技術型高中學生自主學習指標建構之研究

The Study on Constructing Autonomous Learning Indicator of Technological and Vocational High School Students

10.6249/SE.202209_73(3).0020

游玉英(Yu-Ying Yu)；洪榮昭(Jon-Chao Hong)；林騰蛟(Teng-Chiao Lin)；袁宇熙(Yu-Hsi Yuan)

技術型高中 ； 自主學習 ； 自主學習指標 ； 指標建構 ； KJ法 ； Technical high school ； autonomous learning ； autonomy learning indicator ； indices construction ； K J Method

中等教育

73卷3期（2022 / 09 / 01）

55 - 84

繁體中文

在108課綱以素養為導向的理念下，構建學生的自主學習，已成為12年國民基本教育下學生的重要課題。為了促進學生的自主學習，構建自主學習指標成為自主學習素養發展和評量的重要基礎。因此，本研究旨在構建不同層面與向度的自主學習指標，以供評估技術型高中學生的自主學習現況。研究程序首先透過文獻分析彙整自主學習指標架構，再用KJ法進行指標分類和層面重組。經過三回合KJ法分析，總結出自主學習指標系統架構初稿，包括4個層面、15個向度、157個指標。以14名專家進行修正式德菲術，以完善指標修訂，再以專家問卷進行一致性分析，以確立自主學習的層面、向度與指標。藉由1,347名技術型高中學生填答，以考驗指標的信效度。分析結果支持本研究所建構的技術型高中自主學習指標具備信度與效度，可供教育單位、教師與學生運用於評估學生的自主學習現況。

Under the context of the 12-year Basic Education Curriculum Guidelines (12-year BECG), it becomes an important topic to construct students' autonomous learning to align with the literacy-oriented philosophy of Taiwan's 108 New Curriculum. Constructing an autonomous learning indicator framework is an important foundation to develop and assess students' autonomous learning literacy. Thus, this study aims to construct an autonomous learning indicator framework with multilevel, and dimensions to assess the current situation in autonomous learning of vocational high school students. First, the study conducted literature review to construct the structure of autonomous learning. Then, the study applied the KJ method to classify and organize the level of the initial index. After three rounds of the KJ method, the study developed the primary autonomous learning indicator framework with 4 levels, 15 dimensions, and 157 indexes. The primary autonomous learning indicator framework was refined by 14 experts through the Modified Delphi Technique. The expert survey was conducted to collect data and verify the consistency. After the indexes, dimensions, and levels of the autonomous learning indicator framework were completed, a total of 1,347 vocational high school students in Taiwan were invited to participate in the survey. The survey results shows good validity and reliability, which indicates that the autonomous learning indicator framework can be used to assess students' autonomous learning in vocational high school. This framework can serve as reference for educational administrators, teachers, and students to assess autonomous learning.

1. 林吟霞(2018)。運用德國─工作站學習法促進學生自主學習的教學策略。課程與教學，21(2)，1-32。
   連結：
2. 林家興,黃佩娟(2013)。臺灣諮商心理師能力指標建構之共識研究。教育心理學報，44(3)，735-750。
   連結：
3. 林堂馨(2018)。以自主學習為主的大學能力本位課程設計及實施。課程與教學，21(2)，59-84。
   連結：
4. 邱秀香(2018)。自主學習與大學通識教育制度規劃。實踐博雅學報，27，19-37。
   連結：
5. 高寶玉,徐慧璇(2018)。自主學習課堂實踐之張力：香港個案研究。課程與教學，21(2)，33-58。
   連結：
6. 謝易霖(2019)。與英雄同行：自主學習取向課程實踐之教師反思。課程與教學，22(2)，145-172。
   連結：
7. Ackerman, R.,Thompson, V. A.(2017).Meta-reasoning: Monitoring and control of thinking and reasoning.Trends in Cognitive Sciences,21(8),607.
8. Bernard, V. L.,Thomas, J. K.(1990).Evidence that stock prices do not fully reflect the implications of current earnings for future earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,13,305-340.
9. Biemiller, A.,Meichenbaum, D.(1992).The nature and nurture of the self-directed learner.Educational Leadership,50(2),75-80.
10. Bii, P.(2013).Chatbot technology: A possible means of unlocking student potential to learn how to learn.Educational Research,4(2),218-221.
11. Boud, D.(2012).Developing student autonomy in learning.Routledge.
12. Brockett, R. G.,Hiemstra, R.(2018).Self-direction in adult learning: Perspectives on theory, research, and practice.Routledge.
13. Caceres, A.,Hall, D. L.,Zelaya, F. O.,Williams, S. C.,Mehta, M. A.(2009).Measuring fMRI reliability with the intra-class correlation coefficient.Neuroimage,45(3),758-768.
14. Candy, P. C.(2004).Linking thinking: Self-directed learning in the digital age.Department of Education, Science and Training=DEST.
15. Cheng, S. F.,Kuo, C. L.,Lin, K. C.,Lee-Hsieh, J.(2010).Development and preliminary testing of a self-rating instrument to measure self-directed learning ability of nursing students.International Journal of Nursing Studies,47(9),1152-1158.
16. Christie, C. A.,Barela, E.(2005).The Delphi technique as a method for increasing inclusion in the evaluation process.The Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation,20(1),105.
17. Dawes, J.(2008).Do data characteristics change according to the number of scale points used? An experiment using 5-point, 7-point and 10-point scales.International Journal of Market Research,50(1),61-104.
18. Dewey, J.(1966).Democracy and education (1916).The Middle Works,9,4-58.
19. Fisher, M. J.,King, J.(2010).The self-directed learning readiness scale for nursing education revisited: A confirmatory factor analysis.Nurse Education Today,30(1),44-48.
20. Garrison, D. R.(1997).Self-directed learning: Toward a comprehensive model.Adult Education Quarterly,48(1),18-33.
21. Grow, G.(1994).In defense of the staged self-directed learning model.Adult Education Quarterly,44(2),109-114.
22. Guglielmino, L. M.(1989).Reactions to Field's investigation into the SDLRS: Guglielmino responds to Field’s investigation.Adult Education Quarterly,39(4),235-240.
23. Hair, J. F.,Hollingsworth, C. L.,Randolph, A. B.,Chong, A. Y. L.(2016).An updated and expanded assessment of PLS-SEM in information systems research.Industrial Management & Data Systems,117(3),442-458.
24. Hair, J. F.,Hult, G. T. M.,Ringle, C. M.,Sarstedt, M.(2017).A primer on partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM).Sage.
25. Hakim, S.,Weinblatt, J.(1993).The Delphi process as a tool for decision making: The case of vocational training of people with handicaps.Evaluation and Program Planning,16(1),25-38.
26. Holden, M. C.,Wedman, J. F.(1993).Future issues of computer-mediated communication: The results of a Delphi study.Educational Technology Research and Development,41(4),5-24.
27. Holec, H.(1981).Autonomy and foreign language learning.Pergamon.
28. Holland, R. W.,Aarts, H.,Langendam, D.(2006).Breaking and creating habits on the working floor: A field-experiment on the power of implementation intentions.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,42(6),776-783.
29. Jairath, N.,Weinstein, J.(1994).The Delphi methodology (Part Two): A useful administrative approach.Canadian Journal of Nursing Administration,7(4),7-20.
30. Jansen, R. S.,Van Leeuwen, A.,Janssen, J.,Jak, S.,Kester, L.(2019).Self-regulated learning partially mediates the effect of self-regulated learning interventions on achievement in higher education: A meta-analysis.Educational Research Review,28,100292.
31. Keetch, K. M.,Schmidt, R. A.,Lee, T. D.,Young, D. E.(2005).Especial skills: their emergence with massive amounts of practice.Journal of Experimental Psychology,31(5),970.
32. Knowles, M.(1975).Self-directed learning: A guide for learners and teachers.Association Press.
33. Leake, D. B.,Ram, A.(1995).Learning, goals, and learning goals: A perspective on goal-driven learning.Artificial Intelligence Review,9(6),387-422.
34. Leibenstein, H.,Maital, S.(1992).Empirical estimation and partitioning of X-inefficiency: a data-envelopment approach.The American Economic Review,82(2),428-433.
35. Little, D.(2009).Language learner autonomy and the European language portfolio: Two L2 English examples.Language Teaching,42(2),222-233.
36. Lofstrom, E.,Nevgi, A.(2007).From strategic planning to meaningful learning: diverse perspectives on the development of web-based teaching and learning in higher education.British Journal of Educational Technology,38(2),312-324.
37. Long, H. B.(2000).Understanding self-direction in learning.Practice & theory in self-directed learning
38. Long, H. B.(1989).Self-directed learning: Emerging theory & practice.Norman, OK:Oklahoma Research Center for Continuing Professional and Higher Education.
39. Lumsden, L.(1999).Student motivation: Cultivating a love of learning.ERIC Clearinghouse on Educational Management.
40. Mcgraw, K. O.,Wong, S. P.(1996).Forming inferences about some intraclass correlation coefficients.Psychological Methods,1(4),390-390.
41. Michalski, R. S.,Ram, A.(1994).Learning as goal-driven inference.MIT Press.
42. Montin, L.,Koivisto, J. M.(2014).Effectiveness of self-directed learning methods compared with other learning methods in nursing education related to nursing students’ or registered nurses’ learning outcomes: a systematic review protocol.JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports,12(2),1-8.
43. Morrow, L. M.,Sharkey, E.,Firestone, W. A.(1993).,National Reading Research Center.
44. Pilling-Cormick, J.,Garrison, D. R.(2007).Self-directed and self-regulated learning: Conceptual links.Canadian Journal of University Continuing Education,33(2),13-33.
45. Radhakrishnan, J.,Ontañón, S.,Ram, A.(2009).Goal-driven learning in the GILA integrated intelligence architecture.proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI),2009(9),1205-1210.
46. Ram, A.,Cox, M. T.,Narayanan, S.(1995).Goal-driven learning in multistrategy reasoning and learning systems.Goal-driven learning
47. Rojewski, J. W.,Meers, G. D.(1991).Rojewski, J. W. & Meers, G. D. (1991). Directions for future research in vocational special needs education. University of Illinois, Campus Research Board..
48. Sangsawang, T.(2020).An instructional design for online learning in vocational education according to a self-regulated learning framework for problem solving during the COVID-19 crisis.Indonesian Journal of Science and Technology,5(2),283-198.
49. Satty, T. L.(1980).The analytic hierarchy process.McGraw Hill.
50. Satty, T. L.(2003).Decision making with the AHP: Why is the principal eigenvector necessary.European Journal of Operational Research,145,85-91.
51. Shen, W. Q.,Chen, H. L.,Hu, Y.(2014).The validity and reliability of the self-directed learning instrument (SDLI) in mainland Chinese nursing students.BMC Medical Education,14(1),1-7.
52. Shrout, P. E.,Fleiss, J. L.(1979).Intraclass correlations: Uses in assessing rater reliability.Psychological Bulletin,86(2),420-447.
53. Singer, R. N.(1988).Strategies and meta-strategies in learning and performing self-paced athletic skills.The Sport Psychologist,2(1),49-68.
54. Sperling, R. A.,Howard, B. C.,Staley, R.,DuBois, N.(2004).Metacognition and self-regulated learning constructs.Educational Research and Evaluation,10(2),117-139.
55. Stockdale, S.,Brockett, R.(2011).Development of the PRO-SDLS: A measure of self-directed learning based on the personality responsibility orientation model.Adult Education Quarterly,61(2),161-180.
56. Sweller, J.(2016).Working memory, long-term memory, and instructional design.Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition,5(4),360-367.
57. Teknomo, K.(2006).Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) tutorial.Revoledu.com,6(4),1-20.
58. Theeuwes, J.(2019).Goal-driven, stimulus-driven, and history-driven selection.Current Opinion in Psychology,29,97-101.
59. Tough, A.(1971).The adult’s learning projects: A fresh approach to theory and practice in adult learning.Ontario Institute for Studies in Education.
60. Tsuda, M.,Elbo, R. A.(2001).Japan’s official development assistance: Issues and challenges in Asia.Panorama,3(2),5-28.
61. Van Rensburg, G. H.,Botma, Y.(2015).Bridging the gap between self-directed learning of nurse educators and effective student support.Curationis,38(2),1-7.
62. Wiggins, G.,McTighe, J.(1998).What is backward design.Understanding by Design,1,7-19.
63. Williams, B.,Brown, T.(2013).A confirmatory factor analysis of the self-directed learning readiness scale.Nursing and Health Sciences,15(4),430-436.
64. Wolters, C.(2010).,University of Houston, Department of Educational Psychology.
65. Yuan, H. B.,Williams, B. A.,Fang, J. B.,Pang, D.(2012).Chinese baccalaureate nursing students’ readiness for self-directed learning.Nurse Education Today,32(4),427-431.
66. Zimmerman, B. J.(2002).Becoming a self-regulated learner: An overview.Theory into Practice,41(2),64-70.
67. Zimmerman, B. J.,Kitsantas, A.(1996).Self-regulated learning of a motoric skill: The role of goal setting and self-monitoring.Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,8(1),60-75.
68. Zimmerman, B. J.,Martinez-Pons, M.(1990).Student differences in self-regulated learning: Relating grade, sex, and giftedness to self-efficacy and strategy use.Journal of Educational Psychology,82(1),51.
69. 川田喜二郎(1986)。KJ 法─渾混談。中央公論社。
70. 中華民國成人教育學會（編）(1996).終生學習與教育改革.師大書苑.
71. 王俊斌(2018)。網紅世代的自主學習：在展現自我與智慧學習之間。教育研究月刊，296，31-46。
72. 田慧,陳美如(2020)。自主學習的理念與教學設計。教育研究月刊，309，41-58。
73. 吳炯憲(2006)。新北，樹德科技大學。
74. 吳清山(2017)。自主學習。教育研究月刊，278，133-134。
75. 宋文娟(2001)。一種質量並重的研究法─德菲法在醫務管理學研究領域之應用。醫務管理期刊，2(2)，11-20。
76. 宋修德,李懿芳,林清南(2021)。技術型高級中等學校自主學習的理念與實踐。臺灣教育評論月刊，10(2)，133-141。
77. 李隆盛(1999)。能力分析與堪蝶法（DACUM）法。職場導向能力及課程發展研討會
78. 周曉丹(2018)。臺中，朝陽科技大學。
79. 林水見(2012)。高職如何推動生涯輔導。商業職業教育，126，21-28。
80. 林清山(1992).心理與教育統計學.東華書局.
81. 洪詠善,盧秋珍(2017)。國中理解與實踐自主學習之案例探究。教育研究月刊，27，30-45。
82. 張紹勳(2012).模糊多準則評估法及統計.五南出版.
83. 許全守(1999)。目標導向教學之探討。技術及職業教育雙月刊，54，48-55。
84. 許良仲(2010)。臺中，朝陽科技大學。
85. 游玉英(2020)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學。
86. 游家政(1996)。德懷術及其在課程研究上的應用。花蓮師院學報，6，1-24。
87. 楊世承(2016)。高齡者參與木球運動自主學習團體動機、特徵與困境之研究：以雲林縣元長鄉五塊村社區為例。成人及終身教育學刊，27(12)，37-79。
88. 楊欣淳,葛建培,楊欣于(2017)。高中職餐旅學生證照考試自主學習策略之探討。建國科大社會人文期刊，36(2)，33-48。
89. 劉湘川,簡茂發(1993)。脊估計法在徑路分析上之應用。初等教育研究集刊，1，21-32。
90. 瞿海源,鐘蔚文(2001)。臺北市政府委託中央研究院研究臺北市政府委託中央研究院研究,臺北市政府社會局。
91. 簡菲莉,陳佩英(2020)。探究高中自主學習課程化之學習者視角。教育研究月刊，309，24-40。