發展遲緩兒幼兒園活動參與研究

Participation of Children with Developmental Delay in Preschool Activities

10.6172/BSE.201807_43(2).0002

謝中君(Jung-jiun Shie)

活動參與 ； 發展遲緩兒 ； 驗證性因素分析 ； confirmatory factory analysis ； developmental delay ； participation

特殊教育研究學刊

43卷2期（2018 / 07 / 31）

31 - 64

繁體中文

本研究目的有二：一、編製一份觀察者評量「幼兒園活動參與量表」，建立其信度及效度資料；二、探討發展遲緩兒在幼兒園活動中的參與情形。自編評量表為利用跨活動情境的設計來建立參與的共同因素，以四種幼兒園常見的活動情境（團體討論、繪畫、團體遊戲及自由遊戲活動）來編寫題目，各活動題目於進行探索性因素分析後，找出四個活動的共同因素，即專注、回應、合適行為及互動，再以共同因素的原始題目作為觀察變項，進行二階驗證性因素分析。結果顯示，專注、回應、合適行為之二階因素模式有良好適配度，自由遊戲之互動模式的適配度亦佳。共有153位正常發展幼兒及16位發展遲緩兒參與正式量表編製。本評量表與「文蘭適應行為量表」的同時效度亦合宜。本評量表具有合適的評分者一致性信度，參與研究的評分者均經過訓練，評分者一致性之同意度已達.8。利用自編「幼兒園活動參與量表」評量就讀臺北市22個融合班級30對3至6歲發展遲緩兒及其正常發展同儕的參與表現，結果發現發展遲緩兒在專注、回應表現及自由活動的互動表現均較同儕差，惟在合適行為表現上，發展遲緩兒在四個活動的表現與其同儕相近。此外，發展遲緩兒在繪畫、團體遊戲、自由遊戲的回應表現均比團體討論活動佳，但四個活動的專注或合適行為表現，彼此間沒有顯著差異。

Purpose: This study was twofold. First, the study developed an assessment tool called the Preschool Activity Participation Scale (PAPS) to help professionals observe and evaluate children's participation in preschool activities; the reliability and validity of the PAPS were also established. Second, the study evaluated the performance of the participation of the children with and without developmental delay. Methods: The PAPS was designed to establish the shared constructs of participation within the most common contexts in preschool activities. The test items were designed for each of the following four preschool activities: circle time, drawing, games, and free play. The validation process was as follows. (1) Test items were designed according to the context of each activity and examined and revised separately through an exploratory factor analysis. (2) After the analysis, four shared constructs were identified, namely attention, response, adequate behavior, and interaction. (3) A second-order confirmatory factor analysis was utilized to examine the fitness of the three shared constructs, namely attention, response, and adequate behavior. The test items for the four activities in each shared construct were used as the observation variables and analyzed through a second-order confirmatory factor analysis. Results/Findings: The results indicated that the fitness of the following shared construct patterns was adequate: attention, response, and adequate behavior. The construct pattern of interaction tested through the confirmatory factory analysis was satisfactory. A total of 153 children with normal development and 16 with developmental delay (DD) participated in the process of the confirmatory factor analysis. (4) The concurrent validity of the PAPS was also examined through the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale (VABS). The results showed the concurrent validity between the PAPS and VABS to be adequate. Notably, the interrater reliability was 0.8. The participation of the 30 pairs of children with and without DD was assessed by the PAPS. Conclusions/Implications: The results indicated that children with DD had significantly lower scores than their peers on the construct of attention in the circle time, group games, and free play activities; on the construct of response in all four activities; and on the construct of interaction in the free play activity. Notably, the children from both groups demonstrated similar performance levels on the construct of adequate behavior. Additionally, children with DD performed better in the activities of drawing, games, and free play than in the activity of circle time in terms of the construct of response. Children with DD performed similarly on the constructs of attention and adequate behavior in all four activities.

1. 陳介宇、蔡昆瀛(2009)。「幼兒情緒與行為問題檢核表」編製之研究。測驗年刊，56(2)，235-268。
   連結：
2. 趙麗華、王天苗(2013)。「學前兒童社會行為量表」編製之研究。測驗學刊，60，741-766。
   連結：
3. 蔡明富、吳裕益、莊涵皓(2014)。「學前兒童社會行為評量系統」編製之研究。特殊教育研究學刊，39(2)，1-31。
   連結：
4. 特殊教育法（2014）： 中華民國一百零三年六月十八日總統華總一義字第10300093311 號令公布。[The Special Education Act (2014). The Presidential Order No. Hua-Zong-Yi-Yi-Zi 10300093311 promulgated June 18, 2014.]
5. Bailey, D.(Ed.),Wolery, M.(Ed.)(1992).Teaching infants and preschooles with disability.New York, NY:MacMillan.
6. Bedell, G.,Coster, W.(2008).Measuring participation of school-aged children with traumatic brain injuries: Considerations and approaches.Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation,23(4),220-229.
7. Bronson, M.,Hauser-Cram, P.,Warfield, M.(1995).Classroom behaviors of preschool children with and without developmental disabilities.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,16(3),371-390.
8. Brown, M.,Gordon, W.(1987).Impact of impairment on activity patterns of children.Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation,68,828-832.
9. Brown, W.,Odom S.,Li, S.,Zercher, C.(1999).Ecobehaviroal assessment in early childhood programs: A portrait of preschool inclusion.The Journal of Special Education,33(3),138-153.
10. Bult, M.,Verschuren, O.,Gorter, J.,Jongmans, M.,Piskur, B.,Ketelaar, M.(2010).Cross-cultural validation and psychometric evaluation of the Dutch language version of the children's assessment of participation and enjoyment (CAPE) in children with and without physical disabilities.Clinical Rehabilitation,24(9),843-853.
11. Burstein, N.(1986).The effects of classroom organization of mainstreamed preschool children.Exceptional Children,52(5),425-434.
12. Carta, J.,Greenwood, C.,Atwater, J.(1985).ESCAPE: Ecobeheavioral system for complex assessments of preschool environments.Kansas, KS:University of Kansas, Juniper Gardens Children's Project, Bureau of Child Research.
13. Carta, J.,Greenwood, C.,Schute, D.,Arreaga-Mayer, C.,Terry, B.(1988).Code for instructional structure and student academic response: Mainstream version (MS-CISSAR).Kansas, KS:University of Kansas, Juniper Gardens Children's Project, Bureau of Child Research.
14. Chen, J. Q.,McNamee, G. D.(2007).Bridging: Assessment for teaching and learning in early childhood classroom, Pre-3.Thousand Oaks, CA:Corwin Press.
15. Coster, W.,Khetani, M.(2008).Measuring participation of children with disabilities: Issues and challenges.Disability and Rehabilitation,30(8),639-648.
16. de Bildt, A.,Sytema, S.,Kraijer, D.,Sparrow, S.,Minderaa, R.(2005).Adaptive functioning and behaviour problems in relation to level of education in children and adolescents with intellectual disability.Journal of Intellectual Disability Research,49(9),672-681.
17. DeWein, M.,Miller, L.(2008).The effect of a teacher report on the sustainability of an intervention to facilitate engagement by a child with developmental delays.Education and Treatment of Children,31(3),333-350.
18. Dunst, C. J.,Bruder, M.,Trivette, C.,Hamby, D.,Raab, M.,McLean, M.(2001).Characteristics and consequences of everyday natural learning opportunities.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,21(2),68-92.
19. Dunst, C. J.,Hamby, D.,Trivette, C. M.,Raab, M.(2002).Young children's participation in everyday family and community activity.Psychological Reports,91(3),875-897.
20. Dunst, C. J.,Trivette, C.,Humphries, T.,Raab, M.,Roper, N.(2001).Contrasting approaches to natural learning environment interventions.Infants and Young Children,14(2),48-63.
21. Ehrmann, L.,Aeschleman, S.,Svanum, S.(1995).Parental reports of community activity patterns: A comparison between young children with disabilities and their nondisabled peers.Research in Developmental Disabilities,16(4),331-343.
22. Eriksson, L.,Welander, J.,Granlund, M.(2007).Participation in everyday school activities for children with and without disabilities.Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities,19(5),485-502.
23. Finn, J. Folger, J.,Cox, D.(1991).Measuring participation among elementary grade students.Educational and Psychological Measurement,51(2),393-402.
24. Finn, J.,Pannozzo, G.(2004).Classroom organization and student behavior in kindergarten.The Journal of Educational Research,98(2),79-92.
25. Finn, J.,Pannozzo, G.,Voelkl, K.(1995).Disruptive and inattentive-withdrawn behavior and achievement among fourth graders.The Elementary School Journal,95(5),421-434.
26. Fisher, A.,Bryze, K.,Hume, V.,Griswold, L.(2007).School AMPS: School version of the assessment of motor and process skills.Fort Collins, CO:Three Star Press.
27. Fredricks, J.,Blumenfeld, P.,Paris, A.(2004).School engagement: Potential of the concept, state of the edvidence.Review of Education Research,74(1),59-109.
28. Godfrey, S.,Grisham-Brown, J.,Schuster, J.,Hemmeter, M.(2003).The effects of three techniques on student participation with preschool children with attending problems.Education and Treatment of Children,26(3),255-272.
29. Goncu, A.(Ed.)(1999).Children's engagement in the world: Sociocultural perspectives.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
30. Hooper, D.,Coughlan, J.,Mullen, M.(2008).Structural equation modelling: Guidelines for determining model fit.Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods,6(1),53-60.
31. Hunt, P.,Soto, G.,Maier, J.,Doering K.(2003).Collaborative teaming to support students at risk and students with severe disabilities in general education classrooms.Exceptional Children,69(3),315-332.
32. Hunt, P.,Soto, G.,Maier, J.,Liboiron, N.,Bae, S.(2004).Collaborative teaming to support preschoolers with severe disabilities who are placed in general education early childhood programs.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,24(3),123-142.
33. Huston, A.,Wright, J.,Marquis, J.,Green, S.(1999).How young children spend their time: Television and other activities.Developmental Psychology,35(4),912-925.
34. Imms, C.(2008).Children with cerebral palsy participate: A review of the literature.Disability and Rehabilitation,30(24),1867-1884.
35. King, G.,Law, M.,King, S.,Hurley, P.,Hanna, S.,Kertoy, M.,Rosenbaum, P.,Young, N.(2004).Children's assessment of participation and enjoyment (CAPE) and preferences for activities of children (PAC).San Antonio, TX:Harcourt Assessment.
36. Kishida, Y.,Kemp, C.(2006).Measuring child engagement in inclusive early childhood settings: Implications for practice.Australian Journal of Early Childhood,31(2),14-19.
37. Kishida, Y.,Kemp, C.(2006).A measure of engagement for children with intellectual disabilities in early childhood settings: A preliminary study.Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability,31(2),101-114.
38. Kishida, Y.,Kemp, C.,Carter, M.(2008).Revision and validation of the individual child engagement record: A practitioner-friendly measure of learning opportunities for children with disabilities in early childhood settings.Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability,33(2),158-170.
39. Kontos, S.,Moore, D.,Giorgetti, K.(1998).The ecology of inclusion.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,18(1),38-48.
40. Law, M.(2002).Participation in the occupations of everyday life.American Journal of Occupational Therapy,56(6),640-649.
41. Mahoney, G.,Wheeden, C.(1999).The effect of teacher style on interactive engagement of preschool-aged children with special learning needs.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,14(1),51-68.
42. Malmskog, S.,McDonnell, A.(1999).Teacher-mediated facilitation of engagement by children with developmental delays in inclusive preschools.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,19(4),203-216.
43. McBride, B.,Schwartz, I.(2003).Effects of teaching early interventionists to use discrete trials during ongoing classroom activities.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,23(1),5-17.
44. McCormick, L.,Noonan, M.,Heck, R.(1998).Variables affecting engagement in inclusive preschool classrooms.Journal of Early Intervention,21(2),160-176.
45. McWilliam R. A.,de Kruif, R. E.(1998).Engagement quality observation system III (E-Qual).Chapel Hill, NC:Frank Porter Graham Child Development Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
46. McWilliam, R. A.(1991).Children's engagement questionnaire.Chapel Hill, NC:Frank Porter Graham Child Development Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
47. McWilliam, R. A.(1991).Targeting teaching at children's use of time. Perspectives on preschooler's engagement.Teaching Exceptional Children,23(4),42-43.
48. McWilliam, R. A.,Bailey, D.(1995).Effects of classroom social structure and disability on engagement.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,15(2),123-147.
49. McWilliam, R. A.,Trivette, C. M.,Dunst, C.(1985).Behavior engagement as a measure of the efficacy of early intervention.Analysis and Intervention in Developmental Disabilites,5(1-2),59-71.
50. Morrison, R.,Sainato, D.,Benchaaban, D.,Endo, S.(2002).Increasing play skills of children with aitism using activity schedules and correspondence training.Journal of Early Intervention,25(1),58-72.
51. Noreau, L.,Lepage, C.,Boissiere, L.,Picard, R.,Fougeyrollas, P.,Mathieu, J.,Desmarais, G.,Nadeau, L.(2007).Measuring participation in children with disabilities using the Assessment of Life Habits.Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology,49(9),666-671.
52. Norris, C.,Pignal, J.,Lipps, G.(2003).Measuring school engagement.Educational Quarterly Review,9(2),25-34.
53. Odom, S.,Peterson, C.,McConnell, S.,Ostrosky, M.(1990).Ecobehavioral analysis of early education/specialized classroom settings and peer social interaction.Education and Treatment of Children,13(4),316-330.
54. Ponitz, C.,Rimm-Kaufman, S.,Grimm, K.,Curby, T.(2009).Kindergarten classroom quality, behavioral quality, and reading achievement.School Psychology Review,38(1),102-120.
55. Rimm-Kaufman, S. E.(2005).Rimm-Kaufman, S. E. (2005). Classroom observation protocal for the early learning study. Unpublishied protocol, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA..
56. Rimm-Kaufman, S.,La Paro, K.,Downer, J.,Pianta, R.(2005).The contribution of classroom setting and quality of instruction to children's behavior in kindergarten classrooms.The Elementary School Journal,105(4),377-394.
57. Robertson, J.,Green, K.,Alper, S.,Schloss, P.,Kohler, F.(2003).Using a peer-mediated intervention to facilitate children's participation in inclusive childcare activities.Education and Treatment of Children,26(2),182-197.
58. Soo, C.,Tate, R.,Williams, L.,Waddingham, S.,Waugh, M.(2008).Development and validation of the paediatric care and needs scale (PCANS) for assessing support needs of children and youth with acquired brain injury.Developmental Neurorehabilitation,11(3),204-214.
59. Staudt, M.(2007).Treatment engagement with caregivers of at risk children: Gaps in research and conceptualization.Journal of Child and Families Studies,16(2),183-196.
60. Strain, P.,Cassandra, D.,Kohler, F.(1995).Activity engagement and social interaction development in young children with autism: An examination of "Free" intervention effects.Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders,3(2),108-123.
61. Tabachnick, B.,Fidell, L.(2006).Using multivariate statistics.Boston, MA:Allyn &Bacon.
62. Thompson, T.(Ed.),Felce, D.(Ed.),Symons, F. J.(Ed.)(2000).Behavioral observation: Technology and applications in developmental disabilities.Baltimore, MD:Paul. H. Brookes.
63. Wilson, L.,Mott, D.,Batman, D.(2004).The asset-based context matrix: A tool for assessing children's learning opportunities and participation in natural environments.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,24(2),110-120.
64. Wiltz, N.,Klein, E.(2001)."What do you do in child care" children's perceptions of high and low quality classrooms.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,16(2),209-236.
65. Wolery, M.R.,Pauca, T.,Brashers, M.,Grant, S.(2000).Quality of inclusive experiences measure.Chapel Hill, NC:Frank Porter Graham Child Development Center.
66. World Health Organization(2001).International classification of functioning, disability, and health.Geneva, Switzerland:Author.
67. World Health Organization(2007).Internaional classification of functioning, disability, and health-Child and youth.Geneva, Switzerland:Author.
68. 王莉惠、簡淑真(1990)。幼兒教師引導行為與幼兒學習行為關係之研究。中等教育，41(5)，9-15。
69. 朱家雄(2006)。幼兒園課程。臺北=Taipei Taiwan:五南=Wu-Nan Books。
70. 吳武典、張正芬、盧台華、邱紹春(2004)。修訂文蘭適應行為量表指導手冊。臺北=Taipei Taiwan:心理=Psychological。
71. 周淑惠(2006)。幼兒園課程與教學：探究取向之主題課程。臺北=Taipei Taiwan:心理=Psychological。
72. 林芷榆(2009)。臺東=Taitung, Taiwan，國立臺東大學幼兒教育研究所=National Taitung University。
73. 張博雅(2008)。新北市=New Taipei, Taiwan，輔仁大學兒童與家庭研究所=Fu-Zen University。
74. 陳政見、劉英森(2001)。幼稚園兒童活動量評量表。臺北=Taipei Taiwan:心理=Psychological。
75. 黃永寬(2005)。幼兒運動遊戲之學習行為研究。國立體育學院論叢，16，1-15。
76. 鄒啟蓉、盧台華(2000)。發展遲緩幼兒社會行為及相關問題研究。特殊教育研究學刊，20，171-191。
77. 蔡昆瀛(2004)。教師行為對發展遲緩幼兒及普通幼兒之影響效能研究。台北市立師範學院學報，35，23-46。

1. 李穎安(2021)。自閉症與注意力缺陷過動症兒童之口語敘事表現。特殊教育季刊，158，37-48。