题名

析探初任高考公務人員的工作責任、工作生活平衡及人際關係滿意度之影響

并列篇名

Exploring the Impact of Work Responsibilities and Work-Life Balance on the Satisfaction of Interpersonal Relationships of Newly-Recruited Senior Civil Servants

DOI

10.6166/TJPS.202203_(91).0003

作者

謝儲鍵(Chu-chien Hsieh)；陳敦源(Don-yun Chen)

关键词

初任高考公務人員 ； 工作責任 ； 工作生活平衡 ； 人際關係滿意度 ； Newly-recruited Senior Civil Servants ； Work Responsibility ； Work-life Balance ； Satisfaction of Interpersonal Relationships

期刊名称

政治科學論叢

卷期/出版年月

91期（2022 / 03 / 01）

页次

85 - 130

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

近年，公務人員的服務動機、績效表現與離職（調職）問題成爲組織管理的核心議題。尤其，在公職考試的報考人數逐年下降的情況下，行政機關面臨到組織留才的挑戰。然而，雖然許多研究已明確指出工作責任會影響工作滿意度的認知，而工作生活平衡與人際關係分別是工作責任及工作滿意度的重要組成因子，但卻較少研究將此變數單獨進行分析。因此，本文欲以「公務人員高等考試三級考試」（以下簡稱：高考）之初任文官作爲調查對象，探討工作責任認知及工作生活平衡態度對於人際關係滿意度的影響情況程度。此次調查資料採用「『爲官之道』：臺灣新進公務人員生涯長期追蹤調查研究（臺灣文官調查VII，2019-2022，第二期）」爲分析來源，共蒐集了216位通過2019年高考三級的新進公務人員，透過問卷調查方式探討工作責任、工作生活平衡及人際關係滿意度之相互影響。本研究資料處理之特別處在於：一、使用當年通過高考之初任公務人員爲研究樣本；二、有別於過去大多將工作滿意度作爲依變數，本文改以人際關係滿意度作爲結果變數；三、結合工作責任與工作生活平衡分析與人際關係滿意度之差異性。研究發現則有以下三點：一、初任公務人員若過度超時加班或身體健康狀態不佳會降低與主管及同事的人際關係滿意度，若需要承擔照顧（未成年）子女的家庭責任也會造成工作與生活的失衡；二、初任公務人員愈能在工作與生活取得平衡，則愈能提升主管與同事的人際關係滿意度；三、初任公務人員在工作責任上愈重視組織內部規範及個人自主性，則會降低與主管及同事關係的滿意度，而工作生活平衡在兩者間不具有中介效果。
英文摘要

Over the past couple of years, the issues of work performance and resignation (transfer) among civil servants have been addressed in the organizational management research on attracting and retaining talent. However, there are few studies discussing work cognition, attitudes and observations of the newcomers employed through the senior civil service examination. Hence, this research aims to analyze the impact that work responsibilities and work-life balance have on interpersonal relationships, and their correlations, based on the data collected from the Taiwanese Government Bureaucrat Survey VII (2019-2022). The differences of this study compared to past research include: (1) we conducted the first survey given to beginning civil servants; (2) we employed satisfaction of interpersonal relationships as the dependent variable instead of work satisfaction; (3) we combined elements of work responsibility and work-life balance for the independent and mediating variables. The major findings show that: (1) conditions of overworking and decreased physical health have a negative effect on the satisfaction of interpersonal relationships, and the responsibility of child care has shown a negative effect on work-life balance; (2) a higher cognition of work-life imbalance has a negative effect on the satisfaction of interpersonal relationships; (3) the work responsibilities of internal organizational norms and autonomy have partial negative effects on satisfaction of interpersonal relationships with supervisors and colleagues, and the mediating effect of work-life balance shows a non-significant influence.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會科學綜合
参考文献
  1. 吳宗憲, Chuang-hsien(2012)。台南市政府文官公共服務動機與工作滿意、工作努力意願之實證研究－以個人／組織配適度作為調節變項。公共行政學報，43，91-126。
    連結：
  2. 張鎧如, Kai-ju,陳敦源, Don-yun,簡鈺珒, Yu-ching,李仲彬, Chun-ping(2015)。探索臺灣公務人員工作績效之影響因素：能力、動機與機會的整合觀點。東吳政治學報，33(4)，1-71。
    連結：
  3. 游子正, Tzu-cheng,董祥開, Hsiang-kai(2020)。公務人員「單位離職傾向」之影響因素分析。文官制度季刊，12(3)，45-86。
    連結：
  4. 黃朝盟, Chao-meng,嚴秀娟, Hsiu-chuan(2018)。公共行政教育是否造就出更好的公務人員？準公務人員的工作信心與公共服務動機。文官制度季刊，10(3)，55-84。
    連結：
  5. 黃煥榮, Huan-iung(2021)。員工幸福感的意涵與影響因素之探討。文官制度季刊，13(1)，67-103。
    連結：
  6. 董祥開, Hsiang-kai,林嚴凡, Yen-fan(2019)。公私部門轉換經驗對工作滿意度之影響：以公私部門工作差異認知為中介變項。行政暨政策學報，68，1-4。
    連結：
  7. 潘瑛如, Ying-ju,李隆盛, Lung-shen(2015)。初薦任公務人員公共服務動機及其前因之探究。文官制度季刊，7(1)，35-69。
    連結：
  8. 簡忠仁, Chung-jen,黃敏萍, Min-ping,鄭伯壎, Bor-shiuan,林良軒, Liang-hsuan(2019)。上下只會交征賊嗎？領導者與部屬的私交關係如何增進組織效益。管理學報，36(2)，195-223。
    連結：
  9. 職涯Career學習網，2009，〈性格，決定職場命運〉，Career學習網網頁，http://learning.career.com.tw/learning/userplane/paper_display.asp?ap_id=35。2021/7/23。Career Learning. 2009. “Xingge, jueding zhichang mingyun” [The Personality Determines the Fate of the Workplace]. in http://learning.career.com.tw/learning/userplane/paper_display.asp?ap_id=35. Latest update 23 July 2021.
  10. 考選統計年報，2020，〈公務人員考試暨檢覈報考人數表〉，考試院網頁，https://wwwc.moex.gov.tw/main/content/wHandMenuFile.ashx?file_id=2163，2020/5/14。The Aunnal Report of Ministry of Examination. 2020. “Gongwurenyuan kaoshi ji jianhe baokaorenshu biao” [The Table on Numbers of Applicants for Civil Service Examinations]. in https://wwwc.moex.gov.tw/main/content/wHandMenuFile.ashx?file_id=2163. Latest update 14 May 2020.
  11. Allen, T. D.(2001).Family-Supportive Work Environments: The Role of Organizational Perceptions.Journal of Vocational Behavior,58(3),414-435.
  12. Anderson, E. S.,Coffey, S. B.,Byerly, T. R.(2002).Formal Organizational Initiatives and Informal Workplace Practices: Links to Work-Family Conflict and Job-Related Outcomes.Journal of Management,28(6),787-810.
  13. Ashforth, B. E.,Humphrey, R. H.(1993).Emotional Labor in Service Roles: The Influence of Identity.Academy of Management Review,18(1),88-115.
  14. Babatunde, A.,Mordi, C.,Simpson, R.,Adisa, T.,Oruh, E.(2020).Time Biases: Exploring the Work-Life Balance of Single Nigeria Managers and Professionals.Journal of Managerial Psychology,35(2),57-70.
  15. Baltes, B. B.,Briggs, T. E.,Huff, J. W.,Wright, J. A.,Neuman, G. A.(1999).Flexible and Compressed Workweek Schedules: A Meta-Analysis of Their Effects on Work-Related Criteria.Journal of Applied Psychology,84(4),496-513.
  16. Barker, R. G.(1968).Ecological Psychology: Concepts and Methods for Studying the Environment of Human Behavior.Stanford:Stanford University Press.
  17. Bastien, D. T.(1987).Common Patterns of Behavior and Communication in Corporate Mergers and Acquisitions.Human Resource Management,26(1),17-33.
  18. Blustein, D. L.(2011).A Relational Theory of Working.Journal of Vocational Behavior,79(1),1-17.
  19. Career職場情報，2017，〈鐵飯碗跟你想的不一樣〉，臺北市就業服務處網頁，https://www.okwork.taipei/ESO/content/tw/Article/161117075814/170420101920，2017/4/20。Career, 2017. “Tiefanwan genni xiangde buyiyang” [The Iron Rice Bowl Is Not What You Think]. in https://www.okwork.taipei/ESO/content/tw/Article/161117075814/170420101920. Latest update 20 April 2017.
  20. Carnevale, G. D.,Wechsler, B.(1992).Trust in the Public Sector: Individual and Organizational Determinants.Administration and Society,23(4),471-494.
  21. Chen, C. A.,Chen, D. Y.,Liao, Z. P.,Kuo, M. F.(2020).Winnowing Out High-PSM Candidates: The Adverse Selection Effect of Competitive Public Service Exams.International Public Management Journal,23(4),443-464.
  22. Clark, S. C.(2001).Work Cultures and Work/Family Balance.Journal of Vocational Behavior,58,348-365.
  23. Cooper, Phillip J.(ed.),Newland, Chester A.(ed.)(1997).Handbook of Public Law and Administration.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  24. Dansereau, F.,Graen, G.,Haga, W. J.(1975).A Vertical Dyad Linkage Approach to Leadership within Formal Organizations: A Longitudinal Investigation of the Role Making Process.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,13(1),46-78.
  25. Deluga, R. J.(1994).Supervisor Trust Building, Leader-Member Exchange & Organizational Citizenship Behavior.Occupational and Organizational Psychology,67(4),315-326.
  26. Desrochers, S.,Hilton, J. M.,Larwood, L.(2005).Preliminary Validation of the Work-Family Integration-Blurring Scale.Journal of Family Issues,26(4),442-466.
  27. Dex, S.,Bond, S.(2005).Measuring Work-Life Balance and Its Covariates.Work, Employment and Society,19(3),627-637.
  28. Evans, W. R.,Davis, W. D.,Frink, D. D.(2011).An Examination of Employee Reactions to Perceived Corporate Citizenship.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,41,938-964.
  29. Feuille, P.,Chachere, D. R.(1995).Looking Fair or Being Fair: Remedial Voice Procedures in Nonunion Workplaces.Journal of Management,21(1),27-42.
  30. Fiske, A. P.(1991).Structures of Social Life. The Four Elementary Forms of Human Relations.New York:Free Press.
  31. Font, J.(1997).Quality Measurement in Spanish Municipalities: Transferring Private Sector Experiences.Public Productivity and Management Review,21(1),44-55.
  32. George, B.,Pandey, S. K.(2017).We Know the Yin-But Where is the Yang? Toward a Balanced Approach on Common Source Bias in Public Administration Scholarship.Review of Public Personnel Administration,37(2),245-270.
  33. Goldberg, D. P.,Hillier, V. F.(1979).A Scaled Version of the General Health Questionnaire.Psychological Medicine,9(1),139-145.
  34. Golembiewski, R. T.,McConkie, M.(1975).The Centrality of Interpersonal Trust in Group Processes.New York:Wiley.
  35. Greenberg, L. S.(2012).Emotions, the Great Captains of Our Lives: Their Role in the Process of Change in Psychotherapy.American Psychologist,67(8),697-707.
  36. Greenhaus, J.,Beutell, J. N.(1985).Source of Conflict Between Work and Family Roles.The Academy of Management Review,10(1),76-88.
  37. Gross, J. J.,John, O. P.(2003).Individual Differences in Two Emotion Regulation Process: Implications for Affect, Regulationships, and Well-Being.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,85(2),348-362.
  38. Guo, Y.,Rammal, H. G.,Benson, J.,Zhu, Y.,Dowling, P. J.(2018).Interpersonal Relations in China: Expatriates’ Perspective on the Development and Use of Guanxi.International Business Review,27(2),455-464.
  39. Han, Y.,Perry, J. L.(2020).Employee Accountability: Development of A Multidimensional Scale.International Public Management Journal,23(2),224-251.
  40. Harris, K. J.,Harris, R. B.,Brouer, R. L.(2009).LMX and Subordinate Political Skill: 50 Direct and Interactive Effects on Turnover Intentions and Job Satisfaction.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,39(10),2373-2395.
  41. Higgins, C. A.,Duxbury, L. E.,Irving, R. H.(1992).Work-Family Conflict in the Dual-Career Family.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,51(1),51-75.
  42. Hofstede, G.,Hofstede, G. J.(2005).Cultures and Organizations. Software of the Mind.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  43. Houston, D. J.(2000).Public-Service Motivation: A Multivariate Test.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,10(4),713-728.
  44. Indeed. 2021. “Dealing with Interpersonal Conflict at Work.” in https://www.indeed.com/career-advice/career-development/interpersonal-conflict. Latest update 15 July 2021.
  45. Jex, S. M.,Thomas, J. L.(2003).Relations Between Stressors and Group Perceptions: Main and Mediating Effects.Work and Stress,17(2),158-169.
  46. Jiang, H.,Men, R. L.(2015).Creating an Engaged Workforce: The Impact of Authentic Leadership, Transparent Organizational Communication, and Work-Life Enrichment.Communication Research,44(2),225-243.
  47. Jones, G. R.,George, J. M.(1998).The Experience and Evolution of Trust: Implications for Cooperation and Teamwork.The Academy of Management Review,23(3),531-546.
  48. Karasek, R.,Theorell, T.(1990).Healthy Work: Stress, Productivity and The Reconstruction of Working Life.New York:Basic Books.
  49. Kim, J.(2015).What Increase Public Employees’ Turnover Intention?.Public Personnel Management,44(4),496-519.
  50. Kim, S.,Park, S. M.(2014).Determinants of Job Satisfaction and Turnover Intentions of Public Employees: Evidence from US Federal Agencies.International Review of Public Administration,19(1),63-90.
  51. Lu, L.,Chang, Y. Y.,Lai, S. Y. L.(2011).What Differentiates Success from Strain: The Moderating Effects of Self-Efficacy.International Journal of Stress Management,18(4),396-412.
  52. McFarland, L. A.(2004).Work-Family Balance.The Industrial Organizational Psychologist,41(4),47-53.
  53. McPherson, S. 2021. “How Much of Your “Authentic Self”? Should You Really Bring to Work?” in https://www.hbrtaiwan.com/article_content_AR0010442.html. Latest update 18 July 2021.
  54. Milkie, M. A.,Peltola, P.(1999).Playing All the Roles: Gender and the Work-Family Balancing Act.Journal of Marriage and the Family,61(2),476-490.
  55. Mudor, H.(2011).Conceptual Framework on the Relationship Between Human Resource Management Practices, Job Satisfaction, and Turnover.Journal of Economics and Behavioral Studies,2(2),41-49.
  56. Nadler, D. A.(1993).Techniques for the Management of Organization Change.Handbook of Organizational Consultation,New York:
  57. Nappo, N.(2020).Job Stress and Interpersonal Relationships Cross Country Evidence from the EU15: A Correlation Analysis.BMC Public Health,20,1143.
  58. Navajas-Romero, V.,Ariza-Montes, A.,Hernández-Perlines, F.(2020).Analyzing the Job Demands-Control-Support Model in Work-Life Balance: A Study among Nurses in the European Context.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,17(8),2847.
  59. Nohria, Nitin(ed.),Eccles, Robert G.(ed.)(1992).Networks and Organizations: Structure, Form, and Action.Boston:Harvard Business School Press.
  60. Organ, D. W.(1988).Organizational Citizenship Behavior: The Good Soldier Syndrome.Lexington:Lexington.
  61. Organ, D. W.,Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.(2005).Organizational Citizenship Behavior:Its Nature, Antecedents, and Consequences.New York:Sage Publications.
  62. Oskamp, Stuart(ed.),Costanzo, Mark(ed.)(1993).Gender Issues Incontem-Porarys Ociety.Newbury Park:Sage Publication.
  63. Perreault, M.,Power, N.(2021).Work-life Balance as a Personal Responsibility: The Impact on Strategies for Coping with Interrole Conflict.Journal of Occupational Science,1-15.
  64. Pino, O.,Rossini, G.(2012).Perceived Organizational Stressors and Interpersonal Relationships as Predictors of Job Satisfaction and Well-Being among Hospital Nurses.International Journal of Psychology and Behavioral Sciences,2(6),196-207.
  65. Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Lee, J. Y.,Podsakoff, N. P.(2003).Common Method Biases in Behavioral Research: A Critical Review of the Literature and Recommended Remedies.Journal of Applied Psychology,88(5),879-903.
  66. Rusbult, C.,Lowery, D.(1985).When Bureaucrats Get the Blues: Responses to Dissatisfaction among Federal Employees.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,15(1),80-103.
  67. Simoni, P. S.,Paterson, J. J.(1997).Hardiness, Coping and Burnout in the Nursing Workplace.Journal of Professional Nursing,13(3),178-185.
  68. Siu, O. L.,Spector, P. E.,Cooper, C. L.,Lu, C. Q.(2005).Work Stress, Self-Efficacy, Chinese Work Values, and Work Well-Being in Hong Kong and Beijing.International Journal of Stress Management,12(3),274-288.
  69. Somers, M. J.,Birnbaum, D.,Casal, J.(2021).Supervisor Support, Control Over Work Methods and Employee Well-Being: New Insights into Nonlinearity From Artificial Neural Networks.The International Journal of Human Resource Management,32(7),1620-1642.
  70. Sprung, J. M.,Jex, S. M.(2012).Work Locus of Control as a Moderator of the Relationship between Work Stressors and Counterproductive Work Behavior.International Journal of Stress Management,19(4),272-291.
  71. Staw, B. M.,Bell, N. E.,Clausen, J. A.(1986).The Dispositional Approach to Job Attitudes: A Lifetime Longitudinal Test.Administrative Science Quarterly,31(1),56-77.
  72. Teddlie, C.,Tashakkori, A.(2009).Foundations of Mixed Methods Research: Integrating Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches in the Social and Behavioral Sciences.Los Angeles:Sage.
  73. Trivellas, P.,Reklitis, P.,Platis, C.(2013).The Effect of Job Related Stress on Employees’ Satisfaction: A Survey in Health Care.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,73,718-726.
  74. Vignoli, E.,Croity-Belz, S.,Chapeland, V.,de Fillipis, A.,Garcia, M.(2005).Career Exploration in Adolescents: The Role of Anxiety, Attachment, and Parenting Style.Journal of Vocational Behavior,67(2),153-168.
  75. Zerubavel, E.(1996).Lumping and Splitting: Notes on Social Classification.Sociological Forum,11(3),421-433.
  76. 中央社，2011 ，〈過勞死疑超時工作，勞委會檢討〉，勞動部網頁，https://tmsc.osha.gov.tw/news2cont.asp?kk=1562，2021/6/13。Ministry of Labor. 2011. “Guolaosi yi chaoshi gongzuo, laoweihui jiantao” [Suspicion of Overwork]. in https://tmsc.osha.gov.tw/news2cont.asp?kk=1562. Latest update 13 June 2021.
  77. 中央社，2021，〈綠委爆每年1,500公務員離職，鐵飯碗留不住年輕人〉，聯合新聞網網頁，https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202103100167.aspx，2021/6/23。Central News Agency. 2021. “Luwei bao meinian 1500 gongwuyuan lizhi, tiefanwan liubuzhu nianqingren” [The DPP Legislator Claimed that 1500 Public Servants Resigned Every Year Which Caused the Iron Rice Bowl to be Unattactive to Young People]. in https://udn.com/news/story/7314/5308080. Latest update 23 June 2021.
  78. 江岷欽, Min-chin,許道然, Dao-ran(2002)。政府組織公民行為之研究。T&D飛訊，4，1-23。
  79. 李吳澤, Wu-che(2015)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwan，臺北教育大學心理與諮商學研究所=Department of Psychology and Counseling, National Taipei University of Education。
  80. 李選, Sheuan,張婷, Ting(2012)。由落實公務人員核心價值談感動服務。T&D飛訊，145，1-21。
  81. 李選, Sheuan,張婷, Ting(2020)。論公務人員強化情緒平衡機制以提升行政效能與身心健康。T&D飛訊，267，1-26。
  82. 林坤霖, Kuen-iin,楊東岳, Dong-yue(2016)。公務人員組織文化與工作績效關係之研究－以高雄市為例。全球商業經營管理學報，8，125-136。
  83. 許道然, Dao-ran(2003)。公部門組織信任與組織公民行為關係之研究。空大行政學報，13，3-36。
  84. 郭諭陵, Yu-Ling(2006)。教師工作的性別垂直隔離。國立臺北教育大學學報，19(2)，225-254。
  85. 陳韋權, W. C.(2020)。情緒能力發展對職場工作的影響。T&D飛訊，267，1-36。
  86. 陳敦源, Don-yun,蘇孔志, Kung-chih,簡鈺珒, Yu-chin,陳序廷, Shiu-ting(2011)。論資排輩還是工作表現？年資因素對於我國公務人員績效考評影響之研究。文官制度季刊，3(1)，53-91。
  87. 曾執轡，2020，〈去考公務員？人力流動率超乎想像，戳破公職「鐵飯碗」神話〉，聯合新聞網網頁，https://opinion.udn.com/opinion/story/121013/5000415，2021/7/12。Zheng, Jhih-pei. 2020. “Qukao gongwuyuan? renli liudonglu chaohu xiangxiang, chuopo gongzhi tiefanwan shenhua” [Go to Take the Civil Service Exam?]. in https://opinion.udn.com/opinion/story/121013/5000415. Latest update 12 July 2021.
  88. 費孝通，1948，《鄉土中國》，上海：觀察社。Fei, Xiao-tong. 1948. Siang Tu Jhong Guo [Earthbound China]. Shanghai: Observer.
  89. 黃于寶, Yu-Bao(2013)。臺北=Taipei, Taiwan，國立臺灣師範大學科技應用與人力資源發展研究所=Department of Technology Application and Human Resource Development, National Taiwan Normal University。
  90. 黃光國（編）, Kwang-kuo(ed.)(1988).中國人的權力遊戲.臺北=Taipei:巨流=Chuliu Publishing.
  91. 蔡秀涓, Hsiu-cheng(2004)。世代因素對公務人員工作價值觀影響之實證分析：以考試院暨所屬機關為例。東吳政治學報，18，41-67。
  92. 蔡昀芝，2017，〈鐵飯碗變「錄音帶」：你不知道的公務員結構性過勞危機〉，關鍵評論網網頁， https://www.thenewslens.com/article/86194，2021/7/5。Tsai, Yun-chih, 2017. “Tiefanwan bian luyindai: ni buzhidao de gongwuyuan jiegouxing guolao weiji” [The Iron Rice Bowl Becomes a “Tape”: The Structural Overwork Crisis of Civil Servants You Didn’t Know]. in https://www.thenewslens.com/article/86194. Latest update 5 July 2021.
  93. 鄭匡宇，2019，〈公務體系打滾20年，為何我不建議你當公務員〉，換日線網頁，https://crossing.cw.com.tw/article/11472，2021/11/28。Cheng, Kuang-yu 2019. “Gongwu tixi dagun 20 nian, weihe wo bujianyi ni dang gongwuyuan” [Working in the Field of Public Sectors, Why Don’t I Recommend You being a Public Servant]. in https://crossing.cw.com.tw/article/11472, Latest update 28 November 2021.
  94. 鄭伯壎, Bor-shiuan(1995)。差序格局與華人組織行為。本土心理學研究，3，142-219。
  95. 戴元利，2020，〈業務爆量、工時爆肝，公務員人才外流瀕「災難臨界點」〉，TVBS新聞網網頁，https://news.tvbs.com.tw/life/1419001，2021/7/10。Dai, Yun-li, 2020. “Yewu baoliang, gongshi baogan, gongwuyuan rencai wailiubin zainan lin jiedian” [The Business and Working Hours Exploded, and the Brain Drain of Civil Servants Was on a Critical Point of Disaster]. in https://news.tvbs.com.tw/life/1419001, Latest update 10 July 2021.
  96. 謝儲鍵, Chu-chien,林煥笙, Huan-Sheng(2020)。會做人很重要嗎？初探人際關係建立對菜鳥公務人員之職場發展。2020台灣政治學會年會，臺北=Taipei:
print cancel