運用「整合性音樂素養」畫出國中音樂課程的實踐藍圖

Using Comprehensive Musicianship to Draw the Practical Blueprint on Junior High School Music Curriculum

10.6244/JOMR.202211_(37).02

黃靜芳(Ching-Fang HUANG)

整合性音樂素養 ； 音樂課程 ； 教學歷程 ； 學習表現 ； 行動研究 ； Comprehensive Musicianship ； music curriculum ； teaching process ； learning performance ； action research

音樂研究

37期（2022 / 11 / 01）

41 - 92

繁體中文

本研究運用「整合性音樂素養」（Comprehensive Musicianship，以下簡寫為CM）於國中音樂課程，旨在規劃CM音樂課程設計、探討CM教師教學歷程與分析CM學生學習表現。課程主題「動手玩音樂」下設計三個單元：動手玩燈光秀、動手DIY卡祖笛、動手做創作曲，採用行動研究法於4個七年級班級循環教學，參與者為七年級學生116位、研究者本人與國中原班音樂教師，收集資料包括學生問卷回饋單、教師教學省思、教師觀課紀錄與教學錄影，透過三角檢證效度，提出綜合省思與結論：1.在音樂課程設計上CM具有統整音樂要素、體驗音樂角色與活化學習策略的特色；2.在教師教學歷程上CM注重充足探索時間、強化創作引導、重視班級經營；3.在學生學習表現上CM能提升學習動機、體會美感經驗與學到帶得走能力。

This study investigates Comprehensive Musicianship (CM) in a junior high school curriculum in order to research into the design of CM music curriculum, establish the pedagogical procedures of teachers, and analyze learning performance of students. Three lessons under the Play Music by Hands Curriculum were inserted into the regular music class, namely music light show, kazoo DIY, and music composition. Action research was adopted for four-cycle music curricula. Participants in this project include: 116 seventh graders at junior high school, their music teacher, and the researcher. Data were collected from questionnaires done by the students, teaching reflections, teaching records and videos. Triangulation was utilized to present findings. The conclusions are as follows: First, regarding music curriculum design, CM is conducive to integrate musical elements, experiencing music roles, and diversifying learning strategies. Second, regarding teaching procedures, teachers who apply CM pay attention to allowing students sufficient time to explore, encouraging students' motivation to compose, and reinforcing class management to help students learn deeply. Third, regarding students' learning performance, CM students demonstrate greater motivation for learning, have better aesthetic experience, and acquire more application competencies.

1. 吳木崑, M.-K.(2009)。杜威經驗哲學對課程與教學之啟示。臺北市立教育大學學報：教育類，40(1)，35-54。
   連結：
2. 卓甫見, F.-C.(2013)。整合性音樂基礎訓練面面觀。藝術學報，93，237-262。
   連結：
3. 陳姿光, T.-K.(2019)。「整合性音樂素養」理念運用於流行音樂產業系一年級理論課程之個案研究。清華教育學報，36(2)，43-90。
   連結：
4. 單文經, W.-J.(2020)。在十二年國教課綱「總綱」中遇見杜威。當代教育研究季刊，28(2)，1-29。
   連結：
5. Abeles, H. F.,Hoffer, C. R.,Klotman, R. H.(1994).Foundations of music education.New York:Schirmer Books.
6. Brahms, J. (1869). Hungarian dance no. 5. Retrieved from https://toplayalong.com/sheet-music/brahms-hungarian-dance-no-5-violin
7. Burton, L.(2021).Comprehensive musicianship—The Hawaii music curriculum project.Visions of Research in Music Education,16,Article 35.
8. Center for Collaborative Action Research. (2021). Tutorial 10: Cycles of change. Activities. Action Research Tutorials. Retrieved from https://www.actionresearchtutorials.org/10-activities
9. Choksy, L.,Abramson, R. M.,Gillespie, A. E.,Woods, D.,York, F.(2001).Teaching music in the twenty-first century.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
10. Goodlad, J. I.(1979).Curriculum inquiry: The study of curriculum practice.New York:McGraw Hill.
11. Hanley, B.,Montgomery, J.(2002).Contemporary curriculum practices and their theoretical bases.The new handbook of research on music teaching and learning,New York:
12. Jorgensen, E. R.(2002).Philosophical issues in curriculum.The new handbook of research on music teaching and learning,New York:
13. Lune, H.,Berg, B. L.(2017).Qualitative research methods for the social sciences.Boston:Pearson.
14. Mark, M. L.(1996).Contemporary music education.New York:Schirmer Books.
15. Phelps, R. P.,Ferrara, L.,Goolsby, T. W.(1993).A guide to research in music education.London:Scarecrow Press.
16. Pike, P. D.(2013).Profiles in successful group piano for children: A collective case study of children’s group-piano lessons.Music Education Research,15,92-106.
17. Reimer, B.(1989).A philosophy of music education.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice Hall.
18. Reimer, B.(2003).A philosophy of music education: Advancing the vision.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
19. Sindberg, L. K.(2016).Elements of a successful professional learning community for music teachers using comprehensive musicianship through performance.Journal of Research in Music Education,64,202-219.
20. Temple, M.(2019).Teaching comprehensively.Illinois Music Educator,79(3),37-39.
21. Thomson, W.(2021).The anatomy of a flawed success: Comprehensive musicianship revisited.Visions of Research in Music Education,16,Article 23.
22. Warner, R. W.(2021).CM reflections of a band director.Visions of Research in Music Education,16,Article 29.
23. Willoughby, D.(2021).Comprehensive musicianship.Visions of Research in Music Education,16,Article 28.
24. Yoo, H.,Kang, S.(2017).Teaching the Korean folk song (Arirang) through performing, creating, and responding.General Music Today,31(1),16-25.
25. 王文科, W.-K.,王智弘, C.-H.(2020).教育研究法.臺北=Taipei:五南=Wunan.
26. 王郁菁, Y.-C.(2009)。國立臺灣師範大學=National Taiwan Normal University。
27. 丘永福（編）, Y.-F.(Ed.),余昕晏（編）, H.-Y.(Ed.),李其昌（編）, C.-C.(Ed.)(2019).國民中學藝術課本.臺北=Taipei:康軒文教=Kang Hsuan Educational.
28. 包威爾, J.,柴婉玲（譯）, W.-L.(Trans.)(2017).好音樂的科學Ⅱ：從古典旋律到搖滾詩篇—看美妙樂曲如何改寫思維、療癒人心.臺北=Taipei:大寫=Briefing Press.
29. 朱彥霖, Y.-L.(2005)。臺北市立師範學院=Taipei Municipal Teachers College。
30. 林小玉, S.-Y.(2020)。音樂教學法之我見我思：以整合性音樂素養為例。對話：台灣奧福教育協會第 14 屆專刊，臺中=Taichung:
31. 林小玉, S.-Y.,朱彥霖, Y.-L.(2006)。「整合性音樂基本能力」模式之內涵與在大學音樂基礎訓練課程上之應用。2006 音樂教育學術研討會：音樂教學法之理論與實務論文集，臺北=Taipei:
32. 林怡妙, Y.-M.(2015)。國立臺南大學=National University of Tainan。
33. 教育部。（2021）。《十二年國民基本教育課程綱要：總綱》。檢索自https://reurl.cc/QjneGo【Ministry of Education. (2021). Curriculum guidelines of 12-year basic education: General guidelines. Retrieved from https://reurl.cc/QjneGo】
34. 教育部。（2018）。《十二年國民基本教育課程綱要：國民中小學暨普通型高級中等學校，藝術領域》。檢索自 https://reurl.cc/436OxR 【Ministry of Education. (2018). Curriculum guidelines of 12-year basic education: Elementary, junior high schools and general senior high schools, the arts domain. Retrieved from https://reurl.cc/436OxR】
35. 畢恆達, H.-D.(2020).教授為什麼沒告訴我：2020 進化版.新北=New Taipei:小畢空間=Bih Space.
36. 郭芳秀, F.-H.(2016)。國立臺灣師範大學=National Taiwan Normal University。
37. 鈕文英, W.-I.(2007).教育研究方法與論文寫作.臺北=Taipei:雙葉書廊=Yeh Yeh Book Gallery.
38. 黃靜芳, C.-F.(2020)。音樂與自然科學的美妙相遇—從自製樂器開展的跨領域美感教學。臺灣教育評論月刊，9(11)，45-54。
39. 葉重新, C.-H.(2017).教育研究法.新北=New Taipei:心理=Psychological.
40. 蔡清田, C.-T.(2013).教育行動研究新論.臺北=Taipei:五南=Wunan.
41. 蕭麗珊, L.-S.(2017)。國立臺南大學=National University of Tainan。
42. 鍾欣韻, H.-Y.(2018)。國立臺南大學=National University of Tainan。