領導者和追隨者的性別組成與追隨者服從意願之關係

The Relationship between Leader-Member Gender Combination and Followers' Obedience

10.29735/SJEB.200712.0004

羅新興(Hsin-Hsin Lo)；林靜如(Ching-Ju Lin)

領導者 ； 追隨者 ； 性別組成 ； 服從意願 ； Leader ； Follower ； Gender Combination ； Obedience

東吳經濟商學學報

59期（2007 / 12 / 01）

101 - 117

繁體中文

本研究針對公務機關與民營企業的領導者與追隨者進行調查，探討領導者和追隨者的性別組成與追隨者服從意願的關聯性。分析所回收的620份有效問卷資料，獲得以下研究發現：女性追隨者的服從意願高於男性追隨者。男性領導的追隨者之服從意願高於女性領導的追隨者。男性領導者所領導的男性追隨者所表現之服從意願，高於由女性領導者所領導的男性追隨者；但是女性追隨者無論是由男性或者女性領導者所領導，其所表現的服從意願無顯著差異。本研究針對研究發現討論管理實務上的意義與未來研究方向。

This study examined the relationship of leader-follower gender combination and followers' obedience. The members of public and civilian organizations were selected as target sample. Three findings, resulted from the research of the 620 effective responses, are as follows. First, female followers are more obedient than male ones. Second, the followers of male leaders are more obedient than those of the female leaders. Final, male-led male followers are more obedient than female-led male ones. This study empirically explains the above findings.

1. Barnard, C. I.(1938).The Functions of Executive.MA:Harvard University Press.
2. Bergen, D. J.,J. E. Williams(1991).Sex Stereotypes in the United States Revisited: 1972-1988.Sex Roles,24,413.
3. Blackmore, J.(1999).Troubling women-feminism, leadership, and educational change.Philabelphia:Open University.
4. Bobo, L.(1998).Race, Interests, and Beliefs About Affirmative action.The American Behavioral Scientist,41(7),985-1003.
5. Breckler, S. J.(1984).Empirical validation of affect behavior, and cognition as destine components of attitude.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,May,1191-1205.
6. Byrne, D.(1971).The Attraction Paradigm.New York:Academic Press.
7. Chatman, J.,C. O`Reilly(2004).Asymmetric Reactions to Work Group Sex Diversity among Men and Women.Academy of Management Journal,47(2),193-208.
8. Chi, S. C.,H. H. Lo(2003).Taiwanese Employees` Justice Perception on Co-Workers` Punitive Events.The Journal of Social Psychology,143(1),27-42.
9. Conger, J. A.,R. N. Kanungo,S. T. Menon(2000).Charismatic Leadership and Follower Effects.Journal of Organizational Behavior,21,747-767.
10. Conner, J. M.,L. A. Serbin,R.A. Ender(1978).Responses of Boys and Aggressive, Assertive, and Passive Behaviors of Male and Female Characters.Journal of Genetic Psychology,133,59-69.
11. Crampton, S. M.,J. M. Mishra(1999).Women in Management.Public Personnel Management,28(1),87-106.
12. Eagly, A. H.,M. B. Kite(1987).Are stereotypes of nationalities applied to both women and men?.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,53,451-462.
13. Eagly, A. H.,S. J. Karau,M. G. Makhijani(1995).Gender and the Effectiveness of Leaders: A Meta-Analysis.Psychological Bulletin,117,125-145.
14. Everett, L.,D. Thome,C. Danehower(1996).Cognitive Moral Development and Attitudes toward Women Executives.Journal of Business Ethics,15,1277-1235.
15. Fiedler, F. E.(1967).A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness.New York:McGraw-Hill.
16. Glick, P.,S. T. Fiske(1996).The Ambivalent Sexism Inventory: Differentiating Hostile and Benevolent Sexism.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,70,491-512.
17. Gombeski, W. R.,D. J. Koscic(1989).Improving Managerial Effectiveness.Marketing Research,1(3),68-72.
18. Greene, C. N.(1979).A Longitudinal Investigation of Modifications to a Situational Model of Leadership Effectiveness.Academy of Management Proceeding.
19. Hays, R. D.,T. Hayashi,A. L. Stewart(1989).A Five Item Measure of Socially Desirable Response set.Educational and Psychological Measurement,49,629-636.
20. Hoffman, C.,N. Hurst(1990).Gender stereotypes: Perception or rationalization.?.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,58(2),197-208.
21. House, R. J.(1971).A Path-Goal Theory of leader effectiveness.Administrative Science Quarterly.
22. Lerner, G.(1986).The creation of patriarchy.New York:Oxford University Press.
23. Parke, F.,P. Fagenson(1994).An Introductory Overview of Women in Corporate Management.Women in Management.
24. Pierro, A.,L. Cicero,M. Bonaiuto,D. Van Knippenberg,A. W. Kruglanski(2005).Leader Group Prototypicality and Leadership Effectiveness: The moderating Role of Need for Cognitive Closure.Leadership Quarterly,16(4),503-516.
25. Quezada-Broeder, G.,R. Martin(2003).Leading Individuals to Creative Performance: Exploring-Leader-Culture Relationships and Their Effects on Subordinate Performance, Attitudes and Perceptions.Australian Journal of Psychology,55-59.
26. Richeson, J. A.,N. Ambady(2001).Who`s in Charge? Effects of Situational Roles on Automatic Gender Bias.Sex Roles,44(5),493-512.
27. Schmidt, L. L.,J. Wood,D. J. Lugg(2005).Gender Differences in Leader and Follower Perceptions of Social Support in Antarctica.Acta Astronautica,56(4),923-931.
28. Schmitt, M. T.,N. K. Branscombe,D. M. Kappen(2003).Attitudes toward Group-Based Inequality: Social Dominance or Social Identity?.British Journal of Social Psychology,42,161-186.
29. Sidanius, J.,F. Pratto,M. Mitchell(1994).In-Group Identification, Social Dominance Orientation, and Differential Intergroup Social Allocation.The Journal of Social Psychology,134(2),151-167.
30. Tsui, A. S.,C. A. O`Reilly(1989).Beyond Simple Demographic Effects: The Importance of Relational Demography in Superior-Subordinate Dyads.Academy of Management Journal,32,402-423.
31. Tsui, A. S.,T. Egan,K. Xin,M. Chemers,S. Okampo,M. Costanzo(edited)(1995).Diversity in Organizations: Perspectives from a Changing Workplace.Thousand Oaks:Sage.
32. Van Knippenberg, D.,B. Van Knippenberg,D. de Cremer,M. A. Hogg(2004).Leadership, Self, and Identity: A Review and Research Agenda.Leadership Quarterly,15(6),825-856.
33. 王大方(1996)。玻璃天花板：管理女性VS.女性領導。台北:時報文化。
34. 王方(2002)。性別與勞動的社會學分析：台灣女性勞動的福利與權益問題。勞資關係月刊，19(12)，736-746。
35. 古益靈譯、Graham, S. D.著(2003)。服從：世界各大企業的員工培訓指標。台北:海洋文化出版社。
36. 李美枝(1984)。女性心理學。台北:大洋出版社。
37. 陳心田(1998)。博士論文(博士論文)。中山大學企業管理學系。
38. 劉秀娟、林明寬譯、Basow, S. A.著(1998)。兩性關係。台北:揚智出版社。
39. 羅新興、陳忠虎、陳秀清(2004)。領導者類型、追隨者類型與領導效能關係之研究。國防管理學報，25(2)，51-60。

1. 陳嵩(2017)。部屬目標導向與上司知覺部屬忠誠、關係、及能力之關聯。人力資源管理學報，17(2)，27-54。
2. 陳正專(2010)。分佈式領導的微觀政治學。彰化師大教育學報，18，1-18。
3. 陳正專、巫慧萍、王志全(2011)。運動團隊領導權力分散之探析。運動研究，20(1)，61-73。
4. 羅新興、梁成明(2014)。團隊成員的獎懲經驗對集體獎懲系統正義知覺之影響—探討預先告知與集體責任共識的跨層次調節效果。管理與系統，21(3)，393-420。
5. 周國民(2014)。女性家長式領導探究－一所小型學校個案為例。教育理論與實踐學刊，29，29-58。