Causes and Consequences of Firms' Decision to Discontinue Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosure in Earnings Releases

公司自願性停止在盈餘宣告中提供擬制性盈餘的原因與經濟後果之研究

10.6552/JOAR.2016.63.1

李艷榕(Yen-Jung Lee)；朱承平(Cheng-Ping Chu)

擬制性盈餘 ； 策略性揭露 ； 盈餘管理 ； Non-GAAP (Pro-forma) earnings ； Regulation G ； Strategic disclosures ； Earnings management

會計評論

63期（2016 / 07 / 01）

1 - 46

英文

本文旨在探討為何有些公司自願停止在盈餘宣告中提供擬制性盈餘資訊，並研究此一選擇如何影響這些公司後續的財務報導政策。我們以人工收集資料的方式收集2002-2010 年間樣本公司在盈餘宣告中所揭露的擬制性盈餘資訊。我們發現有近五分之一的樣本公司在我們的樣本期間(2002-2010)內，停止了在盈餘宣告中提供擬制性盈餘資訊。由於美國證管會在2001 年12 月起加強對擬制性盈餘揭露的監管，並且實施Regulation G 要求公司提高擬制性盈餘揭露的透明度，我們發現在美國證管會加強對擬制性盈餘揭露的監管之前，公司若提供擬制性盈餘資訊試圖誤導投資人或公司只從提供擬制性盈餘資訊獲得有限的好處，則這些公司較可能在我們的樣本期間停止在盈餘宣告中提供擬制性盈餘資訊，顯示在美國證管會加強對擬制性盈餘揭露的監管後，提供擬制性盈餘資訊的成本提高而獲得的好處減少。此外，若公司曾收到美國證管會質疑該公司擬制性盈餘的意見函，則這樣的公司也比較可能停止在盈餘宣告中提供擬制性盈餘資訊。本文也發現若公司比較可能投機性的提供擬制性盈餘，則在停止提供擬制性盈餘資訊後，公司會使用盈餘管理取代提供擬制性盈餘資訊，但投資人察覺到這些公司可能在停止提供擬制性盈餘資訊後增加盈餘操縱使盈餘品質變差，因此在停止提供擬制性盈餘資訊後投資人給予這些公司的未預期盈餘較低的評價。

This paper investigates why firms voluntarily stop providing non-GAAP earnings disclosure in their earnings releases (hereafter, stopped firms) and whether this decision affects their subsequent financial reporting policies. Using hand-collected non-GAAP earnings disclosure data between 2002 and 2010, we observe that about one-fifth of our sample firms stopped non-GAAP earnings reporting altogether during our sample period. Consistent with the idea that the SEC’s increased scrutiny and the transparency of non-GAAP disclosure required by Regulation G increase the costs and decrease the benefits of non-GAAP reporting, we find that firms issuing non-GAAP disclosure to mislead investors and firms deriving fewer benefits from non-GAAP reporting are more likely to relinquish non-GAAP disclosure. Moreover, firms receiving the SEC’s comment letters questioning their use of non-GAAP financial measures in SEC filings are more inclined to stop providing non-GAAP disclosure in earnings releases. Furthermore, we find that stopped firms that are more likely to be opportunistic non-GAAP reporters tend to substitute accrual management for non-GAAP disclosure after they stop non-GAAP reporting. Interestingly, investors react less strongly to unexpected earnings of these firms after they stopped disclosing non-GAAP information, consistent with the market perceiving earnings news of opportunistic reporting firms as less informative after their stop decision.

1. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). 2001. Cautionary advice regarding the use of "pro forma" financial information in earnings releases. Available at: https://www.sec.gov/rules/other/33-8039.htm. Accessed: April 24, 2012.
2. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). 2002. SEC brings first pro forma financial reporting case—Trump Hotels charged with issuing misleading earnings release. Available at: https://www.sec.gov/news/headlines/trumphotels.htm. Accessed: April 24, 2012.
3. Henry, D. 2001. Companies use every trick to pump earnings and fool investors. The latest abuse: Pro forma reporting. Available at: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2001-05-13/the-numbers-game. Accessed: April 24, 2012.
4. Taub, S. 2001. Money managers say pro forma results are useful. Available at: http://ww2.cfo.com/2001/11/money-managers-say-pro-forma-results-are-useful/. Accessed: April 24, 2012.
5. National Investor Relations Institute (NIRI). 2001. Earnings press release guidance Available at: http://www.niri.org/members/ProFormaGuidelines.html. Accessed: April 24, 2012.
6. Levitt, A. 1998. The numbers game. Available at: https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/speecharchive/1998/spch220.txt. Accessed: April 24, 2012.
7. Black, E. L., T. E. Christensen, T. T. Joo, and R. Schmardebeck. 2014. The relation between earnings management and pro forma reporting. Working paper, University of Oklaahoma, University of Georgia, New Mexico State University and University of Missouri at Columbia. (DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.2259379)
8. Barton, J.,Simko, P. J.(2002).The balance sheet as an earnings management constraint.The Accounting Review,77(Supplement),1-27.
9. Bartov, E.,Givoly, D.,Hayn, C.(2002).The rewards to meeting or beating earnings expectations.Journal of Accounting and Economics,33,173-204.
10. Bergstresser, D.,Philippon, T.(2006).CEO incentives and earnings management.Journal of Financial Economics,80,511-529.
11. Bhattacharya, N.,Black, E. L.,Christensen, T. E.,Larson, C. R.(2003).Assessing the relative informativeness and permanence of pro forma earnings and GAAP operating earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,36,285-319.
12. Bhattacharya, N.,Black, E. L.,Christensen, T. E.,Mergenthaler, R. D.(2004).Empirical evidence on recent trends in pro forma reporting.Accounting Horizons,18,27-43.
13. Black, D. E.,Black, E. L.,Christensen, T. E.,Heninger, W. G.(2012).Has the regulation of pro forma reporting in the US changed investors' perceptions of pro forma earnings disclosures?.Journal of Business Finance & Accounting,39,876-904.
14. Black, D. E.,Christensen, T. E.(2009).U.S. managers' use of "pro forma" adjustments to meet strategic earnings targets.Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,36,297-326.
15. Bowen, R. M.,Davis, A. K.,Matsumoto, D. A.(2005).Emphasis on pro forma versus GAAP earnings in quarterly press releases: Determinants, SEC intervention, and market reactions.The Accounting Review,80,1011-1038.
16. Cheng, Q.,Warfield, T. D.(2005).Equity incentives and earnings management.The Accounting Review,80,441-476.
17. Cohen, D. A.,Dey, A.,Lys, T. Z.(2008).Real and accrual based earnings management in the pre and post Sarbanes-Oxley periods.The Accounting Review,83,757-787.
18. Cohen, D. A.,Zarowin, P.(2010).Accrual-based and real earnings management activities around seasoned equity offerings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,50,2-19.
19. Core, J.,Guay, W.(2002).Estimating the value of employee stock option portfolios and their sensitivities to price and volatility.Journal of Accounting Research,40,613-630.
20. Curtis, A.,McVay, S. E.,Whipple, B. C.(2014).The disclosure of non-GAAP earnings information in the presence of transitory gains.The Accounting Review,89,933-958.
21. Dechow, P. M.,Dichev, I. D.(2002).The quality of accruals and earnings: The role of accrual estimation errors.The Accounting Review,77(s-1),35-59.
22. Dechow, P. M.,Sloan, R. G.(1995).Detecting earnings management.The Accounting Review,70,193-225.
23. Deloitte(2010).SECeason's Greetings! Highlights of the 2010 AICPA national conference on current SEC and PCAOB developments.Deloitte Heads Up,17(43),1-51.
24. Doyle, J. T.,Jennings, J. N.,Soliman, M. T.(2013).Do manager define non-GAAP earnings to meet or beat analyst forecasts?.Journal of Accounting and Economics,56,40-56.
25. Doyle, J. T.,Lundholm, R. J.,Soliman, M. T.(2003).The predictive value of expenses excluded from pro forma earnings.Review of Accounting Studies,8,145-174.
26. Elliott, J. A.,Hanna, J. D.(1996).Repeated accounting write-offs and the information content of earnings. 1996.Journal of Accounting Research,34(Supplement),135-155.
27. Entwistle, G. M.,Feltham, G. D.,Mbagwu, C.(2006).Financial reporting regulation and reporting of pro forma earnings.Accounting Horizons,20,39-55.
28. Fama, E. F.,French, K. R.(1997).Industry costs of equity.Journal of Financial Economics,43,153-193.
29. Frankel, R.,McVay, S.,Soliman, M.(2011).Non-GAAP earnings and board independence.Review of Accounting Studies,16,719-744.
30. Gompers, P.,Ishii, J.,Metrick, A.(2003).Corporate governance and equity prices.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,118,107-156.
31. Guay, W. R.(1999).The sensitivity of CEO wealth to equity risk: An analysis of the magnitude and determinants.Journal of Financial Economics,53,43-71.
32. Healy, P. M.(1985).The effect of bonus schemes on accounting decisions.Journal of Accounting and Economics,7,85-107.
33. Heflin, F.,Hsu, C.(2008).The impact of the SEC's regulation of non-GAAP disclosures.Journal of Accounting and Economics,46,349-365.
34. Jennings, R.,Marques, A.(2011).The joint effect of corporate governance and regulation on the disclosure of manager-adjusted non-GAAP earnings in the U.S..Journal of Business Finance &Accounting,38,364-394.
35. Johnson, S.(2010).CFOs are dismayed and discouraged by the SEC's approach to non-GAAP reporting.CFO Magazine,26,27-29.
36. Jones, J. J.(1991).Earnings management during import relief investigation.Journal of Accounting Research,29,193-228.
37. Karpoff, J. M.,Lee, D. S.,Martin, G. S.(2008).The cost to firms of cooking the books.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,43,581-611.
38. Kasznik, R.,McNichols, M. F.(2002).Does meeting earnings expectations matter? Evidence from analyst forecast revisions and share prices.Journal of Accounting Research,40,727-759.
39. Kolev, K.,Marquardt, C. A.,McVay, S. E.(2008).SEC secrutiny and the evolution of non-GAAP reporting.The Accounting Review,83,157-184.
40. Kothari, S. P.,Leone, A. J.,Wasley, C. E.(2005).Performance matched discretionary accrual measures.Journal of Accounting and Economics,39,163-197.
41. Lev, B.,Zarowin, P.(1999).The boundaries of financial reporting and how to extend them.Journal of Accounting Research,37,353-385.
42. Lougee, B. A.,Marquardt, C. A.(2004).Earnings informativeness and strategic disclosure: An empirical examination of "pro forma" earnings.The Accounting Review,79,769-795.
43. Marques, A.(2006).SEC interventions and the frequency and usefulness of non-GAAP financial measures.Review of Accounting Studies,11,549-574.
44. McNichols, M. F.(2002).Discussion of the quality of accruals and earnings: The role of accrual estimation errors.The Accounting Review,77(Supplement),61-69.
45. Palepu, K. G.(1986).Predicting takeover targets: A methodological and empirical analysis.Journal of Accounting and Economics,8,3-35.
46. Petersen, M. A.(2009).Estimating standard errors in finance panel data sets: Comparing approaches.The Review of Financial Studies,22,435-480.
47. Roychowdhury, S.(2006).Earnings management through real activities manipulation.Journal of Accounting and Economics,42,335-370.
48. Yi, Han(2012).Has regulation G improved the information quality of non-GAAP earnings disclosures?.Seoul Journal of Business,18,95-145.
49. Zang, A. Y.(2012).Evidence on the trade-off between real activities manipulation and accrual-based earnings management.The Accounting Review,87,675-703.
50. Zhang, H.,Zheng, L.(2011).The valuation impact of reconciling pro forma earnings to GAAP earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,51,186-202.

1. 羅勝議,劉啟群,林家瑜,尤琳蕙(2019)。Using Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosures to Meet or Beat Analyst Forecasts: Evidence since the Passage of Regulation G。會計審計論叢，9(2)，55-81。