戒菸方案之隨機控制試驗之系統性文獻回顧

Randomized Controlled Trials for Smoking Cessation: A Systematic Review

10.6288/TJPH201433103050

吳昭儀(Chao-Yi Wu)；王曉琳(Hsiao-Lin Wang)；陳韻玲(Yun-Ling Chen)；吳博儒(Bo-Ru Wu)；陳詞章(Tsyr-Jang Chen)；潘璦琬(Ay-Woan Pan)

系統性文獻回顧 ； 戒菸 ； 介入方案 ； systematic review ； smoking cessation ； intervention

台灣公共衛生雜誌

33卷5期（2014 / 10 / 01）

470 - 482

繁體中文

吸菸對於健康有相當程度危害，戒菸一直是衛生健康單位關心的議題，然而科技媒介介入與傳統戒菸方案之成效差異的研究仍不足。本研究目的是透過系統性文獻回顧以探討現有戒菸方案之成效。本研究搜尋近三年研究，篩選後共收錄36篇文獻，其中藥物與尼古丁替代療法類23篇，科技媒介介入方式4篇及非科技媒介介入方式9篇。非尼古丁藥物於六個月與一年追蹤戒菸率分別可達47.4%和26.8%，最常使用的藥物為戒必適與威博雋。尼古丁替代療法六個月與一年追蹤戒菸率分別可達33.3%和30.0%，最常使用為尼古丁貼片及口嚼錠。科技媒介介入方式以電話簡訊最多，六個月戒菸率可達30%。非科技媒介介入方式則以包含認知行為治療的合併式療法最多，六個月追蹤戒菸率可達57.1%。藥物和尼古丁替代療法需注意其副作用和成癮問題，而科技媒介和非科技媒介介入方式則有個案順從性的考量。本研究透過系統性回顧探討不同戒菸介入方案的優點和限制，有助未來發展多元化戒菸方案之參考。

Smoking poses a great threat to health, and smoking cessation is always a critical concern of health authorities; however, the effectiveness of smoking cessation programs has been limited. The aim of this study was to systematically review the literature related to smoking cessation programs. We searched for randomized controlled trial studies related to smoking cessation in the last 3 years, and 36 articles were reviewed. They were categorized into 3 types: 23 medication interventions (non-nicotine medicine/nicotine medicine), 9 non-technological interventions, and 4 technology-based interventions. The average cessation rate was higher with the non-nicotine medication approach than with the others. The 6-month and 1-year cessation rate were 47.4% and 26.8%, respectively. Varenicline and bupropion were the most commonly prescribed medications. The 6-month and 1-year cessation rates for nicotine replacement therapies were 33.3% and 30.0%, respectively. Nicotine patches and gum were used most frequently. Among the technology-based interventions, the telephone and text approach was used most often. The cessation rate could reach 30.0%. Of non-technological interventionss, cognitive-behavioral therapies were most common. The 6-month cessation rate could reach 57.1%. The side-effects and addiction potential of medications and nicotine replacement therapies should be noted. The results of the literature review revealed that there were strengths and limitations of the various interventions. Through the development of diverse intervention programs, we may be able to reach more people who need to cease smoking.

1. 張文道、王雅瑜、周崇頌(2007)。台灣中部某醫學中心門診戒菸治療病患一年追蹤。台灣家庭醫學雜誌，17，38-52。
   連結：
2. 張景然、王珮蘭、許世慧(2009)。影響完成電話戒菸諮商個案戒菸成效及維持成效相關因素之探討。輔導與諮商學報，31，1-15。
   連結：
3. 張德聰、潘瑞香、張景然(2006)。單次與多次電話諮商戒菸成效之比較：以戒菸專線服務中心為例。中華心理衛生學刊，19，213-29。
   連結：
4. 薛光傑、杜明勳、葛魯蘋、周明岳、陳麗玲(2006)。某醫學中心門診戒菸成效。台灣家庭醫學雜誌，16，1-12。
   連結：
5. 衛生福利部國民健康署戒菸治療管理中心：戒菸率統計資料， 2014 。 http://ttc.hpa.gov.tw/quit/SysE/E0401M01.asp 。引用 2014/09/04 。 Office for Smoking Cessation Services, Health Promotion Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Statistics of smoking cessation rates, 2014. Available at: http://ttc.hpa.gov.tw/quit/SysE/E0401M01.asp. Accessed September 4, 2014. [In Chinese]
6. 衛生福利部國民健康署：成年人吸菸行為調查摘要報告， 2014 。 http://tobacco.hpa.gov.tw/Show.aspx?MenuId=581 。引用 2014/09/04 。 Health Promotion Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, R.O.C. (Taiwan). Abstract for adult smoking behavior surveillance system, ASBS. Available at: http://tobacco.hpa.gov.tw/Show.aspx?MenuId=581. Accessed September 4, 2014. [In Chinese]
7. American Psychiatric Association(ed.)(2013).Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.VA:Arlington.
8. Bock, BC,Fava, JL,Gaskins, R(2012).Yogaas a complementary treatment for smoking cessation in women.J Womens Health,21,240-8.
9. Bolliger, CT,Issa, JS,Posadas-Valay, R(2011).Effects of varenicline in adult smokers: a multinational, 24-week, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study.Clin Ther,33,465-77.
10. Caponnetto, P,Cibella, F,Mancuso, S,Campagna, D,Arcidiacono, G,Polosa, R(2011).Effect of a nicotine-free inhalator as part of a smoking-cessation programme.Eur Respir J,38,1005-11.
11. Carmody, TP,Delucchi, K,Duncan, CL(2012).Intensive intervention for alcohol-dependent smokers in early recovery: a randomized trial.Drug Alcohol Depend,122,186-94.
12. Chan, SS,Leung, DY,Abdullah, AS,Wong, VT,Hedley, AJ,Lam, TH(2011).A randomized controlled trial of a smoking reduction plus nicotine replacement therapy intervention for smokers not willing to quit smoking.Addiction,106,1155-63.
13. Chan, SS,Leung, DY,Wong, DC,Lau, CP,Wong, VT,Lam, TH(2012).A randomized controlled trial of stage-matched intervention for smoking cessation in cardiac out-patients.Addiction,107,829-37.
14. Civljak, M,Sheikh, A,Stead, LF,Car, J(2013).Internet-based interventions for smoking cessation.Cochrane Database Syst Rev,7,CD007078.
15. Cox, LS,Nollen, NL,Mayo, MS(2012).Bupropion for smoking cessation in African American light smokers: a randomized controlled trial.J Natl Cancer Inst,104,290-8.
16. de Dios, MA,Anderson, BJ,Stanton, C,Audet, DA,Stein, M(2012).Project impact: a pharmacotherapy pilot trial investigating the abstinence and treatment adherence of Latino light smokers.J Subst Abuse Treat,43,322-30.
17. Ebbert, JO,Croghan, IT,Severson, HH,Schroeder, DR,Hays, JT(2011).A pilot study of the efficacy of varenicline for the treatment of smokeless tobacco users in Midwestern United States.Nicotine Tob Res,13,820-6.
18. Ebbert, JO,Severson, HH,Croghan, IT,Danaher, BG,Schroeder, DR(2013).Comparative effectiveness of the nicotine lozenge and tobacco-free snuff for smokeless tobacco reduction.Addict Behav,38,2140-5.
19. Eisenberg, MJ,Grandi, SM,Gervais, A(2013).Bupropion for smoking cessation in patients hospitalized with acute myocardial infarction: a randomized, placebo-controlled trial.J Am Coll Cardiol,61,524-32.
20. Free, C,Knight, R,Robertson, S(2011).Smoking cessation support delivered via mobile phone text messaging (txt2stop): a single-blind, randomised trial.Lancet,378,49-55.
21. Goldade, K,Whembolua, GL,Thomas, J(2011).Designing a smoking cessation intervention for the unique needs of homeless persons: a community-based randomized clinical trial.Clin Trials,8,744-54.
22. Hall, SM,Humfleet, GL,Munoz, RF,Reus, VI,Prochaska, JJ,Robbins, JA(2011).Using extended cognitive behavioral treatment and medication to treat dependent smokers.Am J Public Health,101,2349-56.
23. Hughes, JR,Rennard, SI,Fingar, JR,Talbot, SK,Callas, PW,Fagerstrom, KO(2011).Efficacy of varenicline to prompt quit attempts in smokers not currently trying to quit: a randomized placebo-controlled trial.Nicotine Tob Res,13,955-64.
24. Jha, P,Ramasundarahettige, C,Landsman, V(2013).21st-century hazards of smoking and benefits of cessation in the United States.N Engl J Med,368,341-50.
25. Joksic, G,Spasojevic-Tisma, V,Antic, R,Nilsson, R,Rutqvist, LE(2011).Randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind trial of Swedish snus for smoking reduction and cessation.Harm Reduct J,8,25.
26. Kahn, R,Gorgon, L,Jones, K(2012).Selegiline transdermal system (STS) as an aid for smoking cessation.Nicotine Tob Res,14,377-82.
27. Kalman, D,Herz, L,Monti, P(2011).Incremental efficacy of adding bupropion to the nicotine patch for smoking cessation in smokers with a recent history of alcohol dependence: results from a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study.Drug Alcohol Depend,118,111-8.
28. Katanoda, K,Jiang, Y,Park, S,Lim, MK,Qiao, YL,Inoue, M(2014).Tobacco control challenges in East Asia: proposals for change in the world's largest epidemic region.Tob Control,23,359-68.
29. Kim, SS,Kim, SH,Ziedonis, D(2012).Tobacco dependence treatment for Korean Americans: preliminary findings.J Immigr Minor Health,14,395-404.
30. Morris, CD,Waxmonsky, JA,May, MG,Tinkelman, DG,Dickinson, M,Giese, AA(2011).Smoking reduction for persons with mental illnesses: 6-month results from community-based interventions.Community Ment Health J,47,694-702.
31. Mueller, SE,Petitjean, SA,Wiesbeck, GA(2012).Cognitive behavioral smoking cessation during alcohol detoxification treatment: a randomized, controlled trial.Drug Alcohol Depend,126,279-85.
32. Murray, RL,Leonardi-Bee, J,Marsh, J(2013).Systematic identification and treatment of smokers by hospital based cessation practitioners in a secondary care setting: cluster randomised controlled trial.BMJ,347,f4004.
33. Okuyemi, KS,Goldade, K,Whembolua, GL(2013).Motivational interviewing to enhance nicotine patch treatment for smoking cessation among homeless smokers: a randomized controlled trial.Addiction,108,1136-44.
34. Ramon, JM,Nerin, I,Comino, A(2013).A multicentre randomized trial of combined individual and telephone counselling for smoking cessation.Prev Med,57,183-8.
35. Reitzel, LR,McClure, JB,Cofta-Woerpel, L(2011).The efficacy of computer-delivered treatment for smoking cessation.Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev,20,1555-7.
36. Rennard, S,Hughes, J,Cinciripini, PM(2012).A randomized placebo-controlled trial of varenicline for smoking cessation allowing flexible quit dates.Nicotine Tob Res,14,343-50.
37. Richmond, R,Indig, D,Butler, T,Wilhelm, K,Archer, V,Wodak, A(2013).A randomized controlled trial of a smoking cessation intervention conducted among prisoners.Addiction,108,966-74.
38. Rose, JE,Behm, FM(2013).Adapting smoking cessation treatment according to initial response to precessation nicotine patch.Am J Psychiatry,170,860-7.
39. Siddiqi, K,Khan, A,Ahmad, M(2013).Action to stop smoking in suspected tuberculosis (ASSIST) in Pakistan: a cluster randomized, controlled trial.Ann Intern Med,158,667-75.
40. Steinberg, MB,Randall, J,Greenhaus, S,Schmelzer, AC,Richardson, DL,Carson, JL(2011).Tobacco dependence treatment for hospitalized smokers: a randomized, controlled, pilot trial using varenicline.Addict Behav,36,1127-32.
41. Tashkin, DP,Rennard, S,Hays, JT,Ma, W,Lawrence, D,Lee, TC(2011).Effects of varenicline on smoking cessation in patients with mild to moderate COPD: a randomized controlled trial.Chest,139,591-9.
42. Thun, MJ,Carter, BD,Feskanich, D(2013).50-year trends in smoking-related mortality in the United States.N Engl J Med,368,351-64.
43. Tonnesen, P,Lauri, H,Perfekt, R,Mann, K,Batra, A(2012).Efficacy of a nicotine mouth spray in smoking cessation: a randomised, double-blind trial.Eur Respir J,40,548-54.
44. Tse, LA,Fang, XH,Wang, WZ,Qiu, H,Yu, IT(2012).Incidence of ischaemic and haemorrhagic stroke and the association with smoking and smoking cessation: a 10-year multicentre prospective study in China.Public Health,126,960-6.
45. Walker, N,Howe, C,Bullen, C(2011).Does improved access and greater choice of nicotine replacement therapy affect smoking cessation success? Findings from a randomized controlled trial.Addiction,106,1176-85.
46. Ward, KD,Asfar, T,Al Ali, R(2013).Randomized trial of the effectiveness of combined behavioral/pharmacological smoking cessation treatment in Syrian primary care clinics.Addiction,108,394-403.
47. West, R,Zatonski, W,Cedzynska, M(2011).Placebo-controlled trial of cytisine for smoking cessation.N Engl J Med,365,1193-200.
48. Whittaker, R,Borland, R,Bullen, C,Lin, RB,McRobbie, H,Rodgers, A(2009).Mobile phone-based interventions for smoking cessation.Cochrane Database Syst Rev,4,CD006611.
49. Williams, JM,Anthenelli, RM,Morris, CD(2012).A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study evaluating the safety and efficacy of varenicline for smoking cessation in patients with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder.J Clin Psychiatry,73,654-60.
50. Wu, WY,Chen, SC,Yen, CH,Chou, MC,Lee, MC(2005).Effectiveness of the combination of nicotine replacement therapy and counseling at a government-sponsored smoking cessation clinic in Taiwan.Chung Shan Med J,16,9-15.
51. 葉美玲、陳興夏、張惠芬(2002)。網際網路輔助戒菸課程於青少年之成效。台灣醫學，6，648-60。
52. 廖倩誼、呂喬洋、何佩玲、林怡君、邱哲宜(2004)。社區民眾戒菸教育介入成效研究。北市醫學雜誌，1，311-8。
53. 鄭秀月、李茹萍(2009)。戒菸門診個案持續戒菸行為與自我效能之研究。台灣醫學，13，223-30。
54. 蕭玉霜、賴瓊儀(2005)。“戒菸教育活動”介入成效之探討。實證護理，1，22-8。
55. 蘇庭進(2012)。電話戒菸諮商。諮商與輔導，323，25-9+32。

1. 廖翎聿(2017)。慢性阻塞性肺病住院老人之心肺耐力相關影響因素探討。高雄醫學大學護理學系碩士班學位論文。2017。1-202。