道德判斷的「雙重歷程模式」：認知、情緒與文化的整合觀點

The Dual-process Model of Moral Judgment: An Integrated Viewpoint of Cognition, Emotion, and Culture

10.6254/2011.36.33

陳舜文(Shun-Wen Chen)；邱振訓(Chen-Hsun Chiu)

道德心理學 ； 道德判斷 ； 雙重歷程模式 ； dual-process model ； moral judgment ； moral psychology

本土心理學研究

36期（2011 / 12 / 31）

33 - 76

繁體中文

當代本土心理學者針對西方道德心理學的研究典範提出兩項質疑：一是認為過去理論過於強調道德判斷時的理性層面，而忽視情感層面；二是認為道德發展模式並非完全普世皆然。為了解決當代道德心理學的理論爭議，本文針對人們的道德判斷歷程，提出一項整合認知、情緒與文化的理論模式：「雙重歷程模式」。此模式的主要論點如下：（1）人們的道德判斷包含兩種心智歷程：「自動歷程」可以快速且下意識地處理訊息；「精緻歷程」則是有意識、耗時且主動處理訊息。（2）這兩種歷程都包含情緒與認知成分。（3）道德判斷同時受到生物與社會文化因素之影響，具有人類普同性與文化特殊性。此模式除了能夠整合各項觀點，並且重新解釋過去實徵資料，還能對於道德心理學的未來研究方向，提出新的議題與展望。

Is moral judgment universal or culture-relative? Is it dominated by emotional or cognitive processes? In order to address these perplexing questions, the authors propose a dual-process model and argue that: (1) moral judgment involves two kinds of psychological processes (an automatic process, which is sub-conscious and fast, and an elaborative process, which is conscious and time-consuming); (2) both processes contain emotional and cognitive components; and (3) moral judgment psychological processes are influenced by both biological-evolutional and social-cultural factors. Prospects for further studies of indigenous moral psychology and epistemological issues are discussed.

1. 黃光國(1998)。兩種道德：台灣社會中道德思維研究的在詮釋。本土心理學研究，9，121-175。
   連結：
2. Piaget, J. (1932). The moral judgment of the child. London: Routeledge & Kegan Paul.
3. James, W. (1890). The principles of psychology. New York: Henry Holt.
4. Bartlett, F. C. (1932). Remembering. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
5. Anderson, C. A.,Lepper, M. R.,Ross, L.(1980).The perseverance of social theories: The role of explanation in the persistence of discredited information.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,39,1037-1049.
6. Anderson, S. W.,Bechara, A.,Damasio, H.,Tranel, D.,Damasio, A.(1999).Impairment of social and moral behavior related to early damage in human prefrontal cortex.Nature Neuroscience,2,1032-1037.
7. Archer, M. S.(1995).Realist social theory: The morphogenetic approach.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
8. Batson, C. D.(1991).The altruism question: Toward a social psychological answer.Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
9. Baumeister, R.(2005).The cultural animal.New York:Oxford University Press.
10. Bolhuis, J. J.(Ed.)(2005).Behavior of animals: Mechanisms, functions, and evolution.Malden, MA:Blackwell.
11. Bourdieu, P.(1989).Social space and symbolic power.Sociological Theory,7,14-25.
12. Brandt, A. M.(Ed.)(1997).Morality and health.New York:Routeledge.
13. Choi, I.,Nisbett, R. E.,Norenzayan, A.(1999).Causal attribution across cultures: Variation and university.Psychological Bulletin,125,47-63.
14. Damasio, A.(1994).Descartes' error: Emotion, reason, and the human brain.New York:Putman.
15. Damon, W.(Ed.)(1998).Handbook of child psychology, Vol. 1: Theoretical models of human development.New York:Wiley.
16. Foot, P.(1978).Virtues and vices and other essays in moral philosophy.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
17. Gibbs, J. C.(1979).Kohlberg's moral stage theory: A Piagetian revision.Human Development,22,89-112.
18. Giddens, A.(1984).The constitution of society.Cambridge:Polity Press.
19. Gigerenzer, G.(2007).Gut feelings: The intellgence of unconscious.New York:Viking.
20. Gigerenzer, G.(2000).Adaptive thinking: Rationality in the real world.London:Oxford University Press.
21. Gilbert, D. T.(1991).How mental systems believe.American Psychologist,46,107-119.
22. Gilligan, C.(1977).In a different voice: Women's conceptions of the self and of morality.Harvard Educational Review,47(1),43-61.
23. Goslin, D. A.(Ed.)(1969).Handbook of socialization theory and research.Chicago:Rand McNally.
24. Graham, J.,Haidt, J.,Nosek, B.(2009).Liberals and conservatives use different sets of moral foundations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,96,1029-1046.
25. Greene, J. D.,Sommerville, R. B.,Nystrom, L. E.,Darley, J. M.,Cohen, J. D.(2001).An fMRI investigation of emotional engagement in moral judgment.Science,293,2105-2108.
26. Habermas, J.(1971).Knowledge and human interests.Boston, MA:Beacon Press.
27. Haidt, J.(2001).The emotional dog and its rational tail: A social intuitionist approach to moral judgment.Psychological Review,108,814-834.
28. Haidt, J.(2007).The new synthesis in moral psychology.Science,316,998-1002.
29. Harris, G. G.(1989).Concepts of individual, self, and person in description and analysis.American Anthropologist,91(3),599-612.
30. Hauser, M. D.(2006).Moral minds: How nature designed a universal sense of right and wrong.New York:Ecco Press/HarperCollins.
31. Heine, S.,Proulx, T.,Vohs, K.(2006).The meaning maintenance model: On the coherence of social motivation.Personality and Social Psychology Review,10,88-110.
32. Hirt, E. R.,Kardes, F. R.,Markman, K. D.(2004).Activating a mental stimulation mind-set through generation of alternatives: Implications for debiasing in related and unrelated domain.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,40,374-383.
33. Hong、 Y.,Morris, M. W.,Chiu, C.,Benet-Martinex, V.(2000).Multicultural minds: A dynamic constructivist approach to culture and cognition.American Psychologist,55,709-720.
34. Hume, D.,Norton, D. F.(Ed.),Norton, M. J.(Ed.)(2000).A treatise of human nature.New York:Oxford University Press.
35. Jacobs, J.(2002).Dimensions of moral theory.Oxford:Blackwell Publishing.
36. Joyce, R.(2006).The evolution of morality.Cambridge:MIT Press.
37. Kahneman, D.(2003).A perspective on judgment and choice: Mapping bounded rationality.American Psychologist,58(9),697-720.
38. Kahneman, D.,Miller, D. T.(1986).Norm theory: Comparing reality to its alternatives.Psychological Review,93,136-153.
39. Kant, I,Gregor, M.(Trans.)(1997).Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
40. Kennett, J.(2006).Do psychopaths really threaten moral rationalism?.Philosophical Explorations,9(1),69-82.
41. Kohlberg, L.(1981).Essays on moral development Vol. 1: The philosophy of moral development.San Francisco, CA:Harper & Row.
42. Kohlberg, L.(1984).Essays on moral development Vol. 2: The philosophy of moral development.San Francisco, CA:Harper & Row.
43. Korsgaard, C. M.(2008).The constitution of agency: Essays on practical reason and moral psychology.New York:Oxford University Press.
44. Lehrer, J.(2009).How we decide.New York:Houghton Mifflin Publishing.
45. Lin、 Y. S.(1974).The evolution of the Pre-Confucian meaning of Jen and the Confucian cocept of moral autonomy.Monumenta Serica,31,178-198.
46. Macedo, S.(Ed.),Ober, J.(Ed.)(2006).Primates and philosophers.New Jersey:Princeton University Press.
47. Malloy, T. E.(2001).Difference to inference: Teaching logical and statistical reasoning through on-line interactivity.Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, and Computers,33,270-273.
48. Markman, K.,McMullen, M.,Elizage, R.(2008).Counterfactual thinking, persistence and performance: A test of the reflection and evaluation model.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,44,421-428.
49. Markus, H. R.,Kitayama, S.(1991).Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion and motivation.Psychological Review,98,224-253.
50. Markus, H. R.,Nurius, P.(1986).Possible selves.American Psychologist,41,954-969.
51. Miller, A. G.(Ed.)(2004).The social psychology of good and evil.New York:Guilford.
52. Morris、 M. W.,Peng, K.(1994).Culture and cause: American and Chinese attributions for social and physical events.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,67,949-971.
53. Moscovici, S.(1998).Social consciousness and its history.Cultural & Psychology,4(3),411-429.
54. Nichols, S.(2002).How psychopaths threaten threaten moral rationalism: Is it irrational to be amoral?.Monist,85,285-304.
55. Nisbett, R. W.(2003).The georgraphy of thought: How Asians and Westerners think differently... and why.New York:Free Press.
56. Norenzayan, A.,Heine, S. J.(2005).Psychological universals: What are they and how can we know?.Psychological Bulletin,131,763-784.
57. Petrinovich, L.,O''Neill, P.(1996).Influence of wording and framing effect on moral intuition.Ethology and Sociobiology,17,145-171.
58. Prinz, J.(2007).The emotional construction of morals.New York:Oxford University Press.
59. Shafer-Landau, R.(2003).Moral realism: A defense.New York:Oxford University Press.
60. Shah, J. Y.(Ed.),Garner, W. L.(Ed.)(2008).Handbook of motivation science.New York:Guilford Press.
61. Shariff, A.,Norenzayan, A.(2007).God is watching you: Priming God concepts increases prosocial behavior in an anonymous economic game.Paychological Science,18,803-809.
62. Shweder, R. A.(2000).The psychology of practice and the practice of the three psychologies.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,3,207-222.
63. Sibicky, M. E.,Schroeder, D. A.,Dovidio, J. F.(1995).Empathy and helping: Considering the consequences of intervention.Basic and Applied Social Psychology,16,435-453.
64. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.(Ed.)(2008).Moral psychology, Vol. 3: The Neuroscience of morality.Cambridge:MIT Press.
65. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.(Ed.)(2008).Moral psychology, Vol. 1: The evolution of morality.Cambridge:MIT Press.
66. Sinnott-Armstrong, W.(Ed.)(2008).Moral psychology, Vol. 2: The cognitive science of morality.Cambridge:MIT Press.
67. Sloman, S. A.(1996).The empirical case for two systems of reasoning.Psychological Bulletin,119,3-22.
68. Snarey, J.(1985).Cross-cultural university of social-moral development: A critical review of Kohlberian research.Psychological Bulletin,97,202-232.
69. Stinger, J.(Ed.),Shweder, R. A.(Ed.),Herdt, G.(Ed.)(1990).Cultural psychology: Essays on comparative human development.New York:Cambridge University Press.
70. Tavris, C.,Aronson, E.(2007).Mistakes were made (but not by me).New York:Harcourt.
71. Thomson, J. J.(1985).The trolley problem.Yale Law Journal,94,1395-1415.
72. Toi, M.,Batson, C. D.(1982).More evidenve that empathy is a source of altruistic motivation.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,42,281-292.
73. Tomasello, M.(1999).The cultural origins of human cognition.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
74. Tomasello, M.(2009).Why we cooperate.Cambridge:MIT Press.
75. Wagner, W.,Duveen, G.,Farr, R.,Jovchelovitch, S.,Lorenzi-Cioldi, F.,Markova, I.(1999).Theory and method of social representations.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,2,95-125.
76. 余英時(2008)。東漢生死觀。台北:聯經出版公司。
77. 余英時編(1992)。中國歷史轉型時期的知識份子。台北:聯經出版公司。
78. 馬慶強(1997)。中國人之感性與認知方面的道德發展：一個七階段發展理論。本土心理學研究，7，166-212。
79. 陳舜文(1999)。「仁」與「禮」：台灣民眾的家庭價值觀與工作態度。應用心理學刊，4，205-227。
80. 馮涵棣(1997)。階段論與文化脈動的省思。本土心理學研究，7，236-245。
81. 黃光國(1997)。建構理論的「結構理路」。本土心理學研究，7，221-228。
82. 黃光國(2011)。心理學的科學革命方案。台北:心理出版社。
83. 黃光國(2009)。儒家關係主義：哲學反思、理論建構與實徵研究。台北:心理出版社。
84. 黃俊傑編(1982)。天道與人道。台北:聯經出版公司。
85. 楊中芳編、高尚仁編(1991)。中國人‧中國心。台北:遠流出版公司。
86. 葉紹國(1996)。道德推理中的關懷導向與正義導向思考之區辨及其在中國社會實踐的特徵。本土心理學研究，5，264-311。
87. 蔡啟政(1995)。結構之外：歷史的社會學理路初探。二十一世紀雙月刊，32，39-49。

1. 陳舜文,符碧真,危芷芬,王秀槐(2021)。華人的學業成就目標與儒家倫理觀：兼回應「台灣青少年是否認為努力與學業成就關乎道德？」一文。中華心理學刊，63(4)，357-372。
2. 謝炎君、林栢章、林晏瑜、林玥秀(2016)。以Tenbrunsel and Smith-Crowe 倫理決策模型探討餐旅系學生之倫理察覺與決策行為。觀光休閒學報，22(3)，251-276。
3. (2015)。Bandura道德疏離機制量表對於國內中小學學生適切性之研究。教育學刊，45，85-125。