自我控制是否能促進老年人在變異練習的獲益？

Can Self-Control Facilitate the Benefit of Variable Practice in Older Adults?

10.6222/pej.4602.201306.0604

林靜兒(Ching-Er Lin)；卓俊伶(Hank Jwo)

動作學習 ； 恆常練習 ； 絕對誤差 ； 變異誤差 ； 保留測驗 ； motor learning ； constant practice ； absolute error ； variable error ； retention tests

體育學報

46卷2期（2013 / 06 / 01）

143 - 152

繁體中文

目的：過去研究發現變異的練習情境並未對老年人的動作學習帶來較大的效益，因此本研究結合自我控制的概念與基模理論所演繹的練習變異性假說，旨在探討自我控制對老年人在變異練習動作表現與學習的影響。方法：將36位自願參加的女性老年人（平均年齡71.1 ± 4.5歲）隨機分派至自我控制－變異練習組、無自我控制－變異練習組或恆常練習組，依變項為絕對誤差值與變異誤差值，實驗工作為三段式N字型相對時宜的按鍵工作，經過獲得期90次的試作後，進行10分鐘與一天後各12次的立即與延遲保留測驗。結果：獲得期經3（組別）×9（區間）混合設計二因子變異數分析，其中區間為重複量數，以及最小平方法的事後比較發現，老年人在有無自我控制變異練習的絕對誤差值與變異誤差值未達統計顯著差異，但兩組變異練習的絕對誤差值均大於恆常練習組且達統計顯著差異。立即與延遲保留測驗經單因子變異數分析發現，有無自我控制變異練習的絕對誤差值與變異誤差值未達統計顯著差異，但兩組變異練習的絕對誤差值在立即保留測驗中大於恆常練習組且達統計顯著差異。結論：老年人在變異練習情境的動作表現與學習不受自我控制影響。

Purpose: Previous studies found that the variable practice condition didn't promote benefits for motor learning in older adults. Therefore, this study combined the concept of self-control with the variability of practice hypothesis, which derived from the Schema theory, to investigate the effects of self-controlled variable practice on motor performance and learning in older adults. Methods: Thirty six female older adults (mean age = 71.1 ± 4.5 years) served as participants, whom were randomly assigned to one of variable practice with self-control group, variable practice without self-control group, and constant practice group. Dependent variables were absolute error and variable error scores. Participants practiced three movement patterns of ”N” shape that had the same relative timing. Each participant practiced 90 trails during acquisition. Ten minutes immediate retention and 24 hours delayed retention tests, which consisted of 12 trails. Results: Mixed-design 3 (group) × 9 (block) ANOVA with repeated measures on block for acquisition and post hoc of LSD indicated that no statistical significance were found on variable practice between with and without self-control in terms of absolute error and variable error scores. But constant practice group was significant less than variable practice groups on absolute error score. One way ANOVA for immediate and delay retentions indicated that no statistical significance were found on variable practice between with and without self-control in terms of absolute error and variable error scores. But constant practice group was significant less than variable practice groups in immediate retention on absolute error score. Conclusions: It is concluded that there is no effect of self-controlled variable practice on motor performance and learning in older adults.

1. 卓俊伶(2004)。老年人相對時宜動作表現與學習的練習變異效應。臺灣運動心理學報，5，87-99。
   連結：
2. 葉俊良、卓俊伶、林靜兒、陳重佑(2007)。自我控制回饋對空間性動作表現、學習及錯誤估計的效應。大專體育學刊，9(1)，23-35。
   連結：
3. Adams, J. A.(1971).A closed-loop theory of motor learning.Journal of Motor Behavior,3,111-149.
4. Adams, J. A.(1987).Historical review and appraisal of research on the learning, retention, and transfer of human motor skills.Psychological Bulletin,101,41-74.
5. Adams, J. A.(1961).The second facet of forgetting: A review of warm-up decrement.Psychological Bulletin,58,257-273.
6. Cavanaugh, J. C.,Blanchard-Fields, F.(2011).Adult development and aging (6th ed.).Belmont, CA:Wadsworth.
7. Chiviacowsky, S.,Wulf, G.(2002).Self-controlled feedback: Does it enhance learning because performers get feedback when they need it?.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,73,408-415.
8. Chiviacowsky, S.,Wulf, G.(2005).Self-controlled feedback is effective if it is based on the learner's performance.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,76,42-48.
9. Dick, M. B.,Hsieh, S.,Dick-Muehlke, C.,Davis, D. S.,Cotman, C. W.(2000).The variability of practice hypothesis in motor learning: Does it apply to Alzheimer's disease?.Brain and Cognition,44,470-489.
10. Hergenhahn, B. R.,Olson, M. H.(2008).An introduction to theories of learning (8th ed.).Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
11. Janell, C. M.,Barba, D. A.,Frehlich, S. G.,Tennant, L. K.,Cauraugh, J. H.(1997).Maximizing performance feedback effectiveness through videotape replay and a self-controlled learning environment.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,68,269-279.
12. Janelle, C. M.,Kim, J.,Singer, R. N.(1995).Subject-controlled performance feedback and learning of a closed motor skill.Perceptual and Motor Skills,81,627-634.
13. Kirk, R. E.(1995).Experimental design: Procedures for the behavior science (3rd ed.).Pacific Grove, CA:Brooks/Cole.
14. Lin, C. E.,Jwo, H.,Chen, C. Y.(2003).Age differences in the variability of practice hypothesis.VII IOC Olympic World Congress on Sport Sciences,Athens, Greece:
15. Magill, R. A.(2011).Motor learning and control: Concepts and applications (9th ed.).New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
16. Magnuson, C. E.,Wright, D. L.(2004).Random practice can facilitate the learning of tasks that have different relative time structures.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,75,197-202.
17. McCraken, H. D.,Stelmach, G. E.(1977).A test of the schema theory of discrete motor learning.Journal of Motor Behavior,9,193-201.
18. Moxley, S. E.(1979).Schema: The variability of practice hypothesis.Journal of Motor Behavior,11,65-70.
19. Newell, K. M.,Shapiro, D. C.(1976).Variability of practice and transfer of training: Some evidence toward a schema view of motor learning.Journal of Motor Behavior,8,233-244.
20. Schmidt, R. A.(1975).A schema theory of discrete motor skill learning.Psychological Review,82,225-260.
21. Schmidt, R. A.,Lee, T. D.(2011).Motor control and learning: A behavioral emphasis (5th ed.).Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
22. Schunk, D. H.(2012).Learning theories: An educational perspective (6th ed.).Boston, MA:Pearson Education.
23. Spirduso, W. W.,Francis, K. L.,MacRae, P. G.(2005).Physical dimensions of aging (2nd ed.).Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
24. Titzer, R.,Shea, J.,Romack, J.(1993).The effect of learner control in the acquisition and retention of a motor task.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,15(suppl.),S84.
25. Wu, W.,Magill, R. A.(2011).Allowing learners to choose: Self-controlled practice schedules for learning multiple movement patterns.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,82,449-457.
26. Wulf, G.,Clauss, A.,Shea, C. H.,Whitacre, C.(2001).Benefits of self-control in dyad practice.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,72,299-303.
27. Wulf, G.,McNevin, N.,Shea, C. H.,Wright, D. L.(1999).Learning phenomena: Future challenges for the dynamical systems approach to understanding the learning of complex motor skills.International Journal of Sport Psychology,30,531-557.
28. Wulf, G.,Toole, T.(1999).Physical assistance devices in complex motor skill learning: Benefits of a self-controlled practice schedule.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,70,265-272.
29. 黃富順(1995)。老化與健康。臺北市:師大書苑。

1. 李宗蓁,吳忠誼(2021)。理性與身體感性的共融－對網球選手類型區辨的現象學探索。體育學報，54(1)，87-105。