,Patel, S. S.,Sereno, A. B.(2013).Evidence of cognitive dysfunction after soccer playing with ball heading using a novel tablet-based approach.PloS one,8(2),e57364.
44. 陳柏諺(2015)。臺北醫學大學。
45. 葉玉卿(2012)。淺談足球訓練中運動傷害的產生與預防。運動健康休閒學報，3，101-106。