题名

工會領導者謙遜與工會團隊集體謙遜對勞資關係氣候的影響：檢視勞資合作的中介角色

并列篇名

Exploring the Effects of Union Leader Humility and Collective Humility of Union Management Team on Industrial Relations Climate: Mediating Role of Union-Enterprise Cooperation

DOI

10.6147/JHRM.201912_19(2).0003

作者

林豪傑(Hao-Chieh Lin)；郭嘉博(Jia-Bo Guo)；王議賢(Yi-Hsien Wang)

关键词

勞資關係氣候 ； 勞資合作 ； 高層理論 ； 領導者謙遜 ； 集體謙遜 ； industrial relations climate ； union-enterprise cooperation ； upper echelons theory ； leader humility ； collective humility

期刊名称

人力資源管理學報

卷期/出版年月

19卷2期（2019 / 12 / 01）

页次

57 - 82

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究檢視工會領導者謙遜與工會團隊集體謙遜對勞資關係氣候的影響。藉由蒐集55位人資主管與163位工會幹部的55組配對問卷資料，結果顯示工會領導者謙遜會提升工會團隊的集體謙遜；另勞資合作在工會領導者謙遜及工會團隊集體謙遜與勞資關係氣候之間具完全中介作用。過去研究大多探討勞資關係氣候對員工態度或行為的影響，經檢視工會領導者特質在組織層次之勞資合作與關係氣候中的角色，本研究填補勞資關係文獻之缺口。另檢視工會領導者謙遜的外溢效果，亦回應學者主張擴大高層理論的適用對象、全面地探討領導者與團隊之社會性互動對組織運作的影響。而從組織內部互動為主軸的研究脈絡，延伸到企業與工會的關係介面，本研究也提升了謙遜研究的理論意涵。
英文摘要

This study employs the upper echelons theory to examine the respective effect of union leader humility and collective humility of union management team on industrial relations climate. Analytical results based on 55 sets of dyadic data collected from 55 human resource supervisors and 163 union stewards show that union leader humility produces a spillover effect on union management team and thus promotes collective humility. Also, union-enterprise cooperation plays a full mediating role in translating union leader humility and collective humility of union management team into advantageous industrial relations climate. Our study contributes to the industrial relations and upper echelons research. By exploring how union leader characteristics shape union-enterprise cooperation and relationship climate at the organization-level, we complement prior studies, which tend to examine the effects of industrial relations climate on employee attitude and behaviors. An examination of the spillover effects of union leader humility also responds to recent calls for expanding the research targets of upper echelons theory and more comprehensively identifying the effects of the social dynamics between top leaders and their cadre on an organization. Moreover, we advance the theoretical implications of humility research by extending its prior oblique focus on intra-organizational dynamics to inter-organizational interface as well.
主题分类 社會科學 > 心理學
社會科學 > 社會學
社會科學 > 經濟學
社會科學 > 管理學
社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. 彭台光,高月慈,林鉦棽(2006)。管理研究中的共同方法變異：問題本質、影響、測試和補救。管理學報，23，77-98。
    連結：
  2. 蔡維奇,紀乃文(2008)。團隊情感氛圍形成的前因 、 情境調節及個人層次後果變項之研究。組織與管理，1(1)，1-37。
    連結：
  3. Ackers, P.(2017).Waving not drowning: British industrial relations in the twenty-first century.British Journal of Industrial Relations,55,672-675.
  4. Ancona, D.,Malone, T. W.,Orlikowski, W. J.,Senge, P. M.(2007).In praise of the incomplete leader.Harvard Business Review,85(2),92-100.
  5. Andrevski, G.,Richard, O. C.,Shaw, J. D.,Ferrier, W. J.(2014).Racial diversity and firm performance: The mediating role of competitive intensity.Journal of Management,40,820-844.
  6. Angle, H. L.,Perry, J. L.(1986).Dual commitment and labor-management relationship climates.Academy of Management Journal,29,31-50.
  7. Argyle, M.(1991).Cooperation: The basis of sociability.New York:Routledge.
  8. Barling, J.,Fullagar, C.,Kelloway, E. K.(1992).The union and its members: A psychological approach.New York:Oxford University Press.
  9. Berson, Y.,Da’as, R,Waldman, D. A.(2015).How do leaders and their teams bring about organizational learning and outcomes?.Personnel Psychology,68,79-108.
  10. Bollen, K. A.(Ed.),Long, J. S.(Ed.)(1993).Testing structural equation models.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
  11. Bromiley, P.,Rau, D.(2016).Social behavioral, and cognitive influences on upper echelons during strategy process: A literature review.Journal of Management,42,174-202.
  12. Burke, C. S.,Stagl, K. C.,Klein, C.,Goodwin, G. F.,Salas, E.,Halpin, S. M.(2006).What type of leadership behaviors are functional in teams? A meta-analysis.The Leadership Quarterly,17,288-307.
  13. Butler, P. D.,Swift, M.,Kothari, S.,Nazeeri-Simmons, I.,Friel, C. M.,Longaker, M. T.,Britt, L. D.(2011).Integrating cultural competency and humility training into clinical clerkships: Surgery as a model.Journal of Surgical Education,68,222-230.
  14. Cannella, A. A.,Holcomb, T. R.(2005).A multi-level analysis of the upper-echelons model.Multi-Level Issues in Strategy and Methods,4,195-237.
  15. Chan, D.(1998).Functional relations among constructs in the same content domain at different levels of analysis: A typology of composition models.Journal of Applied Psychology,83,234-246.
  16. Chatterjee, A.,Hambrick, D. C.(2007).It's all about me: Narcissistic chief executive officers and their effects on company strategy and performance.Administrative Science Quarterly,52,351-386.
  17. Chen, G.,Bliese, P. D.(2002).The role of different levels of leadership in predicting self-and collective efficacy: Evidence for discontinuity.Journal of Applied Psychology,87,549-556.
  18. Chen, M.-J.(2014).Presidential address-Becoming ambicultural: A personal quest, and aspiration for organizations.Academy of Management Review,39,119-137.
  19. Chen, M.-J.,Miller, D.(2015).Reconceptualizing competitive dynamics: A multidimensional framework.Strategic Management Journal,36,758-775.
  20. Cheung, M. F.,Wu, W. P.(2014).Leader-member exchange and industrial relations climate: mediating of participatory management in China.Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources,52,255-275.
  21. Colbert, A. E.,Barrick, M. R.,Bradley, B. H.(2014).Personality and leadership composition in top management teams: Implications for organizational effectiveness.Personnel Psychology,67,351-387.
  22. Collins, J.(2001).Level 5 leadership: The triumph of humility and fierce resolve.Harvard Business Review,79(1),66-76.
  23. Dastmalchian, A.,Blyton, P.,Adamson, R.(1989).Industrial relations climate: Testing a construct.Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,62,21-32.
  24. de Andrés-Alonso, P.,Azofra-Palenzuela, V.,Romero-Merino, M. E.(2010).Beyond the disciplinary role of governance: How boards add value to Spanish foundations.British Journal of Management,21,100-114.
  25. De Prins, P.,Stuer, D.,Gielens, T.(2018).Revitalizing social dialogue in the workplace: The impact of a cooperative industrial relations climate and sustainable HR practices on reducing employee harm.The International Journal of Human Resource Management
  26. Deery, S. J.,Iverson, R. D.(2005).Labor-management cooperation: Antecedents and impact on organizational performance.Industrial and Labor Relations Review,58,588-609.
  27. Deery, S. J.,Iverson, R. D.,Erwin, P.(1999).Industrial relations climate, attendance behaviour and the role of trade unions.British Journal of Industrial Relations,37,533-558.
  28. Dobbins, T.,Dundon, T.(2017).The chimera of sustainable labour-management partnership.British Journal of Management,28,519-533.
  29. Drucker, P. F.(1992).The new society of organizations.Harvard Business Review,70(5),95-104.
  30. Eaton, A. E.,Rubinstein, S. A.,Kochan, T. A.(2008).Balancing acts: Dynamics of a union coalition in a labor management partnership.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society,47,10-35.
  31. Edwards, J. R.,Rothbard, N. P.(2000).Mechanisms linking work and family: Clarifying the relationship between work and family constructs.Academy of Management Review,25,178-199.
  32. Fan, X.,Thompson, B.,Wang, L.(1999).Effects of sample size, estimation methods, and model specification on structural equation modeling fit indexes.Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal,6,56-83.
  33. Ferris, G. R.,Hochwarter, W. A.,Buckley, M. R.,Harrell-Cook, G.,Frink, D. D.(1999).Human resources management: Some new directions.Journal of Management,25,385-415.
  34. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D. F.(1981).Structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error: Algebra and statistics.Journal of Marketing Research,18,382-388.
  35. Fortin-Bergeron, C.,Doucet, O.,Hennebert, M.-A.(2018).The role of management and trade union leadership on dual commitment: The mediating effect of the workplace relations climate.Human Resource Management Journal,28,462-478.
  36. Fox, A.(1974).Beyond contract: Work, power and trust relations.London:Faber and Faber.
  37. Frostenson, M.(2016).Humility in business: A contextual approach.Journal of Business Ethics,138,91-102.
  38. Fuller, J. B.,Hester, K.(1998).The effect of labor relations climate on the union participation process.Journal of Labor Research,19,173-187.
  39. George, J. M.,Bettenhausen, K.(1990).Understanding prosocial behavior, sales performance, and turnover: A group-level analysis in a service context.Journal of Applied Psychology,75,698-709.
  40. Gilbert, D. T.(Ed.),Fiske, S. T.(Ed.),Lindzey, G.(Ed.)(1998).The handbook of social psychology.Boston, MA:McGraw-Hill.
  41. Gill, C.(2009).Union impact on the effective adoption of high performance work practices.Human Resource Management Review,19,39-50.
  42. Glick, W. H.(1988).Response: Organizations are not central tendencies: Shadowboxing in the dark, round 2.Academy of Management Review,13,133-137.
  43. Hambrick, D. C.(2007).Upper echelons theory: An update.Academy of Management Review,32,334-343.
  44. Hambrick, D. C.,Mason, P. A.(1984).Upper echelons: The organization as a reflection of its top managers.Academy of Management Review,9,193-206.
  45. Hammer, T. H.,Bayazit, M.,Wazeter, D. L.(2009).Union leadership and member attitudes: A multi-level analysis.Journal of Applied Psychology,94,392-410.
  46. Hayes, A. F.(2013).Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach.New York:Guilford.
  47. Hofmann, D. A.,Jones, L. M.(2005).Leadership, collective personality, and performance.Journal of Applied Psychology,90,509-522.
  48. Hooper, D.,Coughlan, J.,Mullen, M.(2008).Structural equation modelling: Guidelines for determining model fit.Journal of Business Research Methods,6,53-60.
  49. Jeung, C.-W.,Yoon, H. J.(2016).Leader humility and psychological empowerment: Investigating contingencies.Journal of Managerial Psychology,31,1122-1136.
  50. Johnstone, S.,Wilkinson, A.(2018).The potential of labour-management partnership: A longitudinal case analysis.British Journal of Management,29,554-570.
  51. Kahn, W. A.(1990).Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work.Academy of Management Journal,33,692-724.
  52. Kerfoot, K.(1998).The strategic use of humility.Nursing Economics,16,238-239.
  53. Kipnis, D.(1972).Does power corrupt?.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,24,33-41.
  54. Kish-Gephart, J. J.,Campbell, J. T.(2015).You don't forget your roots: The influence of CEO social class background on strategic risk taking.Academy of Management Journal,58,1614-1636.
  55. Klein, K. J.(Ed.),Kozlowski, S. W. J.(Ed.)(2000).Multilevel theory, research, and methods in organizations: Foundations, extension, and new directions.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  56. Kochan, T. A.,Riordan, C. A.,Kowalski, A. M.,Khan, M.,Yang, D.(2019).The changing nature of employee and labor-management relationships.Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior,6,195-219.
  57. Kwon, S. S.(2013).The impact of transformational labor leadership on members' willingness to participate in union activities in Korea: Exploration of universality and substitutability for antagonism.The International Journal of Human Resource Management,24,265-284.
  58. Lambert, S. J.(1990).Processes linking work and family: A critical review and research agenda.Human Relations,43,239-257.
  59. Lewin, D.(Ed.),Lipsky, D. B.(Ed.),Sockell, D.(Ed.)(1987).Advances in industrial and labor relations.Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
  60. Mao, J.,Chiu, C.-Y.,Owens, B. P.,Brown, J. A.,Liao, J.(2019).Growing followers: Exploring the effects of leader humility on follower self-expansion, self-efficacy, and performance.Journal of Management Studies,56,343-371.
  61. Mayer, D. M.,Kuenzi, M.,Greenbaum, R.,Bardes, M.,Salvador, R. B.(2009).How low does ethical leadership flow? Test of a trickle-down model.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,108,1-13.
  62. Morgeson, F. P.,Hofmann, D. A.(1999).The structure and function of collective constructs: Implications for multilevel research and theory development.Academy of Management Review,24,249-265.
  63. Morris, J. A.,Brotheridge, C. M.,Urbanski, J. C.(2005).Bringing humility to leadership: Antecedents and consequences of leader humility.Human Relations,58,1323-1350.
  64. Mosca, J. B.,Pressman, S.(1995).Unions in the 21st century.Public Personnel Management,24,159-166.
  65. Nadkarni, S.,Chen, T.,Chen, J.(2016).The clock is ticking! Executive temporal depth, industry velocity, and competitive aggressiveness.Strategic Management Journal,37,1132-1153.
  66. Nava, M.(2008).The servant of all: Humility, humanity, and judicial diversity.Golden Gate University Law Review,38(2)
  67. Newman, A.,Cooper, B.,Holland, P.,Miao, Q.,Teicher, J.(2019).How do industrial relations climate and union instrumentality enhance employee performance? The mediating effects of perceived job security and trust in management.Human Resource Management,58,35-44.
  68. Ou, A. Y.,Tsui, A. S.,Kinicki, A. J.,Waldman, D. A.,Xiao, Z.,Song, L. J.(2014).Humble chief executive officers' connections to top management team integration and middle managers’ responses.Administrative Science Quarterly,59,34-72.
  69. Ou, A. Y.,Waldman, D. A.,Peterson, S. J.(2018).Do humble CEOS matter? An examination of CEO humility and firm outcomes.Journal of Management,44,1147-1173.
  70. Owens, B. P.,Hekman, D. R.(2012).Modeling how to grow: An inductive examination of humble leader behaviors, contingencies, and outcomes.Academy of Management Journal,55,787-818.
  71. Owens, B. P.,Hekman, D. R.(2016).How does leader humility influence team performance? Exploring the mechanisms of contagion and collective promotion focus.Academy of Management Journal,59,1088-1111.
  72. Owens, B. P.,Johnson, M. D.,Mitchell, T. R.(2013).Expressed humility in organizations: Implications for performance, teams, and leadership.Organization Science,24,1517-1538.
  73. Owens, B. P.,Wallace, A. S.,Waldman, D. A.(2015).Leader narcissism and follower outcomes: The counterbalancing effect of leader humility.Journal of Applied Psychology,100,1203-1213.
  74. Park, S. H.,Luo, Y.(2001).Guanxi and organizational dynamics: Organizational networking in Chinese firms.Strategic Management Journal,22,455-477.
  75. Parker, S. K.(2007).That is my job’: How employees' role orientation affects their job performance.Human Relations,60,403-434.
  76. Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Podsakoff, N. P.(2012).Sources of method bias in social science research and recommendations on how to control it.Annual Review of Psychology,63,539-569.
  77. Pohler, D.,Luchak, A.(2015).Are unions good or bad for organizations? The moderating role of management's response.British Journal of Industrial Relations,53,423-459.
  78. Pyman, A.,Holland, P.,Teicher, J.,Cooper, B. K.(2010).Industrial relations climate, employee voice and managerial attitudes to unions: An Australian study.British Journal of Industrial Relations,48,460-480.
  79. Ritchie, W. J.,Anthony, W. P.,Rubens, A. J.(2004).Individual executive characteristics: Explaining the divergence between perceptual and financial measures in nonprofit organizations.Journal of Business Ethics,53,267-281.
  80. Rubinstein, S. A.(2001).The local union revisited: New voices from the front lines.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society,40,405-435.
  81. Snape, E. D.,Redman, T.(2012).Industrial relations climate and union commitment: An evaluation of workplace-level effects.Industrial Relations,51,11-28.
  82. Sousa, M.,van Dierendonck, D.(2017).Servant leadership and the effect of the interaction between humility, action, and hierarchical power on follower engagement.Journal of Business Ethics,141,13-25.
  83. Staines, G. L.(1980).Spillover versus compensation: A review of the literature on the relationship between work and nonwork.Human Relations,33,111-129.
  84. Staw, B.(Ed.),Cummings, I.(Ed.)(1984).Research in organizational behaviour.Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
  85. Sun, W.,Xu, A.,Shang, Y.(2014).Transformational leadership, team climate, and team performance within the NPD team: Evidence from China.Asia Pacific Journal of Management,31,127-147.
  86. Triandis, H. C.(Ed.),Berry, J. W.(Ed.)(1980).Handbook of cross-cultural psychology.Boston, MA:Allyn and Bacon.
  87. Tuggle, C. S.,Schnatterly, K.,Johnson, R. A.(2010).Attention patterns in the boardroom: How board composition and processes affect discussion of entrepreneurial issues.Academy of Management Journal,53,550-571.
  88. Valizade, D.,Ogbonnaya, C.,Tregaskis, O.,Forde, C.(2016).A mutual gains perspective on workplace partnership: Employee outcomes and the mediating role of the employment relations climate.Human Resource Management Journal,26,351-368.
  89. Vera, D.,Rodriguez-Lopez, A.(2004).Strategic virtues: Humility as a source of competitive advantage.Organizational Dynamics,33,393-408.
  90. Voos, P. B.(1989).The practices consonant with cooperative labor-relations.Labor Law Journal,40,483-490.
  91. Wagar, T. H.(1997).Is labor-management climate important? Some Canadian evidence.Journal of Labor Research,18,163-174.
  92. Walker, J. M.,Lawler, J. J.(1979).Dual unions and political processes in organizations.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society,18,32-43.
  93. Wang, L.,Owens, B. P.,Li, J. J.,Shi, L.(2018).Exploring the affective impact, boundary conditions, and antecedents of leader humility.Journal of Applied Psychology,103,1019-1038.
  94. Wu, W.-P.,Lee, Y.-D.(2001).Participatory management and industrial relations climate: A study of Chinese, Japanese and US firms in Taiwan.The International Journal of Human Resource Management,12,827-844.
  95. Zhang, H.,Shu, C.,Jiang, X.,Malter, A. J.(2010).Managing knowledge for innovation: The role of cooperation, competition, and alliance nationality.Journal of International Marketing,18,74-94.
  96. Zhang, Y.,Waldman, D. A.,Han, Y.-L.,Li, X.-B.(2015).Paradoxical leader behaviors in people management: Antecedents and consequences.Academy of Management Journal,58,538-566.
  97. Zhou, K. Z.,Wu, F.(2010).Technological capability, strategic flexibility, and product innovation.Strategic Management Journal,31,547-561.
  98. 王一芝(2019)。長榮罷工給台灣上的一課。天下雜誌，677
  99. 王弈翔(2018)。桃園市，國立中央大學。
print cancel