鐵路司機員適應影響行車安全壓力源之能力量測

Measurement of Train Drivers' Ability to Adapt Stress When Driving

10.6402/TPJ.200806.0139

張新立(Hsin-Li Chang)；朱來順(Lai-Shun Ju)

鐵路司機員 ； 壓力源 ； 焦點團體法 ； Rasch模式 ； Train driver ； Stressor ； Focus group method ； Rasch model

運輸計劃季刊

37卷2期（2008 / 06 / 30）

139 - 163

繁體中文

本研究以軌道系統安全理論為基礎，嘗試從「環境」、「設備」、與「管理」三個構面去探索影響鐵路司機員行車安全之壓力源，並評量不同社經屬性司機員適應這些壓力源能力之差異。本研究首先透過焦點團體法篩選可能影響鐵路司機員行車安全之壓力源，再經由具相關專業經驗之專家以質化及量化之方法作進一步過濾後，製作成量測鐵路司機員適應影響其行車安全壓力源之能力量表，並以臺鐵局之司機員為實證研究之對象。本研究採用Rasch量測方法校估所有壓力源之適應難度與受測司機員之適應能力，以突破傳統將測驗所得之「原始等級尺度資料」當成「等距尺度資料」直接加以運算並進行統計推論所潛存之缺失。研究結果顯示，臺鐵局司機員於行車過程中較難適應並克服之行車安全壓力源主要來自環境構面，其次為來自設備構面之壓力，而來自管理構面之壓力則相對地低。至於鐵路司機員適應影響行車安全壓力源之能力，則發現經驗是影響其適應壓力之最主要因素，即服務年資愈長者，其適應壓力源之能力也愈高。本研究提供臺鐵局一套頗具價值之行車安全資訊，足以協助相關安全管理措施之研擬與推動。

This study was conducted to develop an approach from ”environment”, ”equipment”, and ”management” to measure the ability of train drivers to adapt to job stress and ensure safe driving. Through focus group discussion and expert judgment, a questionnaire was designed to explore the stressors confronted by train drivers when driving and measure their ability to adapt to driving stress. A survey was conducted to collect the responses of Taiwan Railway Administration (TRA) train drivers, and the Rasch model, which can estimate values on an interval scale from ordinal responses, was then applied to explore the difficulties of various stressors to be confronted and the abilities of train drivers to adapt to stress while driving. The study results showed that most of the critical stressors come from the driving external environment, and is found to be the most important factor to determine the ability to adapt to job stress for safe driving. The study results offer valuable information about the stressors confronted by train drivers, and provide consultation assistance on railway safety management.

1. 張新立、吳舜丞(2007)。多層面Rasch模式於學術研討會論文評分之應用。測驗學刊，4，425-432。
   連結：
2. Aiken, L. R.(1996).Rating Scales and Checklists: Evaluating Behavior, Personality, and Attitudes.New York:John Wiley & Son, Inc..
3. Akerstedt, T.,Gillberg, M.,Torsvall, L.,Froberg, J.(1980).Oregelbundna Arbetstder: Sammanfattning av en Undersokning av Turlistearbetande Lokforare.Rapporter Fran Laboratoriet for Klinisk Stressforskning,132,51-61.
4. Andersen, T.(1999).16th ESREDA Seminar, Safety and Reliability in Transportation.Glasgow UK:
5. Andrich, D.(1988).Rasch Models for Measurement.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
6. Andrich, D.(1978).A Rating Formulation for Ordered Response Categories.Psychometrika,43(2),561-573.
7. Baddeley, A.(1972).Selective Attention and Performance in Dangerous Environment.British Journal of Psychology,63,537-546.
8. Bond, T. G.,Fox, C. M.(2001).Applying the Rasch Model: Fundamental Measurement in the Human Science.NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
9. Collis, L.,Schmid, F.,Noyes J.,Bransby M. (Eds.)(2001).The Institution of Electrical Engineers.London:
10. Cooper, C. L.,Baglioni, A. J.(1988).A Structural Model Approach toward the Development of a Theory of the Link Between Stress and Mental Health.British Journal of Medical Psychology,2,87-102.
11. David, E.(2001).Rail Safety.Reliability Engineering and System Safety,74,291-297.
12. Dorrian, J.,Roach, G. D.,Fletcher, A.,Dawson, D.(2006).The Effects of Fatigue on Train Handling During Speed Restriction.Transportation Research Part F,4,243-257.
13. Edkins, G. D.,Pollock, C. M.(1997).The Influence of Sustained Attention on Railway Accidents.Accident Analysis and Prevention,29(4),533-539.
14. Embretson, S. E.,Reise, S. P.(2000).Item Response Theory for Psychologists.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
15. Farrington-Darby, T.,Wilson, J.,Norris, B.(2005).Rail Human Factors: Supporting the Integrated Railway.London:Ashgate.
16. Fisher, W. P.,Harvey, R. F.,Taylor, P.,Kilgore, K. M.,Kelly, C. K.(1995).Rehabits: A Common Language of Functional Assessment.Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation,76(2),113-122.
17. Gerbino, W.,Strano, F.(2002).Human Factors in Transportation, Communication, Health, and the Workplace.Maastricht:Shaker.
18. Grabarerk, I.(2002).Ergonomic Diagnosis of the Driver`s Workplace in an Electric Locomotive.International Joint Occupation Safety Ergonomic,8(2),225-242.
19. Guttman, L.(1950).The Basis for Scalogram Analysis, Measurement and Prediction.NJ:Princeton University Press.
20. Hall, S.(1999).Hidden Dangers- Railway Safety in the Era of Privatization.Ian Allan, UK:
21. Hambleton, R.,Swaminathan, H.(1985).Item Response Theory: Principles and Applications.Boston, MA, U.S.A.:Hingham.
22. Helmreich, R.,Chidster, T.,Foushee, H.,Gregorich, S.,Willhelm, J.(1990).How Effective Is Cockpit Resource Management Training? Issues in Evaluating the Impact of Programs to Enhance Crew Coordination.Flight Safety Digest,9(5),1-17.
23. Hudoklin, A.,Rozman, V.(1996).Reliability of Railway Traffic Personnel.Reliability Engineering and System Safety,52,165-169.
24. Jansson, A.,Olsson, A.,Kecklund, L.(2005).Rail Human Factors: Supporting the Integrated Railway.London:Ashgate.
25. Kecklund, L.,Ingre, M.,Kecklund, G.,Söderström, M.(2001).Presented at 2 Signaling Safety.Swedish National Rail Administration.
26. Kecklund, L.,Olsson, E.,Jansson, A.,Kecklund, G.,Ingre, M.(2003).The TRAIN-Project: Effects of Organizational Factors, Automatic Train Control, Work Hours and Environment: Suggestions for Safety Enhancing Measures.Proceedings of the 47th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
27. Kolmodin, H.,Swensson, A.(1975).Problems Related to Shift Work: A Field Study of Swedish Railroad Workers with Irregular Work Hours.Scand J Work Environ and Health,1,254-262.
28. Linacre, J. M.(1989).Many Face Rasch Measurement.Chicago:MESA Press.
29. Linacre, J. M.,Wright, B. D.(1997).A User`s Guide to Winsteps: Rasch-Model Computer Program.Chicago:MESA.
30. Mack, Z.,Broadbent, S.,Miller, M.(2004).Contemporary Ergonomics 2004.Boca Raton, FL:CRC Press.
31. Massof, R. W.,Fletcher, D. C.(2001).Evaluation of the NEI Visual Functioning Questionnaire as an Interval Measure of Visual Ability in Low Vision.Vision Research,41,397-413.
32. Masters, G. N.(1982).A Rasch Model for Partial Credit Scoring.Psychometrika,47(2),149-174.
33. Matteson, A. J.,Ivancevich, J. M.(1987).Controlling Work Stress.London:Jossey-Bass.
34. McLeod, R.,Walker, G.,Mills, A.(2005).Rail Human Factors: Supporting the Integrated Railway.London:Ashgate.
35. Nachreiner, F.,Hanecke, K.(1992).Vigilance.Handbook of Human Performance,3,261-288.
36. Nagel, D. C.,E. L. Wiemer,D. C. Nagel (Eds.)(1988).Human factors in aviation.San Diego:Academic Press.
37. Netterstrom, B.,Paludan, L.(1981).Institut fo Scial Medicin.Arbejdsmiljofondet, Danmark:Kobenhavns Universitet.
38. Ohlsson, K.(1990).Statens Vag-och transport forsknings institutet.Linkoping:
39. Park, K. S.(1987).Human Reliability: Analysis, Prediction, and Prevention of Human Errors.Amsterdam:Elsevier.
40. Pasquiui, A.,Rizzo, A.,Save, L.(2004).A Methodology for the Analysis of SPAD.Safety Science,42(5),437-455.
41. Steinickc, W.,Meissner, T.(2003).The Project European Driver`s Desk (EUDD)-A Multidisciplinary Approach towards the Future Modular Train, Ergonomics in the Digital Age.Proceedings of the XVth Triennial Congress of the International Ergonomics Association and the Seventh Joint Conference of the Ergonomics Society of Korea and Japan Ergonomics Society
42. Torsi, S.,Rizzi, A.,Pozzi, S.(2003).Designing Documents for Train Operators: A Contribution to Graphic from Cultural Psychology.Information Design Journal,11,123-137.
43. Tsang, P.,Wilson, G.(1997).Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics.New York:John Wiley & Sons.
44. Turner, C.,Harrison, R.,Lowe, E.(2003).Contemporary Ergonomics 2003.London:Taylor & Francis.
45. Van, D. F.,Schoonman, F.(1988).Railway Signals Passed at Danger: Situational and Personal Factors.Application Ergonomic,19,235-241.
46. Vidulich, M.,Stratton, M.,Wilson, G.(1994).Performance-Based and Physiological Measures of Situational Awareness.Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine.
47. Whitlock, W.,Pethick, J.,Mills, A.(2005).Rail Human Factors: Supporting the Integrated Railway.London:Ashgate.
48. Wilson, J. R.,Norris, B. J.(2006).Human Factors in Support of a Successful Railway: A Review.Cong Tech Work.
49. Wright, B. D.(1997).A History of Social Science Measurement.Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice,16(4),33-45.
50. Wright, B. D.(1996).Reliability and Separation.Rasch Measurement Transactions,2,136-145.
51. Wright, B. D.,Master, G. N.(1982).Rating Scale Analysis.Chicago:MESA Press.
52. Zhu, W.(1996).Should Total Scores from a Rating Scale be Used Directly?.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,67,363-372.
53. Zhu, W.,Cole, E.(1996).Many-Faceted Rasch Calibration of a Gross Motor Instrument.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,67,24-34.
54. 王文中(2004)。Rasch測量模式與其在教育與心理之應用。教育與心理研究，27(4)，637-694。
55. 余民寧(1992)。試題反應理論的介紹（二）－基本概念和假設。研習資訊，9(1)，5-9。
56. 余善法、馬良慶、崔明煊(1998)。火車司機職業緊張因素分析。工業及生產職業病，24(3)
57. 李婷婷(1999)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。交通大學工業工程與管理學系。
58. 張新立、楊筑雅、吳晉光(2005)。鐵路司機員工作壓力與影響因素研究。鐵道學報，24(3)
59. 詹益統(1996)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立交通大學管理科學研究所。
60. 臺灣鐵路管理局(2007)。臺灣鐵路96年年鑑。
61. 趙吉山,胡安洲(2003).鐵路運輸安全管理.北京:中國鐵道出版社.

1. 湯靜薰(2017)。臺鐵局機務機班乘務人員生活品質與工作壓力之關聯性研究-以左營機務分段為例。義守大學資訊管理學系學位論文。2017。1-113。