應用探究式深度討論於閱讀與寫作翻轉學習課程設計與教學實務

An Application of Inquiry-Based Quality Talk to the Flipped Design and Teaching of ＂Reading & Writing＂ Courses

10.6120/JoEMLS.202007_57(2).0015.RS.CM

蔡娉婷(Tina Pingting Tsai)；許慶昇(Chingsheng Hsu)；林至中(Jyhjong Lin)

翻轉學習 ； 探究式深度討論 ； 閱讀與寫作課程 ； 課程設計 ； 實務教學 ； Flipped learning ； Inquiry-based quality talk ； ＂Reading and Writing＂ course ； Class design ； Practical teaching

教育資料與圖書館學

57卷2期（2020 / 07 / 01）

253 - 286

繁體中文

近年來，教育部積極鼓勵大學校院強化學生的閱讀與寫作訓練，以提升學生的重點剖析、事理敘述、情境設計等能力，因此閱讀與寫作已成為各大學的重點通識課程之一，而翻轉學習即為國內教育界常使用的閱讀與寫作相關課程教學方法。本文探討如何應用探究式深度討論於翻轉學習模式，並針對運用此新模式的閱讀與寫作課程進行設計，使課程能運用探究式深度討論，增加學生分析綜整與敘述設計的能力，以提升學生的閱讀與寫作學習成效。本文運用此課程設計於某大學閱讀與寫作課程「飲食文學」單元，設計此單元的教材內容以及探究式深度討論機制，並經由實務教學、準實驗研究法的對照分析，以及學生的滿意度調查，驗證此新模式的學生學習成效及滿意度。

In recent years, called from the Ministry of Education, ＂reading and writing＂ has become a core course in the general education sectors of universities. Its characteristics are mainly to cultivate students' abilities about emphasis analysis, reason narrative, and scenario design. Further, flipped learning is commonly used for the teaching of its classes. This paper presents how to integrate an innovative inquiry-based quality talk in flipped learning and then proposes, in such a new integrated flipped learning model, a ＂reading and writing＂ class design method for enhancing students' learning effects on their ＂reading and writing＂ abilities. Then, this method is applied to the 'food literature' unit in a ＂reading and writing＂ course at a domestic university to design its learning contents and inquiry-based quality talk activities. For verification, a quasi-experimental study on the comparative analysis and its associated questionnaires have been conducted to validate the effects and students' satisfaction of applying the new model to ＂reading and writing＂ classes.

1. 徐筱玲, Hsiao-Ling,陳浩然, Hao-Jan Howard,林微庭, Wei-Tin(2019)。深度討論和高層次思考：台灣大學生之研究。教育資料與圖書館學，56(1)，107-130。
   連結：
2. 蔡娉婷, Tina Pingting,許慶昇, Chingsheng,林至中, Jyhjong(2019)。應用ePUB3電子書於翻轉式寫作課程設計與教學實務：以摘要寫作為例。教育資料與圖書館學，56(1)，50-67。
   連結：
3. 蔡娉婷, Tina Pingting,許慶昇, Chingsheng,林至中, Jyhjong(2019)。應用深度討論於ePUB3電子書翻轉式閱讀理解學習課程設計與教學實務。教育資料與圖書館學，56(3)，343-372。
   連結：
4. Abd-El-Khalick, F.,BouJaoude, S.,Duschl, R.,Lederman, N. G.,Mamlok-Naaman, R.,Hofstein, A.,Niaz, M.,Treagust, D.,Tuan, H.-L.(2004).Inquiry in science education: International perspectives.Science Education,88(3),397-419.
5. Alavi, C.(Ed.)(1995).Problem-based learning in a health sciences curriculum.Routledge.
6. Alonso, F.,López, G.,Manrique, D.,Viñes, J. M.(2005).An instructional model for web-based e-learning education with a blended learning process approach.British Journal of Educational Technology,36(2),217-235.
7. Bersin, J.(2004).The blended learning book: Best practices, proven methodologies, and lessons learned.Pfeiffer.
8. Bonk, C. J.,Graham, C. R.(2006).The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs.Pfeiffer.
9. Chen, H. Y.-L.,Chen, N.-S.(2014).Design and evaluation of a flipped course adopting the holistic flipped classroom approach.2014 IEEE 14th International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies
10. Chu, H.-C.,Yang, C.(2017).Learning achievements and attitudes in a computer science course: Activating students flipped learning via ICT technologies.2017 6th IIAI International Congress on Advanced Applied Informatics (IIAI-AAI)
11. Edwards, C. H.(1997).Promoting student inquiry.The Science Teacher,64(7),18-21.
12. Evenson, D. H.(Ed.),Hmelo, C. E.(Ed.)(2000).Problem based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
13. Grant, M. M.(2002).Getting a grip on project-based learning: Theory, cases and recommendations.Meridian: A Middle School Computer Technologies Journal,5
14. Kim, Y.,Ahn, C.(2018).Effect of combined use of flipped learning and inquiry-based learning on a system modeling and control course.IEEE Transactions on Education,61(2),136-142.
15. Lee, C.-I.,Tsai, F.-Y.(2004).Internet project-based learning environment: The effects of thinking styles on learning transfer.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,20(1),31-39.
16. Merrill, M. D.(1994).Instructional design theory.Educational Technology.
17. Murphy, P. K.(Ed.)(2017).Classroom discussions in education.Taylor and Francis.
18. Murphy, P. K.,Greene, J. A.,Firetto, C. M.,Hendrick, B. D.,Li, M.,Montalbano, C.,Wei, L.(2018).Quality talk: Developing students’ discourse to promote high-level comprehension.American Educational Research Journal,55(5),1113-1160.
19. Pugsee, P.(2017).The effect of collaborative learning techniques in the flipped classroom learning: Computer ethics course.2017 IEEE 6th International Conference on Teaching Assessment, and Learning for Engineering (TALE)
20. Quality Talk. (2020). http://quality-talk.org/
21. Ram, M. P.,Sinha, A.(2017).An implementation framework for flipped classrooms in higher education.Proceedings of the Special Collection on eGovernment Innovations in India
22. Roehl, A.,Reddy, S. L.,Shannon, G. J.(2013).The flipped classroom: An opportunity to engage millennial students through active learning strategies.Journal of Family & Consumer Sciences,105(2),44-49.
23. Schneider, R. M.,Krajcik, J.,Marx, R. J.,Soloway, E.(2002).Performance of students in project-based science classrooms on a national measure of achievement.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,39(5),410-422.
24. Thorne, K.(2003).Blended learning: How to integrate online & traditional learning.Kogan Page.
25. Tsai, T. P.,Lin, L. C.,Lin, J.(2019).A study on the preview effectiveness of learning contents in ePUB3 eBook-based flip blended learning models.International Journal of Mobile and Blended Learning,11(2),50-67.
26. Wen, A. S.,Zaid, N. M.,Harun, J.(2016).Enhancing students CT problem solving skills using flipped classroom model.2016 IEEE 8th International Conference on Engineering Education (ICEED)
27. Wilkinson, I. A. G.,Soter, A. O.,Murphy, P. K.(2010).Developing a model of Quality Talk about literary text.Bringing reading research to life
28. Zhang, H.,Meng, L.,Han, X.,Yuan, L.,Wang, J.(2016).Exploration and practice of blended learning in HVAC course based on flipped classroom.2016 International Symposium on Educational Technology (ISET)
29. 王世豪（編）, Shih-Hao (Ed.)(2019).深度討論力：高教深耕的國文閱讀思辨素養課程.五南=Wunan.
30. 王憶貞, Yi-Jhen(2018)。大葉大學資訊管理學系=Department of Information Management, Da-Yeh University。
31. 朱振藩, Zhen-Fan(2012).點食成經：袁枚《隨園食單．須知單》新解.麥田=Rye Field.
32. 吳姿瑩, Tzu-Ying(2019)。國立政治大學圖書資訊與檔案學研究所=Graduate Institute of Library, Information and Archival Studies, National Chengchi University。
33. 李盈萱, Ying-Hsuan(2020)。國立臺灣師範大學英語學系=Department of English, National Taiwan Normal University。
34. 林文月, Wen-Yueh(1999).飲膳札記.洪範=Hung-Fan.
35. 林奕吾, Yi-Wu(2017)。國立臺灣師範大學圖書資訊學研究所=Graduate Institute of Library & Information Studies, National Taiwan Normal University。
36. 侯秋玲, ChiuLing(2007)。探究取向語文課程之偕同探究。國教學報，19，107-133。
37. 洪振方, Jeng-Fung(2003)。探究式教學的歷史回顧與創造性探究模式之初探。高雄師大學報，15，641-662。
38. 胡衍南（編）, Yan-Nan(ed.),王世豪（編）, Shih-Hao(ed.)(2020).深度討論教學法理論與實踐.元照=Angle.
39. 張曼娟, Man-Chuan(2004).黃魚聽雷.皇冠=Crown Culture.
40. 張新仁, Shin-Jen(1992).寫作教學研究：認知心理學取向.復文=Fu Wen Books.
41. 張輝誠, Huei Cheng(2015)。翻轉教學新浪潮—學思達教學法介紹。T&D飛訊，207，1-20。
42. 張瓈月, Li-Yueh(2011)。國立新竹教育大學教育學系=Department of Education, National Hsinchu University of Education。
43. 逢甲大學國語文教學中心（編）, Feng Chia University (Ed.)(2018).閱讀書寫．建構反思II.逢甲大學=Feng Chia University.
44. 陳泓諺, Hung-Yen(2015)。國立臺灣海洋大學應用英語研究所=Institute of Applied English, National Taiwan Ocean University。
45. 陳冠蓉, Kuan-Jung(2019)。知古與創新－飲食評論單元的深度思辨寫作教學設計。2019深度討論．國文創新教學論壇，台北，台灣=Taipei, Taiwan:
46. 陳毓凱, Yu-Kai,洪振方, Jung-Feng(2007)。兩種探究取向教學模式之分析與比較。科學教育月刊，305，4-19。
47. 焦桐（編）=Jiao Tong(ed.)(2003).台灣飲食文選I.二魚=Fish & Fish.
48. 潘洪建（編）, Hongjian(ed.),劉華（編）, Hua(ed.),蔡澄（編）, Cheng(ed.)(2012).課程與教學論基礎.江蘇大學出版社=Jiangsu University Press.
49. 蔡季娟, Chi-Chuan(2019)。國立高雄師範大學國文學系=Department of Chinese, National Kaohsiung Normal University。
50. 蔡娉婷, Tina Pingting(2018).應用寫作一本通.博課師科技=BOOCs.
51. 蔡娉婷, Tina Pingting(2020)。探究式深度討論翻轉學習應用於閱讀與寫作課程之研究。2020教學創新示範學校國際研討會，雲林，台灣=Yunlin, Taiwan:
52. 蔡娉婷, Tina Pingting(2019)。應用ePUB3電子書混合式學習於國文課程之教學實踐。大學教學實務與研究學刊，2018年大學教師優良創新課程及教學競賽專刊=Competition for Excellent Innovative Curriculum and Teaching of University Teachers in 2018，129-154。
53. 蕭淑芬, Shu-Fen(2018)。國立臺灣師範大學圖書資訊學研究所=Graduate Institute of Library & Information Studies, National Taiwan Normal University。
54. 韓良露, Liang-Lu(2001).美味之戀—人在台北,玩味天下.方智=Fine Press.