遊客破壞行為之環境因素：以露營場野餐桌遭遊客破壞為例

Environmental Factors of Visitors’ Vandalism: A Case Study of Carvings on Campground Picnic Tables

10.6267/JTLS.2016.22(1)2

楊增華(Tzeng-Hua Yang)；林欣儀(Shin-Yi Lin)；陳昶霖(Chang-Lin Chen)

環境暗示 ； 環境因子 ； 環境設計 ； 環境設計預防犯罪 ； 破窗理論 ； environmental cue ； environmental factor ； environmental design ； crime prevention through environmental design ； broken windows theory

觀光休閒學報

22卷1期（2016 / 04 / 01）

37 - 59

繁體中文

本研究探索哪些環境因素能誘導或抑制遊客破壞行為，研究以露營場野餐桌為研究對象，並依犯罪預防領域之「防衛空間理論」設計調查表，記錄野餐桌週遭的8 項環境因素，以及野餐桌遭遊客破壞的情形。研究發現，野餐桌已遭破壞的程度越大，遭到新破壞程度會越大。黃色野餐桌遭新破壞之情況高於暗紅色野餐桌。管理程度較強的露營地，野餐桌遭破壞的情況較輕微。研究發現能實質影響遊客心理之環境因素才與破壞行為之發生有關，遊憩管理單位宜儘速修復遭破壞的設施，藉以釋放此處不可破壞的意象予遊客，同時注意園區的設計與管理，以有效抑制破壞行為發生。研究結果有助於犯罪預防的理論建構，並協助管理單位制定防止遊客破壞的有效策略。

This study aims to explore which environmental factors can encourage or deter vandal. Picnic tables on campgrounds were selected as research subjects. According to Newman’s Defensible space theory, eight environmental factors, surrounding picnic tables as well as carvings on picnic tables were recorded. The results indicated that the extent of new carvings on picnic tables was significantly related to the extent of previous carvings. Compared with dark-red picnic tables, yellow picnic tables have a higher probability of new carvings. In addition, well-managed campgrounds have fewer new carvings on their picnic tables than those that are poorly managed. This study demonstrates that only environmental factors can essentially affect vandals’ intentions. The campground management should repair vandalized equipment as soon as possible and take good care of the campground to demonstrate that vandalism is not allowed in the property. The results of this study could both increase knowledge of crime prevention and prevent tourist vandalism in recreation areas.

1. 張樑治、宋秉明(2003)。為什麼遊客會破壞遊憩環境？統整五套不同理論後的觀點。犯罪學期刊，6(1)，283-300。
   連結：
2. 楊增華、鄭雅筠(2013)。環境態度與情境因素對遊客破壞行為之影響－以陽明山國家公園遊客亂丟垃圾行為為例。戶外遊憩研究，26(4)，89-98。
   連結：
3. Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations, British Columbia, Canada. (2013). Forest vandalism. Retrieved July 27, 2013, from http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/ftp/dpg/external/!publish/!web/Recreation/recreation.htm
4. Keep America Beautiful. (2010). Litter in America: Results from the nation's largest litter study.Retrieved September 16, 2014, from http://www.kab.org/site/DocServer/LitterFactSheet_ COSTS.pdf?docID=5183
5. Abdullah, A.,Marzbali, M. H.,Bahauddin, A.,Maghsoodi M. J.(2012).The relationship between territorial functioning and victimisation: A comparative study of high and low crime rate estates.Social and Behavioral Sciences,50,899-908.
6. Barker, M.,Bridgeman, C.(1994).Preventing vandalism: What works?.Crime detection and prevention series (No. 56),56
7. Bell, P. A.,Greene, T. C.,Fisher, J. D.,Baum, A.(2001).Environmental psychology.Fort Worth, TX:Harcourt College.
8. Bellizzi, J. A.,Hite, R. E.(1992).Environmental color, consumer feelings, and purchase likelihood.Psychology and Marketing,9(5),347-363.
9. Brown, B. B.,Altman, I.(1983).Territoriality, defensible space and residential burglary: An environmental analysis.Journal of Environmental Psychology,3(3),203-220.
10. Brown, G.,Devlin, A. S.(2003).Vandalism: Environmental and social factors.Journal of College Student Development,44(4),502-516.
11. Buck, A. J.,Hakim, S.,Swanson, C.,Rattner, A.(2003).Vandalism of vending machines: Factors that attract professionals and amateurs.Journal of Criminal Justice,31(1),85-95.
12. Carrasco, M.,Barker, E. D.,Tremblay, R. E.,Vitaro, F.(2006).Eysenck's personality dimensions as predictors of male adolescent trajectories of physical aggression, theft and vandalism.Personality and Individual Differences,41(7),1309-1320.
13. Chang, L.-C.,Chen, C.-C.(2009).An interaction effect of visitor moral emotions and perceived defensible space on flower picking in national forest recreation areas.Taiwan Journal of Forest Science,24(2),79-90.
14. Christine, F.-M.(2013).Advanced color image processing and analysis.New York:Springer.
15. Cialdini, R. B.,Reno, R. R.,Kallgren, C. A.(1990).A focus theory of normative conduct:Recycling the concept of norms to reduce littering in public places.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,58(6),1015-1026.
16. Corraliza, J. A.,Berenguer, J.(2000).Environmental values, beliefs, and actions: A situational approach.Environment and Behavior,32(6),832-848.
17. Dijkstra, K.,Pieterse, M. E.,Pruyn, A. Th. H.(2008).Individual differences in reactions towards color in simulated healthcare environments: The role of stimulus screening ability.Journal of Environmental Psychology,28(3),268-277.
18. Gärling, T.(Ed.),Golledge, R. G.(Ed.)(1993).Behavior and environment: Psychological and geographical approaches.Amsterdam:North-Holland.
19. Gärling, T.(Ed.),Golledge, R.G.(Ed.)(1993).Behavior and environment: Psychological and geographical approaches.Amsterdam:North-Holland.
20. Goldstein, A. P.(1996).The psychology of vandalism.New York:Plenum.
21. Gramann, J. H.,Bonifield, R. L.,Kim, Y.-G.(1995).Effect of personality and situational factors on intentions to obey rules in outdoor recreation areas.Journal of Leisure Research,27(4),326-343.
22. Hakim, S.,Rengert, G. F.,Shachmurove, Y.(2001).Target search of burglars: A revised economic model.Papers in Regional Science,80,121-137.
23. Hakim, S.,Shachmurove, Y.(1996).Spatial and temporal attributes of commercial burglaries.American Journal of Economics and Sociology,55(4),443-456.
24. Herndon, R. W.,Iacono, W. G.(2005).Psychiatric disorder in the children of antisocial parents.Psychological Medicine,35(12),1815-1824.
25. Heywood, J. L.,Murdock, W. E.(2002).Social norms in outdoor recreation: Searching for the behavior-condition link.Leisure Sciences,24(3-4),283-295.
26. Ibitayo, O. O.,Virden, R. J.(1996).Visitor and manager perception of depreciative behavior in urban park setting.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,14(4),36-51.
27. Lin, I. Y.(2004).Evaluating a servicescape: The effect of cognition and emotion.International Journal of Hospitality Management,23(2),163-178.
28. Lin, I. Y.,Mattila, A. S.(2010).Restaurant servicescape, service encounter, and perceived congruency on customers' emotions and satisfaction.Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management,19(8),819-841.
29. Manfredo, M.(Ed.)(1992).Influencing human behavior.Champaign, IL:Sagamore.
30. Newman, O.(1996).Creating defensible space.Washington, DC:U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Policy Development and Research.
31. Newman, O.(1972).Defensible space: Crime prevention through urban design.New York:Macmillan.
32. Rezaee, S.,Rao, S. P.,Arbi, E.(2010).Vandalism in Tehran, Iran: Influence of some of the urban environmental factors.Journal of Design and Built Environment,6,1-10.
33. Rhee, S. H.,Waldman, I. D.(2002).Genetic and environmental influences on antisocial behavior: A meta-analysis of twin and adoption studies.Psychological Bulletin,128(3),490-529.
34. Samdahl, D. M.,Christensen, H. H.(1985).Environmental cues and vandalism: An exploratory study of picnic table carving.Environment and Behavior,17(4),445-458.
35. Scott, M. L.,La Vigne, N. G.,Palmer, T.(2007).Preventing vandalism.Washington, DC:The Urban Institute Justice Policy Center.
36. Swearingen, T. C.,Johnson, D. R.(1995).Visitors' responses to uniformed park employees.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,13(1),73-85.
37. Taylor, R. B.,Gottfredson, S. D.,Brower, S.(1984).Block crime and fear: Defensible space, local social ties, and territorial functioning.Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency,21(4),303-331.
38. Teevan, J. J.,Dryburgh, H. B.(2000).First person accounts and sociological explanations of delinquency.Canadian Review of Sociology,37(1),77-93.
39. Weisburd, D.,Groff, E. R.,Yang, S.-M.(2014).Understanding and controlling hot spots of crime: The importance of formal and informal social controls.Prevention Science,15(1),31-43.
40. Welsh, B. C.,Farrington, D. P.(2008).Effects of improved street lighting on crime.Oslo, Norway:The Campbell Collaboration.
41. Welsh, B. C.,Farrington, D. P.(2004).Surveillance for crime prevention in public space:Results and policy choices in Britain and America.Criminology and Public Policy,3(3),497-526.
42. Willemse, H. M.(1996).Overlooking crime prevention: Ten years of crime prevention in the Netherlands.Security Journal,7(3),177-184.
43. Wilson, J. Q.,Kelling, G. L.(1982).Broken windows: Police and neighborhood safety.Atlantic Monthly,249(3),29-38.
44. Wise, J.(1982).A gentle deterrent to vandalism.Psychology Today,82,31-38.
45. Yavuz, A.,Kuloğlu, N.(2010).An experimental study on vandalism: Trabzon Parks.Scientific Research and Essays,5(17),2463-2471.
46. 江慶興(1998)。破窗理論與犯罪偵防－以美國紐約市警察局為例。警學叢刊，29(3)，71-92。
47. 邱淑蘋(1997)。公共圖書館破壞行為之研究－原因、結果及預防之道。台北市立圖書館館訊，15(2)，1-10。
48. 徐磊青、楊公俠(2005)。環境心理學：環境、知覺和行為。台北=Taipei, Taiwan:五南文化=Wu-Nan Culture。
49. 張樑治、余嬪、陳朝圳(2008)。亂丟垃圾成因：綜合遊客道德情緒與森林遊樂區防衞空間因子之觀點。中華林學季刊，41(1)，77-92。
50. 楊士隆(2006)。犯罪心理學。台北=Taipei, Taiwan:五南文化=Wu-Nan Culture。
51. 楊國樞編、文崇一編、吳聰賢編、李亦園編(1989)。社會及行為科學研究法。台北=Taipei, Taiwan:東華書局=Tunghua。
52. 謝淑敏(2003)。從犯罪學理論探討考詴作弊預防對策。復興崗學報，78，315-332。

1. 董俊廷、楊增華(2018)。低自我控制與環境因素對遊客違規戲水行為之影響。戶外遊憩研究，31(2)，1-24。
2. 董孟修(2019)。台灣戒嚴時期至2018年的露營活動。戶外遊憩研究，32(4)，91-121。
3. 謝炎君、林栢章、林晏瑜、林玥秀(2016)。以Tenbrunsel and Smith-Crowe 倫理決策模型探討餐旅系學生之倫理察覺與決策行為。觀光休閒學報，22(3)，251-276。
4. 楊增華,黃（女禹）靖(2021)。告示牌對遊客不當行為意向之影響－以陽明山國家公園擎天崗遊客跨越欄杆為例。戶外遊憩研究，34(3)，1-27。