题名

探討問題導向學習在醫學教育臨床實務能力之成效及啟示

并列篇名

Efficiency and Implications of Problem-Based Learning on Clinical Competence in Medical Education

DOI

10.6173/CJSE.2014.2201.01

作者

洪佳慧(Chia-Hui Hung)；林陳涌(Chen-Yung Lin)

关键词

情境學習理論 ； 問題導向學習 ； 認識論 ； 臨床實務能力 ； Situated Learning Theory ； Problem-Based Learning ； Epistemology ； Clinical Competence

期刊名称

科學教育學刊

卷期/出版年月

22卷1期（2014 / 03 / 01）

页次

1 - 32

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

近年來，問題導向學習（Problem-Based Learning，PBL）在醫學教育上的應用日漸普遍。一般認為，PBL讓學生在問題情境中學習知識的使用與產出問題解決的原則，但實證研究顯示，關於PBL成效沒有一致性的看法。因此，本文目的為以認識論與心理學觀點為核心，針對PBL可否促進臨床能力之議題，分析支持與反對PBL可提升臨床實務能力的立場辯證，提出良好規劃的PBL課程實務。由理論辯證中發現，PBL認識論觀點強調具實用性的做中學，以及建構學習，與醫學教育欲培育具備臨床能力的醫生相符；由情境學習理論的觀點，PBL將臨床案例融入問題情境中，模擬臨床實務，協助學習遷移，亦是符合醫學教育發展核心能力的需求。基於上述結果，本文以Skilbeck之情境模式作為課程設計的架構，建議PBL教案應提升擬真程度，促使外顯與內隱記憶發展，符合情境學習需求，並能讓學生有機會做中學；課程實施上選擇合適PBL模組實施課程；而在評量上應整合多元測驗，尤其是提供主觀性評量以檢視整體的學習成效。最後，透過本文所提出之理論與實務連結的PBL課程設計，期望可作為成功詮釋PBL成效之基礎。
英文摘要

Problem-Based Learning (PBL) has been used increasingly and more widely in medical education in the recent years. PBL involves the use of context of problems that allows students to use their prior knowledge for producing principles of problem solving. However, the empirical researches show that the effectiveness of PBL is not conclusive. In concert with the outcome-based medical education, the purpose of this article was to outline the epistemological and psychological perspectives of PBL and to discuss whether PBL enhance clinical competencies. Furthermore, the argumentations of supportive and opposite opinions of PBL were analyzed to propose strategies for designing a PBL curriculum. From the perspective of theoretical dialectic, the epistemology of PBL stressed on learning by doing and constructive learning, corresponding to the medical education that fosters clinical competence of doctors. From the situated learning perspective, PBL applied clinical cases of real-life scenarios to demonstrate clinical practices and to facilitate learning transfer, which also fulfilled the needs of medical education in developing students' core knowledge. Our findings based on the Skilbeck's situational model of course design, suggested that a higher level of authentic PBL environments should be created to facilitate the learning of explicit and implicit memories and to meet the requirements of situated learning. Adaption of an appropriate PBL module would help students in learning by doing. The effectiveness of learning should be evaluated by multi assessments such as subjective evaluation. This article may be referenced to provide a theoretical basis for practice applications of developing of a well-designed, effective, and successful PBL curriculum.
主题分类 社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 廖述盛、黃秀美、賴崇閔(2011)。虛擬實境結合問題導向學習應用於行動化醫學教育之研究。科學教育學刊，19(3)，237-256。
    連結：
  2. Albanese, M. A.(2000).Problem-based learning: Why curricula are likely to show little effect on knowledge and clinical skills.Medical Education,34(9),729-738.
  3. Albanese, M. A.,Mitchell, S.(1993).Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues.Academic Medicine,68(1),52-81.
  4. Anderson, J. R.(1995).Cognitive psychology and its implications.New York:W. H. Freeman.
  5. Anderson, W. D.(2011).Outside looking in: Observations on medical education since the Flexner report.Medical Education,45(1),29-35.
  6. Barrett, T.,Moore, S.(2010).New approaches to problem-based learning: Revitalising your practice in higher education.New York:Routledge.
  7. Barrows, H. S.(1992).The tutorial process.Alton, IL:Southern Illinois University School of Medicine.
  8. Barrows, H. S.(1996).Problem-based learning in medicine and beyond: A brief overview.New Directions for Teaching and Learning,1996(68),3-12.
  9. Barrows, H. S.(1986).A taxonomy of problem-based learning methods.Medical Education,20(6),481-486.
  10. Barrows, H. S.,Tamblyn, R. M.(1980).Problem-based learning: An approach to medical education.New York:Springer.
  11. Basu Roy, R.,McMahon, G. T.(2012).Video-based cases disrupt deep critical thinking in problem-based learning.Medical Education,46(4),426-435.
  12. Berkson, L.(1993).Problem-based learning: Have the expections been met?.Academic Medicine,68(10),S79-88.
  13. Blake, R. L.,Hosokawa, M. C.,Riley, S. L.(2000).Student performances on step 1 and step 2 of the United States medical licensing examination following implementation of a problembased learning curriculum.Academic Medicine,75(1),66-70.
  14. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Duguid, P.(1989).Situated cognition and the cultural of learning.Educational Researcher,18(1),32-42.
  15. Brown, J. S.,Collins, A.,Newman, S. E.(1989).Cognitive apprenticeship: Teaching the crafts of reading, writing, and mathematics.Knowing, learning, and instruction: Essays in honor of Robert Glaser,Hillsdale, NJ:
  16. Budé, L.,Van De Wiel, M. W. J.,Imbos, T.,Berger, M. P. F.(2011).The effect of directive tutor guidance on students' conceptual understanding of statistics in problem-based learning.British Journal of Educational Psychology,81(2),309-324.
  17. Carraccio, C.,Wolfsthal, S. D.,Englander, R.,Ferentz, K.,Martin, C.(2002).Shifting paradigms: From Flexner to competencies.Academic Medicine,77(5),361-367.
  18. Coderre, S.,Mandin, H.,Harasym, P. H.,Fick, G. H.(2003).Diagnostic reasoning strategies and diagnostic success.Medical Education,37(8),695-703.
  19. Colliver, J. A.(2000).Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Research and theory.Academic Medicine,75(3),259-266.
  20. Colliver, J. A.(1999).Research strategy for problem-based learning: Cognitive science or outcomes research?.Teaching & Learning in Medicine,11(2),64-65.
  21. Cooke, M.,Irby, D. M.,O'Brien, B. C.(2010).Educating physicians: A call for reform of medical school and residency.San Fracisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  22. Daley, B. J.,Torre, D. M.(2010).Concept maps in medical education: An analytical literature review.Medical Education,44(5),440-448.
  23. David, T.,Patel, L.,Burdett, K.,Rangachari, P.(2005).Problem-based learning in medicine: A practical guide for students and teachers.London:Royal Society of Medicine Press.
  24. Dochy, F.,Segers, M.,Van Den Bossche, P.,Gijbels, D.(2003).Effects of problem-based learning: A meta-analysis.Learning and Instruction,13(5),533-568.
  25. Dolmans, D. H. J. M.,De Grave, W.,Wolfhagen, I. H. A. P.,Van Der Vleuten, C. P. M.(2005).Problem-based learning: Future challenges for educational practice and research.Medical Education,39(7),732-741.
  26. Ende, J.(2010).Theory and practice of teaching medicine.Philadelphia, PA:American College of Physicians.
  27. Evensen, D. H.(Ed.),Hmelo, C. E.(Ed.)(2000).Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interactions.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associations.
  28. Evensen, D. H.,Hmelo, C. E.(2000).Problem-based learning: A research perspective on learning interaction.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associations.
  29. Farrow, R.,Norman, G.(2003).The effectiveness of PBL: The debate continues. Is metaanalysis helpful?.Medical Education,37(12),1131-1132.
  30. Gazzaniga, M. S.,Ivry, R. B.,Mangun, G. R.(2002).Cognitive neuroscience: The biology of the mind (2nd ed.).New York:W. W. Norton & Company.
  31. Gentner, D.,Loewenstein, J.,Thompson, L.(2003).Learning and transfer: A general role for analogical encoding.Journal of Educational Psychology,95(2),393-408.
  32. Gibbins, J.,McCoubrie, R.,Forbes, K.(2011).Why are newly qualified doctors unprepared to care for patients at the end of life?.Medical Education,45(4),389-399.
  33. Gijbels, D.,Dochy, F.,Van Den Bossche, P.,Segers, M.(2005).Effects of problem-based learning: A meta-analysis from the angle of assessment.Review of Educational Research,75(1),27-61.
  34. Groen, G. J.,Patel, V. L.(1985).Medical problem-solving: Some questionable assumptions.Medical Education,19(2),95-100.
  35. Halperin, E. C.(2010).Preserving the humanities in medical education.Medical Teacher,32(1),76-79.
  36. Harden, R. M.(2007).Outcome-based education: The future is today.Medical Teacher,29(7),625-629.
  37. Hartling, L.,Spooner, C.,Tjosvold, L.,Oswald, A.(2010).Problem-based learning in preclinical medical education: 22 years of outcome research.Medical Teacher,32(1),28-35.
  38. Hébert, R.,Bravo, G.(1996).Development and validation of an evaluation instrument for medical students in tutorials.Academic Medicine,71(5),488-494.
  39. Hung, W.(2006).The 3C3R model: A conceptual framework for design problems in PBL.Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-based Learning,1(1),55-75.
  40. Jenkings, K. N.,Barber, N.(2004).What constitutes evidence in hospital new drug decision making?.Social Science & Medicine,58(9),1757-1766.
  41. Kalaian, H. A.,Mullan, P. B.,Kasim, R. M.(1999).What can studies of problem-based learning tell us? Synthesizing and modeling PBL effects on national board of medical examination performance: Hierarchical linear modeling meta-analytic approach.Advances in Health Science Education,4(3),209-221.
  42. Kirkhart, M. W.(2001).The nature of declarative and nondeclarative knowledge for implicit and explicit learning.The Journal of General Psychology,128(4),447-461.
  43. Kirschner, P. A.,Sweller, J.,Clark, R. E.(2006).Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching.Educational Psychologist,41(2),75-86.
  44. Kosko, B.、陳雅雲譯(2004)。模糊的未來：從社會、科學到晶片中的天堂。臺北市:究竟。
  45. Lave, J.,Wenger, E.(1991).Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  46. Lockyer, J.,Wycliffe-Jones, K.,Raman, F. M.,Sandhu, A.,Fidler, H.(2011).Moving into medical practice in a new community: The transition experience.Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions,31(3),151-156.
  47. Lysaght, R.,Bent, M.(2005).A comparative analysis of case presentation modalities used in clinical reasoning coursework in occupational therapy.The American Journal of Occupational Therapy,59(3),314-324.
  48. Manderson, L.(1998).Applying medical anthropology in the control of infectious disease.Tropical Medicine & International Health,3(12),1020-1027.
  49. Mann, K. V.(2011).Theoretical perspectives in medical education: Past experience and future possibilities.Medical Education,45(1),60-68.
  50. McLean, M.,Henson, Q.,Hiles, L.(2003).The possible contribution of student drawings to evaluation in a new problem-based learning medical programme: A pilot study.Medical Education,37(10),895-906.
  51. Miller, G. E.(1990).The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance.Academic Medicine,65(9),S63-67.
  52. Norman, G. R.(2009).Teaching basic science to optimize transfer.Medical Teacher,31(9),807-811.
  53. Norman, G. R.,Schmidt, H. G.(1992).The psychological basis of problem-based learning: A review of the evidence.Academic Medicine,67(9),557-565.
  54. Norman, G. R.,Schmidt, H. G.(2000).Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Theory, practice and paper darts.Medical Education,34(9),721-728.
  55. Oldroyd, D. R.(1986).The arch of knowledge: An introductory study of the history of the philosophy and methodalogy of science.New York:Routledge.
  56. O'Neill, G.,Hung, W.(2010).Seeing the landscape and the forest floor: Changes made to improve the connectivity of concepts in a hybrid problem-based learning curriculum.Teaching in Higher Education,15(1),15-27.
  57. O'Neill, P. A.(2000).The role of basic sciences in a problem-based learning clinical curriculum.Medical Education,34(8),608-613.
  58. Papa, F. J.,Harasym, P. H.(1999).Medical curriculum reform in North America, 1765 to the present: A cognitive science perspective.Academic Medicine,74(2),154-164.
  59. Patrício, M.,Julião, M.,Fareleira, F.,Young, M.,Norman, G.,Vaz Carneiro, A.(2009).A comprehensive checklist for reporting the use of OSCEs.Medical Teacher,31(2),112-124.
  60. Pease, M. A.,Kuhn, D.(2011).Experimental analysis of the effective components of problem-based learning.Science Education,95(1),57-86.
  61. Persson, A. C.,Fyrenius, A.,Bergdahl, B.(2010).Perspectives on using multimedia scenarios in a PBL medical curriculum.Medical Teacher,32(9),766-772.
  62. Portilla-Figueras, A.,Jiménez-Fernández, S.,Salcedo-Sanz, S.(2010).A project-based competitive learning scheme to teach mobile communications.International Journal of Electrical Engineering Education,47(4),460-468.
  63. Rogoff, B.(1990).Apprenticeship in thinking: Cognitive development in social context.New York:Oxford University Press.
  64. Sahin, M.(2010).Effects of problem-based learning on university students' epistemological beliefs about physics and physics learning and conceptual understanding of Newtonian mechanics.Journal of Science Education and Technology,19(3),266-275.
  65. Salomon, G.(Ed.)(1993).Distributed cognition: Psychological and educational considerations.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  66. Savin-Baden, M.(2000).Problem-based learning in higher education: Untold stories.Philadelphia, PA:SRHE.
  67. Savin-Baden, M.(2008).Problem-based learning in electronic engineering: Locating legends or promising problems?.International Journal of Electrical Engineering Education,45(2),96-109.
  68. Savin-Baden, M.,Major, C. H.(2004).Foundations of problem-based learning.New York:Open University Press.
  69. Schmidt, H. G.(1993).Foundations of problem-based learning: Some explanatory notes.Medical Education,27(5),422-432.
  70. Schmidt, H. G.,Dauphinee, W. D.,Patel, V. L.(1987).Comparing the effects of problembased and conventional curricula in an international sample.Journal of Medical Education,62(4),305-315.
  71. Schmidt, H. G.,Muijtjens, A. M. M.,Van Der Vleuten, C. P. M.,Norman, G. R.(2012).Differential student attrition and differential exposure mask effects of problem-based learning in curriculum comparison studies.Academic Medicine,87(4),463-475.
  72. Schmidt, H. G.,Rotgans, J. I.,Yew, E. H. J.(2011).The process of problem-based learning: What works and why.Medical Education,45(8),792-806.
  73. Schmidt, H. G.,Van Der Molen, H. T.,Te Winkel, W. W. R.,Wijnen, W. H. F. W.(2009).Constructivist, problem-based learning does work: A meta-analysis of curricular comparisons involving a single medical school.Educational Psychologist,44(4),227-249.
  74. Skilbeck, M.(1984).School-based curriculum development.London:Harper and Row.
  75. Sockalingam, N.,Rotgans, J.,Schmidt, H. G.(2011).Student and tutor perceptions on attributes of effective problems in problem-based learning.Higher Education: The International Journal of Higher Education and Educational Planning,62(1),1-16.
  76. Squire, L. R.、Kandel, E. R.、洪蘭譯(2001)。透視記憶。臺北市:遠流。
  77. Stojković, S.,Milojević, D.(2011).ATP-EMTP-based approach to teaching insulation coordination in the electrical engineering curriculum.International Journal of Electrical Engineering Education,48(2),130-145.
  78. Sweeney, G.(1999).The challenge for basic science education in problem-based medical curricula.Clinical and Investigative Medicine,22(1),15-22.
  79. Swing, S. R.(2007).The ACGME outcome project: Retrospective and prospective.Medical Teacher,29(7),648-654.
  80. Taylor, D.,Miflin, B.(2008).Problem-based learning: Where are we now?.Medical Teacher,30(8),742-763.
  81. Thompson, T.,Musket, S.(2005).Does priming for mastery goals improve the performance of students with an entity view of ability?.British Journal of Educational Psychology,75(3),391-409.
  82. Torp, L.,Sage, S.(2002).Problems as possibilities: Problem-based learning for K-16 education (2nd ed.).Alexandria, VA:Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
  83. Tulving, E.,Schacter, D. L.(1990).Priming and human memory system.Science,247(4940),301-306.
  84. Van Blankenstein, F. M.,Dolmans, D. H.,Van Der Vleuten, C. P.,Schmidt, H. G.(2011).Which cognitive processes support learning during small-group discussion? The role of providing explanations and listening to others.Instructional Science,39(2),189-204.
  85. Van Gessel, E.,Nendaz, M. R.,Vermeulen, B.,Junod, A.,Vu, N. V.(2003).Development of clinical reasoning from the basic science to the clerkships: A longitudinal assessment of medical students'need and self-perception after a traditional learning unit.Medical Education,37(11),966-974.
  86. Vernon, D. T. A.,Blake, R. L.(1993).Does problem-based learning work? A meta-analysis of evaluative research.Academic Medicine,68(7),550-563.
  87. Voss, J. L.,Lucas, H. D.,Paller, K. A.(2010).Conceptual priming and familiarity: Different expressions of memory during recognition testing with distinct neurophysiological correlates.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,22(11),2638-2651.
  88. Weatherall, D.(2011).Science and medical education: Is it time to revisit Flexner?.Medical Education,45(1),44-50.
  89. Wenger, E.(1998).Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  90. 孫振青(1987)。知識論。臺北市:五南。
  91. 黃光雄、蔡清田(2003)。課程設計：理論與實際。臺北市:五南。
  92. 楊坤原、張賴妙理(2005)。問題本位學習的理論基礎與教學歷程。中原學報（人文及社會科學系列），33(2)，215-235。
  93. 詹志禹編(2002)。建構論理論基礎與教育應用。臺北市:正中書局。
  94. 謝博生(1997)。醫師教育模式之變遷。醫學教育，1(2)，3-10。
被引用次数
  1. Wu, Hsiu-Ying,Tsen, Fen-Yu,Li, Ai-Tzu,Hsu, Chiun,Ho, Chao-Chi,Chang, Chia-Hsuin(2018).Students' Perspective on the Key Elements and Effectiveness of Problem-based Learning Group Discussion.醫學教育,22(4),125-139.
  2. 曾采楨,郭文英,張寧郁,唐敏華,林玉蘭(2020)。讀心術－運用多元教學提昇參與兩年期訓練課程之護理師異常心律判讀及處理能力。護理雜誌，67(6)，61-69。
  3. 董曜瑜、洪嘉駿、施昆易、王淑卿、王國華(2018)。一個混成式案例教學模式應用於非正式科學師資培育之成效：由學習參與和學習感受觀點。科學教育學刊，26(2)，171-196。
  4. 黃志雄(2016)。大學「教」與「學」的教學歷程與反思：以特殊幼兒教育課程為例。弘光學報，78，119-146。
  5. 黃志雄、田育芬(2016)。大學教師參與問題導向學習之專業發展社群個案研究。教育研究與發展期刊，12(1)，147-172。
  6. 蔣世寶(2021)。基於問題導向課程活動之合作學習研究。中科大學報，8(2)，53-78。
  7. 林珮如(2021)。以問題導向學習應用於特殊教育輔助科技課程之實踐成效。特殊教育研究學刊，46(2)，1-29。
  8. 羅翊邦,蔣立琦,周汎澔(2016).以學習共同體實踐實證護理於臨床實習教學－哈伯馬斯批判理論的應用.源遠護理,10(1),5-13.
  9. (2019)。大學教師對校外參訪見學的問題意識與經驗詮釋。教育研究學報，53(1)，1-24。
print cancel