化舊助新：反向型師徒、知識分享與組織創新之個案研究

Turning Old to Enable New: A Case Study on Knowledge Sharing of Reverse Mentoring for Organizational Innovation

10.6160/SYSMR.202203_30(2).0003

陳登煌(Teng-Huang Chen)；陳蕙芬(Hui-Fen Chen)

反向型師徒 ； 知識分享 ； 組織創新 ； 質性個案研究 ； Reverse Mentoring ； Knowledge Sharing ； Organizational Innovation ； Qualitative Case Study

中山管理評論

30卷2期（2022 / 03 / 01）

325 - 366

繁體中文

科技進展與環境變遷，創新成為迫切需求；世代差異擴大，跨世代工作共處，運用世代間差異成為管理重點。本研究探討反向型師徒的知識分享如何有益組織創新。師徒研究著重於分析傳統型師徒、師徒功能與益處、培訓等主題，較少研究探討反向型師徒、知識分享與組織創新。知識分享文獻也很少探討跨世代知識如何整合的議題。本研究選取一家傳統紡織業者為個案，採詮釋型質性個案研究，以人員訪談與實地觀察搜集資料。本研究發現反向型師徒的知識分享，與產品、製程與管理創新間有巧妙聯結，及三種轉化舊知識方式—活化認知、細化技能與融化情意。由此新觀點帶出理論與實務貢獻。反向型師徒，協助舊組織將時代變遷所帶來的阻力，轉化為組織創新之助力。

In the context of the expansion of generational differences and the rapid evolution of technology, this paper explores the application of ＂reverse mentoring＂ in organizations. The reverse mentoring exploit the knowledge gap between generations and transforms into a source of organizational innovation through knowledge sharing. In the past, the study of mentoring focused on the analysis of traditional apprenticeship, formal or informal apprenticeship, and apprenticeship functions. Few studies have focused on the sharing of knowledge between mentors and mentees. Besides, these studies also neglected to examine the reverse mentoring, a younger and less experienced mentor and an elder and more experienced mentee. This study selected a traditional industry (textile industry) as a case study, employed a qualitative case study method, using personnel interviews and observations as the primary data collection method, and analyzing the factory's weaving of shallow staff and senior staff. The findings showed that how reverse mentoring could promote organizational innovation. In theory, this paper proposes an interpretation of the knowledge sharing of the reverse mentoring relationship and points out another way to promote organizational innovation. In practice, this study argues that organizations can use reverse mentoring to drive product innovation, process innovation, and management innovation. The reverse mentoring can help the old organizations transform the barriers brought by the time changes into the enablers for organizational innovation.

1. Liao, S. H.,Fei, W. C.,Chen, C. C.(2007).Knowledge Sharing, Absorptive Capacity, and Innovation Capability: An Empirical Study of Taiwan's Knowledge-Intensive Industries.Journal of Information Science,33(3),340-359.
   連結：
2. 王思峰, S. F.,林于荻, Y. D.,陳禹辰, Y. C.(2003)。組識文化如何影響知識分享之探索性個案研究。臺大管理論叢，13(2)，59-99。
   連結：
3. 李昭蓉, J.-R.(2012)。師徒怎麼配？論師徒功能、員工知識分享與創新行為關係中師徒類型之調節角色。人力資源管理學報，12(4)，81-105。
   連結：
4. 侯勝宗, S.-T.(2012)。見所未見：詮釋性個案研究方法初探。組織與管理，5(1)，111-153。
   連結：
5. 姜定宇, D.-Y.,葛玉璇, Y.(2018)。因人而異的知識分享：對自己人偏私的調節效果。人力資源管理學報，18(2)，1-30。
   連結：
6. 許芳銘, F.-M.,張志舜, C.-S.(2006)。與解決問題有關的知識分享互動模式─以認知觀點。交大管理學報，26(2)，187-214。
   連結：
7. 廖述賢, S.-H.,吳啓絹, C.-C.,胡大謙, D.-C.,樂薏嵐, Y.-L.(2008)。組織文化、知識取得、組織學習與組織創新關聯性之研究。人力資源管理學報，8(4)，1-29。
   連結：
8. 廖國鋒, G.-F.,吳建平, C.-P.(2007)。個體工作滿足、知識分享與組織創新能力之關聯性研究。科技管理學刊，12(4)，1-34。
   連結：
9. 鄭瑩妮, Y.-N.,胡昌亞, C.,簡世文, S.-W.(2013)。師徒功能與徒弟知識分享。商略學報，5(1)，37-56。
   連結：
10. Alexander, L.,Van Knippenberg, D.(2014).Teams in Pursuit of Radical Innovation: A Goal Orientation Perspective.Academy of Management Review,39(4),423-438.
11. Alsop, R.(2008).The Trophy Kids Grow Up: How the Millennial Generation Is Shaking Up the Workplace.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
12. Blau, J. R.,McKinley, W.(1979).Ideas, Complexity, and Innovation.Administrative Science Quarterly,24(2),200-219.
13. Boisot, M.(1998).Knowledge Assets: Securing Competitive Advantage in the Information Economy.New York:Oxford University Press.
14. Bryant, S. E.(2005).The Impact of Peer Mentoring on Organizational Knowledge Creation and Sharing: An Empirical Study in a Software Firm.Group & Organization Management,30(3),319-338.
15. Burdett, J.(2014).Reverse Mentoring Becomes a Two-Way Street: Case Study of a Mentoring Project for IT Competence.Development and Learning in Organizations: An International Journal,28(3),13-16.
16. Černe, M.,Hernaus, T.,Dysvik, A.,Škerlavaj, M.(2017).The Role of Multilevel Synergistic Interplay Among Team Mastery Climate, Knowledge Hiding, and Job Characteristics in Stimulating Innovative Work Behavior.Human Resource Management Journal,27(2),281-299.
17. Chaudhuri, S.,Ghosh, R.(2012).Reverse Mentoring: A Social Exchange Tool for Keeping the Boomers Engaged and Millennials Committed.Human Resource Development Review,11(1),55-76.
18. Chen, Y. C.(2013).Effect of Reverse Mentoring on Traditional Mentoring Functions.Leadership and Management in Engineering,13(3),199-208.
19. Connelly, C. E.,Zweig, D.,Webster, J.,Trougakos, J. P.(2012).Knowledge Hiding in Organizations.Journal of Organizational Behavior,33(1),64-88.
20. Cotugna, N.,Vickery, C. E.(1998).Reverse Mentoring: A Twist to Teaching Technology.Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics,98(10),1166-1168.
21. Daft, R. L.,Lengel, R. H.(1986).Organizational Information Requirements, Media Richness and Structural Design.Management Science,32(5),513-644.
22. Davenport, T. H.,Prusak, L.(1998).Working Knowledge: How Organizations Manage What They Know.Boston:Harvard Business School Press.
23. Dierickx, I.,Cool, K.(1989).Asset Stock Accumulation and Sustainability of Competitive.Advantage Management Science,35(12),1504-1511.
24. Dunning, J. H.(2000).The Eclectic Paradigm as an Envelope for Economic and Business Theories of MNE Activity.International Business Review,9(2),163-190.
25. Feldman, M. S.,Orlikowski, W. J.(2011).Theorizing Practice and Practicing Theory.Organization Science,22(5),1240-1253.
26. Finkelstein, L. M.,Allen, T. D.,Rhoton, L. A.(2003).An Examination of the Role of Age in Mentoring Relationships.Group & Organization Management,28(2),249-281.
27. Ghobadi, S.(2015).What Drives Knowledge Sharing in Software Development Teams: A Literature Review and Classification Framework.Information & Management,52(1),82-97.
28. Gibbert, M.,Krause, H.(2002).Practice Exchange in a Best Practice Marketplace.Knowledge Management Case Book: Siemens Best Practices,NJ:
29. Gioia, D. A.,Corley, K.,Hamilton, A.(2012).Seeking Qualitative Rigor in Inductive Research: Notes on the Gioia Methodology.Organizational Research Methods,16(1),15-31.
30. Glaser, B. G.,Strauss, A. L.(1967).The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research.Chicago:Aldine.
31. Gold, A. H.,Malhotra, A.,Segars, A. H.(2001).Knowledge Management: An Organizational Capabilities Perspective.Journal of Management Information Systems,18(1),185-214.
32. Goodyear, M.(2006).Mentoring: A Learning Collaboration.Educause Quarterly,29(4),51-53.
33. Grant, R. M.(1996).Toward a Knowledge ‐ Based Theory of the Firm.Strategic Management Journal,17(S2),109-122.
34. Haas, M. R.,Hansen, M. T.(2007).Different Knowledge, Different Benefits: Toward a Productivity Perspective on Knowledge Sharing in Organizations.Strategic Management Journal,28(11),1133-1153.
35. Haggard, D. L.,Dougherty, T. W.,Turban, D. P.,Wilbanks, J. E.(2011).Who is a Mentor? A Review of Evolving Definitions and Implications for Research.Journal of Management,37(1),280-304.
36. Harvey, M.,McIntyre, N.,Thompson Heames, J.,Moeller, M.(2009).Mentoring Global Female Managers in the Global Marketplace: Traditional, Reverse, and Reciprocal Mentoring.The International Journal of Human Resource Management,20(6),1344-1361.
37. Hendriks, P.(1999).Why Share Knowledge? The Influence of ICT on the Motivation for Knowledge Sharing.Knowledge and Process Management,6(2),91-100.
38. Hodge, B. J.,Anthony, W. P.,Gales, L. M.(1996).Organization Theory: A Strategic Approach.New Jersey:Prentice-Hall.
39. Intezari, A.,Taskin, N.,Pauleen, D. J.(2017).Looking Beyond Knowledge Sharing: An Integrative Approach to Knowledge Management Culture.Journal of Knowledge Management,21(2),492-515.
40. Koulopoulos, T.,Keldsen, D.,林添貴（譯）(2017).Z世代效應：改變未來企業經營的六股力量.台北市:時報文化出版.
41. Kram, K. E.(1985).Mentoring at Work: Developing Relationships in Organizational Life.Glenview:Scott, Foresman and Company.
42. Kram, K. E.(1983).Phases of the Mentor Relationship.Academy of Management Journal,26(4),608-625.
43. Kremer, H.,Villamor, I.,Aguinis, H.(2019).Innovation Leadership: Best-Practice Recommendations for Promoting Employee Creativity, Voice, and Knowledge Sharing.Business Horizons,62(1),65-74.
44. Lee, P.,Gillespie, N.,Mann, L.,Wearing, A.(2010).Leadership and Trust: Their Effect on Knowledge Sharing and Team Performance.Management Learning,41(4),473-491.
45. Leh, A. S.(2005).Lessons Learned from Service Learning and Reverse Mentoring in Faculty Development: A Case Study in Technology Training.Journal of Technology and Teacher Education,13(1),25-41.
46. Locke, K. D.(2001).Grounded Theory in Management Research.London:Sage.
47. Moon, T. M.(2014).Mentoring the Next Generation for Innovation in Today’s Organization.Journal of Strategic Leadership,5(1),23-35.
48. Mooradian, T.,Renzl, B.,Matzler, K.(2006).Who Trusts? Personality, Trust and Knowledge Sharing.Management Learning,37(4),523-540.
49. Morris, L. V.(2017).Reverse Mentoring: Untapped Resource in the Academy?.Innovative Higher Education,42(4),285-287.
50. Murphy, W.(2012).Reverse Mentoring at work: Fostering Cross‐Generational Learning and Developing Millennial Leaders.Human Resource Management,51(4),549-573.
51. Noe, R. A.(1988).An Investigation of the Determinants of Successful Assigned Mentoring Relationships.Personnel Psychology,41(3),457-479.
52. Nonaka, I.,Takeuchi, H.(1995).The Knowledge-Creating Company: How Japanese Companies Create the Dynamics of Innovation.New York:Oxford University Press Inc..
53. Nonaka, I.,Von Krogh, G.,Voelpel, S.(2006).Organizational Knowledge Creation Theory: Evolutionary Paths and Future Advances.Organization Studies,27(8),1179-1208.
54. Orlikowski, W. J.(2002).Knowing in Practice: Enacting a Collective Capability in Distributed Organizing.Organization Science,13(3),249-273.
55. Pachana, N. A.(ed.)(2015).Encyclopedia of Geropsychology.New York:Springer.
56. Rahman, Z.,De Clercq, D.,Wright, B.,Bouckenooghe, D.(2016).Explaining Employee Creativity: The Roles of Knowledge-Sharing Efforts and Organizational Context.Academy of Management Proceeding,389-394.
57. Rhee, Y. W.,Choi, J. N.(2017).Knowledge Management Behavior and Individual Creativity: Goal Orientations as Antecedents and In-Group Social Status as Moderating Contingency.Journal of Organizational Behavior,38(6),813-832.
58. Samson, D.(1991).Manufacturing and Operations Strategy.Melbourne:Prentice Hall.
59. Scandura, T. A.(1992).Mentorship and Career Mobility: An Empirical Investigation.Journal of Organizational Behavior,13(2),169-174.
60. Scandura, T. A.(1998).Dysfunctional Mentoring Relationships and Outcomes.Journal of Management,24(3),449-467.
61. Swap, W.,Leonard, D.,Shields, M.,Abrams, L.(2001).Using Mentoring and Storytelling to Transfer Knowledge in the Workplace.Journal of Management Information Systems,18(1),95-114.
62. Szulanski, G.(1996).Exploring Internal Stickiness: Impediments to the Transfer of Best Practice Within the firm.Strategic Management Journal,17(S2),27-43.
63. Tidd, J.,Bessant, J.,Pavitt, K.(2005).Managing Innovation: Integrating Technological, Market and Organizational Change.Chichester:John Wiley and Sons Ltd..
64. Turban, D. B.,Dougherty, T. W.(1994).Role of Protégé Personality in Receipt of Mentoring and Career Success.Academy of Management Journal,37(3),688-702.
65. Wanberg, C. R.,Welsh, E. T.,Hezlett, S. A.(2003).Mentoring Research: A Review and Dynamic Process Model.Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management,22,39-124.
66. Wang, C. L.,Ahmed, P. K.(2004).The Development and Validation of the Organisational Innovativeness Construct Using Confirmatory Factor Analysis.European Journal of Innovation Management,7(4),303-313.
67. Wang, T.,Zatzick, C. D.(2019).Human Capital Acquisition and Organizational Innovation: A Temporal Perspective.Academy of Management Journal,62(1),99-116.
68. Yang, J.-T.(2007).The Impact of Knowledge Sharing on Organizational Learning and Effectiveness.Journal of Knowledge Management,11(2),83-90.
69. Zauchner-Studnicka, S.(2017).A model for Reverse-Mentoring in Education.International Journal of Educational and Pedagogical Science,11(3),551-558.
70. 朱思年, S.-N.,陳蕙芬, H.-F.,游銘仁, M.-J.,吳靜吉, J.-J.(2016).師徒關係與社會創新的在地實踐.台北市=Taipei City:遠流=Yuan-Liou Publishing Co., Ltd..
71. 蕭瑞麟, R.-L.(2017).不用數字的研究：質性研究的思辨脈絡.台北=Taipei City:五南=Wu-Nan Book Inc.

1. 楊秀萍,范惟翔(2023)。AR魔鏡融入美髮業成功之研究。管理資訊計算，12(2)，31-43。
2. (2023)。旅行社領隊專業人員知識分享動機與效益之探討。島嶼觀光研究，14(4)，1-21。