The Impact of Incentive Compensation Structure on the Choice Strategy of Earnings Management

10.6656/MR.202001_39(1).ENG141

Yun-Sheng Hsu；Hsueh-Ju Chen；Sheng-Hua Huang

Incentive Compensation ； Stock-Based Compensation ； Accruals-Based Earnings Management ； Classification Shifting ； Real Earnings Management

管理評論

39卷1期（2020 / 01 / 01）

141 - 161

英文

Purpose - The purpose of the paper is to explore whether the impact of an incentive compensation system is just the manipulation of financial statements or at the expense of real future benefits. Specifically, it studies whether the compensation structure mitigates the negative influences. Design/methodology/approach - By empirical study, the paper explore the influences of incentive compensation system on the use of accrual-based, classification shifting, and real earnings management. Findings - The results show that incentive compensation simultaneously increases the use of accrual-based, classification shifting, and real earnings management. And a stock-based compensation system decreases the use of real earnings management, but increases the use of classification shifting and accruals-based earnings management. Research limitations/implications - This study only considers 5 compensations including salaries, bonuses and extraordinary charges, stock dividends, cash dividends, and employee stock options. In addition, earnings management methods are limited to classification shifting, accruals-based, or real earnings management. Practical implications/Social implication - The incentive compensation harm the firm's real benefit, that could be mitigates by a stock-based compensation structure. Originality/value - A stock-based compensation structure could mitigate the negative influences of the incentive compensation system.

1. Chen, Ching-Lung,Weng, Pei-Yu,Fan, Hung-Shu(2016).Institutional Ownership, Income Smoothing and the Value-relevance of Accounting Numbers.Management Review,35(3),1-27.
   連結：
2. Hsu, Yun-Sheng,Chan, Yu-Hsyen,Huang, Wan-Ting(2016).CEO Compensation Structure, Dominance and R&D Expenditures.Journal of Contemporary Accounting,17(1),35-62.
   連結：
3. Hung, Yu-Shun,Wang, Tay-Chang(2013).Relative Sensitivity of Performance Measures in Top Executive Compensation Structure.Journal of Management and Business Research,30(3),263-293.
   連結：
4. Hung, Yu-Shun,Wang, Tay-Chang(2008).An Analysis of the Relative Importance of Performance Measures in Top Executive Stock-Based Compensation Contract.International Journal of Accounting Studies,46(1),1-29.
   連結：
5. Lin, Chan-Jane,Huang, Hui-Chun(2016).Voluntary Financial Restatements: The Perspectives of Management Incentives and Pressures.Management Review,35(1),1-20.
   連結：
6. Lin, Shu-Hui,Hu, Shing-Yang(2003).CEO Compensation Structure in Taiwan's Listed Companies.Academia economic Papers,31(2),171-206.
   連結：
7. Wang, Hsiao-Wen,Chen, Hsin-Yu,Wu, Pei-San(2013).R&D Expenditure and CEO Compensation: The Impact of Corporate Control and Growth Opportunity on Managerial Opportunism.Management Review,32(1),39-62.
   連結：
8. Abernathy, John L.,Beyer, Brooke,Rapley, Eric T.(2014).Earnings Management Constraints and Classification Shifting.Journal of Business Finance & Accounting,41(5-6),600-626.
9. Alfred, Lye Chye Loh, Tan Tin Hoe, and Trevor Wilkins (2001), “The Role of the Discretionary Accruals and Classification Decisions in the Management of Earnings,” SSRN working paper, (April 30), (accessed December 17, 2019), [available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3080778].
10. Altman, Edward(1968).Financial Ratio, Discriminate Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy.Journal of Finance,23(4),589-609.
11. Armstrong, Christopher S.,Jagolinzer, Alan D.,Larcker, David F.(2010).Chief Executive Officer Equity Incentives and Accounting Irregularities.Journal of Accounting Research,48(2),225-271.
12. Banker, Rajiv D.,Datar, Srikant M.(1989).Sensitivity, Precision, and Linear Aggregation of Signals for Performance Evaluation.Journal of Accounting Research,27(1),21-39.
13. Barber, William R.,Kang, Sok-Hyon,Kumar, Krishna R.(1998).Accounting Earnings and Executive Compensation: The Role of Earnings Persistence.Journal of Accounting and Economics,25(2),169-193.
14. Barton, Jan,Simko, Paul J.(2002).The Balance Sheet as an Earnings Management Constraint.The Accounting Review,77(Supplement),1-27.
15. Bergstresser, Daniel,Philippon, Thomas(2006).CEO Incentives and Earnings Management.Journal of Financial Economics,80(3),511-529.
16. Bhattacharya, Utpal,Daouk, Hazem,Welker, Michael(2003).The World Price of Earnings Opacity.The Accounting Reviews,78(3),641-678.
17. Bradshaw, Mark T.,Sloan, Richard G.(2002).GAAP versus the Street: An Empirical Assessment of Two Alterna-Tive Definitions of Earnings.Journal of Accounting Research,40(1),41-66.
18. Burgstahler, David,Dichev, Ilia D.(1997).Earnings Management to Avoid Earnings Decreases and Losses.Journal of Accounting and Economics,24(1),99-126.
19. Burns, Natasha,Kedia, Simi(2006).The Impact of Performance-Based Compensation on Misreporting.Journal of Financial Economics,79(1),35-67.
20. Bushman, Robert M.,Engel, Ellen,Smith, Abbie J.(2006).An Analysis of the Relation between the Stewardship and Valuation Roles of Earnings.Journal of Accounting Research,44(1),53-83.
21. Bushman, Robert M.,Indjejikian, Raffi J.(1993).Accounting Income, Stock Price, and Managerial Compensation.Journal of Accounting and Economics,16(1-3),3-23.
22. Carter, Mary Ellen,Lynch, Luann J.,Zechman, Sarah L. C.(2009).Changes in Bonus Contracts in the Post-Sarbanes-Oxley Era.Review of Accounting Studies,14(4),480-506.
23. Chan, Lilian H.,Chen, Kevin C. W.,Chen, TaiYuan,Yu, Yangxin(2015).Substitution between Real and Accruals-Based Earnings Management after Voluntary Adoption of Compensation Clawback Provisions.The Accounting Review,90(1),147-174.
24. Cheng, Qiang,Warfield, Terry D.(2005).Equity Incentives and Earnings Management.The Accounting Review,80(2),441-476.
25. Cheng, Shijun(2004).R&D Expenditures and CEO Compensation.The Accounting Review,79(2),305-327.
26. Cohen, Daniel A.,Zarowin, Paul(2010).Accrual-Based and Real Earnings Management Activities around Seasoned Equity Offerings.Journal of Accounting and Economics,50(1),2-19.
27. Commerford, Benjamin P.,Hatfield, Richard C.,Houston, Richard W.(2018).The Effect of Real Earnings Management on Auditor Scrutiny of Management’s Other Financial Reporting Decisions.The Accounting Review,93(5),145-163.
28. De Angelis, David,Grinstein, Yaniv(2015).Performance Terms in CEO Compensation Contract.Review of Finance,19(2),619-651.
29. Dechow, Patricia M.,Skinner, Douglas J.(2000).Earnings Management: Reconciling the Views of Accounting Academics, Practitioners and Regulators.Accounting Horizons,14(2),235-250.
30. Degeorge, Francois,Patel, Jayendu,Zeckhauser, Richard J.(1999).Earnings Management to Exceed Thresholds.Journal of Business,72(1),1-33.
31. Doyle, Jeffrey T.,Jennings, Jared N.,Soliman, Mark T.(2013).Do Managers Define Non-GAAP Earnings to Meet or Beat Analyst Forecasts?.Journal of Accounting and Economics,56(1),40-56.
32. Eilifsen, Aasmund and Kjell Henry Knivsfla (2019), “Core Earnings Management: How Do Audit Firms Interact with the Balance between Classification Shifting and Accruals Management?” SSRN working paper, (December 17), (accessed December 17, 2019), [available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3080778].
33. Erickson, Merle,Hanlon, Michelle,Maydew, Edward L.(2006).Is There a Link between Executive Equity Incentives and Accounting Fraud?.Journal of Accounting Research,44(1),113-143.
34. Fahlenbrach, Rüdiger(2009).Shareholder Rights, Boards and CEO Compensation.Review of Finance,13(1),81-113.
35. Fan, Yun,Barua, Abhijit,Cready, William M.,Thomas, Wayne B.(2010).Managing Earnings Using Classification Shifting: Evidence from Quarterly Special Items.The Accounting Review,85(4),1303-1323.
36. Fields, Thomas D.,Lys, Thomas Z.,Vincent, Linda(2001).Empirical Research on Accounting Choice.Journal of Accounting and Economics,31(1-3),255-307.
37. Goldman, Eitan,Slezak, Steve L.(2006).An Equilibrium Model of Incentive Contracts in the Presence of Information Manipulation.Journal of Accounting and Economic,80(3),603-626.
38. Graham, John R.,Havey, Campbell R.,Rajgopal, Shiva(2005).The Economic Implications of Corporate Financial Reporting.Journal of Accounting and Economic,40(1-3),3-73.
39. Gunny, Katherine(2010).The Relation between Earnings Management Using Real Activities Manipulation and Future Performance: Evidence from Meeting Earnings Benchmarks.Contemporary Accounting Research,27(3),855-888.
40. Healy, Paul(1985).The Effect of Bonus Schemes on Accounting Decisions.Journal of Accounting and Economics,7(1-3),85-107.
41. Heckman, James J.(1979).Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error.Econometrica,47(1),153-161.
42. Holmstrom, Bengt(1979).Moral Hazard and Observability.The Bell Journal of Economics,10(1),74-91.
43. Holthausen, Robert W.,Larcker, David F.,Sloan, Richard G.(1995).Annual Bonus Schemes and the Manipulation of Earnings.Journal of Accounting and Economic,19(1),29-74.
44. Hunton, James E.,Mauldin, Elaine G.,Wheeler, Patrick R.(2008).Potential Functional and Dysfunctional Effects of Continuous Monitoring.The Accounting Review,83(6),1551-1569.
45. Jensen, Michael C.,Meckling, William H.(1976).Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure.Journal of Financial Economics,3(4),305-360.
46. Jensen, Michael C.,Murphy, Kevin J.(1990).Performance Pay and Top-Management Incentives.Journal of Political Economy,98(2),225-264.
47. Joo, Jeong Hwan,Chamberlain, Sandra L.(2017).The Effects of Governance on Classification Shifting and Compensation Shielding.Contemporary Accounting Research,34(4),1779-1811.
48. Kothari, S. P.,Leone, Andrew J.,Wasley, Charles E.(2005).Performance Matched Discretionary Accrual Measures.Journal of Accounting and Economic,39(1),163-197.
49. Lambert, Richard A.(2001).Contract Theory and Accounting.Journal of Accounting and Economic,32(1-3),3-87.
50. Lambert, Richard A.,Larcker, David F.(1987).An Analysis of the Use of Accounting and Market Measures of Performance in Executive Compensation Contracts.Journal of Accounting Research,25(Supplement),85-129.
51. Larcker, David F.,Richardson, Scott A.,Tuna, Irem(2007).Corporate Governance, Accounting Outcomes, and Organizational Performance.The Accounting Review,82(4),963-1008.
52. Laux, Christian,Laux, Volker(2009).Board Committees, CEO Compensation, and Earnings Management.The Accounting Review,84(3),869-891.
53. Lee, Jan-Zan,Chen, Jeng-Fang(2004).The Effect of Audit Client’s Importance on Magnitude of Earnings Management: From the Perspective of Audit Groups within the Big Five.International Journal of Accounting Studies,38(1),59-80.
54. Li, Zhi,Wang, Lingling(2016).Executive Compensation Incentives Contingent on Long-term Accounting Performance.Review of Financial Studies,29(6),1586-1633.
55. Mayers, David,Smith, Clifford W.(2010).Compensation and Board Structure: Evidence from the Insurance Industry.Journal of Risk and Insurance,77(2),297-327.
56. McVay, Sarah Elizabeth(2006).Earnings Management Using Classification Shifting: An Examination of Core Earnings and Special Items.The Accounting Review,81(3),501-531.
57. Murphy, Kevin J.(2000).Performance Standards in Incentive Contracts.Journal of Accounting and Economic,30(3),245-278.
58. Myer, Stewart C.,Majluf, Nicholas S.(1984).Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions when Firms Have Information that Investors Do not Have.Journal of Financial Economics,13(2),187-221.
59. Narayanan, M. P.(1996).Form of Compensation and Managerial Decision Horizon.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,31(4),467-497.
60. Nelson, Mark,Elliott, John A.,Tarpley, Robin L.(2002).Evidence from Auditors about Managers’ and Auditors’ Earnings Management Decisions.The Accounting Review,77(Supplement),175-202.
61. Ozkan, Neslihan,Singer, Zvi,You, Haifeng(2012).Mandatory IFRS Adoption and the Contractual Usefulness of Accounting Information in Executive Compensation.Journal of Accounting Research,50(4),1077-1107.
62. Roychowdhury, Sugata(2006).Earnings Management through Real Activities Manipulation.Journal of Accounting and Economics,42(3),335-370.
63. Schipper, Katherine(1989).Commentary on Earnings Management.Accounting Horizons,3(1-3),91-102.
64. Taiwan Economic Journal (2017), “Taiwan Economic Journal Database,” (accessed December 17, 2019), [available at http://www.tej.com.tw/twsite/%E9% A6%96%E9%A0%81/tabid/163/language/zh-TW/Default.aspx].
65. Watts, Ross L.,Zimmerman, Jerold L.(1978).Towards a Positive Theory of the Determination of Accounting Standards.The Accounting Review,53(1),112-134.
66. Zang, Amy Y.(2012).Evidence on the Trade-Off between Real Activities Manipulation and Accrual-based Earnings Management.The Accounting Review,87(2),675-703.