三至六歲幼兒的因果思考：法則推理

Young Children's Causal Thinking: Rule Reasoning

10.6129/CJP.2010.5201.05

莊麗娟(Li-Chuan Chuang)

心智理論 ； 因果思考 ； 法則推理 ； 條件推理 ； causal thinking ； conditional reasoning ； rule reasoning ； theory of mind

中華心理學刊

52卷1期（2010 / 03 / 01）

75 - 93

繁體中文

為了深入瞭解學前幼兒的因果思考能力，以澄清近年來發展心理學研究的疑點，本研究以物理因果之「法則推理」為焦點，調整國外研究設計（斜坡－彈珠裝置），擴展研究向度（含「法則的歸納」與「法則的應用」二向度），追蹤80名3-6歲幼兒的因果推理。此外，為了瞭解法則推理能力是否具有跨領域的關聯性，另以「心智理論」作業，進行相關分析。結果發現：(1)3歲幼兒已能從系列線索中，歸納因果法則，並能依據特定法則，預測一系列的相關效應，其已能處理if-then的條件推理，並呈現逐年提昇一個階層的發展趨勢，及至5歲，幼兒已能有效運思if-if-if-then的階層性法則；(2)法則推理具有跨領域的關聯性，唯隨著推理內涵的不同，其相關頗有變異。其中，if-then層次的「法則的歸納」比「法則的應用」更具有跨領域的相關。

Aiming at understanding young children's causal thinking in order to clarify the current issues of developmental psychology, this study traced 80 young children's causal inference focusing on the rule reasoning of physical causality. Researcher modified the current design (the marble-ramp apparatus) and extended the dimensions of research including generating and using of rules. Besides, to understand whether rule reasoning possesses the generality cross domains, researcher employed children’s theory of mind and made correlative analysis. Results revealed that: (1) 3-year-oldscould already draw causal conclusion from evident clues and make prediction for relative effects by using specific rules. In addition, they employed if-then conditional reasoning and showed their breakthrough with the growing of their age. Around 5 years, young children were able to employ the if-if-if-then hierarchical rule effectively. (2) Rule reasoning seemed to have the generality cross domains. However, the correlations varied in different dimensions. Besides, rather than using rules, generating rules in the level of if-then, had stronger positive correlation between performance on theory of-mind and on physical causality tasks.

1. 鄒啓蓉(2005)。學齡前幼兒「錯誤信念」發展研究。特殊教育研究學刊，29，25-48。
   連結：
2. Babies do not play dice, either: An enquiry concerning cognitive development of causal reasoning in infants and young children
3. Atran, S.(1998).Folk biology and the anthropology of science: Cognitive universals and cultural particulars.Behavioral and Brain Sciences,21,547-609.
4. Baron-Cohen, S.(1994).How to build a baby that can read minds: Cognitive mechanisms in mindreading.Cahiers de Psychologie Cognitive/Current Psychology of Cognition,13,513-552.
5. Bartsch, K.,Wellman, H. M.(1995).Children talk about the mind.New York:Oxford University Press.
6. Bullock, M.,Gelman, R.(1979).Preschool children's assumptions about cause and effect: Temporal ordering.Child Development,50,89-96.
7. Carlson, S. M.,Moses, L. J.(2001).Individual differences in inhibitory control and children's theory of mind.Child Development,72,1032-1053.
8. Colvert, E.,Custance, D.,Swettenham, J.(2002).Rule-based reasoning and theory of mind in autism: A commentary on the work of Zelazo, Jacques, Burack and Frye.Infant and Child Development,11,197-200.
9. Flavell, J. H.,Green, F. L.,Flavell, E. R.(1995).Young children's knowledge about thinking.Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development,60(1),1-96.
10. Frye D.,Zelazo, P. D.,Burack, J. A.(1998).Cognitive complexity and control: Implications for theory of mind in typical and atypical development.Current Directions in Psychological Science,7,116-121.
11. Frye, D.,Zelazo, P. D.,Brooks, P.,Samuels, M. C.(1996).Inference and action in early causal reasoning.Developmental Psychology,32,120-131.
12. Frye, D.,Zelazo, P. D.,Palfai, T.(1995).Theory of mind and rule-based reasoning.Cognitive Development,10,483-527.
13. Gelman, R.,Bullock, M.,Meck, E.(1980).Preschoolers' understanding of simple object transformations.Child Development,51,691-699.
14. Gelman, S. A.,Heyman, G. D.,Legare, C. H.(2007).Developmental changes in the coherence of essentialist beliefs about psychological characteristics.Child development,78,757-774.
15. Gelman, S. A.,Wellman, H. M.(1991).Insides and essence: Early understandings of the non-obvious.Cognition,38,213-244.
16. German, T. P.,Nichols, S.(2003).Children's counterfactual inferences about long and short causal chains.Developmental Science,6,514-523.
17. Gopnik, A.,Meltzoff, A. N.(1997).Words, thoughts and theories.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
18. Gopnik, A.,Sobel, D. M.,Schulz, L. E.,Glymour, C.(2001).Causal learning mechanisms in very young children: Two-, three-, and four-year-olds infer causal relations from patterns of variation and covariation.Developmental Psychology,37,620-629.
19. Gopnik, A.,Wellman, H. M.,L. Hirschfield(Eds.),S. A. Gelman(Eds.)(1994).Mapping the mind: Domain specificity in cognition and culture.New York:Cambridge University Press.
20. Graham, S. A.,Kilbreath, C. S.,Welder, A. N.(2004).Thirteen-month-olds rely on shared labels and shape similarity for inductive inferences.Child Development,75,409-427.
21. Gupta, P. D.,Bryant, P. E.(1989).Young children's causal inferences.Child Development,60,1138-1146.
22. Hala, S.(1997).The development of social cognition.Hove, England:Psychology Press.
23. Hala, S.,Russell, J.(2001).Executive control within strategic deception: A window on early cognitive development?.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,80,112-141.
24. Hogrefe, G. J.,Wimmer, H.,Perner, J.(1986).Ignorance versus false belied: A developmental lag in attribution of epistemic states.Child Development,57,567-582.
25. Hughes, C.,Ensor, R.(2007).Executive function and theory of mind: Predictive relations from ages 2 to 4.Developmental Psychology,43,1447-1459.
26. Kalish, C.(1996).Causes and symptoms in preschoolers' conceptions of illness.Child Development,67,1647-1670.
27. Leslie, A. M.,Keeble, S.(1987).Do six-month-old infants perceive causality?.Cognition,25,265-288.
28. Leslie, A. M.,Thaiss, L.(1992).Domain specificity in conceptual development: Neuropsychological evidence from autism.Cognition,43,225-251.
29. Li, H.,Zheng, C.,Gao, X.,Gao, S.,Lin, C.(2005).The influence of complexity and reasoning direction on children's causal reasoning.Cognitive Development,20,87-101.
30. McClelland, J. L.,Thompson, R. M.(2007).Using domain-general principles to explain children's causal reasoning abilities.Developmental Science,10,333-356.
31. Morton, J. B.,Munakata, Y.(2002).Active versus latent representations: A neural network model of perseveration and dissociation in early childhood.Developmental Psychobiology,40,255-265.
32. Moses, L. J.,Flavell, J. H.(1990).Inferring false beliefs from actions and reactions.Child Development,61,929-945.
33. Opfer, J. E.,Bulloch, M. J.(2007).Causal relations drive young children's induction, naming, and categorization.Cognition,105,206-217.
34. Perner, J.(1991).Understanding the representational mind.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
35. Perner, J.,Lang, B.,Kloo, D.(2002).Theory of mind and self control: More than a common problem of inhibition.Child Development,73,752-767.
36. Piaget, J.(1930).The child's conception of physical causality.London:Routledge.
37. Piaget, J.(1929).The child's conception of the world.London:Routledge.
38. Ruffman, T.,Olson, D. R.,Ash, T.,Keenan, T.(1993).The ABCs of deception: Do young children understand deception in the same way as adults?.Developmental Psychology,29,74-87.
39. Ruffman, T.,Perner, J.,Olson, D. R.,Doherty, M.(1993).Reflecting on scientific thinking: Children's understanding of the hypothesis-evidence relation.Child Development,64,1617-1636.
40. Preschool children learn causal structure from conditional interventions
41. Shultz, T. R.,Mendelson, R.(1975).The use of covariation as a principle of causal analysis.Child Development,46,394-399.
42. Simpson, A.,Riggs, K. J.,Simon, M.(2004).What makes the windows task difficult for young children: Rule inference of rule use?.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,87,155-170.
43. Slaughter, V.,Jaakkola, R.,Carey, S.,M. Siegal(Eds.),C. C. Peterson (Eds.)(1999).Children's understanding of biology and health.Cambridge MA:Cambridge University Press.
44. Sobel, D. M.,Tenenbaum, J. B.,Gopnik, A.(2004).Children's causal inferences from indirect evidence: Backwards blocking and Bayesian reasoning in preschoolers.Cognitive Science,28,303-333.
45. Sodian, B.(1991).The development of deception in young children.British Journal of Developmental Psychology,9,173-188.
46. Sophian, C.,Huber, A.(1984).Early developments inchildren's causal judgments.Child Development,55,512-526.
47. Spelke, E. S.,Breinlinger, K.,Macomber, J.,Jacobson, K.(1992).Origins of knowledge.Psychological Review,99,605-632.
48. Sullivan, K.,Winner, E.(1991).When 3-year-olds understand ignorance, false belief and representational change.British Journal of Developmental Psychology,9,159-171.
49. Szarkowicz, D. L.(2002).When they wash him they'll know he'll be Harry: Young children's thinking about thinking within a story context.International Journal of Early Years Education,8,71-81.
50. Wimmer, H.,Perner, J.(1983).Beliefs about beliefs: Representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception.Cognition,13,103-128.
51. Two experimental variations on the standard false belief task
52. Yerys, B. E.,Munakata, Y.(2006).When labels hurt but novelty helps: Children's perseveration and flexibility in a card-sorting task.Child Development,77,1589-1607.
53. Zelazo, P. D.,Jacques, S.,Burack, J. A.,Frye, D.(2002).The relation between theory of mind and rule use: Evidence from persons with autism-spectrum disorders.Infant and Child Development,11,171-195.
54. 保心怡(2003)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立台灣師範大學人類發展家庭學系。

1. 陳紹慶(2013)。體現認知的心理學觀點及研究取向。中華心理學刊，55(3)，405-416。
2. 侯天麗(2012)。專家島嶼之萌發：探究父母的教學策略。科學教育學刊，20(2)，119-144。
3. 莊麗娟、侯天麗(2013)。三～六歲幼兒的天真古生物學─恐龍的結構與行為。科學教育學刊，21(3)，291-315。