题名

內部行銷、外部行銷對互動行銷與顧客滿意度間關係干擾效果之研究：多層次分析模型

并列篇名

The Moderating Effects of Internal Marketing and External Marketing upon the Relationship between Interactive Marketing and Customer Satisfaction: A Multi-level Model

DOI

10.6160/2012.06.06

作者

黃銘章(Ming-Chang Huang)；李萍萍(Ping-Ping Lee)

关键词

內部行銷 ； 外部行銷 ； 互動行銷 ； 顧客滿意 ； 階層線性模式 ； Internal marketing ； external marketing ； interactive marketing ； customer satisfaction ； hierarchical linear modeling

期刊名称

中山管理評論

卷期/出版年月

20卷2期（2012 / 06 / 01）

页次

637 - 672

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

員工與顧客之間的互動是影響顧客滿意的關鍵，內部行銷與外部行銷則是影響互動行銷的重要因素，但內部行銷與外部行銷屬組織層級變項，互動行銷與顧客滿意度則屬個人層級變項，為避免分析時受資料巢套的影響，本研究以階層線性模式檢視內部行銷、外部行銷、互動行銷與顧客滿意度間關係跨層次之干擾效果。本研究共獲得29所大專院校合作，回收29份招生人員問卷、201份大專教師問卷及405份學生問卷。實證結果發現：（1）互動行銷對顧客滿意度有正向影響；（2）內部行銷對顧客滿意度有正向影響；（3）內部行銷對互動行銷與顧客滿意度之間的關係有正向干擾效果；（4）外部行銷對顧客滿意度有正向影響；（5）外部行銷對互動行銷與顧客滿意度之間的關係有負向的干擾效果。
英文摘要

The interaction between employees and customers is the key to customer satisfaction. Both internal marketing and external marketing are critical elements in interactive marketing. However, internal marketing and external marketing belong to organizational level constructs; interactive marketing and customer satisfaction belong to individual level constructs. To avoid nested effects, this study applied hierarchical linear modeling (HLM) to test the cross level moderating effects of internal marketing and external marketing on the relationship between interactive marketing and customer satisfaction. Evidence from twenty-nine universities, which include twenty-nine questionnaires, were responded by recruitment staff. Two hundred and one questionnaires were responded by school teachers, four hundred and five questionnaires were responded by students. The results showed that: (1) interactive marketing had a positive effect on customer satisfaction, (2) internal marketing had a positive effect on customer satisfaction, (3) internal marketing had a positive moderating effect upon the relationship between interactive marketing and customer satisfaction, (4) external marketing had a positive effect on customer satisfaction, (5) external marketing had a negative moderating effect on the relationship between interactive marketing and customer satisfaction.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. 林妙雀、溫福星(2010)。部落格互動與社群對部落格使用者忠誠度之跨層次研究─以部落客人格特質與涉入度為干擾變數。資訊管理學報，17(3)，107-130。
    連結：
  2. 林鉦棽(2005)。組織公民行為之跨層次分析─層級線性模式的應用。管理學報，22(4)，503-524。
    連結：
  3. 林鉦棽、彭台光(2006)。多層次管理研究：分析層次的概念、理論和方法。管理學報，23(6)，649-675。
    連結：
  4. 陳怡伶、丘宏昌、謝依靜、張文華(2006)。網路企業關係結合方式與顧客滿意度之關係─不同知覺價格下之分析。臺大管理論叢，16(2)，51-72。
    連結：
  5. 彭台光、林鉦棽(2008)。組織現象和層次議題：非獨立性資料的概念和實證。組織與管理，11(1)，95-121。
    連結：
  6. 黃俊英、林義屏、董玉娟(1999)。非營利組織顧客滿意模式之研究─以台南捐血中心為例。亞太管理評論，4(3)，323-339。
    連結：
  7. 黃思明、耿慶瑞(2003)。互動行銷技術對顧客服務再工程之影響。電子商務研究，1(2)，119-146。
    連結：
  8. 黃銘章、溫福星、陳虹如、卜唯平(2004)。影響多國籍企業回應當地需求因素之研究─以行銷組合當地化為例。企業管理學報，66，41-76。
    連結：
  9. 溫福星、邱皓政(2009)。組織研究中的多層次調節式中介效果：以組織創新氣氛、組織承諾與工作滿意的實證研究為例。管理學報，26(2)，189-211。
    連結：
  10. 劉先祥、魏正(2009)。大學休閒運動學系招生行銷策略之探討。大專體育，100，21-28。
    連結：
  11. 蔡雅芳、胡哲生(2005)。組織內部與外部價值活動之交易互動─價值鏈觀點。管理學報，22(6)，727-742。
    連結：
  12. 中華民國教育部統計處，2009，「大專校院概況表」，http://www.edu.tw/statistics/content.aspx?site_content_sn=8869, accessed on February 19, 2009.
  13. Andaleeb, S. S.,Conway, C.(2006).Customer Satisfaction in the Restaurant Industry: An Examination of the Transaction-Specific Model.Journal of Services Marketing,20(1),3-11.
  14. Anderson, E. W.,Fornell, C.,Lehmann, D. R.(1994).Customer Satisfaction, Market Share, and Profitability: Finding from Sweden.Journal of Marketing,58(3),53-66.
  15. Bansal, H. B.,Mendelson, M. B.,Sharma, B.(2001).The Impact of Internal Marketing Activities on External Marketing Outcomes.Journal of Quality Management,6(1),61-76.
  16. Barnes, B. R.,Fox, M. T.,Mossis, D. S.(2004).Exploring the Linkage between Internal Marketing, Relationship. Marketing and Service Quality: A Case Study of a Consulting Organization.Total Quality Management & Business Excellence,15(5-6),593-601.
  17. Bettencourt, L. A.,Brown, S. W.(1997).Contact Employees: Relationships among Workplace Fairness, Job Satisfaction, and Prosocial Service Behaviors.Journal of Retailing,73(1),39-61.
  18. Bettencourt, L. A.,Brown, S. W.,MacKenzie, S. B.(2005).Customer-Oriented Boundary-Spanning Behaviors: Test of Social Exchange Model of Antecedents.Journal of Retailing,81(2),141-157.
  19. Bitner, M. J.(1997).Introduction to the Second Special Issue Services Marketing: Perspectives on Service Excellence.Journal of Retailing,73(3),299-301.
  20. Cano, C. R.,Sams, D.(2009).The Importance of an Internal Marketing Orientation in Social Service.International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing,14(3),285-295.
  21. Cardozo, R. N.(1965).An Experimental Study of Customer Effort, Expectation and Satisfaction.Journal of Marketing Research,2(3),244-249.
  22. Crosby, L. A.,Evans, K. R.,Cowles, D.(1990).Relationship Quality in Services Selling: An Interpersonal Influence Perspective.Journal of Marketing,54(3),68-81.
  23. De Vrye, Catherine、王秀婷譯、高慧雯譯(2002)。黃金服務 15 秒。台北:商智文化事業股份有限公司。
  24. Ferdous, A. S.(2008).Integrated Internal Marketing Communication.The Marketing Review,8(3),223-235.
  25. Flipo, J. P.(1986).Service Firms: Interdependence of External and Internal Marketing Strategies.European Journal of Marketing,20(8),5-14.
  26. Gavin, G. B.,Hofmann, D. A.(2002).Using Hierarchical Linear Modeling to Investigate the Moderating Influence of Leadership Climate.The Leadership Quality,13(1),15-33.
  27. Greene, W. E.,Walls, G. D.,Schrest, L. J.(1994).Internal Marketing: The Key to External Marketing Success.Journal of Services Marketing,8(4),5-13.
  28. Griffith, J.(2001).Do Satisfied Employees Satisfy Customers? Support-Services Staff Morale and Satisfaction among Public School Administrators, Students, and Parents.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,31(8),1627-1658.
  29. Grönroos, C.(1998).Marketing Services: The Case of a Missing Product.Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing,13(4-5),322-338.
  30. Grönroos, C.(2009).Marketing as Promise Management: Regaining Customer Management for Marketing.Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing,24(5-6),351-359.
  31. Grönroos, C.(1999).Relationship Marketing: Challenges for the Organization.Journal of Business Research,46(3),327-335.
  32. Grönroos, C.(1982).An Applied Service Marketing.European Journal of Marketing,16(7),30-41.
  33. Gummesson, E.(1990).Marketing-Orientation Revisited: The Crucial Role of the Part-time Marketer.European Journal of Marketing,25(2),60-75.
  34. Hair, J. F.,Rolph, E. A.,Ronld, L. T.,William, C. B.(1998).Multivariate Data Analysis.New:Macmillan.
  35. Hallowell, R.,Schlesinger, L. A.,Zornitsky, J.(1996).Internal Service Quality, Customer and Job Satisfaction: Linkages and Implications for Management.Human Resource Planning,19(2),20-31.
  36. Hartline, M. D.,Ferrell, O. C.(1996).The Management of Customer-Contact Service Employees: An Empirical Investigation.Journal of Marketing,60(4),52-70.
  37. Hofmann, D. A.(1997).An Overview of the Logic and Rationale of Hierarchical Linear Models.Journal of Management,23(6),723-744.
  38. Homburg, C.,Wieseke, J.,Bornemann, T.(2009).Implementing the Marketing Concept at Employee-Customer Interface: The Role of Customer Need Knowledge.Journal of Marketing,73(4),64-81.
  39. Homeburg, C.,Stock, R. M.(2005).Exploring the Conditions under which Salesperson Work Satisfaction Can Lead to Customer Satisfaction.Psychology & Marketing,22(5),392-420.
  40. Hwang, I. S.,Chi, D. J.(2005).Relationships among Internal Marketing, Employee Job Satisfaction and International Hotel Performance: An Empirical Study.International Journal of Management,22(2),285-293.
  41. Iacobucci, D.,Grayson, K.,Ostrom, A.(1994).Customer Satisfaction Fables.Sloan Management Review,35(4),93-96.
  42. Iacobucci, D.,Ostrom, A.,Grayson, K.(1995).Distinguishing Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction: The Voice of the Consumer.Journal of Consumer Psychology,4(3),277-303.
  43. Jongbloded, B.(2003).Marketisation in Higher Education, Clark's Triangle and the Essential Ingredients of Markets.Higher Education Quarterly,57(2),110-135.
  44. Karantinou, K. M.,Hogg, M. K.(2001).Exploring Relationship Management in Professional Service: A Study of Management Consultancy.Journal of Marketing Management,17(3-4),263-286.
  45. Keller, S. B.,Lynch, D. F.,Ellinger, A. E.,Ozment, J.,Calantone, R.(2006).The Impact of Internal Marketing Efforts in Distribution Service Operation.Journal of Business Logistics,27(1),109-137.
  46. Lam, S. K.,Kraus, F.,Ahearne, M.(2010).The Diffusion of Market Orientation throughout title Organization: A Social Learning Theory Perspective.Journal of Marketing,74(5),61-79.
  47. Liao, H.,Chuang, A.(2004).A Multilevel Investigation of Factors Influencing Employee Service Performance and Customer Outcomes.Academy of Management Journal,47(1),41-58.
  48. Lings, I. N.(1999).Managing Service Quality with Internal Marketing Schematics.Long Range Planning,32(4),452-463.
  49. Lings, I. N.(2004).Internal Market Orientation Construct and Consequences.Journal of Business Research,57(4),405-413.
  50. Logaj, V.,Trnavcevic, A.(2006).Internal Marketing and Schools: The Slovenian Case Study.Managing Global Transitions,4(1),79-96.
  51. Mathieu, J. E.,Schulze, W.(2006).The Influence of Team Knowledge and Formal Plans on Episodic Team Process- Performance Relationships.Academy of Management Journal,49(3),605-619.
  52. Mohr, L. A.,Bitner, M. J.(1995).The Role of Employee Effort in Satisfaction with Service Transactions.Journal of Business Research,32(2),239-252.
  53. Mudie, P.(2003).Internal Customer: By Design or by Default.European Journal of Marketing,37(9),1261-1276.
  54. O''cass, A.(2001).The Internal-External Marketing Orientation of a Political Party: Social Implication of Political Party Marketing Orientation.Journal of Public Affairs,1(2),136-152.
  55. Oliver, R. L.(1980).A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction Decisions.Journal of Marketing Research,17(4),460-469.
  56. Oliver, R. L.(1999).Whence Consumer Loyalty?.Journal of Marketing,63(4),33-44.
  57. Rafiq, M.,Ahmed, P. K.(2000).Advances in the Internal Marketing Concept: Definition, Synthesis and Extension.Journal of Service Marketing,14(6),449-462.
  58. Snell, L.,White, L.(2009).An Exploratory Study of the Application of Internal Marketing in Service Organizations.Service Marketing Quarterly,30(3),195-211.
  59. Tansuhaj, P.,Randall, D.,McCullough, J.(1988).A Service Marketing Management Model: Integrating Internal and External Marketing Functions.The Journal of Service Marketing,2(1),31-38.
  60. Thomas, D. R. E.(1978).Strategy Is Different in Service Industry.Harvard Business Review,56(4),158-165.
  61. Tsai, Y.,Tang, T. W.(2008).How to Improve Service Quality: Internal Marketing as a Determining Factor.Total Quality Management & Business Excellence,19(11),1117-1126.
  62. Voss, G. B.,Godfrey, A.,Seiders, K.(2010).How Complementarity and Substitution Alter the Customer Satisfaction-Repurchase Link.Journal of Marketing,74(6),111-127.
  63. Wieseke, J.,Ahearne, M.,Lam, A. K.,van Dick, R.(2009).The Role of Leaders in Internal Marketing.Journal of Marketing,73(2),123-145.
  64. Yi, Y.,La, S.(2004).What Influences the Relationship Between Customer Satisfaction and Repurchase Intention? Investigating the Effects of Adjusted Expectations and Customer Loyalty.Psychology & Marketing,21(5),351-373.
  65. Zeithaml, V. A.,Bitner, M. J.(2003).Services Marketing: Integrating Customer Focus across the Firm.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  66. 吳清山(2007)。中華民國教育年報。台北:國立教育資料館。
  67. 洪順慶(2005)。行銷管理。台北:新陸書局股份有限公司。
  68. 洪順慶(2003)。從心行銷─從滿意到愛慕的服祕訣。台北:天下雜誌服份有限公司。
  69. 曹耀鈞、黃俊英(2004)。台灣技職院校應積極採取的行銷作為─以正修科技大學為例。正修學報，17，209-218。
  70. 莊英慎、林水順(2003)。顧客對高等教育機構行銷特性認知分析─以中華大學為例。中華管理學報，4(3)，91-113。
  71. 棚部得博、鍾淑娟譯(2000)。行銷大事典。台北:小知學文化。
  72. 溫福星(2006)。階層線性模式。台北:雙葉書廊有限公司。
  73. 溫福星、邱皓政(2011)。多層次模式方法論。台北:新亞測驗評量暨技術發展中心。
被引用次数
  1. 鄭之勛(2017)。以服務行銷觀點探討公立醫院的醫療服務品質管理。國立臺灣大學碩士在職專班國際企業管理組學位論文。2017。1-105。 
print cancel