脆弱性研究的演變與當前發展

The Evolution and Develpment of Vulnerability Studies

10.6161/jgs.2015.77.03

林冠慧(Kuan-Hui Elaine Lin)；張長義(Chang-Yi Chang)

脆弱性 ； 氣候變遷衝擊 ； 永續性 ； 災難 ； 適應性 ； Vulnerability ； climate change impact ； sustainability ； disasters ； adaptation

地理學報

77期（2015 / 06 / 01）

49 - 82

繁體中文

脆弱性研究在2001年政府間氣候變遷第二工作小組以「衝擊、適應性與脆弱性」為題，重新定義脆弱性概念，使其成為氣候變遷科學的學術典範後，脆弱性成為氣候變遷、災害風險、災難管理、永續發展等學門的重要研究領域。儘管脆弱性在國際上具有相當高的應用性，然臺灣學界對脆弱性領域的認識與應用普遍多偏向實證主義取徑下的災害風險分析，而忽略了脆弱性自二次大戰以來從行為地理學、後馬克思主義、實在論、後現代主義、女性主義、生態理論等思潮吸取養份所形成的豐富多元樣貌。此侷限也反應出雖然1990年代末開始，英文期刊便出現不少優秀的論文以回顧脆弱性概念的發展與演繹，然華文學界本身卻少有優良的回顧論文。因此本文從二十世紀中災害研究的典範起始，引領讀者認識二次大戰後學術典範移轉所演育出的兩個脆弱性早期最重要的思潮，並論述這些早期思潮如何和其他思想論辯與交融，形成近代脆弱性多元論述的形態。文中梳理了當代脆弱性在不同知識論下所形成的五種不同分析取徑，並深入探討當前臺灣脆弱性研究在這廣博的理論思潮、研究方法與社會應用上的特性。文末批判了當前臺灣脆弱性研究在思維與方法上的單向與局限性，並提出開拓不同思潮以進行臺灣本土脆弱性（適應性）研究之必要，以形成臺灣在其特殊性上的主體論述，並有助於增強和國際學界的對話。

Since the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Working Group II expanded the term climate change in its 2001 report as ＂Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability＂, vulnerability has become a theme in the fields of hazard risk, disaster management, sustainability science and, of course, climate change. Vulnerability is a broad concept with wide-ranging applicability; however, academia in Taiwan primarily approach vulnerability through positivist hazard risk analysis. This approach reveals an inability of academia to understand the significance of other epistemological fields and ideologies, such as behavioral geography, (post-) Marxism, Realism, Postmodernism, Feminism, and Ecology theory, and their contribution to contemporary vulnerability study. This study examines the evolution of vulnerability studies from the mid-20th century onward and its early practices that emerged after WWII, and also characterizes five schools of thought that constitute the entire] spectrum of vulnerability studies in subsequent decades. Major debates and their influences are also discussed. Finally, this study identifies the uni-dimensional nature and current limitations of research in Taiwan This study also calls for engagement with the social sciences and humanities, including human geography, in the study of vulnerability issues in society, thereby deepening our understanding of vulnerability.

1. 何明錦、洪鴻智、陳建忠、陳令韡、簡長毅、陳素櫻、王暉堯(2009)。綜合性地震脆弱度與風險評估：以新竹市為例。建築學報，70，111-26。
   連結：
2. 吳杰穎、黃昱翔(2011)。颱洪災害脆弱性評估指標之建立：以南投縣水里鄉為例。都市與計劃，38(2)，195-218。
   連結：
3. 李欣輯、楊惠萱(2012)。坡地災害社會脆弱度指標評估與應用。都市與計劃，39(4)，375-406。
   連結：
4. 李欣輯、楊惠萱、廖楷民、蕭代基(2010)。水災社會脆弱性指標之建立。建築與規劃學報，10(3)，163-82。
   連結：
5. 洪鴻智、陳令韡(2012)。颱洪災害之整合性脆弱度評估－大甲溪流域之應用。地理學報，65，79-96。
   連結：
6. 張宜君、林宗弘(2012)。不平等的災難：921 大地震下的受災風險與社會階層化。人文與社會研究集刊，24(2)，193-231。
   連結：
7. 許文耀、曾幼涵(2004)。災難因子與心理症狀間之關係：以921 地震為例。臨床心理學刊，1(1)，30-9。
   連結：
8. 許文耀、曾幼涵(2003)。921 地震後災民的資源變化與心理症狀間的關係。中華心理衛生學刊，16(2)，1-19。
   連結：
9. 蕭煥章(2008)。Taipei，文化大學地理學研究所=Department of Geography, Chinese Culture University。
   連結：
10. Polsky, C. D. Schröter, A. Patt, S. Gaffin, M. L. Martello, R. Neff, H. Selin. 2003. Assessing vulnerabilities to the effects of global change: An eight-step approach. Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs Working Paper: Environment and Natural Resources Program, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
11. White, G. F. 1945. Human adjustment to floods: A geographic approach to the flood problem in the United States. Research Paper no 29. Chicago: University of Chicago, Department of Geography.
12. Barrows, H. H. 1923. Geography as human ecology. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 13: 1-14, doi: 10.2307/2560816.
13. Rockström, J., and D. Liverman. 2012. Future earth: Research for global sustainability. Future Earth Transition Team.
14. Adger, W. N.(2003).Social capital, collective action, and adaptation to climate change.Economic Geography,79(4),387-404.
15. Adger, W. N.(2006).Vulnerability.Global Environmental Change,16(3),268-81.
16. Adger, W. N.(1999).Social vulnerability to climate change and extremes in coastal Vietnam.World Development,27(2),249-69.
17. Adger, W. N.,Brooks, N.,Bentham, G.,Agnew, M.,Eriksen, S.(2004).New indicators of vulnerability and adaptative capacity.Norwich:Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research.
18. Adger, W. N.,Brooks, N.,Conway, D.(2010).Progress in global environmental change.Global Environmental Change,20(4),547-9.
19. Bankoff, G.(2001).Rendering the world safe: Vulnerability as western discourse.Disasters,25(10),19-35.
20. Bankoff, G.,Frerks, G.,Hilhorst, D.(2004).Mapping vulnerability: Disasters, development and people.Sterling, VA:Earthscan.
21. Bebbington, A.(1999).Capitals and capabilities: A framework for analyzing peasant viability, rural livelihoods and poverty.World Development,27(12),2021-44.
22. Berkes, F.(ed.),Folke, C.(ed.)(1998).Linking social and ecological systems: Management practices and social mechanisms for building resilience.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
23. Berkes, F.,Colding, J.,Folke, C.(2003).Navigating social-ecological systems: Building resilience for complexity and change.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
24. Birkmann, J. (ed.)(2006).Measuting vulnerability to natural hazards: Towards disaster resilient societies.Tokyo:United Nations University.
25. Blaikie, P.(1985).The political economy of soil erosion in developing countries.New York:Longman Inc.
26. Blaikie, P.,Brookfield, H.(1987).Land degradation and society.London:Methuen.
27. Blaikie, P.,Cannon, T.,Davis, I.,Wisner, B.(1994).At risk: Natural hazards, people's vulnerability, and disasters.London:Routledge.
28. Bogardi, J. J.(2004).Hazards, risks and vulnerabilities in a changing environment: The unexpected onslaught on human security?.Global Environmental Change,14,361-5.
29. Bohle, H. G.,Downing, T. E.,Watts, M. J.(1994).Climate change and social vulnerability: Toward a sociology and geography of food insecurity.Global Environmental Change,4(1),37-48.
30. Burton, I.,Kates, R. W.,White, G. F.(1978).The environment as hazard.New York:Oxford University Press.
31. Cameron, E. S.(2012).Securing indigenous politics: A critique of the vulnerability and adaptation approach to the human dimensions of climate change in the Canadian Arctic.Global Environmental Change,22(1),103-14.
32. Chambers, R.(1989).Vulnerability, coping, and policy.IDS Bulletin,20,1-7.
33. Chambers, R.,Conway, G.(1992).Sustainable rural livelihoods: Practical concepts for the 21st Century.Brighton, UK:Institute of Development Studies.
34. Clark, W. C.(ed.),Munn, R. E.(ed.)(1986).Sustainable development of the biosphere.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
35. Clark, W. C.(ed.),Munn, R. E.(ed.)(1986).Sustainable development of the biosphere.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
36. Clark, W. C.,Jager, J.,Corell, R.,Kasperson, R.,McCarthy, J. J.,Cash, O.,Cohen, S. J.,Desanker, P.,Dickson, N. M.,Epstein, P.,Guston, D. H.,Hall, J. M.,Teeger, C.,Janetos, A.,Leary, N.,Amy, M. A. L.(2000).Assessing vulnerability to global environmental risks.Cambridge, MA:Environment and Natural Resources Program, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University.
37. Clark, W. C.,Jager, J.,van Eijndhoven, J.,Dickson, N. M.(2001).Learning to manage global environmental risks: A comparative history of social responses to climate change, Ozone depletion and acid rain.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
38. Cloke, P. J.,Philo, C.,Sadler, D.(1991).Approaching human geography: An introduction to contemporary theoretical debates.New York:The Guilford Press.
39. Crona, B. I.,Rönnbäck, P.,Jiddawi, N.,Ochiewo, J.,Maghimbi, S.,Bandeira, S.(2009).Murky water: Analyzing risk perception and stakeholder vulnerability related to sewage impacts in mangroves of East Africa.Global Environmental Change,19(2),227-39.
40. Cutter, S. L.(1996).Vulnerability to environmental hazards.Progress in Human Geography,20(4),529-39.
41. Cutter, S. L.,Barnes, L.,Berry, M.,Burton, C.,Evans, E.,Tate, E.,Webb, J.(2008).A place-based model for understanding community resilience to natural disasters.Global Environmental Change,18(4),598-606.
42. Cutter, S. L.,Boruff, B. J.,Shirley, W. J.(2003).Social vulnerability to environmental hazards.Social Science Quarterly,84(2),242-61.
43. Cutter, S. L.,Mitchell, J. T.,Scott, M. S.(2000).Revealing the vulnerability of people and places: A case study of Georgetown County, South Carolina.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,90(4),713-37.
44. Department for International Development=DFID(2001).Sustainable livelihoods guidence sheets.London:DFID.
45. Dietz, T.,Ostrom, E.,Stern, P. C.(2003).The struggle to govern the commons.Science Technology Human Values,302,1902-12.
46. Dow, K.(1992).Exploring differences in our common future(s): The meaning of vulnerability to global environmental change.Geoforum,23(3),417-36.
47. Downing, T. E.,Aerts, J.,Soussan, J.,Barthelemy, O.,Bharwani, S.,Ionescu, C.,Hinkel, J.,Klein, R. J. T.,Mata, L.,Moss, S.,Purkey, D.,Ziervogel, G.(2006).Integrating social vulnerability into water management.Oxford:Stockholm Environment Institute.
48. Eakin, H.,Benessaiah, K.,Barrera, J. F.,Cruz-Bello, G. M.,Morales, H.(2011).Livelihoods and landscapes at the threshold of change: Disaster and resilience in a Chiapas coffee community.Regional Environmental Change,12,475-88.
49. Eakin, H.,Bojorquez-Tapia, L. A.(2008).Insights into the composition of household vulnerability from multicriteria decision analysis.Global Environmental Change,18(1),112-27.
50. Eakin, H.,Luers, A. L.(2006).Assessing the vulnerability of social-environmental systems.Annual Review of Environment and Resources,31,365-94.
51. Field, C. B.(ed.),Barros, V.(ed.),Stocker, T. F.(ed.),Qin, D.(ed.),Dokken, D. J.(ed.),Ebi, K. L.(ed.),Mastrandrea, M. D.(ed.),Mach, K. J.(ed.),Plattner, S. K. A. G. K.(ed.),Tignor, M.(ed.),Midgley, P. M.(ed.)(2012).Managing the risks of extreme events and disasters to advance climate change adaptation. A special report of working groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
52. Folke, C.(2006).Resilience: The emergence of a perspective for social-ecological systems analyses.Global Environmental Change,16(3),253-67.
53. Folke, C.,Hahn, T.,Olsson, P.,Norberg, J.(2005).Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems.Annual Review of Environment and Resources,30,441-73.
54. Fussel, H. M.(2007).Vulnerability: A generally applicable conceptual framework for climate change research.Global Environmental Change,17(2),155-67.
55. Gunderson, L. H.(ed.),Holling, C. S.(ed.),Light, S. S.(ed.)(1995).Barriers and bridges to the renewal of ecosystems and institutions.New York:Columbia University Press.
56. Gunderson, L. H.,Folke, C.(2005).Resilience-now more than ever.Ecology and Society,10(2),22.
57. Gunderson, L. H.,Holling, C. S.(2002).Panarchy: Understanding transformations in human and nature systems.Washington, D.C., USA:Island Press.
58. Hahn, M. B.,Riederer, A. M.,Foster, S. O.(2009).The livelihood vulnerability index: A pragmatic approach to assessing risks from climate variability and change-A case study in Mozambique.Global Environmental Change,19(1),74-88.
59. Hewitt, K.(1983).Interpretations of calamity from the viewpoint of human ecology.London:Allen and Unwin Inc..
60. Holling, C. S.(1973).Resilience and stability of ecological systems.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,4,1-23.
61. IPCC(2007).Climate change 2007: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
62. IPCC(2014).Climate change 2014: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
63. IPCC,Field, C. B.(ed.),Barros, V.(ed.),Stocker, T. F.,Qin, D.(ed.),Dokken, D. J.(ed.),Ebi, K. L.(ed.),Mastrandrea, M. D.(ed.),Mach, K. J.(ed.),Plattner, G.-K.(ed.),Allen, S. K.(ed.),Tignor, M.(ed.),Midgley, P. M.(ed.)(2012).Managing the risks of extreme events and disasters to advance climate change adaptation. A special report of working groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
64. Jakobsen, K.(2013).Livelihood asset maps: A multidimensional approach to measuring risk-management capacity and adaptation policy targeting-A case study in Bhutan.Regional Environmental Change,13,219-33.
65. Janssen, M. A.,Ostrom, E.(2006).Resilience, vulnerability, and adaptation: A cross-cutting theme of the international human dimensions programme on global environmental change.Global Environmental Change,16(3),237-9.
66. Johnston, R. J.(1991).The dictionary of human geography.Oxford:Blackwell.
67. Johnston, R. J.(1991).Geography and geographers: Anglo-American human geography since 1945.London:Edward Arnold.
68. Kasperson, J. X.,Kasperson, R. E.(2005).The social contours of risk: Risk analysis, corporations and the globalization of risk.London:Earthscan.
69. Kasperson, J. X.,Kasperson, R. E.(2001).Global environmental risk.New York:United Nations University Press.
70. Kasperson, R. E.(ed.),Berberian, M.(ed.)(2011).Integrating science and policy: Vulnerability and resilience in global environmental change.London:Earthscan.
71. Kasperson, R. E.,Kasperson, J. X.(2001).Climate change, vulnerability and social justice.Stockholm, Sweden:Stockholm Environment Institute.
72. Kates, R. W.(1962).Hazard and choice perception in flood plain management.University of Chicago Press.
73. Kates, R. W.,Clark, W. C.,Corell, R.,Hall, J. M.,Jaeger, C. C.,Lowe, I.,McCarthy, J. J.,Schellnhuber, H. J.,Bolin, B.,Dickson, N. M.,Faucheu, S.,Gallopin, G. C.,Grübler, A.,Huntley, B.,Jäger, J.,Jodha, N. S.,Kasperson, R. E.,Mabogunje, A.,Matson, P.,Mooney, H.,moore III, B.,Riordan, T.,Svedin, U.(2001).Environment and development: Sustainability science.Science,292(5517),641-2.
74. King, B.(2011).Spatialising livelihoods: Resource access and livelihood spaces in South Africa.Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,36(2),297-313.
75. Lebel, L.,Anderies, J. M.,Campbell, B.,Folke, C.,Hatfield-Dodds, S.,Hughes, T. P.,Wilson, J.(2006).Governance and the capacity to manage resilience in regional social-ecological systems.Ecology and Society,11(1),19.
76. Leichenko, R. M.,O'Brien, K. L.(2002).The dynamics of rural vulnerability to global change.Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change,7(1),1-18.
77. Lin, K. H.,Chang, C. Y.(2013).Everyday crises: Marginal society livelihood vulnerability and adaptability to hazards.Progress in Development Studies,13(1),1-18.
78. Lin, K. H.,Polsky, C.(2015).Indexing livelihood vulnerability to the effects of Typhoons in indigenous communities of Taiwan.The Geographical Journal
79. Liverman, D. M.(1990).Vulnerability to global environmental change.Understanding global environmental change: The contributions of risk analysis and management,Worcester, MA:
80. Liverman, D. M.(1999).Vulnerability and adaptation to drought in Mexico.Natural Resources Journal,39(1),99-115.
81. Liverman, D. M.(1999).Geography and the global environment.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,89(1),107-20.
82. Liverman, D. M.(2008).Assessing impacts, adaptation and vulnerability: Reflections on the Working Group II Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.Global Environmental Change,18(1),4-7.
83. Lo, W. C.,Tsai, T. C.,Hsu, C. H.(2012).Building vulnerability to debris flows in Taiwan: A preliminary study.Natural Hazards,64,2107-28.
84. Luers, A. L.,Lobell, D. B.,Sklar, L. S.,Addams, C. L.,Matson, P. A.(2003).A method for quantifying vulnerability, applied to the agricultural system of the Yaqui Valley, Mexico.Global Environmental Change,13,255-67.
85. McCarthy, J. J.(ed.),Canziani, O. F.(ed.),Leary, N. A.(ed.),Dokken, D. J.(ed.),White, K. S.(ed.)(2001).Climate change 2001: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
86. McLaughlin, P.,Dietz, T.(2007).Structure, agency and environment: Toward an integrated perspective on vulnerability.Global Environmental Change
87. Miller, F.,Osbahr, H.,Boyd, E.,Thomalla, F.,Bharwani, S.,Ziervogel, G.,Walker, B.,Birkmann, J.,van der Leeuw, S.,Rockstrom, J.,Hinkel, J.,Downing, T.,Folker, C. ,Nelson, D.(2010).Resilience and vulnerability: Complementary or conflicting concepts?.Ecology and Society,15(3),11.
88. Nielsen, J. Ø.,Reenberg, A.(2010).Cultural barriers to climate change adaptation: A case study from Northern Burkina Faso.Global Environmental Change,20,142-52.
89. NOAA(1999).Community vulnerability assessment tool.New Hanover County, North Colorlina:NOAA.
90. O'Brien, K. L.,Leichenko, R. M.(2000).Double exposure: Assessing the impacts of climate change within the context of economic globalization.Global Environmental Change,10(3),221-32.
91. O'Brien, K. L.,Leichenko, R.,Kelkar, U.,Venema, H.,Aandahl, G.,Tompkins, H.,Javed, A.,Bhadwal, S.,Barg, S.,Nygaard, L.,West, J.(2004).Mapping vulnerability to multiple stressors: Climate change and globalization in India.Global Environmental Change,14(4),303-13.
92. Oliver-Smith, A.(1986).Natural disasters and cultural responses.Williamsburg:College of William and Mary.
93. Oliver-Smith, A.,Hoffman, S. M.(1999).The angry earth: Disaster in anthropological perspective.New York:Routledge.
94. Olsson, P.,Folke, C.,Berkes, F.(2004).Adaptive comanagement for building resilience in social-ecological systems.Environmental Management,34(1),75-90.
95. Olsson, P.,Folke, C.,Hahn, T.(2004).Social-ecological transformation for ecosystem management: The development of adaptive co-management of a wetland landscape in southern Sweden.Ecology and Society,9(4),2.
96. Ostrom, E.(ed.),Dietz, T.(ed.),Dolsak, N.(ed.),Stern, P. C.(ed.),Stonich, S.,Weber, E. U.(ed.)(2002).The drama of the commons.Washington, DC:National academy press.
97. Pearce, L.(2000).The University of British Columbia.
98. Peet, R.(1998).Modern geographical thought.Oxford:Blackwell.
99. Peet, R.,Watts, M.(1996).Liberation ecologies: Environment, development, social movements.New York:Routledge.
100. Petheram, L.,Zander, K. K.,Campbell, B. M.,High, C.,Stacey, N.(2010).'Strange changes': Indigenous perspectives of climate change and adaptation in NE Arnhem Land (Australia).Global Environmental Change,20(4),681-92.
101. Polsky C.,Neff, R.,Yarnal, B.(2007).Building comparable global change vulnerability assessments: The vulnerability scoping diagram.Global Environmental Change,17,475-82.
102. Sen, A.(1981).Poverty and famines: An essay on entitlement and deprivation.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
103. Smit, B.,Wandel, J.(2006).Adaptation, adaptive capacity and vulnerability.Global Environmental Change,16(3),282-92.
104. Sultana, F.(2009).Community and participation in water resources management: Gendering and naturing development debates from Bangladesh.Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,34,346-63.
105. Timmerman, P.(1981).,Toronto:University of Toronto, Institute of Environmental Studies.
106. Tschakert, P.(2007).Views from the vulnerable: Understanding climatic and other stressors in the Sahel.Global Environmental Change,17(3-4),381-96.
107. Tucker, C. M.,Eakin, H.,Castellanos, E. J.(2010).Perceptions of risk and adaptation: Coffee producers, market shocks, and extreme weather in Central America and Mexico.Global Environmental Change,20(1),23-32.
108. Turner II, B. L.(2010).Vulnerability and resilience: Coalescing or paralleling approaches for sustainability science?.Global Environmental Change,20(4),570-6.
109. Turner II, B. L.,Clark, W. C.,Kates, R. W.,Richards, J. F.,Mathews, J. T.,Meyer, W. B.(1993).The earth as transformed by human action: Global and regional changes in the biosphere over the past 300 years.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
110. Turner II, B. L.,Kasperson, R. E.,Matson, P. A.,McCarthy, J. J.,Corell, R. W.,Christensen, L.,Eckley, N.,Kasperson, J. X.,Luers, A.,Martello, M. L.,Polsky, C.,Pulsipner, A.,Schiller, A.(2003).A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,100(14),8074-9.
111. Turner II, B. L.,Matson, P. A.,McCarthy, J. J.,Corell, R. W.,Christensen, L.,Eckley, N.,Hovelsrud-Broda, G. K.,Kasperson, J. X.,Kasperson, R. E.,Luers, A.,Martello, M. L.,Mathiesen, S.,Naylor, R.,Polsky, C.,Pulsipher, A.,Sshiller, A.,Selin, H.,Tyler, N.(2003).Illustrating the coupled human-environment system for vulnerability analysis: Three case studies.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,100(14),8080-5.
112. UNISDR(2004).Living with risks: A global review of disaster reduction initiatives.Geneva:United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction, Publication.
113. Veland, S.,Howitt, R.,Dominey-Howes, D.,Thomalla, F.,Houston, D.(2013).Procedural vulnerability: Understanding environmental change in a remote indigenous community.Global Environmental Change,23(1),314-26.
114. Walker, B. H.,Salt, D.,Reid, W. V.(2006).Resilience thinking: Sustaining ecosystems and people in a changing world.Washington, DC:Island Press.
115. Watts, M.(1983).Silent violence: Food, famine and peasantry in Northern Nigeria.Berkley:University of California Press.
116. Watts, M. J.,Bohle, H. G.(1993).The space of vulnerability: The causal structure of hunger and famine.Progress in Human Geography,17,43-67.
117. Zimmerer, K.(1994).Human geography and the new ecology: The prospect and promise of integration.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,84,108-25.
118. 中央研究院環境變遷研究中心(2014)。臺灣及太平洋友邦南島民族氣候變遷調適及因應政策研討會論文集
119. 吳杰穎、江宜錦(2008)。臺灣天然災害統計指標體系建構與分析。地理學報，51，65-84。
120. 林冠慧(2011)。台北=Taipei，國立臺灣大學地理環境資源學研究所=Department of Geography, National Taiwan University。
121. 林冠慧(2004)。全球變遷下脆弱性與適應性研究方法與方法論的探討。全球變遷通訊雜誌，43，33-8。
122. 林冠慧、孫志鴻(2004)。全球變遷人文面向研究的新發展。全球變遷通訊雜誌，41，40-4。
123. 張宜君、林宗弘(2013)。數據的災難？九二一震災社會調查資料庫的現狀與限制。思與言人文社會科學期刊，51(1)，269-311。
124. 陳亮全(2009)。,臺北=Taipei:行政院科技部=Xing zheng yuan ke ji bu=Ministry of Science and Technology。
125. 湯京平、蔡允棟、黃紀(2002)。災難與政治：921 地震中的集體行為與災變情境的治理。政治科學論叢，16，137-62。

1. 陳毅青,宋承恩,王素芬(2020)。整合多尺度自然與行政單元評估南投縣崩塌災害風險。地理學報，96，27-54。
2. 鄧傳忠,曾敏惠,陳宏宇,吳郁玶(2021)。社區災害韌性的探討：以莫拉克颱風災區重建為例。地理學報，99，1-31。
3. 洪廣冀、何俊頤(2018)。自然資源治理與原住民部落發展：後發展與後人類的視角。考古人類學刊，89，93-141。
4. 許耿銘(2017)。都市水患風險脆弱性之初探　臺南市空間與非空間因素的分析。政治科學論叢，74，149-192。
5. 柯昭男,林貝珊,王駿逸(2023)。社區防災計畫對居民災害識覺與行為之影響。危機管理學刊，20(2)，49-56。
6. 廖興中,張鎧如,李天申(2020)。新北市里層級之水災暨坡地災害脆弱性分析：全盤型脆弱性管理架構的初步應用。行政暨政策學報，71，89-137。
7. 劉季宇、詹忠翰、葉錦勳、張宜君、胡伯維、林冠慧、林宗弘(2017)。地震、屋毀與傷亡：集集地震風險的因果分析。都市與計劃，44(1)，83-112。
8. 劉怡君,洪鴻智(2022)。從災害韌性觀點探討流域之脆弱度、衝擊與調適。都市與計劃，49(1)，71-98。
9. 涂建翊,林貝珊,宋郁玲(2018)。以社會脆弱性與韌性建構脆弱性單元的可能性分析臺灣中部地區強降雨災害為例。地理學報，89，1-42。
10. 蕭新煌、許耿銘、林宗弘(2018)。邁向世界風險社會？台灣民眾的社會資本、風險感知與風險因應行為。調查研究：方法與應用，40，127-166。
11. 張燕雲,王鑫(2023)。地方依附的縫補－以921大地震後的台中市霧峰區為例。華岡地理學報，35，60-83。
12. 張育銘,林貝珊(2022)。以韌性觀點探討土石流災後復原與生計：以嘎色鬧部落的露營觀光為例。災害防救科技與管理學刊，11(2)，59-73。