以集群分析方式檢驗華人家長式領導在運動員基本心理需求與動機和動機相關變項間差異情形

Examination of relationships between paternalistic leadership behavior and psychological needs satisfaction or thwarting, motivation, and well-being or ill-being of college team sport athletes: A cluster analysis approach

10.6222/pej.202303_56(1).0008

聶喬齡(Chiao-Lin Nien)；徐碧昭(Pi-Chao Hsu)；李炳昭(Ping-Chao Lee)

自我決定理論 ； 恩德型 ； 需求威脅 ； 適應性結果 ； 領導類型 ； self-determination theory ； selfless benefactor PL leaders ； need thwarting ； adaptive outcome ； leadership style

體育學報

56卷1期（2023 / 03 / 01）

125 - 142

繁體中文;英文

緒論：教練領導行為被視為影響運動員動機及幸福感重要的社會因素之一。對應以西方文化為主的研究成果，華人家長領導行為對於運動員動機歷程和幸福感相關議題研究在國內較不受到重視。本研究以集群分析方式，針對華人家長式領導行為進行集群分組，探索有意義和實際的領導類型，並進一步考驗不同領導類型對於大專團隊運動員在心理需求的滿足和威脅、自我決定動機、幸福感相關指標上的差異。方法：以跨情境的研究設計，241位大專團隊項目運動員（男性佔61%）為對象，進行資料蒐集。在取得知情同意後，填寫華人家長式領導、基本心理需求滿足與威脅、自我決定動機和主觀幸福感、活力感、正負面情緒以及運動倦怠等問卷，進行兩階段式的集群分析，並以多變量變異數分析，檢驗不同領導類型在動機歷程上相關變項上的差異。結果：集群分析發現，三個有意義的領導風格分組，分別是全面型（n=76）、全無型（n=81）、和威德型（n=73）。多變量變異數分析發現，不同組別有差異存在（V=.40, F_(（32,426）)=3.33, p <.05, Eta=.20）。後續分析發現，除了自主性和隸屬感需求受挫外，大部份的適應性結果（需求滿足、自主動機、主觀幸福感、活力感和正面情緒）與非適應性結果（勝任能力受挫、控制動機、無動機、負面情緒與運動倦怠分量表）存在不同領導類型間的差異。其中，全面型的運動員，呈現出高適應性和低非適應性的結果，而威德型則是相反。全無型的運動員在部份非適應性的變項上與威德型類似。結論：集群分析結果呈現特定華人家長式領導類型實際組合，提供各自理論主張的延伸。全無型和威德型在需求滿足受挫，動機類型以及動機結果上的差異提供仁慈領導之外威權領導產生的影響，並做為未來在自我決定理論中，探索本土教練威權領導的啟發。

Introduction: One of the most crucial social factors affecting athletes' motivation and wellbeing is the coach. Few studies have investigated the impacts of paternalistic leadership (PL) behavior on satisfaction or thwarting of psychological needs and motivation- and well-being-related outcomes in sports in Taiwan. This study aimed to explore meaningful PL clusters using a cluster analysis approach and to examine differences in their impacts on satisfaction or thwarting of psychological needs, motivation, and well-being- or ill-being-related variables. Methods: Two hundred and forty-one college team sport athletes were involved in this study. A cross-sectional design was used, and questionnaires were delivered after informed consent was obtained. MANOVA was performed on SDT motivation and well-being-related variables after meaningful groups were found in the cluster analysis. Results: The cluster analysis yielded three groups: laisser-faire PL group (n = 81); authentic PL group (n = 76); and disciplinarian PL group (n = 73). The groups were significantly different (V = .40, F_((32, 4268)) = 3.33, p < .05, eta = .20). Post-hoc results revealed that the disciplinarian PL group was the most maladapted; in contrast, the laisser-faire PL group was similar to the disciplinarian PL group in some motivational variables. Conclusion: The combination of PL and needs satisfaction or thwarting suggests that further investigation of the relationship theory of SDT and PL is warranted.

1. 李烱煌, C.-H.(2016)。運動動機量表第二版之構念效度。體育學報，49(3)，289-302。
   連結：
2. 高三褔, S.-F.,張俊一, C.-Y.(2015)。家長式領導在運動團隊的研究：期刊論文的回顧與分析。臺灣運動心理學報，15(2)，75-106。
   連結：
3. 張文馨, W.-S.,陳思羽, S.-Y.,季力康, L.-K.(2012)。運動熱情與主觀幸福感的關係：正向情緒的中介效果。體育學報，45(4)，301-309。
   連結：
4. 陳建瑋, C.-W.,季力康, L.-K.(2009)。大學生不同運動階段基本心理需求與主觀幸福感之相關研究。體育學報，42(1)，25-37。
   連結：
5. 彭譯箴, Y.-C.,沈緯鈞, W.-J.(2018)。知覺教練領導風格：變項及以人為中心取向的檢視。體育學報，51(2)，169-186。
   連結：
6. 楊鎮瑭, C.-T.,高三福, S.-F(2017)。教練家長式領導八種類型與信任教練、團隊價值觀的關係。臺灣運動心理學報，17(1)，23-37。
   連結：
7. 樊景立, J.-L.,鄭伯壎, B.-S.(2000)。華人組織的家長式領導：一項文化觀點的分析。本土心理學研究，13，126-180。
   連結：
8. 鄭伯壎, B.-S.(2004)。華人文化與組織領導：由現象描述到理論驗證。本土心理學研究，22，195-251。
   連結：
9. 盧俊宏, J.-H.,陳龍弘, L.-H.,卓國雄, K.-H.(2006)。Raedeke和Smith 運動員倦怠問卷（ABQ）之信效度研究。體育學報，39(3)，83-94。
   連結：
10. Balaguer, I.,González, L.,Fabra, P.,Castillo, I.,Mercé, J.,Duda, J. L.(2012).Coaches' interpersonal style, basic psychological needs and the well- and ill-being of young soccer players: A longitudinal analysis.Journal of Sports Sciences,30(15),1619-1629.
11. Bartholomew, K. J.,Ntoumanis, N.,Thøgersen-Ntoumani, C.(2009).A review of controlling motivational strategies from a self-determination theory perspective: Implications for sports coaches.International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology,2(2),215-233.
12. Bartholomew, K. J.,Ntoumanis, N.,Thøgersen-Ntoumani, C.(2011).Psychological need Thwarting in the sport context: Assessing the darker side of athletic experience.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,33(1),75-102.
13. Chen, B.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Beyers, W.,Boone, L.,Deci, E. L.,Van der Kaap-Deeder, J.,Duriez, B.,Lens, W.,Matos, L.,Mouratidis, A.,Ryan, R. M.,Sheldon, K. M.,Soenens, B.,Van Petegem, S.,Verstuyf, J.(2015).Basic psychological need satisfaction, need frustration, and need strength across four cultures.Motivation and Emotion,39(2),216-236.
14. Cronbach, L. J.(1951).Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests.Psychometrika,12,1-16.
15. Curran, T.,Appleton, P. R.,Hill, A. P.,Hall, H. K.(2011).Passion and burnout in elite junior soccer players: The mediating role of self-determined motivation.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,12(6),655-661.
16. Deci, E. L.(Ed.),Ryan, R. M.(Ed.)(2002).Handbook of self-determination theory.University of Rochester Press.
17. Deci, E. L.(Ed.),Ryan, R. M.(Ed.)(2002).Handbook of self-determination research.University of Rochester Press.
18. Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.(2012).Motivation, personality, and development within embedded social contexts: An overview of self-determination theory.Oxford handbook of human motivation
19. Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.(2000).The "What" and "Why" of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior.Psychological Inquiry,11(4),227-268.
20. Delrue, J.,Reynders, B.,Broek, G. V.,Aelterman, N.,De Backer, M.,Decroos, S.,De Muynck, G.-J.,Fontaine, J.,Fransen, K.,van Puyenbroeck, S.,Haerens, L.,Vansteenkiste, M.(2019).Adopting a helicopter-perspective towards motivating and demotivating coaching: A circumplex approach.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,40,110-126.
21. Delrue, J.,Soenens, B.,Morbée, S.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Haerens, L.(2019).Do athletes’ responses to coach autonomy support and control depend on the situation and athletes’ personal motivation?.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,43,321-332.
22. Farh, J. L.,Liang, L.,Chou, L. F.,S., C. B.(2008).Paternalistic leadership in Chinese organizations: Research progress and future research directions.Leadership and management in China: Philosophies, theories, and practices
23. Field, A.(Ed.)(2013).Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS statistics.Sage.
24. Gillison, F. B.,Rouse, P.,Standage, M.,Sebire, S. J.,Ryan, R. M.(2019).A meta-analysis of techniques to promote motivation for health behaviour change from a selfdetermination theory perspective.Health Psychology Review,13(1),110-130.
25. Haerens, L.,Aelterman, N.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Soenens, B.,Van Petegem, S.(2015).Do perceived autonomy-supportive and controlling teaching relate to physical education students' motivational experiences through unique pathways? Distinguishing between the bright and dark side of motivation.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,16,26-36.
26. Haerens, L.,Vansteenkiste, M.,De Meester, A.,Delrue, J.,Tallir, I.,Vande Broek, G.,Goris, W.,Aelterman, N.(2018).Different combinations of perceived autonomy support and control: Identifying the most optimal motivating style.Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy,23(1),16-36.
27. Hodge, K.,Lonsdale, C.,Ng, J. Y.(2008).Burnout in elite rugby: Relationships with basic psychological needs fulfilment.Journal of Sports Sciences,26(8),835-844.
28. Howard, J.,Gagné, M.,Bureau, J.(2017).Testing a continuum structure of selfdetermined motivation: A meta-analysis.Psychological Bulletin,143(12),1346-1377.
29. Jõesaar, H.,Hein, V.,Hagger, M. S.(2012).Youth athletes’ perception of autonomy support from the coach, peer motivational climate and intrinsic motivation in sport setting: One-year effects.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,13(3),257-262.
30. Kline, R. B.(2015).Principles and practice of structural equation modeling.Guilford.
31. Langan, E.,Hodge, K.,McGowan, S.,Carney, S.,Saunders, V.,Lonsdale, C.(2016).The influence of controlled motivation alongside autonomous motivation: Maladaptive, buffering, or additive effects?.International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,14(1),57-71.
32. Lundqvist, C.(2011).Well-being in competitive sports—The feel-good factor? A review of conceptual considerations of well-being.International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology,4(2),109-127.
33. Mageau, G.,Vallerand, R.(2003).The coach-athlete relationship: A motivational model.Journal of Sports Sciences,21,883-904.
34. Mossman, L. H.,Slemp, G. R.,Lewis, K. J.,Colla, R. H.,O’Halloran, P.(2022).Autonomy support in sport and exercise settings: A systematic review and metaanalysis.International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology,1-24.
35. Ntoumanis, N.,Ng, J. Y. Y.,Prestwich, A.,Quested, E.,Hancox, J. E.,ThøgersenNtoumani, C.,Deci, E. L.,Ryan, R. M.,Lonsdale, C.,Williams, G. C.(2021).A meta-analysis of self-determination theory-informed intervention studies in the health domain: Effects on motivation, health behavior, physical, and psychological health.Health Psychology Review,15(2),214-244.
36. Reynders, B.,Van Puyenbroeck, S.,Ceulemans, E.,Vansteenkiste, M.,Vande Broek, G.(2020).How do profiles of need-supportive and controlling coaching relate to team athletes' motivational outcomes? A person-centered approach.Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,42,452-462.
37. Ryan, R. M.,Deci, E. L.(2017).Self-determination theory: Basic psychological needs in motivation, development, and wellness
38. Ryan, R. M.,Deci, E. L.(2019).Brick by rick: The origins, development, and future of self-determination theory.Advances in Motivation Science
39. Ryan, R. M.,Deci, E. L.(2017).Sport, pyhsical activity, and physical education.Self-determination theory: Basic psychological needs in motivation, development, and wellness
40. Standage, M.,Curran, T.,Rouse, P. C.(2018).Self-determination-based theories of sport, exercise, and physical activity motivation.Advances in sport and exercise psychology
41. Standage, M.,Ryan, R. M.(2012).Self-determination theory and exercise motivation: Facilitating self-regulatory processes to support and maintain health and well-being.Advances in motivation in sport and exercise
42. Teixeira, P. J.,Carraça, E. V.,Markland, D.,Silva, M. N.,Ryan, R. M.(2012).Exercise, physical activity, and selfdetermination theory: A systematic review.International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity,9(1),78.
43. Tessier, D.,Smith, N.,Tzioumakis, Y.,Quested, E.,Sarrazin, P.,Papaioannou, A.,Digelidis, N.,Duda, J. L.(2013).Comparing the objective motivational climate created by grassroots soccer coaches in England, Greece and France.International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,11(4),365-383.
44. Van der Kaap-Deeder, J.,Soenens, B.,Ryan, R. M.,Vansteenkiste, M.(2020).Manual of the Basic Psychological Need Satisfaction and Frustration Scale (BPNSFS).Ghent University.
45. 莊耀嘉, Y.-C.,黃光國, K.-K.(1981)。國中學生的成敗歸因與無助感特徵。中華心理學刊，23(2)，155-164。
46. 鄭伯壎, B.-S.(2005).華人領導：理論與實際.桂冠=LaureateBook.

1. (2024)。比較不同文化背景的控制型教練行為。大專體育，167，1-16。
2. (2024)。運動場域中賦權與削權動機氣候的學理發展與特徵。大專體育，168，1-14。