英文摘要
|
This paper calculates carry costs directly and focuses on the effect that carry cost lumpiness has on hedge variables. It shows that carry cost adjusted price changes should be used to reduce errors in the calculated hedge: ratio, profit, and effectiveness. Results demonstrate that the errors can be both statistically and economically significant and tend to be more significant if the asset's carry costs are lumpier (that is, larger and less frequent).We study the traditional regression (TR), carry cost adjusted regression (CCAR), and error correction (EC) hedge ratio calculation approaches. Unlike the CCAR method, the TR and EC approaches err by using the spot price change to represent spot profit. When the payout dates are included in the analysis, the CCAR in-sample hedge effectiveness is statistically significantly higher than it is for the TR and EC approaches. Furthermore, when payout dates are excluded, their hedge effectiveness results converge toward those for the CCAR method.The CCAR approach provides out-of-sample hedge effectiveness that is higher than that for either of the other approaches. Additionally, the (insample to out-of-sample) hedge effectiveness slippage is about half as much for the TR and CCAR approaches as it is for the EC approach. Finally, though the hedge ratios are similar across methods, the hedge profits of the assets studied are significantly mismeasured because the TR and EC methods ignore carry costs.
|
参考文献
|
-
Working, H. (1949). The theory of price of storage. American Economic Review, 39, 1254-1262.
-
Alexander, C.,Barbosa, A.(2007).Effectiveness of minimum-variance hedging.Journal of Portfolio Management,33,46-59.
-
Bodnar, G. M.,Hayt, G. S.,Marston, R. C.(1996).1995 Wharton survey of derivatives usage by US non-financial firms.Financial Management,25,113-133.
-
Bodnar, G. M.,Hayt, G. S.,Marston, R. C.(1998).1998 Wharton survey of financial risk management by US non-financial firms.Financial Management,27,70-91.
-
Brennan, M. J.(1958).The supply of storage.American Economic Review,48,50-71.
-
Ederington, L.(1979).The hedging performance of the new futures markets.Journal of Finance,34,157-170.
-
Ferguson, R.,Leistikow, D.(1999).Futures hedge profit measurement, errorcorrection model vs. regression approach hedge ratios, and data error effects.Financial Management,28,118-125.
-
Ghosh, A.(1996).Cross-hedging foreign currency risk: Empirical evidence from an error correction model.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,6,223-231.
-
Ghosh, A.,Clayton, R.(1996).Hedging with international stock index futures: An intertemporal error correction model.Journal of Financial Research,19,477-491.
-
Kenourgios, D.,Samitas, A.,Drosos, P.(2008).Hedge ratio estimation and hedging effectiveness: The case of the s&p 500 stock index futures contract.International Journal of Risk Assessment and Management,9,121-134.
-
Kroner, F. K.,Sultan, J.(1993).Time-varying distributions and dynamic hedging with foreign currency futures.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,28,535-51.
-
Lafuente, A. J.,Novales, A.(2003).Optimal hedging under departures from the cost-of-carry valuation: Evidence from the Spanish stock index futures market.Journal of Banking & Finance,27,1053-1078.
-
Lee, C. F.,Lin, F. L.,Chen, M. L.(2010).International hedge ratios for index futures market: A simultaneous equations approach.Review of Pacific Basin Financial Markets and Policies,13,203-213.
-
Lee, C. F.,Wang, K.,Chen, Y. L.(2009).Hedging and optimal hedge ratios for international index futures markets.Review of Pacific Basin Financial Markets and Policies,12,593-610.
-
Leistikow, D.(1993).Impacts of shifts in uncertainty on spot and futures price change serial correlation and standardized covariation measures.The Journal of Futures Markets,13,873-887.
-
Leistikow, D.(1992).Testing and adjusting the price-sensitivity approach for biasedness.1992 Southern Finance Association meetings,Jacksonville, FL.:
-
Lien, D.(2009).A note on the Hedging Effectiveness of GARCH Models.International Review of Economics and Finance,18,110-112.
-
Sarno, L.,Valente, G.(2000).The cost of carry model and regime shifts in stock index futures markets: An empirical investigation.The Journal of Futures Markets,20,603-624.
-
Shaffer, D. R.,Demaskey, A.(2005).Currency hedging using the Mean-Gini framework.Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting,25,125-137.
|